Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Forgotten Affairs of Youth” as Want to Read:
The Forgotten Affairs of Youth
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Forgotten Affairs of Youth (Isabel Dalhousie #8)

3.83 of 5 stars 3.83  ·  rating details  ·  3,137 ratings  ·  433 reviews


Nothing captures the charm of Edinburgh like the bestselling Isabel Dalhousie series of novels featuring the insatiably curious philosopher and woman detective. Whether investigating a case or a problem of philosophy, the indefatigable Isabel Dalhousie, one of fiction’s most richly developed amateur detectives, is always ready to pursue the answers
ebook, 272 pages
Published December 6th 2011 by Anchor (first published January 1st 2011)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Forgotten Affairs of Youth, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Forgotten Affairs of Youth

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Isabel Dalhousie is sanctimonious bitch!

She is condescending to her housekeeper.

She slut shames her niece.

She is a snob about her so-called work which she never seems to do.

She thinks her 2 year old son is a food snob because he likes olives, sardines and gherkins.

She justifies her buttinksky behavior by thinking she has the power to make other people happy.

She ponders how lucky and happy she is and assumes those who were not blessed with a trust fund and good education lead lives of quiet despe
Jan Rice
Alexander McCall Smith spent part of his childhood in Botswana. That's how he came to write the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series. When it became a runaway success he was a law professor -- in Edinburgh, I think. He became a literary phenomenon, turning out free-standing books, books for children, and several other series, including the Isabel Dalhousie books. The latter were at first called the "Sunday Philosophy Club," an idea that never actually developed. He's also done a lecture season ...more
Am in the midst of this book! I read McCall Smith for pure pleasure. It is refreshing to pick up a book and know that you really don't have F=to pick it apart!
Finished it; loved it; calm except for Cat who was, once again, choosing incorrectly from mushrooms to men.
The Forgotten Affairs of Youth is the 8th of the Isabel Dalhousie series by Alexander McCall Smith. As always, Isabel’s life is full: she has articles to read for the Review of Applied Ethics, an instance of nepotism by Professor Lettuce to deal with, decisions to make about rising journal production costs, and 2 year-old Charlie has started swearing. Learning of her niece, Cat’s latest liaison and wondering how many boyfriends is too many, Isabel mulls over her own forgotten affairs of youth: t ...more
P.V. LeForge
Three or four books after I’d decided I’d had enough of Alexander McCall Smith’s Isabelle Dalousie series (and read them anyway), The Forgotten Affairs of Youth came out. What a surprise to find that, except maybe for the first volume, it is the best of the lot. Let me go back for a minute.

The first of the Isabelle Dalhousie series was entitled The Sunday Philosophy Club. In it, McCall Smith set up the idea that Isabelle would have kind of an ongoing reading club with others who enjoyed philosop
I love Isabel Dalhousie, loyal citizen of Edinburgh, philospher, owner and editor of the Review of Applied Ethics. I admire her philosophy summed up in this quote: "...she would never accept things as they were. That was what made her do what she did--practice philosophy--and what made her, and everyone else who thought about the world and its unkindnesses, do battle for understanding, for sympathy, for love; in small ways, perhaps, but ways that cumulatively made a difference."

Isabel can turn t
Sandy Michalka
The Forgotten Affairs of Youth by Alexander McCall Smith
This review is the second of three reviews of books that seem to me go together. Part A is Sophie’s World by Jostein Gaarder and Part C is Grace (Eventually): Thoughts on Faith by Anne Lamott. And they are connected in my mind by their interesting, enlightening and unique explorations of the fundamental questions at the center of life. They each show how their children motivate people to confront previously unexplored concepts of morality a
This is the second book in the Isabel series I've read -- I can't remember any details from the first one, which is telling. I'm not sure why I read to the end of this book, since I ultimately found it to be very boring, but I'm glad I did, because it got better toward the end. My biggest complaint about this book is that I found Isabel to be incredibly irritating, self-righteous, and self-absorbed. I also didn't really believe in her -- her musings, particularly about sex and romance, have the ...more
This is the 8th book in the Isabel Dalhousie series. It is my least favorite. I was disappointed in the wandering of thoughts in Isabel's mind. Though she is a philosopher I felt the thoughts went too far afield for the scenes. It happened too many times and I got the feeling that the author was simply trying to fill the space. I really got bored with the musings.

There was too little interaction between Isabel and Jamie, and though they married at the end of the book and the wedding pages evoked
I love Isabel Dalhousie but it has been a while since I have read A Sunday Philosophy Club novel and I found this book a little more drawn out than McCall Smith's earlier books in the series. I did enjoy the read but didn't find it as humorous and the pace was a little slow.
Big sigh of relief that this was back up to AMS' usual standard.

Read & reviewed for The Bookbag.
I've been following Isabel and her adventures in Edinburgh with delight. Nothing much really happens, but you see things through her eyes - always trying to stick to her own ethics and not always succeeding. This trip into her life has her helping a fellow philosopher from Australia find her Scottish roots. Jane was a child of an unmarried college student whose parents (this was the early 60s) made her give up the child for adoption to a couple about to emigrate.
Jane's birth mother died in a ca
I read this Isabel Dalhousie at a bad time (poor Isabel): way too busy with school and holiday stuff, fighting off a stubborn, low key, but obnoxious cold, and intermingled with a few other books that are faster-moving than she ever is. For all those reasons, I didn't find this Isabel outstanding: too little, too slow, too much philosophy, too few points of human interest. My preoccupations aside, the book read as if McCall Smith ripped through writing it so he could get on to something else, an ...more
The Forgotten Affairs of Youth is a refreshing story told from a unique perspective. The main character, Isabel, a philosopher, shares her complex and sometimes rambling thoughts as she progresses through the daily challenges of life. She is so real and so human that sometimes it felt as if parts of the book were lifted from my own thoughts and experiences.

Isabel confronts common situations with tact and integrity such as dealing with her child learning foul words from another child, maintaining
I like Alexander McCall Smith. I haven't been able to get into all of his series but I like this one and the Number One Ladies.

However, after maybe 4 or 5 Isabel Dalhousie's maybe it's over?

The conceit of the series is that Isabel is a professional philosopher. She therefore thinks that her way of experiencing the world is more complicated than it is for non-philosophers. From the purchase of cheese to the revelation of a secret to returning a phone call, every choice is fraught with various mor
Reading one of the Isabel Dalhousie books is like visiting an old and dear friend. Just for a few days, I am taken away to Edinburgh and enjoying walks around town, visits to the deli owned by Isabel's niece, Cat, and sipping cups of tea in the warm, toasty kitchen. Each book is time to catch up. Isabel is an extremely likable character; she is smart, thoughtful, and has a rather exacting moral compass; she is full of common sense and filled with love for her family and country. Even though this ...more
Alexander McCall Smith's books remain favorite "cozy" reads, but this eighth installment in his "Sunday Philosophy Club" series, was the least satisfying of the Isabel Dalhousie books. Still here are the wonderful, small observations about life and relationships, the finely tuned writing, and the comfortable--meant in the best sense possible--characters, but the story was so lacking in plot and suspense, even by the easy standards of McCall Smith's "mysteries." The difficulties Dalhousie faces a ...more
A charming and more satisfying story than the last two previous book in this series, with a nice balance of philosophical thought and human interaction. So, although this feels more 3.5 on my personal scale, I will call it a 4, compared to the last book.

Once again, this is not a mystery but it is another little human puzzle with several little side stories and nice characters. Grace was not very prominent in this book and her situation offhandedly resolved. Cat is still an issue though, but she
Marti Wade
Not much happens in these books, but I enjoy following Isabel's flights of fancy and philosophical musings. Whether you will or not is likely a matter of personality.
I feel vaguely douchebagesque to rate a book I won for free on Goodreads (and a nice beautiful hardcover to boot!) so poorly. But in all fairness to honesty, I found very, very little to like in this book. Isabel is one of the most all around unlikable protagonists I’ve ever encountered. I felt like I was reading this book in a different language…I understood what has happening in the plot but I don’t understand WHY this character has reached such popularity, let alone enough for 8 books in a se ...more
Leila T.
Apparently I'm re-reading this book now, but since I don't remember reading it the first time and i didn't review it, here are some 2014 thoughts:

Casual racism within the first few pages. Repeated once or twice elsewhere in the book.

Tedious and not-interesting philosophizing.

One long yawn re: relationship between Isabel and Jaime.

Unrealistic depiction of a two-year-old, who is remarkably absent from his parents' lives/the book.

Caricatures of lesser, potentially more interesting characters.

Judi Mckay
I had to read this book as it was a book group choice. I hated it from the start. I thought it pretentious, I hated the style where everyone's thoughts are put into the text and I particularly disliked the philosophizing which Isabel does. The story would have been interesting as, say, a short story or novella and the group would have picked up on the philosophical issues raised; I felt they were being pushed at me. I will not be reading any of this series again. I have to say, tho, that I loved ...more
Reading these books reminds me of talking to my son, Dan, another philosopher. You start talking to him about one thing and then he kind of gets this blank stare as his mind goes on down many tangents until you are back to talking about "justice" or "ethics" again. I understand how Isabel's friends feel.

I enjoy these books; though they are gentle reads, they are not always easy reads. And Isabel is, as often before, caught several times in having to live up to her ethical high standards or find
This series has always walked a narrow path between cozy and boring, and this one takes an occasional step off in the direction of boring. It’s three parts philosophical musing to one part plot.

I still like the characters and the setting, and I still get a little thrill from the calm, reflective joie de vivre in Smith’s books. Isabel has an enviable life, which she knows and deeply appreciates.

Concerning the relationship between Isabel and Jamie: (view spoiler)
This book feels darker than previous novels in this series, and perhaps it's because the world has gotten darker--e.g., Grace's decision to invest her life savings in a stock that Isabel made a killing on because of Grace's recommendation via her spiritualist group, then losing it all when the stock tanks mimics events happening in the real world. There is a feeling of foreboding that permeates the novel--it's not as cozy as its predecessors, but it does leave this reader anxious to read the nex ...more
Goodness. I don't even know what to say about this book other than I see no point in continuing to read it. Nothing happens. A woman loves her husband, adores her son, has more money than she knows what to do with and rambles through her live randomly bumping into people while apparently not doing any work at all.

Some books are worth the read because the author uses prose so beautiful that you read it just for the pure pleasure of it. This is not one of these books. It's also not one I'll finish
This is the eighth book about Edinburgh-based philosopher and occasional sleuth Isabel Dalhousie. Reading this series, I sometimes wonder if Alexander McCall Smith has a little competition with himself when he writes each book, to see if he can get away with even less of a plot than in the previous installment. Certainly in this instance the main plot is very sparse and takes up maybe a quarter of the book. It's about Isabel helping an Australian philosopher who is tracking to track down her bir ...more

There is not much convincing to be done with a review of the 8th book in a series. Alexander McCall Smith is my literary palate cleanser -- and boy did I need one after a doozy of a previous read -- and with a trip to Isabel's hometown of Edinburgh, Scotland in my near future (never woulda thunk that when I started this series so many years ago!) it seemed no better time to pick up this next book in the series.

Alas, not much new to report and that's just the way I think fans of this series like
Alison C
The Forgotten Affairs of Youth is the 8th (9th if you count a short story, "The Perils of Morning Coffee," available only as an e-book) in the Isabel Dalhousie series by Alexander McCall Smith. Isabel is a philosopher living in Edinburgh, the owner and editor of the academic journal Review of Applied Ethics, and an independently wealthy woman in her early 40s who has a 2-year-old son, Charlie, along with a much younger boyfriend, Jamie, a somewhat high maintenance housekeeper, Grace, and a rathe ...more
Another Isobel Dalhousie novel set in Edinburgh. The author is very prolific and I'm thinking perhaps enough is enough. This chapter in the Dalhousie series feels like just more of the same, and I am getting tired of the main character's habit of applying her philosophy to every situation she encounters. The early books were so good and I really enjoyed the discussions of morality and ethics so it is rather disappointing to find that this one is less engaging than the others. However, it is sti ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Murder in Clichy (Aimee Leduc Investigations, #5)
  • River of the Dead (Cetin Ikmen, #11)
  • Malice in the Highlands (Erskine Powell, #1)
  • Elegy for Eddie (Maisie Dobbs #9)
  • The Kalahari Typing School for Men by Alexander McCall Smith Summary & Study Guide
  • A Rather Curious Engagement (Penny Nichols, #2)
  • Forever Friends (Hope Springs #3)
  • Glencoe The Story Of The Massacre
  • Fresh from the Country
  • A Christmas Grace (Christmas Stories, #6)
  • Chained to the Barbarian (Palace Brides #2)
  • A Dublin Student Doctor  (Irish Country #6)
  • The Cold Blue Blood (Berger and Mitry, #1)
  • Evernote for Dummies
  • Paging the Dead (A Family History Mystery, #01)
  • The Wedding Shawl (Seaside Knitters, #5)
  • The Sirens Sang of Murder (Hilary Tamar, #3)
  • Threats at Three
Alexander McCall Smith is the author of the international phenomenon The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series, the Isabel Dalhousie Series, the Portuguese Irregular Verbs series, and the 44 Scotland Street series. He is professor emeritus of medical law at the University of Edinburgh in Scotland and has served on many national and international bodies concerned with bioethics. He was born in what ...more
More about Alexander McCall Smith...

Other Books in the Series

Isabel Dalhousie (1 - 10 of 11 books)
  • The Sunday Philosophy Club (Isabel Dalhousie, #1)
  • Friends, Lovers, Chocolate (Isabel Dalhousie, #2)
  • The Right Attitude to Rain (Isabel Dalhousie, #3)
  • The Careful Use of Compliments (Isabel Dalhousie, #4)
  • The Comforts of a Muddy Saturday (Isabel Dalhousie, #5)
  • The Lost Art of Gratitude (Isabel Dalhousie, #6)
  • The Charming Quirks of Others (Isabel Dalhousie, #7)
  • The Uncommon Appeal of Clouds (Isabel Dalhousie, #9)
  • The Novel Habits of Happiness (Isabel Dalhousie, #10)
  • At the Reunion Buffet (Isabel Dalhousie, #10.5) (Isabel Dalhousie Novels)

Share This Book

“..."Charming people, when not actively shooting one another," a friend had once said, which was so unkind, but, like so many unkind comments, had a grain of truth in it. They did shoot one another and had been doing so for centuries. They did bicker over and brood on long-dead history--or history that should be long dead. The problem with history was that it refused to lie down and die.” 3 likes
“He seemed genuinely astonished. "You admire me?"

"Yes," she said gravely. "All of us do things we regret--that's part of being human. And sometimes, I think, moral quality reveals itself not so much in what we do, but in what we later say about what we have done....”
More quotes…