Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Art Criticism” as Want to Read:
Art Criticism
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Art Criticism

by
3.96  ·  Rating Details  ·  412 Ratings  ·  46 Reviews
This is the original free on-line edition and is no longer available. It was taken down for publication.

The entry for the published edition is HERE
.
ebook, 187 pages
Published August 25th 2010 by Self Published

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Art Criticism, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Art Criticism

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 811)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Ami
Jul 22, 2014 Ami rated it it was amazing
Recommended to Ami by: Kate
THIS IS REVIEW FOR THE FREE (AND NO LONGER AVAILABLE) VERSION

If this opinion is RAMBLING or GUSHY, I apologize beforehand.

This free story has been on my radar for awhile, since it IS listed on Favorite Unpublished M/M Stories. However, I haven't really given a lot of attention to online fiction before this time. It's only because I get the M/M slump over the published stories that I start to look for the free stuffs.

Written in 1st person POV (present tense), James is one of those neurotic chara
...more
Vio
Sep 16, 2012 Vio rated it really liked it
Recommended to Vio by: Td
4.5 stars
A wonderful surprise and a great free read. I'm so happy it was recommended to me because it was better than I expected, all due to the prickly voice of James and his very appealing sarcastic wit. I adored him and his weirdo ways, he might be a mess but what a cute mess and worth all the trouble. Turkish and James were an absolute hit for me and I loved their relationship woes, very entertaining. I was amused numerous times throughout, its a gem of find and even better than a lot of pub
...more
Mandapanda
Nov 19, 2014 Mandapanda rated it really liked it
3.75 stars. Free online romance about James, an uptight and very insecure art gallery assistant, and the cruisy, artistic, and very annoying Turkish.

The book starts off with some great scenes between James and Turkish, where Turkish (a photographic artist who is a client of the gallery) is being unreasonably demanding and James is having to suffer in silence and put up with his outlandish and absurd demands. But finally one day James has had enough and tells Turkish exactly what he thinks of his
...more
Td
Sep 09, 2012 Td rated it really liked it
Stories like this make me wonder why I don't explore online fic more often. A delightful story with a slow believable build-up and so much more. I felt like I truly got to know James and Turkish as they got to know each other and I couldn't help the big, goofy grins all throughout their story. It was fun, sarcastic, adorable and sweet...without the sap. An online gem.
Simsala
Nov 02, 2012 Simsala rated it really liked it
3,75 stars

Already several good and thought-out reviews here so I don`t have to...

I had a rocky start with Mr. Grumpy and Mr. Prima-Donna.
I thought the author tried too hard to make them opposites and went a bit overboard in their characterizations.
On top of that not a small amount of typos and kind of a hyphen-mania distracted me all through the first part of the story but it was nice (oh, the dreaded word...) enough to keep me reading.
Shortly after 50% it happened - I started giggling and late
...more
MsMiz (Tina)
Sep 16, 2012 MsMiz (Tina) rated it really liked it
Shelves: glbt-all, free
3.7 - At the end of this all, I absolutely loved it. The title is horrible, yet I understand it. James, you just want to hate him, but you know his snarky hate is just a protection mechanism and he really is a sweet socially inept geek that is just to smart. Turkish/Yusef is a shinning star, smarter than you think he is and just a delight. Would like him to be my friend. This story is uncomplicated and tells a plain old love story of James and Turkish. There are bumps and thank GOD Turkish is pa ...more
Deeze
Sep 18, 2012 Deeze rated it liked it
Mixed feelings on this one, more a 2.5


While I enjoyed parts of this story, I also found myself bored in places. James started off as a fun quirky guy, but then had bouts of whining that got a bit repetitive. Turkish was sweet but I found his use of the word man at the end of sentences didn’t fit with my image of him and brought to mind a laid back surfer rather than a high maintenance artist. But that’s a personal niggle.

Overall a sweet angst free story, with touches of humour from James, when h
...more
Miriam
It wasn't that memorable but I liked it. I just felt that there was more that could be done to highlight the good and bad points of Turkish's and James' relationship.

The main characters were great- Blue GhostGhost gave them a lot of depth. I could almost believe if I walked past an art gallery one day, I can see James and Turkish walking hand in hand. I liked them together even though they were complete opposites. James is this grumpy, commitment phobic guy who's extremely hard to impress while
...more
Bree Cheese
May 29, 2013 Bree Cheese rated it really liked it
Very sweet and straightforward free-online romance between a young gallery assistant and a high maintenance artist. Really great connection between the the two characters.
Bee
This is yet another story that hovers between four and five stars for me. I can’t quite put my finger on why I won’t give it that last star because the story is really good, and the writing too…but as always I go with my gut. It’s pretty close though, so don’t give this story a miss because of it!

James works in an art gallery. He’s not sure about what he wants to do with his future, and he’s not really happy where he is right now. He’s especially not happy with one of the artists he has to work
...more
Cindi
Aug 09, 2012 Cindi rated it it was amazing
Shelves: m-m, 2012, free, fanfiction
4.5 stars

I've been reading a lot of fanfiction lately and it seems like all of the stories I've read have centered around teenagers. This one (thankfully) did not.

James works at an art gallery. Turkish is a difficult photographer that James has to deal with a lot. James feels inadequate in his life and in regards to himself (no self-esteem) and his way of dealing with that is by coming across as rude to just about everyone. Turkish is laid back but a true pain when it comes to his photography. H
...more
SueM
A very good online M/M romance story featuring James, a nerdy art-history major with biting wit, and Turkish (Yusef), a photographic artist. They meet when James, working in a commercial art gallery, prepares Turkish's latest collection to be shown. Sparks fly when they meet, but not in a good way; Yusef comes across as a rather egotistical artist who is constantly changing his mind about how his pieces are to be named, framed, and placed, and as a result, drives James completely batty. Finally ...more
Anke
Jul 15, 2011 Anke rated it it was amazing
Awesome story line!!!! At first I though it would be super cliche and the photographer, Turk, would only be a really hot dude who was totally "Americanized", until I read the story and realized how much detail and research some stuff must have taken. This is a must read for anyone who loves a straightforward romance without too much crazy twists or anything. LOVED IT!!!
Alice
May 30, 2014 Alice rated it really liked it
Really, really good!

At first I didn't think I was going to like this book as both MCs came off as total prats, especially Turkish, who seem to be a bit up his own bum. Eventually though, I warmed to them both, as Turkish showed his sweeter side, and I couldn't help but be charmed by James and his geeky neuroticism.

Easy, fun read. Recommended

Sree
Mar 03, 2012 Sree rated it it was amazing
Amazing book. FUnny, lively and really lovable original characters. I loved Turkish. It takes talent to make a despised character come back and be awesome. i even loved James' grumpy self. The novella is too short IMHO.
Paris
Apr 05, 2013 Paris rated it it was amazing
Shelves: m-m, free-online
Two imperfects make it perfect.
A charming story of two people who are far from ideal but who manage to find their way to each others hearts.
Fangtasia
Nov 15, 2013 Fangtasia rated it really liked it
Lovely, sweet, inspiring, engaging, funny, and all-around enjoyable. A wonderful change of pace from my last read, which left me with a bad taste in my mouth.

Even though it suffers from most of the usual online fic's issues, lack of editing most of all, it's surprisingly well-written and not wordy or repetitive. Well paced, concise, lots of show and very little tell, quirky characters, behaving in believable ways. The conflict was brilliant, and brilliantly handled, too. See? It's not fluffy, bu
...more
Ari
Aug 02, 2012 Ari rated it really liked it
Shelves: mm-romance
OMG, THEIR LOVE STORY WAS JUST AWWWW...

I LOVE TURKISH & HIS LITTLE DUDE JAMES. THE FACT THAT TURKISH WAS MOSLEM MAKES ME LOVE HIM EVEN MORE. AND I LOVE HOW THE AUTHOR SEEMS KNOWS PRETTY WELL ABOUT MOSLEM CIRCUMTANCES.

Sarah_loves_books
ETA: This review is of the original, free online fic Art Criticism by Blue GhostGhost, a pen name of Celeste Spettro.

Original review:

I really loved this book!!!

James is an art gallery assistant, Turkish/Yusef is a photographer. So, just the kind of professions that interest me in a book. The story is told in first person from James' POV (except for the epilogue). But both characters come across very three-dimensional, they are real people with their little flaws, and their emotions are describe
...more
Suki Fleet
Mar 03, 2014 Suki Fleet rated it really liked it
Shelves: m-m
I'd actually never read any books set around the art world, and I found this a new and refreshing story, with great characters. Looking forwards to re reading when it is published officially.

Suki^^
Angel Pedroza
Jul 10, 2014 Angel Pedroza rated it really liked it
Enjoyed this romance very much. The hipster fem guy was very whiney at the beginning but the story was good enough to overcome my initial antipathy.
Zaa
This book was recommended to me by my friend, Ari (thanks gal!) and I'm glad I read this-- it was certainly worth the couple of hours I devoted to it -- it was really excellent.

Started reading this yesterday and I've just finished this morning. My general impression about the book, seriously, its simply awsome! The story is realistic. I liked the two main characters and thought they had good chemistry (enjoyed the banter between the two). Even the supporting characters are well written. Man! Th
...more
Camille
Aug 19, 2012 Camille rated it did not like it
The beginning of this is really funny. The main characters have superb enemy chemistry. And the reasons why James hates Turkish are illustrated well. But then the story goes to hell when the enemies become lovers and James, who was priorly snarky, insightful, funny and cute, suddenly turns into this complete neurotic basket case who is by turns inappropriately insulting and hostile or a timid virgin who jumps at his own shadow and behaves as if he has been molested in the past. At this point, th ...more
Alicia Nordwell
Sep 16, 2012 Alicia Nordwell rated it it was amazing
You know, sometimes I just flat out enjoy a story. I don't want to pick it apart or explain it; I just cruised through and zoned with this really good story. There were interesting characters and scenes that fit perfect to my current mood and I was shocked when I hit the end and realized it was all ready 11:30 pm. Okay, there were a few small editing issues, but frankly, I didn't care. I thought this was very well done and while not quite a 5, it was way more than a 4, so I went whole hog on the ...more
Cisccoutah
Sep 02, 2011 Cisccoutah rated it it was amazing
An amazing first novel from a very talented writer. The characters are sweet without ever becoming cloying and the tensions and conflicts never feel forced or contrived. The book's greatest strength is the way it incorporates themes of anxiety and cultural identity as important, but far from earth shattering, concerns as two people begin a relationship. The art world shop-talk is also hil-arious. Highly recommended.
Shelby
Mar 28, 2013 Shelby rated it really liked it
Super cute story. I enjoyed the back and forth between the two characters. My only criticism is a felt it ended rather quickly. I was just getting into the romance of the two when everything gets wrapped up almost immediately. I wanted to see more of them working out the details of their relationship and lives together.
~♥*Marianna*♥~
Mar 24, 2012 ~♥*Marianna*♥~ rated it it was amazing
Shelves: m-m, artist
This was just wonderful!
James is so funny with his grumpiness and shyness. Adorable.
Turkish is a lovely human being who had to use the sexiest little tricks to make James open up to him.
Not once did I find anything annoying about the plot or characters.

This story was pure happiness!
Ashley♥Alexis
Sep 19, 2012 Ashley♥Alexis rated it really liked it
Most of the nonphblished work i resd some of the most amazing stuff out there. This was brest. Loved it. I wouldn't change anything but I did see blog posts about a sequel and that would be amazing. I loved how the epilogue was told from Turkish's POV
Sian
Apr 14, 2012 Sian rated it really liked it
I loved this story. It takes a bit of work on the authors part to make a character that I really didn't like become one I adored, and it definietly worked here. Very straightforwards, almost simple romance, done very well. I just couldn't stop reading it.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 27 28 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Cold Turkey
  • El Presidio Rides North
  • It's Like This
  • Of sweaters and heartache
  • Pretty Shade of Grey
  • The Introspective Debate of Owen Brody
  • Like a Sparrow Through the Heart (Like a Sparrow, #1)
  • Muffin (Muffin #1)
  • Esperanza
  • The Doors of Time (The Doors of Time #1)
  • Falls Chance Ranch (Falls Chance Ranch #1)
  • Close Protection
  • Second Wind
  • Desert Dropping
  • Underlying
  • Shawn's Voice
  • Heart in Hand
  • Just Hit Send
4817447
My avatar is of Ajax and Eli from my WIP story Haunted City illustrated by the very talented Bliss41
More about Blue GhostGhost...

Share This Book



No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

“You think too much and I bet it kills the magic," he says simply. "Some things are just instinct and if you try and replace that with thinking they die. You can read and think as much as you want before and after, but in the moment, man, you have to, like, let go.” 6 likes
More quotes…