The Trumpet-Major
by
Thomas Hardy,
Simon Vance (Goodreads Author)
Hardy distrusted the application of nineteenth-century empiricism to history because he felt it marginalized important human elements. In The Trumpet Major, the tale of a woman courted by three competing suitors during the Napoleonic wars, he explores the subversive effects of ordinary human desire and conflicting loyalties on systematized versions of history. This edition
...moreAudiobook, 0 pages
Published
June 9th 2009
by Blackstone Audio, Inc.
(first published 1880)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,362)
Sad - It started out great, but I was angry at the turn it took.
I would agree with the fact that Anne, the heroine of the book is the least likeable of Hardy's. I couldn't sympathize with her actions and her course left me angry and frustrated.
Because of this, I don't know that I would ever re-read this book.
However, The Trumpet Major has some of the most lively and interesting characters of Hardy's creation as well. I absolutely loved Uncle Benji who almost seemed to have stepped out of a Dic...more
I would agree with the fact that Anne, the heroine of the book is the least likeable of Hardy's. I couldn't sympathize with her actions and her course left me angry and frustrated.
Because of this, I don't know that I would ever re-read this book.
However, The Trumpet Major has some of the most lively and interesting characters of Hardy's creation as well. I absolutely loved Uncle Benji who almost seemed to have stepped out of a Dic...more
The premise of The Trumpet-Major may sound lighthearted--indeed, such is the reason many contemporaneous critics embraced this novel--but the characters are so finely and deeply sketched, and the events so uniquely depicted, and the voice of the text so true that one soon sees how much richness this premise actually allows. And the wittiness! Not only from the droll voice-of-the-narrator Hardy, but also from characters like Simon Burden and Corporal Tullidge, who pop up like Rosencrantz and Guil...more
fraudio
napoleonic
war
1880
victorian
historical fic (believe this is the only foray into hist-fic that Mr Hardy made)
Unabridged; 10.7 hours; read by Simon Vance.
blurb - Anne Garland, who lives with her widowed mother in a mill owned by Miller Loveday, has three suitors: the local squire's nephew Festus and the miller's two sons, Robert and John. While Festus' aggressive pursuit deters the young woman from considering him as a husband, the indecisive Anne wavers between light-hearted Bob and gentle,...more
napoleonic
war
1880
victorian
historical fic (believe this is the only foray into hist-fic that Mr Hardy made)
Unabridged; 10.7 hours; read by Simon Vance.
blurb - Anne Garland, who lives with her widowed mother in a mill owned by Miller Loveday, has three suitors: the local squire's nephew Festus and the miller's two sons, Robert and John. While Festus' aggressive pursuit deters the young woman from considering him as a husband, the indecisive Anne wavers between light-hearted Bob and gentle,...more
This is quite an uncomfortable read for a Hardy. I wasn't sure why I felt it to be so until I read the excellent Introduction to this edition. It was perceived by readers at the time as a charming pastoral romance and the style was partly a response to the badly-reviewed 'Return of the Native' (a book I like a lot).
There are 3 sides to the book all of which take prominence at various times and result in the disjointed or uneasy feel.
The part that most readers would focus on is the romance 'quadr...more
There are 3 sides to the book all of which take prominence at various times and result in the disjointed or uneasy feel.
The part that most readers would focus on is the romance 'quadr...more
Anne Garland is quite possibly Hardy's least appealing heroine, which unfortunately makes this his least appealing novel. Status-conscious, shy, cold, boring beyond her years, with no apparent talents or hobbies, Anne finds herself the object of the affections of two working-class brothers as well as the heir of the kindly local squire.
Anne is unlike other 'Hardy Girls' and Hardy is unlike himself in this story. He more interested in the military maneuvers during the Napoleonic wars than he is...more
Anne is unlike other 'Hardy Girls' and Hardy is unlike himself in this story. He more interested in the military maneuvers during the Napoleonic wars than he is...more
This was the latest read for my online Hardy reading group – we are reading one book every two months chronologically. I’m a big Hardy fan – and I am so enjoying rediscovering the works I first fell in love with when I was between about eighteen and twenty. I do find though, that my memory of many of the actual plots has suffered greatly over the intervening years – that was certainly the case with The Trumpet Major. My one recollection was of military men in uniform, at the time of the Napoleon...more
Those who criticise this remarkable novel should really go back to school to find out why they are missing the point. It has never achieved the accolades that so many of Hardy's other novels have. Although I more than adequately could, I will not repeat the several other complimentary reviews which are on this site.
Suffice to say that 'The Trumpet Major' occupies an almost unique slot in the Hardy 'repertoire' in that, unlike many of his works (such as 'Jude', Far From The Madding Crowd and 'Te...more
Suffice to say that 'The Trumpet Major' occupies an almost unique slot in the Hardy 'repertoire' in that, unlike many of his works (such as 'Jude', Far From The Madding Crowd and 'Te...more
Having just read "A pair of Blue Eyes" I was hungry for a new Thomas Hardy novel. He doesn't write many these days; his fit of pique over the bad reaction to "Jude" has gone on long enough. This novel is less substantial and quite amusing. Having read it I realise that nothing actually happens! But the description of nothing actually happening is lovely.
Incidently, the French, (led by an Irish American called Tate but not including Bony) did invade Britain at this time - further round the coast...more
Incidently, the French, (led by an Irish American called Tate but not including Bony) did invade Britain at this time - further round the coast...more
I’d not heard of this Hardy novel but found it in a charity shop for 50p so thought it’d be worth getting. I have to say when I think of Hardy I rarely think of him as a laugh out loud author but this time I really was! There were parts that were simply hilarious, such as in the very beginning, “It should be stated that at this time there were two arch-enemies of mankind – satan as usual, and Buonaparte, who had sprung up and eclipsed his elder rival altogether. Mrs Garland alluded, of course,...more
I read one of the free Kindle ebook conversions. ASIN: B004UJI9NW
The conversion seemed fine to me. There were no new pages between chapters but it made no difference to my reading experience and I didn't notice any significant typos.
The story is based in a tiny village in Hardy's imaginary county of Wessex on the South coast of England. It centres around three men, all from the village, returning home to discover Anne - recently blossomed into womanhood and without a suitor. Clearly (and especia...more
The conversion seemed fine to me. There were no new pages between chapters but it made no difference to my reading experience and I didn't notice any significant typos.
The story is based in a tiny village in Hardy's imaginary county of Wessex on the South coast of England. It centres around three men, all from the village, returning home to discover Anne - recently blossomed into womanhood and without a suitor. Clearly (and especia...more
We are so used, these days, to books and drama being character-led that this plot-led book feels dated. The insipid heroine, Anne Garland, and the three men pursuing her read like cardboard cut-outs. Whenever Ann walks through the depths of the countryside, she mysteriously is accosted by one or other of the three men. This feels very contrived.
Yes, there are lots of misunderstandings but these could have taken place beween any four characters. The hero and heroine are sugar sweet, and the two v...more
Yes, there are lots of misunderstandings but these could have taken place beween any four characters. The hero and heroine are sugar sweet, and the two v...more
The Trumpet-Major is usually regarded as one of Hardy's lesser works but I found it enjoyable. The plot is a very 'small' one but as it slowly wends its way, you build-up a very detailed picture of rural life and the frenzy of the military preparations for war that grip the small community. In fact, the main character - The Trumpet-Major himself - doesn't arrive until well into the book, at which point the plot does gain a little pace. From there, it twists and turns with all possible romantic p...more
Hardy has written enough books to keep me happy for years now - and there are still more for me to read, thank goodness! There is something about him - an earthiness, a darkness, that makes his stories (which are always about the complications of human relationships, and explorations of human character weighed against fate) very satisfying and full, though not always happy. This one might be lighter than most, but I very much enjoy how he refuses to simplify relationships. I could say more, but...more
-Macmillan Readers.level 2.
-Time:09/19=30 mintes;09/21=60minutes.
-7 words summery:three boys/love/woman/war/victry/give up/goodbye
-Discussion question:
1.If you have a boyfriend(girlfriend) and he(she) decided to go to dangerous country for our country, what would you do?
;I think I stop him because we may not come back!!
2.How do you stay in touch, when contacting someone? Why do you use it?
;I always use e-mail because it is easy to contact with my firends and family:)
This book is love story, so i...more
-Time:09/19=30 mintes;09/21=60minutes.
-7 words summery:three boys/love/woman/war/victry/give up/goodbye
-Discussion question:
1.If you have a boyfriend(girlfriend) and he(she) decided to go to dangerous country for our country, what would you do?
;I think I stop him because we may not come back!!
2.How do you stay in touch, when contacting someone? Why do you use it?
;I always use e-mail because it is easy to contact with my firends and family:)
This book is love story, so i...more
This book is a typical Thomas Hardy book without so much drama. It is set on the southern shore of England during Napoleon's reign. They actually mention some of the English propaganda that was used to rally young men into defending England.
But, of course, this is a story of heartbreak. It has a happier ending than most of his books - perhaps all of his books. There is very little treachery in this one. So you can enjoy his splendid writing without the anguish of witnessing so much folly, terrib...more
But, of course, this is a story of heartbreak. It has a happier ending than most of his books - perhaps all of his books. There is very little treachery in this one. So you can enjoy his splendid writing without the anguish of witnessing so much folly, terrib...more
I really liked The Trumpet-Major and wish this was a better known Hardy book. Unlike most of Hardy's other works, it does not get bogged down in moral angst. Nobody drags around beating themselves to death over their decisions or lack of bravery.
There is a philosophical tone to this book and the idea one can do better. After all, this is Hardy and he can't help himself. But The Trumpet-Major carries a hopeful tone.
The main character, Anne Garland, is in the midst of a quadrangle of romance an...more
There is a philosophical tone to this book and the idea one can do better. After all, this is Hardy and he can't help himself. But The Trumpet-Major carries a hopeful tone.
The main character, Anne Garland, is in the midst of a quadrangle of romance an...more
This is Thomas Hardy's only historical novel, set in an English village during the Napoleonic Wars. The story line was okay (not Thomas Hardy's best) but I always enjoy reading/listening to Thomas Hardy's descriptions of life in a small English village. I listened to this on one of my favorite web sites: Libri Vox, where you can listen to hundreds of old classics for free. Because they're read by volunteers, some readers are much better than others, but it's a great website for anyone wanting to...more
The Trumpet-Major contains bundles of beautiful descriptions about location and rural life and it has a very interesting historical setting. Though it isn’t the melancholic, angst ridden Hardy that I'm familiar with. And Anne Garland is not someone I found myself particularly caring for. Regardless, there were a few great moments, especially towards the last 1/3 of the book. I'm not sure this story is going to linger with me but it was a good read while it lasted and I'm looking forward to readi...more
(Closer to 3.5, but I had to round down this time.)
The residents of Overcombe are thrilled when a troop of soldiers sets up camp on the outskirts of their village. Among the especially excited are a local miller who lives nearby, as well as his tenants, the widow Mrs. Garland and her daughter Anne. The miller's son, John Loveday, serves as able and celebrated trumpet-major of the dragoon, and his contentment at returning home for a time increases when he is reintroduced to young Miss Garland, no...more
The residents of Overcombe are thrilled when a troop of soldiers sets up camp on the outskirts of their village. Among the especially excited are a local miller who lives nearby, as well as his tenants, the widow Mrs. Garland and her daughter Anne. The miller's son, John Loveday, serves as able and celebrated trumpet-major of the dragoon, and his contentment at returning home for a time increases when he is reintroduced to young Miss Garland, no...more
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I read it for O level English Lit - ooooh, SO many years ago now. But it had exactly what I want from a Hardy novel. I've never bought into the "misery is good" atmosphere of Tess of the d'Urbervilles or Jude the Obscure. What I want from Hardy is fabulous descriptions of Wessex country life in the 1800s, great characterisation, one or two tangled love affairs and a sense of a world no longer here.
That is exactly what I got from this novel. The story is as good as...more
That is exactly what I got from this novel. The story is as good as...more
Hardy's only historical novel takes place in my favorite period of history, the Napoleonic Wars. His descriptions of calvary regiment bivouac procedures, drills, and the false alarm of a French invasion of the coast are superbly written and well worth the read. The title, on the other hand, is misleading, unless Hardy has an obsession with heroes being worthy of the name only by dying. The book could more readily be named "The First Lieutenant" or perhaps even better, "How Stupid Can a Girl Get?...more
A historic and Dorset view of the war with France around the time of Trafalgar. This very pedantry view of country life, love lost & found and the simple country view of simple people. Many aspects of history pop up in the story along with the detailed coming & goings of a simple mill owner and his extended and new family.
A pair of brothers fight of the love of a girl with great dignity and decorum. The older brother losses out completely and dies in battle.
A pair of brothers fight of the love of a girl with great dignity and decorum. The older brother losses out completely and dies in battle.
A bit different from the rest by Hardy. Lovers are still there, and the beloved, but when Ann marry Bob, and not his brother John, the trumpet major walks in the night's dark, while playing his trupet, so long that the tune fades in war fields in Spain!
یکی از چیزهایی که باعث می شود این اثر هاردی متفاوت جلوه کند، زمینه ی رمان است، دوره ی جنگ های ناپلئون، جنگ اما حضوری کم رنگ تر از عشق دارد، صحنه ی وقایع یک آسیاب است دور از میدان های جنگ، سربازها و کارگران جنگ هستند، حتی شیپورچی، جنگ اما در زمینه...more
یکی از چیزهایی که باعث می شود این اثر هاردی متفاوت جلوه کند، زمینه ی رمان است، دوره ی جنگ های ناپلئون، جنگ اما حضوری کم رنگ تر از عشق دارد، صحنه ی وقایع یک آسیاب است دور از میدان های جنگ، سربازها و کارگران جنگ هستند، حتی شیپورچی، جنگ اما در زمینه...more
I liked this book for the style of prose that only Thomas Hardy can deliver. His details of the rich countryside brought to life this story of a miller, his two sons, one who became a trumpet major in the military and the other a sailor. This is a fascinating book, I have read other Hardy books but this one felt much more contemporary due to its subject matter. A book worth reading.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Jun 05, 2008
Jennifer
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
fans of Thomas Hardy and complicated romances
I nearly put this book down for good around page 50 because it gets off to a slow start, but in the end, I'm so glad I finished it. Like other reviewers have said, this novel is a bit different for Hardy. It is a comic-romantic tale set against the historical reality of the Napoleonic wars. I would call it a book about a love triangle, but it's more like a love hexagon. There are lots of funny moments, which struck me as odd compared to Hardy's other novels, and very rarely did I sympathize with...more
I stayed with it to the end, but The Trumpet-Major didn’t hold my attention very well. The various characters were each believable in their own right, but I didn’t like the heroine very much; she was wishy-washy, self-centered, and uninteresting. The one major character I did like did not receive due rewards for his good character. There just wasn’t much to the story other than wondering who the heroine would end up with. It was intriguing to get a glimpse into the life of the English in a time...more
While I enjoyed Hardy's foray into historical fiction, I didn't think it a particularly note-worthy novel. It certainly shed an interesting light on the home-front attitudes and fears of the 'Wessex' people living along the coast in the early years of the Napoleonic wars. With a decent enough plot, the novel keeps the reader's interest, and also has some truly comic moments and characters. Having said this though, I am very glad that I read it; after all, Thomas Hardy wrote it. A solid three sta...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Thomas Hardy, OM, was an English author of the naturalist movement, although in several poems he displays elements of the previous romantic and enlightenment periods of literature, such as his facination with the supernatural. Though he regarded himself primarily as a poet and composed novels mainly for financial gain. The bulk of his work, set mainly in the semi-fictional land of Wessex, delineat...more
More about Thomas Hardy...
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...

Loading...

























Aug 23, 2011 11:37am