Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Not a Fan: Becoming a Completely Committed Follower of Jesus” as Want to Read:
Not a Fan: Becoming a Completely Committed Follower of Jesus
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Not a Fan: Becoming a Completely Committed Follower of Jesus

4.26 of 5 stars 4.26  ·  rating details  ·  14,568 ratings  ·  773 reviews
Are you a follower of Jesus? Don't answer too quickly. In fact, you may want to read this book before you answer at all. Consider it a 'Define the Relationship' conversation to determine exactly where you stand. You may indeed be a passionate, fully devoted follower of Jesus. Or, you may be just a fan who admires Jesus but isn't ready to let him cramp your style. Then agai ...more
Paperback, 215 pages
Published June 1st 2011 by Zondervan (first published May 6th 2011)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Not a Fan, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Not a Fan

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Jul 21, 2013 Lori rated it 1 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: no one
I read this book because my son's girlfriend gave it to him. It's just another book written by another well meaning believer who thinks he has the "to-do list" of an A+ believer in Jesus Christ. In reality what he is spreading is not the Christian way of life but religion. His list includes not having sex, working in soup kitchens, going on mission trips, etc... All these things are fine if they are produced BECAUSE we have a spiritual life. They should never be presented as what we will do as e ...more
Jason Lilly
I am not a fan of Jesus. This book is so powerful and so convicting, I felt uncomfortable reading it. But that is exactly the point. Christianity has become too comfortable and too safe. Christians view following Jesus as getting saved, attending church services, praying before meals and before bedtime, reading some devotionals, listening to Christian music. These things are great, but what truly defines being a follower of Jesus is sacrifice. Jesus demonstrated pure love by giving up his life a ...more
May 16, 2013 Julie rated it 2 of 5 stars
Recommended to Julie by: Vaughn
One reviewer sadly commented after reading this book, "I guess I don't measure up." I would like to encourage her by saying "Of course, you don't. None of us 'measures up.' We are all sinners and that is why Jesus had to do it all. He loves you even though he knows you don't measure up."

I am afraid that for some readers this book may teach that there are two kinds of Christians--lazy pew sitters and radical foreign missionaries. Each chapter ends with an inspiring example of someone who is livi
Kim T.
Not A Fan is a bold, in-your-face book that aggressively packs a punch. It confronts anyone daring enough to ask the question, “Am I a fan or am I a follower?” From the jump, the book holds nothing back, and it asks the reader to define her relationship with Christ. It will challenge, affront, influence, and very definitely impact you as a Christian.

Rating: 5/5 Stars *****
Clark Goble
I was fortunate to read Idleman’s book immediately after Tozer’s The Pursuit of God. I say this because “Not a Fan” is the perfect counterpart to Tozer. Idleman challenges the reader to identify themselves as a follower of Christ or a mere fan and presents the argument that many who identify themselves as the former are actually the latter.

Idleman presents a wonderful argument against the “cheap” Christianity that runs rampant in the Church and encourages his readers to “get to a place where fol
There were some points in this book that I did not agree with, but at the end of the day, it did make me question where the priorities in my life were. However, I do need to say that I would not give this book to a new Christian. The theology is a little confusing. I am, of course, basing this opinion on what I have learned and truly believe. I do believe that we are saved through the grace of God through belief in Jesus as our savior. I am not a big expert on the Bible, but I think it says some ...more
Miss Me.
Jul 17, 2011 Miss Me. rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: People seeking to find God.
Shelves: high-rated
This book is excellent for anyone who's sick and tired of the mundane Christian life. This is a book that encourages you to not just claim to be a Christian, but to be a follower of Christ's teachings. Anyone can say that they are a "Christian" but to actually live a life that emulates who God truly is.

I was hoping for a Francis Chan type of teaching from this book. But even though this book wasn't an in depth challenge to me, it did serve as a good reminder of what it means to be a Christian.

There are couple things that were said that I didn't completely agree with, but overall, I feel this is a great book to get you really thinking about your relationship with God. Am I "all-in"? Am I committed? Am I a fan, or an "enthusiastic admirer," that is running lukewarm for Christ, instead of on fire?

At the beginning of this book, I would answer wholeheartedly that I am a follower of Christ. In all honesty, this book revealed to me that I'm not 100% completely committed. When I'm honest, I
I had to wait for quite awhile for this book to trickle down to Bookman's, so I was really happy to see it the last time I was there. This is a quick read with challenging thoughts for those of us who have spent a lifetime trying to figure out the equation. Man + Faith In Christ = not quite enough? Idelman's examples of "following" seem to set up a new list of to-do's. Or not to-do's. I consider it done, and not by me. It's not my intention to get into a spiritual debate here...but I will spend ...more
A good review of this book

There are some good points and also some problems with this book. The author basically teaches the "surrendered life" which is nothing new. DA Carson's associate Andy Naselli wrote his doctoral dissertation about this movement called "Keswick" or "Higher life" sanctification and you can read a presentation of it here:

I was completely unaware of this model of sanctification until my early 2
This book's popularity is well-deserved. The text has just the right amount of quotable lines (that have you reaching for your pen to copy them down) but not enough to seem gimmick-driven. The examples/metaphors are simple, effective, accessible. The occasional moments of humor are genuinely funny (and never distract from the message of the text). The arguments are supported/spotlighted with quotes from Scripture. The narration is appropriately confessional, encouraging, yet challenging.

You get
Tanara McCauley
Got your church T-shirt? Your “Jesus is my co-pilot” bumper sticker? What about your WWJD bracelet?

Bible? Check! Some verses memorized? Check! Personalized tithe envelopes? You know this maaan!

Okay, okay. Now what about Jesus? You’ve got all the paraphernalia–the outward stuff that clothes you with the Christian image–but do you really have Jesus? Are you a fan, or are you a follower?

Uhhhhhhh……………..what you talkin’ bout Willis?

Willis isn’t here. But if you want to know what I’m talking about, pi
Kara Larson

Listened to this in the car on the way to work. Full of convicting statements that I wish I could have underlined, so I may read it again eventually to remind myself. One thing I have been meditating on is that true followers are slaves. Dedicated 24/7, 100% to the cause of the master. Fans may know much about Jesus, but followers know Jesus.
I do wish there was more emphasis on the gospel power enabling us to follow the way we should. After all, without Christ we are dead and can't follow Him.
Read this book and attended a bible study where we watched the videos. Book great for those in church who want to work to move towards a greater commitment to God in their lives.

Thought this book was great and revolutionary - until I came to the part where they tell the girl she can't become a member of the church because she was living with her boyfriend. I understand, within the institution there has to have rules and regulations in order for things to run properly. But what about the girl's s
This book made me sick. I am not a fan and I don't claim to be a follower. I am a fan of books like this because I just don't like the whole "grace only" belief and "repeat after me and you get eternal life" movement. I really thought I would like this book and it would get me all psyched up about becoming a "real christian" but it made me sick from the beginning.
I thought a fan was going to be described as a one of those people that live however they want but if you ask them, they claim they a
Sarah Walker
absolutly amazing. one of those life changing reads. I am not a fan...I am a follower. I will definitly reread this book.
I started reading this in December. It has challenged me and how I live.

One of the most challenging scriptures in the Bible for me has always been, "Many will say to me 'Lord, Lord didn't I cast out demons in your name, healed the sick in your name, raised the dead in your name.' But I will say to them, 'get away from me for I never knew you.'" Kyle takes this verse and challenges us to not just be a fan of Jesus. Kyle wants us to become a Follower of Christ.

A fan is someone who likes Jesus and
Kayla Warner
This book had some really spot-on Biblical information and incredible accompanying verses. The author, Kyle Idleman, wrote in a way that had humor and heart. However, of course there were some little things that I disagreed with but overall the message of being not a fan but a true committed follower of Christ was inspiring. But one of the only things that I found kind of distracting about this book is that it was written by a pastor. Which, don't get me wrong, devoted pastors have boatloads of ...more
Sometimes I wonder if it is hard to find my recommendations credible when I am excited about a book. Someone might think, "You love every book you read, Amy." Not true, my friends. Not true. I am a critical reader, and when I come across something that I think is of value and worth in Christian literature, you better believe I am going to recommend it loudly. Not a Fan by Kyle Idleman is worth a VERY LOUD proclamation of "two thumbs up" or four thumbs up, if I had them. Not a Fan asked me some d ...more
Todd Wilhelm
This book is an appeal to be totally committed to Christ, or as the author states "all-in." This total commitment is described as being a follower of Christ over against a fan of Christ. Thus the title. The book is written in today's english and will probably appeal to a large segment of American Christians, but I doubt the book will have "staying" power. It reminds me of an expanded version of the little pamphlet written years ago titled "My Heart: Christ's Home" by Robert Munger in that it is ...more
This book made me think. Hard. That's a big part of the reason as to why I gave it 5 stars.
Breaking it down:

+ Nice voice and great descriptions and examples. I loved Kyle's comparisons of Bible concepts and stories to real life instances. As a plus, the real life instances were almost always funny!
+ (somewhat restating from previous bullet) Humor was very enlightening. Good comic relief for some of the heavy topics considered in this book, but still caused some deep thinking for me, no matter ho
Austin Rich
The purpose of the book is completely and entirely biblical. "Examine yourselves to see whether you are in the faith; test yourselves..." - 2 Corinthians 13:5. Idleman attempts to expose the areas of our lives that are not in submission to Christ as a way of furthering our obedience to God. Great! Amen! But Idleman unintentionally encourages legalism by not focusing on the motivation for our obedience. For example, we SHOULD be living lives of righteousness and holiness. We SHOULD be true follow ...more
Reading the reviews has actually really surprised me. This book is very good. It is not meant to be a guideline to follow in a means to measure up a person’s walk with Christ. If that is what you got out of it or if that is what you believe it is you missed the point completely. The author is trying to show that we need to have a personal relationship with God. That if we call ourselves Christians or followers of Christ, and then we should definitely act differently than others who don’t. I don' ...more
This book was one of the most phenomenal books I have ever read. It was truly inspirational and begged for a follow up action in response to reading the book--which is exactly what the writer's intention was. The main premise of the book was addressing this central quesiton: are you a fan or a follower of Christ? Kyle Idleman, the talented and thought-provoking author, argues that even we who think we are following Christ may realistically fall into the category of a fan: that is, an "enthusiast ...more
I read this book as I have never read any of the well-known books in the Christian section. I didn't enjoy the first few chapters at all. I actually restarted several times until I finally got to about chapter 6, and then I was diggin it. Idleman does challenges the reader to really think about their relationship with God. Many people are fans. Why? It's easy. It's the norm. As long as you go to church, your a Christian to many people. You can be involved in every event with God in the descripti ...more
George Hunger
This book by Kyle Idleman is easy to read and written in a casual context that many people will no doubt relate to. He calls Christians to examine their walk with Christ, separating fan from follower. He holds the bar high and does a great job calling people to being completely committed to the call of Christ. For this I gave it two stars...but many may be asking why I didn't rate the book higher.

As I read the book, I kept wondering when he was going to address the source of man's problem and th
There is a difference between a fan of Jesus and a follower of Jesus. With scripture, a story and sprinkled with humor, you start to see yourself more of a fan than a follower. We are easily fooled into thinking that we are a follower but instead we are just a fan. We have to be careful with the church that we attend that the church help our quest to be followers not just believers. The message is believe instead of, repent, die to self, surrender, and commitment. Jesus is asking us daily for ou ...more
Had some good points, but throughout most of the book he made it sound like if you aren't adopting kids from other countries/going on mission trips in other places/spending every single second at work praying w/ people etc., that you're doing it wrong.

Especially had issues w/ the mission trips suggestion, as instead of paying to go on the trip yourself to build houses/whatever, you'd be doing more good by just sending the money to the organization who could then hire locals to build houses etc.
This was an excellent book filled with Biblical truths and examples of why we must remove ourselves from ourselves and be able to have the willingness to seriously follow Jesus instead of being one who believes without making sacrifices of self. At first this book gave me a weird taste of the author being a bit prideful, but he ended up humbling himself and made the book far more interesting as I continued to read it. There were a few reminders which I had already felt past convictions over, cau ...more
Really thought provoking and very good stuff here that makes you think about your life with God to the point where you might get very uncomfortable with your life and think about how to change things (this is a good thing, I promise).

The only thing I didn't like were the totally irrelevant "funny" footnotes. One or two random funny footnotes might have been okay and gotten a chuckle out of me for the cleverness, but when I see a little asterisk -call me crazy- I have an expectation that my eyes
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Christian Readers: "Not a Fan" by Kyle Idleman 5 35 Apr 04, 2013 04:53PM  
  • The Christian Atheist: Believing in God But Living as If He Doesn't Exist
  • Radical Together
  • Erasing Hell: What God Said about Eternity, and the Things We've Made Up
  • Unchristian: What a New Generation Really Thinks about Christianity...and Why It Matters
  • The Resolution for Women
  • Grace: More Than We Deserve, Greater Than We Imagine
  • Sun Stand Still: What Happens When You Dare to Ask God for the Impossible
  • The Hole in Our Gospel: What Does God Expect of Us? the Answer That Changed My Life and Might Just Change the World
  • I Am Second: Real Stories. Changing Lives.
  • Anything: The Prayer That Unlocked My God and My Soul
  • Who Do You Think You Are?: Finding Your True Identity in Christ
  • Grace for the Good Girl: Letting Go of the Try-Hard Life
  • Stop Asking Jesus Into Your Heart: How to Know for Sure You Are Saved
  • Stuff Christians Like
  • Beautiful Outlaw: Experiencing the Playful, Disruptive, Extravagant Personality of Jesus
  • Respectable Sins: Confronting the Sins We Tolerate
Gods at War: Defeating the Idols That Battle for Your Heart Not a Fan: Teen Edition AHA: The God Moment That Changes Everything Not a Fan Follower's Journal Gods at War Student Edition: The battle for your heart that will define your life

Share This Book

“There is no life without death.” 21 likes
“Following Jesus will cost you something. Following Jesus always costs something.” 12 likes
More quotes…