The Fatal Gift of Beauty: The Trials of Amanda Knox
The sexually violent murder of twenty-one-year-old British student Meredith Kercher in Perugia, Italy, on the night of November 1, 2007, became an international sensation when one of Kercher’s housemates, twenty-year-old Seattle native Amanda Knox, as well as her Italian boyfriend and a troubled local man Knox said she “vaguely” knew, was arrested and charged with the murd...more
Hardcover, 306 pages
Published
August 2nd 2011
by Broadway
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
738)
I had hesitated to read this. Being and even other more minor but equally trumped up questions seemed to require better notice. But this happened to involve the girl in my back yard. She was an existentialist's nightmare about a daytime drama. And she would put reason to sleep with her sharp guttery eyes. Existentialism is to be damned and she was in crisis mode. I learned from this pretty shitty book that she made choices, sure enough. Man, that girl made some fatalistic gestures at the wild co...more
A compelling, riveting read.
Burleigh took her time to research and explain the cultural / historical context that both Meredith Kercher and Amanda Knox came to meet during their study abroad experiences; which was incredibly helpful in terms of understanding how sexuality, college life, grief, etc could be (mis)construed by the different nationalities involved. It was chilling to imagine the dark side of getting "lost in translation", and, ultimately terribly sad to accept that what actually ha...more
Burleigh took her time to research and explain the cultural / historical context that both Meredith Kercher and Amanda Knox came to meet during their study abroad experiences; which was incredibly helpful in terms of understanding how sexuality, college life, grief, etc could be (mis)construed by the different nationalities involved. It was chilling to imagine the dark side of getting "lost in translation", and, ultimately terribly sad to accept that what actually ha...more
I am utterly fascinated frighteningly obsessed interested to a normal degree about true crime. Accordingly, I am an avid watcher of Dateline and 48 Hours and any other show that spends an hour in the dark heart of man. Being a criminal defense attorney, I suppose I could chalk it up to curiosity. But that would be a lie. In truth, I have a fever, and the only cure is more Keith Morrison.
I’ve been following the Amanda Knox murder trial for years, now. I first saw it on a primetime special, when...more
I’ve been following the Amanda Knox murder trial for years, now. I first saw it on a primetime special, when...more
This book should have been about 125 pages instead of over 300! I'm not happy with the detailed backround history of every policeman, judge, witnesses etc. as well as the total history of Italy. The timeline and revealing of the actual murder doesnt even happen until page 175 but I was already invested that far so I had to keep going.
The difference in handling legal matters in the US compared to Italy is appaling at best. The fact that they originally convicted Amanda purely on heresay, and the...more
The difference in handling legal matters in the US compared to Italy is appaling at best. The fact that they originally convicted Amanda purely on heresay, and the...more
Nina's book is more about what JUSTICE is and isn't than an in depth look at those who were involved or trapped in the events - having said that I feel Nina did a superb job in presenting the personhood of Amanda - more to the point how Amanda's individuality sunk her ever deeper into the prejudices of the Italian justice system - and no, I don't believe for even one moment that our own fractured partisan judicial system is one whit better - this book strikes a more universal tone - Umbria serve...more
Nov 03, 2011
University of Chicago Magazine
added it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
humanities-division
Nina Burleigh, AM'87
Author
"Foxy Knoxy,” the Italian and British media call her. Voted the 2009 Woman of the Year in an Italian television-news poll, Amanda Knox, then a 22-year-old University of Washington undergrad on a year abroad in Perugia, was also labeled a “luciferina” and a “dirty-minded she-devil” by a Perugian prosecutor, in his closing statements during her trial for the murder of her British roommate, Meredith Kercher. Convicted in December 2009, Knox was sentenced to 26 years in pri...more
Author
"Foxy Knoxy,” the Italian and British media call her. Voted the 2009 Woman of the Year in an Italian television-news poll, Amanda Knox, then a 22-year-old University of Washington undergrad on a year abroad in Perugia, was also labeled a “luciferina” and a “dirty-minded she-devil” by a Perugian prosecutor, in his closing statements during her trial for the murder of her British roommate, Meredith Kercher. Convicted in December 2009, Knox was sentenced to 26 years in pri...more
I think I am in the minority with my feelings on this book. I did not love this book. I knew next to nothing about Amanda Knox and the horrible crime that she was found guilty of. Normally when you read a true crime book you learn so much more about the crime and the people involved. I did not find that to be the case with this book. I finished it not knowing anymore than I did when I started it.
The author did a lot of research and the book is filled with information but for me, it seemed like u...more
The author did a lot of research and the book is filled with information but for me, it seemed like u...more
I have not read other books on this trial so I can’t fairly compare this book to those previously published. I can, however, offer my review of this as a standalone title. From the beginning, the author paints the idyllic with lyric prose and then quickly gets to the brutality of the murder. This balance between beauty and violence seems to be the running theme throughout the entire book. For those that have trouble reading non-fiction and stick to novels, this would be a good book to get your f...more
Nina Burleigh's true crime tome on the murder of Meredith Kercher and the subsequent trial of Amanda Knox in Perugia, Italy, in 2007 is interesting, though not particularly well-constructed. The first half of the book is a somewhat rambling series of vignettes describing the central players in the story, the history of Perugia, and the Masonic movement - in no discernible order,leaving the reader with lots of apparently unconnected information that one needs to self-organize. Then the chronologi...more
This book is not a flimsy true crime book, the kind that relies on rumor and previously published work. Burleigh did some serious research--historical, social, personal, forensic, and geographic. She provides immense background on all the major players and places, while also keeping a compelling narrative pace. This reads like a novel whose ending I unfortunately already know.
Amanda, Raffaele, Meredith, Rudy, and Mignini are all fully formed, cast as real people with real motives and life stori...more
Amanda, Raffaele, Meredith, Rudy, and Mignini are all fully formed, cast as real people with real motives and life stori...more
This book is not what I expected. I expected it to be about Amanda and the trial. It is so much more. Yes the book discusses Amanda and some of the things she went through before the trial. Just a few things were said about the actual trial. Most people followed it while it was happening so you probably do not need the play by play of the trial.
This instead is a look at all the players in the case. The Judge,Amanda, Raffelle, Rudy, Meridith, the roommates, the Magistrate who serves as prosecutor...more
This instead is a look at all the players in the case. The Judge,Amanda, Raffelle, Rudy, Meridith, the roommates, the Magistrate who serves as prosecutor...more
Not having much advance knowledge of the murder conviction of Seattle student Amanda Knox in Italy, I had few expectations of this book. There seem to be two underlying themes: First, that Europeans generally find it impossible to believe any human being could be so naive and trusting as Amanda Knox appears, so she must be faking it. Second, that the Italian legal system seems to be simply a contest to see which side tells a more convincing story about the case and not necessarily concerning fac...more
I'm not a super avid reader of true crime, but I went through a period where I read all the "classics". Most of those stories revolve around one of two things: a strange and interesting crime or a strange and interesting killer. This story has neither, which may be why some people found it disappointing.
If you know anything about the case, you know that Amanda Knox is almost certainly not guilty. This was a brutal, albeit straightforward crime, and it makes absolutely no logical sense that she...more
It's total coincidence that I read this as the Amanda Knox appeal was being decided, but it was a neat tie-in. Obviously, people are falsely accused of crimes every day, only a small minority of whom are pretty white college girls, but the Knox case is still wholly terrifying - this idea that people have just decided that you committed a crime despite the lack of any real evidence to the contrary.
Burleigh overstates her case somewhat - there's probably about 10% too much talk about how much Ama...more
Burleigh overstates her case somewhat - there's probably about 10% too much talk about how much Ama...more
I started this book thinking it was be much more of a straight-forward, data-fueled read, but was surprised when it went much more in-depth than that. It looked at the culture and the people involved, more than just a presentation of the evidence.
I was completely engrossed in the book, sometimes rereading parts several times over so I could be sure I had the right image in my head. There was mention of Amanda's life in Seattle and what her friends thought of her personality and character. The bo...more
I was completely engrossed in the book, sometimes rereading parts several times over so I could be sure I had the right image in my head. There was mention of Amanda's life in Seattle and what her friends thought of her personality and character. The bo...more
I am going to quote a few passages from this book before I write my own comments and opinions. 1) "Taken together, the writings confirmed one thing only: the girl's absence of gravitas. Was she simply, as her Seattle friends and family always insisted, trustful, naive to an almost otherworldly level? Or was she, as those who assumed she killed Meredith believe, masking evil behind a screen of pink hearts and flowers?" This is one of the central questions that one has to answer. Let's not forget...more
I'm not someone who typically reads "true crime" books or books on trials, but this case really captivated me. I hadn't followed the trial and really only picked up on the story the day of the verdict in October. But I found myself fixated on the nightmare of being falsely accused in a foreign country, miles from home, so young and with a limited grasp of the language. Aside from that, once the details of the absolute injustice involved in this particular case surfaced, I became even more intrig...more
I followed the Amanda Knox case with great interest, and didn't buy the notion put out there in the US media that she was an "innocent abroad" victimized by a foreign justice system. Having had enough of my own college roommate drama to fill my own book, I could understand how such conflict could escalate, and rich, white girls who benefit from a social bias can be pretty wretched.
Thus I started this book with the bias that Amanda Knox was guilty, despite having a savvy media pr machine at her...more
Thus I started this book with the bias that Amanda Knox was guilty, despite having a savvy media pr machine at her...more
"...truth will come to light; murder cannot be hid long; a man's son may, but at the length truth will out." So, Shakespeare tells us and it appears to be the case with the tragic death of Meredith Kercher. This is a very well organized, written and researched account of murder in Perugia, Italy. If you are interested in crime in general or this crime in particular, this is book should be your first stop. Nina Burleigh dug so deeply into the Perugian soil she probably disturbed a few Etruscan gr...more
I am a great fan of non-fiction true crime thus I was eager to read this since the accused Amanda Knox is currently in the news as her case is being reviewed by the Italian courts. Knox is a Seattle native, a junior at Univ of Wash who decides to take her junior year in Florence. She is barely settled in the town of Perugia with three female roomates in an old stone cottage, enrolls in the University for Foreigners and quickly gets caught up in the night life. Within weeks she has a boyfriend an...more
I am tempted to blame myself for not being a careful enough reader to really get a lot out of this book. I was on vacation, and didn't feel like taking notes. Maybe I need for things to be stated a little more directly-- was Amanda Knox involved in the murder of her housemate? After reading the book, I have no idea. Seems like Burleigh goes round and round saying this bit of evidence was fabricated and that bit was just plain wrong. . . but why did Knox lie repeatedly about the events of the eve...more
I will review this more when I o to my own blog but this is one of the very books, that A) I skipped through some of and B) I gave up on. First, I skipped parts because if I wanted to read a book on the COMPLETE history of the town, or the formation of the Freemasons or any other of the many side roads this author took I would get a book ON that subject. Ultimately I stopped reading when I came to the realization that not only is it nearly impossible to find accurate information about this case...more
I had high hopes for this book, which sadly didn't materialize. Although I enjoyed the writing, and I am generally in favour of indepth character studies and background information, I have to agree with other reviewers on here, there is such a thing as too much information, especially when it leaves you not really knowing all that much in the end. One gets to know Amanda Knox, at least on some level, but who was Meredith? What was their relationship like? There are allusions to quarrels between...more
I chose this out of a compulsion to know more and somewhat sheepishly, fearing an exploitative, slapdash effort. Surprise, surprise it is a fairly well written exploration of culture clash and the changing perception of Americans abroad. Bruleigh avoids the salacious and gruesome aspects of the case for the most part and steps out of the courtroom to paint a careful portrait of Italy, Perugia, Seattle and all of the principals. There are no clear cut answers, however. In some sense the media han...more
This book, while detailed, misses the mark. What's really missing, perhaps because there is no way to get the info., is a real picture of Amanda Knox (and of the victim), or the other convicted young adults. I saw signs that might have indicated mental illness issues that would have been a natural focus of defense attorneys in the US but that were ignored in the Italian legal process. In the end, though the physical evidence leads me to suspect that Amanda and her boyfriend were not involved in...more
The story of Italy and Amanda Knox. Pretty detailed about Perugia and student life there. It kind of makes me sick to think of all these girls on their own drinking, drugging, having sex with lots of boys, going to an occasional class. No wonder they get in trouble. Amanda's problem is that her emotions are inappropriate to the situation, and recognizing reality is not her strong point. I think the more interesting story would be that of Rudy, the guy who actually did the crime, and many others....more
Given that the case was overturned in the Amanda Knox case, this book will be of interest to most people. The book starts really slow, with an unpolished introduction of the "characters" involved -- most of which were people I didn't care to know about. I had to slog through the first few chapters to get to the details that I haven't already read in news and magazine articles. It's a well-researched book, but could have used a bit more editing. For a public library, this is a must-have to get a...more
Excellent research, excellent writing. One of the best true crime books I've read this year, and another chilling example of coerced confessions wreaking havoc on the justice system, not to mention on the personal lives of the people involved. A tragedy all the way around, the Amanda Knox case is fascinating, especially in the hands of this accomplished author. Nina Burleigh's investigative work takes on not only the issue of false confessions, but xenophobia, cultural disconnect, and misogyny....more
I started this book before the latest judges ruling, that allowed Amanda to come home. The case is fascinating for a lot of reasons and I was watching the trial even before I knew about the book.
The story comes complete with a map of Perugia, the town where the killing happened. And Burleigh spends a lot of time setting the stage for the trial.
She visits Seattle and writes about her upbringing, the divorce of her parents, her high school year and the circumstances that led her to become this int...more
The story comes complete with a map of Perugia, the town where the killing happened. And Burleigh spends a lot of time setting the stage for the trial.
She visits Seattle and writes about her upbringing, the divorce of her parents, her high school year and the circumstances that led her to become this int...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »

Loading...






















" The sun shined on this fatal girl and she's back...more
Mar 27, 2013 11:15am