Christmas at Cold Comfort Farm (Cold Comfort Farm)
WITH AN INTRODUCTION BY ALEXANDER MCCALL SMITH
A glorious collection of stories from the author of Cold Comfort Farm. The title story tells of a typical Christmas at the farm before the coming of Flora Poste. It is a parody of the worst sort of family Christmas: Adam Lambsbreath dresses up as Father Christmas in two of Judith's red shawls. There are unsuitable presents, unp...more
A glorious collection of stories from the author of Cold Comfort Farm. The title story tells of a typical Christmas at the farm before the coming of Flora Poste. It is a parody of the worst sort of family Christmas: Adam Lambsbreath dresses up as Father Christmas in two of Judith's red shawls. There are unsuitable presents, unp...more
Paperback, 320 pages
Published
November 10th 2011
by Vintage Classics
(first published 1940)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
507)
The one thing everyone seems to know of Stella Gibbons is that she wrote one book ' Cold Comfort Farm' and then she was destined to have it hang around her neck like the famous albatross for the rest of her less than stellar career. This may or may not be true, though I remember reading 'Here be dragons' and quite enjoying it, but it cannot be denied that for myself CCF is probably the only book of hers that i would return to. That was until I picked this up whilst Christmas shopping in Exeter....more
Dec 25, 2011
Jemidar
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
kindle-library,
english-authors
Rating clarification: 3.5 stars.
This is a lovely volume of short stories by the author of the classic comic novel Cold Comfort Farm. But be warned, they differ in style to that popular novel, all excepting the titular story, Christmas at Cold Comfort Farm, of course. Also the title of the collection as a whole is somewhat misleading, as only the fist two stories are Christmas themed.
These short stories won't be to everyone's taste as they are period pieces about the upper classes in England duri...more
I have been looking forward so much to reading these stories, although I approached it nervously as I had read some fairly luke warm reviews. If anything I was disappointed in the title story - it was too short I wanted more, the only other Christmassy story was charming though. Overall I so enjoyed these old fashioned stories, and it has made me want to read more Stella Gibbons. I of course read Cold Comfort farm years and years ago, and it is now time for a re-read I think. I also have Westwoo...more
Reading Stella Gibbons is like taking a lovely warm bath - an inherently comforting experience. Obviously the plum in the pudding is her revisiting of the eponymous Cold Comfort Farm on Christmas Day a little before Flora Post makes their aquaintance. Here the Christmas "gifts" are to be given out - although with the gothic twist expected of the Stark household. Pity the recipient of the coffin nail in the pudding. Ada Doom, the matriarch of the clan, commands her descendants to - "Be Gay, Spaw...more
I'm afraid that this book of short stories, rather than being as quirky and arch as the title story and the previous book it was based on, is actually rather painful and haunting. I find myself dreading my spinsterhood as example after example of "Smart Set" who settle are paraded after me. I don't know whether I should rejoice that they've successfully evaded the smug, cruel and immoral Smart Set or mourn that they've married into the slow, uninteresting or deeply flawed world of convention. Le...more
The title of this collection of short stories is a little misleading. It would be easy to suppose that these are stories entirely related to Gibbons' most famous creation, Cold Comfort Farm. However, only one story in the collection ticks this box, and only two of the stories have a Christmas setting. The other stories are generally themed around unassuming women who find true love and conventional happiness at the conclusion.
One of the stories, Cake, makes for uncomfortable reading to a modern...more
One of the stories, Cake, makes for uncomfortable reading to a modern...more
it was a bit weird to be reading this at the same time as Mary McCarthy's The Company she keeps. Although this is from a slightly earlier period in the 20c there were some similarities and aspects that invited comparison. I'm not really a short story fan, but at least Stella Gibbons' stories were short (unlike the novella length of McCarthy) and followed more the short story tradition. Some of the stories seemed as if they belonged to a well-written edition of People's Friend and I did start to...more
I thoroughly enjoyed Christmas at Cold Comfort Farm by Stella Gibbons. I love her book Cold Comfort Farm (and the movie based on it) so I had to check this out when I saw it on the library shelf.
One minor caution - there is only one story about the family from the Cold Comfort Farm, and it's one of the least impressive in the collection. Still, I forgive whoever named the book after that story because I would probably not have noticed the book otherwise. The collection was first published in 19...more
One minor caution - there is only one story about the family from the Cold Comfort Farm, and it's one of the least impressive in the collection. Still, I forgive whoever named the book after that story because I would probably not have noticed the book otherwise. The collection was first published in 19...more
I got a copy of this short story anthology just to read it's title selection "Christmas At Cold Comfort Farm" set (pre Flora Poste) at Cold Comfort. It was hilarious--full of Gibbons' signature wit. This anthology is well worth seeking out just for this story.
Held separately, the other stories in this anthology are quite dated in their outlook, and problematic for the modern reader. Although there are glimpses of Saki-like humor scattered here-and-there, the problem comes in that every story imp...more
Held separately, the other stories in this anthology are quite dated in their outlook, and problematic for the modern reader. Although there are glimpses of Saki-like humor scattered here-and-there, the problem comes in that every story imp...more
A series of sophisicated and deliciously sly attacks on modernity. Although these are short stories, you become as involved with thecharacters as in a novel. The story I enoyed most: 'More than kind'; but my favourtiote quotes comes from 'The friend of man':
'She felt that if she had to spend another year of interesting, congenial work during the days, and sensitive, cultured, intelligent talk in the evenings, she would go mad or die.' (p. 211)
Like too many views, this one over Buckinghamshire co...more
'She felt that if she had to spend another year of interesting, congenial work during the days, and sensitive, cultured, intelligent talk in the evenings, she would go mad or die.' (p. 211)
Like too many views, this one over Buckinghamshire co...more
Jan 05, 2013
Mariano Hortal
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
british-literature,
genre-comedy
Publicado en http://lecturaylocura.com/navidades-e...
La publicación hace algunos años de ”La hija de Robert Poste” fue un bombazo para la editorial Impedimenta, fue una de esas sorpresas que la gente recomendaba naturalmente, el boca a boca (o boca a oreja) sirvió para auparla y convertirla en un clásico de obligada visita, una diversión muy loca y metaficcional con las andanzas de un grupo de brutos ingleses que son visitados por la refinada Flora Poste y hace que cambien sus vidas; no en vano...more
La publicación hace algunos años de ”La hija de Robert Poste” fue un bombazo para la editorial Impedimenta, fue una de esas sorpresas que la gente recomendaba naturalmente, el boca a boca (o boca a oreja) sirvió para auparla y convertirla en un clásico de obligada visita, una diversión muy loca y metaficcional con las andanzas de un grupo de brutos ingleses que son visitados por la refinada Flora Poste y hace que cambien sus vidas; no en vano...more
Dec 27, 2011
Sharri
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
fiction,
short-stories
Stella Gibbon's Cold Comfort Farm (CCF) is among my favorite books, so I had high hopes for this collection of short stories, finally available in the US and -- bonus! -- with an introduction by Alexander McCall Smith.
My first disappointment was that only one of the short stories in the collection was about CCF and, although it had a few funny lines, it wasn't anything special overall and didn't add anything new. (And, it didn't answer the burning questions: WHAT was nasty in the woodshed? and...more
My first disappointment was that only one of the short stories in the collection was about CCF and, although it had a few funny lines, it wasn't anything special overall and didn't add anything new. (And, it didn't answer the burning questions: WHAT was nasty in the woodshed? and...more
Dec 26, 2011
Libby
is currently reading it
Ignoring the fact that this would be much better entitled 'Christmas At Cold Comfort Farm AND OTHER STORIES', please, this is great. I've got just two stories left to read, and I'm saving them--that's how good this book is.
Stella Gibbons' writing is perfect. It has the familiarity of characters which reminds me very much of L.M. Montgomery's short stories. And there's some Roaring Twenties-ish happenings which feel a bit Fitzgerald-y. And then it's funny--not laugh out loud funny. Just quiet ob...more
Stella Gibbons' writing is perfect. It has the familiarity of characters which reminds me very much of L.M. Montgomery's short stories. And there's some Roaring Twenties-ish happenings which feel a bit Fitzgerald-y. And then it's funny--not laugh out loud funny. Just quiet ob...more
This was a book club selection, not one I would have chosen before or after having read it!
While the scene is supposedly rural Brithish life of the 1930's, I found references that made me wonder if it wasn't suppose to have been the 1940's.
While the plot was interesting, the British dialect was so well written, that by the time you figured out what was being said, your mind will be so confused, you need to take a rest from reading.
The most damaging aspect of the book was the illusion that yo...more
While the scene is supposedly rural Brithish life of the 1930's, I found references that made me wonder if it wasn't suppose to have been the 1940's.
While the plot was interesting, the British dialect was so well written, that by the time you figured out what was being said, your mind will be so confused, you need to take a rest from reading.
The most damaging aspect of the book was the illusion that yo...more
I enjoyed this collection of short stories. Laced with wry authorial asides, and careful, subtle wit, Gibbons' stories allow us to glimpse the make-do climate of England in the 1930's. Though WWI is by no means belaboured the series of stories reveals its effects on women in their various spheres; the career woman, the domesticate, the housewife, the spinster.
The stories, if a little obvious at times, are interesting and compelling period pieces in their own right, and for my part, the collecti...more
The stories, if a little obvious at times, are interesting and compelling period pieces in their own right, and for my part, the collecti...more
Very good short stories, one of which is about the Cold Comfort Farm characters of her well known book of the same name. It is quite an art to be able to present the theme for a short story, introduce the characters and form them into people you want to know more about and then wrap the story up nicely. Stella Gibbons does just that and makes me want to read more of her work.
The people of Cold Comfort Farm are characters indeed and are presented deliciously. They make you glad that you do not li...more
The people of Cold Comfort Farm are characters indeed and are presented deliciously. They make you glad that you do not li...more
I picked this up at Christmas time hoping for some comforting, heartwarming Christmas short stories. I enjoyed the compilation in its own right, but it was neither comforting nor heartwarming - and only the first two stories were at all Christmas related.
Definitely an interesting read if you are interested in a subjective account of a particular (upper class intellectual) set in post World War 1 England. But I wouldn't recommend it at Christmas time.
Definitely an interesting read if you are interested in a subjective account of a particular (upper class intellectual) set in post World War 1 England. But I wouldn't recommend it at Christmas time.
I got this because I could not imagine how the Starkadders celebrated Christmas and wanted to find out. That story was really funny but some of the others were absolute gems which really stick in my mind. I would have given this 5 stars, but a few of the stories had a similar theme (a woman who was a fish out of water in one respect or another finding love unexpectedly) and while they were well written, they were too similar to really hold my interest.
I liked some of the short stories, but found myself getting tired of them as I read on, and they became a little more predictable. Also, I find I like having characters that I can follow for a good number of pages and that I learn to like or dislike with time, as opposed to ones that are only there for a short time (with due exceptions, like Borges's The Aleph and other stories which is absolutely fantastic)
This is a book of short stories. Gibbons is a hero of mine so I was, to be fair, wearing rose coloured spectacles when I read it. Most of the stories lived up to my expectations...but a couple of them left me wanting. Nonetheless, I find Gibbons' writing to be intelligent, humorous, and it tends to 'make me think about life'...the sort of fiction I like to read now and again.
Stella Gibbons has been described as the Jane Austen of the 20th Century. Just one of these short stories is based on Cold Comfort farm. The rest are witty and poignant vignettes of English life in the late 30s. This isn't great literature but a very enjoyable read, especially when you are kept in bed by a bad cold and need something amusing to occupy your mind!
The original Cold Comfort farm is so wonderful a read that it would be hard to equal it. This sequel of short stories is certainly dated, which is forgiveable, but far from the quality of Cold Comfort Farm itself. Predictable plots, very much showing how particularly the role of women has changed over the decades.
Even though this was not in the style used by Ms Gibbons in Cold Comfort Farm and Cold Comfort Farm and indeed Crhistmas only featured in two of thd very first short stories in the collection I really enjoyed this book.
The stories were delightful and I got caught up in all of them despuite their brifness!
The stories were delightful and I got caught up in all of them despuite their brifness!
If you're looking for a festive read in the run-up to Christmas, Christmas at Cold Comfort Farm may not be the right choice for you. Only a few stories in the collection have anything to do with Christmas at all. Despite this, each story has been wonderfully crafted and features realistic characters and well thought out storylines. The first tale in the book is absolutely wonderful. I felt that this was much better than the original Cold Comfort Farm, and it has inspired me to read some of Gibbo...more
This is a collection of short stories set in the 1930s. There is an array of stories that all make a small point about this era. It is a quaint collection of stories that I enjoyed (I normally hate short stories). I was a little disappointed as I thought it was a prequel to Cold Comfort Farm telling you about the characters lives before the female protagonist arrives.
Dec 30, 2011
Bettie
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Bettie by:
Brazilliant Laura
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This a collection of short stories, all with some kind of moral. I knew going in that the stories in this collection were outdated as they were from a different era with different mores. Some of the stories' moral lessons were obvious. In others I had no clue to the point of the story. I really did not enjoy this collection. I may be dense but I found no humor in any of the stories.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Stella Dorothea Gibbons was an English novelist, journalist, poet and short-story writer.
Her first novel, Cold Comfort Farm, won the Femina Vie Heureuse Prize for 1933. A satire and parody of the pessimistic ruralism of Thomas Hardy, his followers and especially Precious Bain by Mary Webb -the "loam and lovechild" genre, as some called it, Cold Comfort Farm introduces a self-confident young woman,...more
More about Stella Gibbons...
Her first novel, Cold Comfort Farm, won the Femina Vie Heureuse Prize for 1933. A satire and parody of the pessimistic ruralism of Thomas Hardy, his followers and especially Precious Bain by Mary Webb -the "loam and lovechild" genre, as some called it, Cold Comfort Farm introduces a self-confident young woman,...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...




























Dec 24, 2012 12:44pm
Dec 24, 2012 03:05pm