1st out of 84 books
—
17 voters
Sister Citizen: Shame, Stereotypes, and Black Women in America
Jezebel's sexual lasciviousness, Mammy's devotion, and Sapphire's outspoken anger—these are among the most persistent stereotypes that black women encounter in contemporary American life. Hurtful and dishonest, such representations force African American women to navigate a virtual crooked room that shames them and shapes their experiences as citizens. Many respond by assu...more
Hardcover, 300 pages
Published
September 20th 2011
by Yale University Press
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,583)
Melissa Harris-Perry pulls no punches with her insightful and scathing indictment of the institutions and the damaging myths about black womanhood that keep them from fully realizing their citizenship and their identity. She explores the genesis of such stereotypes as the promiscuous Jezebel, the self-sacrificing Mammy (once again made popular with the inexplicable success of The Help) and the emasculating Sapphire. The book is filled with anecdotes, but it's also backed with meticulous research...more
I found "Sister Citizen" to be the most comprehensive book I have read regarding the stereotypes plaguing black women. The book is clear and concise. This has helped me to better understand myself as a black woman and how I fit in our country. I felt validated about a lot of personal experiences. Ms. Harris-Perry proves again that she is one of America's most incredible political minds. I appreciate how she is using peer-reviewed sources, empirical data,and recent events to tie her themes togeth...more
Loved it and am going to buy it (the copy I read was via the public library)
Skillfully weaves a narrative about the 3 major stereotypes of black women: Sapphire, Jezebel, and Mammy; and the ways that they still impact the way black women view themselves and are viewed/portrayed by others.
Most impactful/resonant to me were the parts on shame and the strong black women, building on what I'd read in When Chickenheads Come Home to Roost: A Hip-Hop Feminist Breaks It Down and Shifting: The Double Li...more
Skillfully weaves a narrative about the 3 major stereotypes of black women: Sapphire, Jezebel, and Mammy; and the ways that they still impact the way black women view themselves and are viewed/portrayed by others.
Most impactful/resonant to me were the parts on shame and the strong black women, building on what I'd read in When Chickenheads Come Home to Roost: A Hip-Hop Feminist Breaks It Down and Shifting: The Double Li...more
Sadly did not get to finish this before it was due, but it was a really excellent critical read. Harris-Perry creates a crooked room (society's stereotyping of African American women) and then examines how African American women proceed to live within this room -- do they align themselves with the room and the false stereotypes or do they stand upright against the room and fight the feeling that they are askew? It's a lose lose situation. As a result of this, how African American women are treat...more
Apr 22, 2012
Angela
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
my book club
Recommended to Angela by:
Colbert Report appearance
Having written a several-paragraph review of "Sister Citizen" before running out of battery and seeing it completely erased, I will attempt to rehash it with slightly more brevity. In her book, Melissa Harris-Perry covers roughly four major topics: the three traditional stereotypes faced by black American women (the promiscuous "Jezebel," the angry "Sapphire," and the nurturing "Mammy"), the more superficially positive stereotype created in response to this of the strong black woman and why it c...more
pretty interesting take on social perceptions of Black women and how stereotypes (strength, hyper-religiousness, sexual promiscuity.......) affect their civic involvement, relationships, and personal feelings. A couple quibbles:
1. in terms of method, it was a sometimes awkward mix of survey research, focus group quotes, personal anecdotes, and literary illustration. A Zora Neale Hurston excerpt would bump up against polling data re gov't.'s slow response to Hurricane Katrina and racial implicati...more
1. in terms of method, it was a sometimes awkward mix of survey research, focus group quotes, personal anecdotes, and literary illustration. A Zora Neale Hurston excerpt would bump up against polling data re gov't.'s slow response to Hurricane Katrina and racial implicati...more
This is one of those books that I am truly glad I read, because it has taught me valuable things that I feel that I should know as a feminist interested in social justice. Harris-Perry writes convincingly of the stereotypes that shape African Americans womens' lives, personally and politically: the oversexed Jezebel, the caretaker Mammy, the Strong Black Women. Her arguments consist of the ways in which those stereotypes determine behavior (going out of one's way to behave in a way that refutes...more
The last quarter of this book kicks it from four to five stars. This is a thorough look at black women in American politics, but not in the traditional sense. This is more a look at how all the things that go into being a black woman inform how they think and act politically. Even that is an over simplification of what the book sets out to do.
The book is well researched and well documented. That's a plus. I feel like the last part of the book really brought together all the little pieces. The f...more
The book is well researched and well documented. That's a plus. I feel like the last part of the book really brought together all the little pieces. The f...more
The crux of Harris-Perry's argument is that the prevailing stereotypes of black women profoundly affect the ways that black women are seen by America, but also the ways that they see themselves. This misrepresentation shapes and often limits black women's participation as American citizens. While scholars may find some of the ground covered here to be a bit familiar, "Sister Citizen" is written for the benefit of all Americans - sister citizens, brother citizens and anyone else who cares about t...more
I picked up Sister Citizen because I am interested from a legal perspective in the implications that stereotyping of African American women has in the workplace. The book more than rewarded my interest.
The book is a pastiche of literary excerpts, critical essays, news analysis, focus group reporting, and statistical surveys that covers everything from the writings of Zora Neale Hurston and the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina to the success of Michelle Obama and the shaming of Shirley Sherrod. In...more
The book is a pastiche of literary excerpts, critical essays, news analysis, focus group reporting, and statistical surveys that covers everything from the writings of Zora Neale Hurston and the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina to the success of Michelle Obama and the shaming of Shirley Sherrod. In...more
I love the analogy that undergirds this book, "trying to stand up straight in a crooked room." Ms. Harris-Perry does a remarkable job of explaining this challenge that is often mis-diagnosed by all. She provides history mixed with present day situations that make hers analysis clear and insightful. The discussion of myths and stereotypes and the effects of them on Black women is instructional. I hope that not only Black women embrace this book, but my fellow Black men do so as well. There is no...more
Sister Citizen is a book that calls a thing by its proper name and makes it real!
Melissa Harris-Perry did a very nice job of using fictional characters to deal with the subject of Black women's oppression within the American society.
I found myself waving my hand and nodding my head in agreement over the issues that are pointed out in this work.
Even though the body of work is supported by research results, I found the overall book to be a good read. Harris-Perry's writing style has a nice flow of...more
Melissa Harris-Perry did a very nice job of using fictional characters to deal with the subject of Black women's oppression within the American society.
I found myself waving my hand and nodding my head in agreement over the issues that are pointed out in this work.
Even though the body of work is supported by research results, I found the overall book to be a good read. Harris-Perry's writing style has a nice flow of...more
A well-documented, researched, and respectfully balanced expose on Black women's social and political experience in America. Authored by Melissa Harris-Perry, a political science professor at Tulane University. Harris-Perry describes with both eloquence and emotion the 'crooked room' in which Black women find (and have found)themselves; badly skewed in terms of how they are perceived, must act to survive socially, politically, financially, etc., in the face of other power segments of American so...more
As someone who believes women face a great deal of shaming and misrepresentation in (at least) American society, I was intrigued by this book's premise of looking through the lens of shame and stereotypes from an African American woman's perspective. A vantage point to which I am generally not privy.
This thorough and well researched examination of black women in America incorporates historical experiences (slavery, care-taking, etc.) with well known literature (Their Eyes Were Watching God, The...more
This thorough and well researched examination of black women in America incorporates historical experiences (slavery, care-taking, etc.) with well known literature (Their Eyes Were Watching God, The...more
It was refreshing to read a book on gender and ethnicity written by a black woman, about black women's personal and political experiences and identities. Too many books on gender fall flat when it comes to discussing intersectionality, and truly paying attention to the multi-faceted experiences of women from various backgrounds.
Everyone should read this book! : )
Everyone should read this book! : )
This is a powerful, thorough account of what it means to be an African American woman in the US, both historically and in the present. The intersectionality embodied by women of color is an important and poignant viewpoint from which to see our culture, society, and political landscape. Melissa Harris-Perry does a wonderful job of making this viewpoint clear and accessible, and shows us how it feels to live in the mind, body and soul of a black woman in the US - the struggle for recognition as a...more
I had to read this book for my sociology course on Poverty and Social justice, so I most likely wouldn't have read this book on my own. However I am glad to have read it. First Dr. Harris-Perry uses comparisons to frequently showcase her point in two settings. When she reviews the empirical or survey data it can be quite taxing and you can loose the point, or maybe that's just me. Anyways it was enlightening to read about the "crooked room" which essentially is how our culture stereotypically po...more
In Sister Citizen, Melissa Harris-Perry sets out to examine what it means to be a black woman who is also an American citizen, melding a more empirical political science approach with discussion of literature and popular culture. She argues that the prevailing stereotypes about African-American women—the promiscuous baby mama, the asexual Mammy who's there to teach white folks, and the Angry Black Woman—trap them on both sides. African-American women have to deal with the structural and cultural...more
I wanted to love this book. I picked it up because I saw Dr. Harris-Perry on the Steven Colbert show and I sensed that she had so much more to say than he allowed her to express in between his comedic shtick. Instead, I struggled to stay awake. Sister Citizen reads more like an academic thesis than a work for the masses. Yet, I kept plodding through it hoping to glean some great insight or knowledge that I didn't have. It wasn't that I disagreed with the author. I understand and agree with her o...more
Jezebel's sexual lasciviousness, Mammy's devotion, and Sapphire's outspoken anger—these are among the most persistent stereotypes that black women encounter in contemporary American life. Hurtful and dishonest, such representations force African American women to navigate a virtual crooked room that shames them and shapes their experiences as citizens. Many respond by assuming a mantle of strength that may convince others, and even themselves, that they do not need help. But as a result, the uni...more
What I really like about this book, besides the fact that Harris-Perry is one of the most honest authors I have ever read, is the fact that it is about women and politics, and not about women and media.
However, the most distrubing section (and most powerful in some cases) is the brief paragraphs were Harri-Perry mentions a desire by a certain group to errect a Mammy monument on the National Mall, right near the Lincoln Memorial.
It is a very powerful book, though at times very analytical. Yet, c...more
However, the most distrubing section (and most powerful in some cases) is the brief paragraphs were Harri-Perry mentions a desire by a certain group to errect a Mammy monument on the National Mall, right near the Lincoln Memorial.
It is a very powerful book, though at times very analytical. Yet, c...more
I like the progression of this book. The author describes stereotypes of black women using empirical and scientific studies, but adds the real life impact of these stereotypes by telling the stories of Hurricane Katrina, Shirley Sherrod and many others. I felt a call to action when I have some control over the space where a black woman could be herself, or could adjust to the "crooked room" that peeps in the USA generally offer her. It will take many many white peeps recognizing and admitting th...more
What I enjoyed most about this book was how Harris-Perry presented her findings in a very statistical manner. She called upon tangible data as proof, illustrating that she understood the stigma behind social politics and it's lack of evidence. While being factual Harris-Perry still never lost sight of her audience, ensuring her findings were put in layman's terms. She also emphasized and re-emphasized throughout Sister Citizen that she wasn't making blanket statements nor was her data 100% corol...more
I really enjoyed this book. I've read on few books on similar subjects in the past and this was by far the easiest read. The first half of the book (4 stars) was decidedly better than the second (3 stars). MHP's use of literary works throughout was genius and inspired me to read/re-read many books and authors. The second half relied much too heavily on statistics (she describes several focus groups and surveys that she used to come to her conclusions). It was understandable since this is technic...more
The second book I have read in the category of "representation" of women in American history and culture. Harris-Perry provides a survey of historic representations of black women as well as new emperical research regarding how those ideas impact women of color personally and politically. The book is well written and a compelling exploration of a demographic that has historically lacked the privilege and access to media and self-representation. I would recommend this book to anyone curious enoug...more
"African American women face specific, damaging, and deeply embedded race and gender stereotypes that make it difficult for them to enjoy accurate recognition in the public sphere. The crooked room created by these stereotypes has psychological consequences for individuals and social and political consequences for black women as a group. The strong black woman ideal is an attempt to straighten these crooked images. But even though the strong black woman is a more positive image than Jezebel, Mam...more
Sister Citizen by Melissa Harris Perry, is a wonderful book about how the 3 main stereotypes of Black women (mammy, Jezebel and angry black women) and how we either resist or acquiesce to those stereotypes influences our political choices. For example, the Jezebel stereotype posits that black women are immoral hyper sexual women. One way that we have resisted this stereotype is to create this "politics of respectability", whereby we try to assimilate into white created norms in the areas of dres...more
Melissa Harris-Perry's Sister Citizen is a book that covers a wide ground: black American women's misrecognition by society and how that misrecognition affects their subjectivity and participation as citizens. Luckily, Harris-Perry's framework is really helpful and she does a great job weaving together analysis of literature and film with findings from academic and census research with actual black women's voices, stories, and experiences.
She carefully balances discussing problematic aspects of...more
She carefully balances discussing problematic aspects of...more
In Sister Citizen, Melissa Harris-Perry proposes the notion that black women in America are pigeon-holed into one of three sterotypes: Jezebel, Mammy or Saphire. Ms. Harris-Perry further suggests that while these sterotypes are promoted by the dominant white culture, they are also perpetuated by black women's racial brothers and their own churches and are deeply rooted in history.
This is an important, well-documented book. While it may not be comprehensive enough to be a core text, it most cert...more
This is an important, well-documented book. While it may not be comprehensive enough to be a core text, it most cert...more
Melissa Harris-Perry’s latest book, Sister Citizen, takes a look at the traditional stereotypes that have affected Black women throughout history: the oversexed and oversexualized Jezebel; the asexual, loyal and nurturing Mammy; and the matriarchal Sapphire (the Angry Black Woman). It describes the origin of each of these stereotypes and the ways in which these stereotypes have affected Black women not only in their personal lives, but also in their political lives. Harris-Perry uses statistical...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2013 Clutch Readi...: Sister Citizen | 14 | 62 | Feb 23, 2013 03:53pm | |
| 2013 Clutch Readi...: The Crooked Room: Intro and Chapter One | 16 | 62 | Feb 07, 2013 01:32pm |
Melissa V. Harris-Perry is professor of political science at Tulane University, where she is founding director of the Anna Julia Cooper Project on Gender, Race, and Politics in the South. She previously served on the faculties of the University of Chicago and Princeton University.
Harris-Perry is author of the eagerly anticipated new book, Sister Citizen: Shame, Stereotypes, and Black Women in Amer...more
More about Melissa V. Harris-Perry...
Harris-Perry is author of the eagerly anticipated new book, Sister Citizen: Shame, Stereotypes, and Black Women in Amer...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“The disobedience if Eve in the Genesis story has been used to justify women's inequality and suffering in many Christian traditions. Thus, what is understood as women's complicity in evil leads much traditional theological reflection on suffering to offer the "consequent admonition to 'grin and bear it' because such is the deserved place of women." Similarly, when Jesus is seen as a divine co-sufferer, the potentially liberating narratives of Jesus as a revolutionary leader who takes the side of the poor and dispossessed can be ignored in favor of religious beliefs more interested in Jesus as a stoic victim. Christ's suffering is inverted and used to justify women's continued suffering in systems of injustice by framing it as redemptive.”
—
5 people liked it
“Citizenship is more than an individual exchange of freedoms for rights; it is also membership in a body politic, a nation, and a community. To be deemed fair, a system must offer its citizens equal opportunities for public recognition, and groups cannot systematically suffer from miser ignition in the form of stereotype and stigma.”
—
3 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...










view 2 comments














