Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Secret History of the Pink Carnation” as Want to Read:
The Secret History of the Pink Carnation
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Secret History of the Pink Carnation (Pink Carnation #1)

3.69 of 5 stars 3.69  ·  rating details  ·  14,503 ratings  ·  1,654 reviews
The year is 1803, and feisty Amy Balcourt will do anything to join the cause of her hero, the Purple Gentian, and his fellow spies, who once tried to save her father from French revolutionaries. But first she must find the mysterious Purple Gentian --- without getting sidetracked by the advances of Lord Richard Selwick, a dashing yet dubious man who by all appearances has ...more
Paperback, 400 pages
Published September 27th 2011 by Signet Select (first published October 10th 2004)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
I feel compelled to defend why I read this book in the first place – which is never good. And in this case, it is difficult, because I myself am still trying to understand why. The title, cover, and plot summary were flashing caution lights. A perusal of several reviews was not encouraging. Why, oh why, did I not heed the warnings?

If I am going to be honest, it came down to these two points:

1) I already had plans to attend an event with author, Tasha Alexander. As the date approached, I learned
This is what I get for being lulled into a false sense of security by a nice cover and an interesting premise. This book promised to be a historical fiction with a bit of mystery thrown in. Instead, it turned out to be a banal bodice-ripping generically bad Regency romance novel.

I could deal with the fact that the “modern” parts of the book were completely unnecessary. I could even deal with the fact that the way people spoke/acted in the 19th century parts and the modern parts were exactly the
Aug 22, 2007 Tara rated it 2 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: oversexed and underaged pseudo-history buffs
Shelves: junk
I would rather like my two hours back that I spent on this book. It's not that it was bad, rather, it had an intriguing premise, but the past/future aspects were poorly merged, the part of the story set in present day was absolutely unsatisfying and the Georgian smut felt out of place, perhaps because of the highly formal nature she tried to give the characters.

The lesson to be learned there is you can't do Pride and Prejudice with an R rating.
Okay, this book started out so cute! It's a great mix of historical fiction (granted with several liberties taken), chick lit, and a cute little Superman/Lois Lane man-in-a-mask love story. It was just a fun read. Until the sex scene... So I don't recommend it. In hind sight, although it was cute, it also was very shallow to begin with.

I HATE it when fun books turn out to be dirty when you're already half way through. Does anyone know if there's a website out there that gives tv/movie type rati
Lisa Kay
a) Scarlet Pimpernel (Anagallis arvensis)
b) Pink Carnation (Dianthus caryophyllus)
a) Purple Gentian (Gentiana verna)
d) Pink Champagne!

a) descriptionb) [image error]

c)descriptiond)[image error]

★★★★✩ This is a review of the audiobook, narrated by Kate Reading, who did a wonderful job on this charming intro to the Pink Carnation series. I cannot recall hearing her before; but, luckily she reads the rest of the audio series as well, so I certainly look forward to listening to her.

I guess you could call this one an “h
I was bitterly disappointed in this book. Given the quality hard cover, the lovely cover art and the blurb, I was expecting something that strives to be Heyer or Austen. I would have been happy with something that fell along the lines of Tasha Alexander or Deanna Raybourne. Heck, I would counted myself lucky if the book had been vaguely reminiscent of Mary Balogh or Julia Quinn. Instead I got something that fell far short of all of those.

Instead of sparkling wit of Heyer and the mannered prose o
Where I got the book: bought retail (yes! full price!) from my local indie bookstore at an author event.

The plot: it's 1803 and Amy, who grew up dreaming of joining the Scarlet Pimpernel's league of daring rescuers, is on her way to France to join her brother. The Scarlet Pimpernel has retired, and now the Purple Gentian stands between England and the machinations of Napoleon, so naturally Amy wants to be on his team. She must not allow herself to be distracted by handsome Lord Richard Selwick..
Shell Schroth

I ADORED this book... The author had me sold on the rest of the series and any of her future contributions to the book addict cause, within the few pages of the prologue..

A combination of Julia Quinn's wit, and C.S. Harris and Deanna Raybourn's sleuth story talent all rolled up with what is obviously, and originally 100% Lauren Willig...

The characters we're real, perfectly flawed and
Don't be fooled by the cover: this book is a romance novel pretending to be historical fiction. I was completely shocked when the first sex scene started (in a small boat on a river which was currently being rowed by someone else! I kept thinking I had missed something and the rower had left the boat, but no). Along with the requisite sex, there are also the requisite shallow protagonists. I kept thinking there must be more to the characters (because I was duped by the cover!), but they really a ...more
Beth F.
If it walks like a duck and talks like a duck it must be a duck, right? Right? Guess again, pal, because this book is no duck. It’s more like a jackelope.

Just take a look at how people have this thing shelved, I dare you. Is it historical fiction? Is it chick lit? Is it a romance novel? Is it a mystery? What is it really? It made me ask myself, “Can a book like this actually exist in the wilds of its reader’s imaginations or is it so mythically unbelievable that it better watch itself for the r
This book was crap. It was just complete and total crap. The thing that made me the most angry is that at the back of the book the author has a "historical note" where she talks about this garbage in light of its place in the "historical fiction" genre. Oh. My. Gosh. THERE WAS NOTHING HISTORICAL ABOUT IT! The Scarlet Letter is historical fiction. Cold Mountain is historical fiction. This, as I have already said, is crap. Mentioning Napoleon and the year 1803 does not make a book historical ficti ...more
Oct 10, 2008 Kim rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: fans of historical romance, chick lit, or swashbuckling films
Recommended to Kim by: my friend Becky
This book is hard to categorize, but it's a lot of fun. Eloise Kelly is a klutzy, directionally challenged graduate student in history (not like anybody I know) who is trying to discover the identity of the Pink Carnation, a spy in the mode of the Scarlet Pimpernel. The key, she believes, may lie in Selwick Hall, the estate of another aristocratic spy, the Purple Gentian, aka Richard Selwick. When Mrs. Selwick-Alderly grants her access to a box full of family papers, letters and journals dating ...more
The first in Lauren Willig's Pink Carnation series. I found this gem in the library. My first by this author and coincidentally the author's first. I was pleasantly pleased with it. I wasn't sure I would be when I opened the first page. I'm not a fan of 1st person POV but I kept on and realized the whole book is not written that way and I came to enjoy the parts that were. This is one of those stories in a story. It starts with a young American woman seeking information for her dissertation on s ...more
This is a genre romance novel with pretensions of grandeur.

I was intrigued by this book because of it's duel format. It features a Harvard Ph.D. candidate in history researching the famous (in her world at least!) Pink Carnation, a British spy during the Napoleonic Wars. Eloise, the student, travels to London after a bad break up and decides to research primary sources on the Pink Carnation. The novel opens with her in a slight jam--she's crushed in an overcrowded Tube ride, has spilled coffee o
This was one of those books that I found easier to read once I gave up any expectations I started with, and I will confess that it did redeem itself in my eyes by the end. It was a cute but predictable story about the hijinks surrounding the doings and identities of the preposterously-named Purple Gentian and Pink Carnation, not that the names really mattered that much. We mostly follow the dense Amy about as she desperately but naively tries to enter the world of espionage. Both she and her lov ...more
Jan 17, 2008 Cynthia rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Cynthia by: Michelle
I really enjoyed this book. It was humorous and cute. This book follows Amy, a wannabe spy adventurer, who tries to join The Purple Gentian's spy network against France shortly after the French Revolution. Of course nothing goes smoothly for the slightly dizzy heroine. The author combines historical fiction with fun chick lit, mostly focusing on Amy's romance with the Purple Gentian. I like both types of work so I enjoyed the combination.

I read some reviews of this book on Amazon and found peopl
I love the Scarlet Pimpernel and Willig has taken the foundation laid by Baroness Orczy and expanded it, creating the Purple Gentian and the Pink Carnation. Two stories in one, the book follows modern day scholar Eloise who is determined to unmask the Pink Carnation as well as Amy, a woman who lived in the time of Napoleon who seeks to join the League of the Purple Gentian. Part historical novel, part romance, and part adventure, this was a surprisingly good read. I will definitely be picking up ...more
The most ridiculous book I read all of last year.

I don't even know where to begin with this book. It is not historical fiction, first of all, it's a blase romance with a quick gloss of supposedly historical moments. The main characters are annoying and uninteresting and every single one of them is frustratingly one dimensional.

Please, save yourself the effort and do not read this book.
Perhaps my disappointment is my own fault. The jacket blurb is fabulous, the cover captivating, the premise intriguing. I waited weeks to have enough to time to curl up on the sofa and read this book. I made it to page 55 (at page 22 I decided to force myself to get to page 100-not going to happen though, I just can't do it.).

I thought I was getting a fabulous historical novel, but it reads like every other Regency era romance out there. Amy and Richard have the exact same modern voice as Eloise
Rosanne Lortz
“Sync’ me! If it isn’t that demmed, elusive pimpernel!” The Scarlet Pimpernel has always been a favorite of mine, the book, the musical, and both the movie versions–starring Leslie Howard (1934) and Anthony Andrews (1982). Perusing several historical fiction blogs, I was intrigued to learn that Lauren Willig has created a whole spin-off series from the original Pimpernel books by Baroness Orczy.

The premise of the first book, The Secret History of the Pink Carnation, is that after Percy Blakeney
Just a quickie review - I'm knackered and my eyes feel like someone poking sticks into them from staring at my screen all day..

I picked it up online from my library. It seems that everyone on the planet other than me had read it, so I thought I'd give it a go.

I love the whole Scarlet Pimpernel thing. I've not yet read the book, but the original movie with Leslie Howard and Raymond Massey is one of my absolute faves, and I'm really not into that whole black-and-white movie thing. I also have an u
Jennifer Osterman
I am all for comedic books and light reads, and regency romances...but this one is just plain silly. Based on the premise, I expected a tale of intrigue, romance and danger. What I got was a tale of idiocy, sex and bumbling. The present-day Harvard student and the 1803 "well-bred" lady who traipses about like a street urchin and practically loses her virginity on a canal boat in front of a boatman without even a second thought think the same, speak the same and act the same. The only reason that ...more
Susan (susayq ~)
This was wonderful! There's a story within a story in this one. Eloise Kelly is grad student who travels to England to find out the identity of the Pink Carnation (who worked with the Purple Gentian and the Scarlet Pimpernel). She meets the decendents of the Purple Gentian and is given some family papers to read that will help her with her discovery.

The antics of Amy and Richard (Richard is the Purple Gentian) are hilarious! Amy is innocent and full of energy and has always wanted to work in th
I guess I liked this book enough to finish it, but there are some things that bothered me about this book enough that I couldn't give it three stars. It could possibly be that I simply don't like explicit romance novels. The mystery is what kept me reading past the lame descriptions of how men can't control themselves around women. Perhaps the author believes the modern fallacy that it's impossible to be chaste when you're in love. Or maybe I'm being prudish. Like I said, romance novels aren't m ...more
4.5 stars.

Yum, yum, yum. This book is a funny, delicious romance that had me grinning multiple times throughout the story.

I loved how the story of Amy is framed by the modern background story of Eloise trying to figure out the identity of the Pink Carnation. As the romance develops in Amy’s story, it becomes a parallel for what occurs in the present – a fun story telling device that I really enjoyed.

For those of you who are tired of the instant hot and heavy scenes that seem to be inserted as a
First and foremost, let me say how terribly delighted I am with Lauren Willig. Not only for delighting me with her own story and characters and lines, but also for all the homages she makes to others of my favorite authors, such as this nod to Austen on page 244: "It is a truth universally acknowledged that one only comes up with clever, cutting remarks long after the other party is happily slumbering away." And this wink at Shakespeare on page 247: "Out, out damned ex!" There are more (too many ...more
I'm not sure if 2 stars is maybe too much for this. But I didn't really hate it, so 1 doesn't seem enough. 1.5 maybe?

In any case, I love the idea of this series. The Scarlet Pimpernel was real! And there were other flowery-named spies around! Romance! Mystery! Action! So it's too bad this book is so disappointing. The disappointment mostly comes from the fact that the two main characters are complete idiots. Amy, we are told over and over, is so intelligent and well-read, but all she does in the
Angela James
Dithered on what to score this, wish we had half stars. Basically, I'd give it a C+. It was a cute story, very easy read, nothing deep or meaningful about it and it entertained me for a few hours. Historical isn't one of my main genres these days, so I think it says a lot that I was engrossed in the story.

I will give a word of caution: if you don't like foolish, naive and somewhat silly heroines, this book is not for you, as Amy is all of the above, but managed to stay on just this side of not
The Lit Bitch
I feel like I just entered the most interesting florist shop in London. I am surrounded by flowers….the Scarlet Pimpernel, the Purple Gentian, and of course the Pink Carnation….but wait I’m in a book! What the deuce are all these flowers doing in a book?? Granted…it’s decidedly less fragrant in the book than in a florist shop but till what the deuce is going on here? Oh wait….I know, I am reading Lauren Willig’s novel The Secret History of the Pink Carnation!

This book is absolutely brilliant and
I cannot even give this book a star, much less say I "read" it as I finally gave up even skimming. Lauren Willig should be shot at 20 paces for her butchering of the Regency period. She willingly admits having played with historical dates and figures to fit her narrative, which is written in the style of a smug modern-day preteen with aspirations to writing: If I had to see "bouncing" or "bounced" or "stamped foot" or "tossed hair" used in any more pages, I would have bounced this book, and then ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
  • A Poisoned Season (Lady Emily, #2)
  • Secrets of a Lady (Charles & Mélanie Fraser #1)
  • Silent in the Grave (Lady Julia, #1)
  • The Huntress (The Dark Queen Saga, #4)
  • Why Mermaids Sing (Sebastian St. Cyr, #3)
  • Vienna Waltz (Charles & Mélanie Fraser #3)
Lauren Willig is the New York Times bestselling author of thirteen works of historical fiction. Her books have been translated into over a dozen languages, awarded the RITA, Booksellers Best and Golden Leaf awards, and chosen for the American Library Association's annual list of the best genre fiction. After graduating from Yale University, she embarked on a PhD in English History at Harvard befor ...more
More about Lauren Willig...

Other Books in the Series

Pink Carnation (1 - 10 of 12 books)
  • The Masque of the Black Tulip (Pink Carnation, #2)
  • The Deception of the Emerald Ring (Pink Carnation, #3)
  • The Seduction of the Crimson Rose (Pink Carnation, #4)
  • The Temptation of the Night Jasmine (Pink Carnation, #5)
  • The Betrayal of the Blood Lily (Pink Carnation, #6)
  • The Mischief of the Mistletoe (Pink Carnation, #7)
  • The Orchid Affair (Pink Carnation, #8)
  • The Garden Intrigue (Pink Carnation, #9)
  • The Passion of the Purple Plumeria (Pink Carnation, #10)
  • The Mark of the Midnight Manzanilla (Pink Carnation, #11)
The Masque of the Black Tulip (Pink Carnation, #2) The Deception of the Emerald Ring (Pink Carnation, #3) The Seduction of the Crimson Rose (Pink Carnation, #4) The Temptation of the Night Jasmine (Pink Carnation, #5) The Betrayal of the Blood Lily (Pink Carnation, #6)

Share This Book

“Tell them I have the headache--no, the plague! I need something nice and contagious.” 14 likes
“LIPID (Last Idiot Person I Dated) syndrome: a largely undiagnosed but pervasive disease that afflicts single women.” 8 likes
More quotes…