Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Barbarian Nurseries” as Want to Read:
The Barbarian Nurseries
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Barbarian Nurseries

3.61 of 5 stars 3.61  ·  rating details  ·  2,090 ratings  ·  422 reviews
The great panoramic social novel that Los Angeles deserves—a twenty-first century, West Coast Bonfire of the Vanities by the only writer qualified to capture the city in all its glory and complexity

With The Barbarian Nurseries, Héctor Tobar gives our most misunderstood metropolis its great contemporary novel, taking us beyond the glimmer of Hollywood and deeper than cam
Hardcover, 432 pages
Published September 27th 2011 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux (first published 2011)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Barbarian Nurseries, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Barbarian Nurseries

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Sep 17, 2013 David rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Mexican art students forced to clean house for stay-at-home moms with desert gardens
Let me be bold here: I think this book deserves to be a modern classic.

Not because it's the greatest book I've ever read. I liked it a lot, but it falls short of true greatness.

I am, however, comparing it to a lot of other classics I've read in the past few years, and in particular, the great melodramatic social commentaries like Bleak House, Mansfield Park, Middlemarch, North and South, Can You Forgive Her?, The Age of Innocence and so on.

Note that while I liked most of those books, I didn't lo
Jeanette  "Astute Crabbist"
This lardful lump of language is heavy-handed and implausible. It took me nearly six weeks to finish, when it should have taken one to two weeks at most. Some days I could only read two or three pages. Not only is the story slow-moving and tedious, but the author's agenda is overpowering. Whenever he wants to be sure you get his point, he spells it out by putting it fully formed into the thoughts of one of the characters. I felt like I was constantly being bludgeoned with authorial intent.

The st
Gary  the Bookworm

Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos I took a break from reading Buddenbrooks, Thomas Mann's early 20th Century tome about the collapse of an German family, to read about a modern Californian family's demise. Because we live in a time of hyper-descent, it takes the Torres-Thompson family less than a decade to accomplish what Buddenbrooks did over three generations. This particular story concerns the fallout from economic malaise on the lives of a pampered family living in a gated community by the sea. Their stoic Mexican housek
Is it a river or a big ditch?

I loved this book. Tobar creates an accurate account of how people from different walks of life interact in Los Angeles and Orange County. I’ve lived here for over 30 years and his insights were startling but at the same time felt like home truths. Araceli Ramirez is an educated woman from Mexico City. She’s also in the States illegally and the only job she’s been able to get is as a housekeeper to an outwardly prosperous Irvine couple with two young boys, ages 9 and
switterbug (Betsey)
The upscale, LA gated community of the Torres-Thompson household has a breathtaking view of the ocean, and a lush tropical or semi-tropical garden maintained by Pepe the underpaid Mexicano gardener. Ironically, the elevation and climate of this suburban McMansion is really desert, so when the Torres-Thomspon household is forced to lay off Pepe due to personal financial problems, and Guadalupe, their underpaid Mexicana nanny, Scott Torres and Maureen Thomson are helpless with their tropical or se ...more
2.5 stars - It was alright, an average book.

At its core, this is a satirical analysis of the all too common misunderstandings and misconceptions that occur between different demographics. It is filled with characters that share with you their inner thoughts, and these hosts serve up plenty of racism, classism and sexism.

While I applaud the author's brazen ability to tackle controversial issues head on without sugar coating the more virulent and shameful behaviors of one man to another, the nove
I was excited to read this book, as I started it during a weeklong trip to LA, and found it in a local bookstore. Finding this book fit in with a feeling I was having that LA was no less a foreign country then London where I'd been 2 weeks prior. Indeed, I have a sense of London's geography, social makeup and customs that I just don't have for LA's - partly because I've visited much more rarely, and partly, because of books -- I read reams upon reams of British fiction old and new, but when was ...more
The complexity and the humor, that’s what I liked.
Each individual’s motivations, history, family, temperament were a fascinating interplay within the context of California/US immigration law and reality, racism, materialism and human striving.
Did the end surprise you too?
I had overwhelming feeling of dread in middle and had to go on hiatus for a few days. I couldn’t bear to read about Araceli crushed.
But she wasn’t crushed! Far from it, yet her freedom is only as long lived as the next Miga sto
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
I have to compare The Barbarian Nurseries to The Help. Both novels are about the inequities between the moneyed and their domestic servants and shine a light on the plight of those the majority opts to keep voiceless in society. And. I'll be honest I am not a big fan of the novel The Help.

We all know the story that The Help tells correct? Ok then moving on to The Barbarian Nurseries by HéctorTobar. In this contemporary novel the Torres-Thompson family of Los Angeles and their illegal Mexican hou
The major feat of Tobar's epic, sprawling, hot-mess of a novel is its ability to capture, I think, what it means to be from Southern California--in all the myriad ways that can mean now.

I don't think I can recall a contemporary novelist who is as humane or as forgiving of some of his seemingly very unforgivable characters. There really is so much to hate here and yet just as one feels one's self getting suitably outraged on behalf of the good guy or gal that same guy or gal does something remark
JS Found
This novel by a Latino novelist and reporter won the California Book Award for Fiction. It was named a best book of the year by the august New York Times Book Review, by the LA Times, the Boston Globe, and the San Francisco Chronicle, according to the book's back cover. It is a provocative look at the illegal immigrant experience in California, where, as in most of the U.S., there is a need for domestics and low-wage workers. It covers race, class, politics, poverty, and an ethnography of the ci ...more
The Barbarian Nurseries is a huge book. Not in pages, but in conflicts and themes. Aricela, the Mexican illegal and her employers, the Torres-Thompson's are symbols of the great divide.
Hector Tobar plants these characters in a McMansion in arid, sun drenched California. The economy has changed and Scott Torres' investments have dried up in much the same way as the tropical garden in the back yard has. Scott Torres struggles with the lawn, his children, his wife, and his mortgage.
In an effort to
Book Concierge
Audiobook performed by Frankie Alvarez

Scott Torres and his wife, Maureen Thompson, live in an ocean-view Spanish-style McMansion with their three children and a staff they can no longer afford. The gardener and nanny have already been let go when we meet Ariceli Ramirez, “the last Mexican standing” in the household – the last, that is, except for Senor Torres, who is only half-Mexican and doesn’t even speak Spanish. An argument over Maureen’s excessive spending leads to a brief physical altercat
Is it a river or a big ditch?

I loved this book. Tobar creates an accurate account of how people from different walks of life interact in Los Angeles and Orange County. I’ve lived here for over 30 years and his insights were startling but at the same time felt like home truths. Araceli Ramirez is an educated woman from Mexico City. She’s also in the States illegally and the only job she’s been able to get is as a housekeeper to an outwardly prosperous Irvine couple with two young boys, ages 9 and
Apr 22, 2015 Sarah rated it 3 of 5 stars
Shelves: audio
Principally a book of Observations, more or less True I guess but largely Banal and in a great number of instances irrelevant to the story. I can't accept this is (as it describes itself) the great sweeping contemporary novel of LA - surely, SURELY, there is more to life there than this. The whole point seems to be to measure the misunderstandings and unbridgeable differences between the demographic groups - mainly the American start-up rich living in soulless and heartless affluence and their M ...more
Dickens writes about East L.A. and the richest parts of Orange County.

Here’s the storyline: Scott and Maureen did well enough in the dot-com world that they could afford three employees to take care of their children and mansion. But things are starting to fray. The gardener and nanny are let go. A fight about money goes too far. The next morning, each parent decides to take a time out for a day or two. Each one thinks the other one is home with their two boys.

But only Araceli, the cook, is wit
Imagine a Tom Wolfe – or perhaps a T.C. Boyle or Don DeLillo – novel without some of the more tempered nuances. The Barbarian Nurseries is a social novel, focusing largely on the schisms between the wealthy and the immigrant population in Southern California and it’s good – at times, really good – before dissolving into a disappointing ending.

Scott Torres is a programmer, a Mexican American with the emphasis on the American, who has fulfilled the American dream: he lives with his lovely blond wi
I have met Hector several times and have had this book on my shelf since he presented it a luncheon. He is quite a brilliant man and I saved this for a book club reading so I could discuss it (next Thur). It was very slow to start and the print is small and the spaces short, so literally hard to read. I lived in LA and had a Guatemalan nanny, so the book had a lot of reverberations for me. We do have all these Hispanic nannies and housekeepers and do not know them at all. There is a great divide ...more
Russell Libonati
I listened to this book on audio CD's I got from the library.

The author has a good command of the English language. It's too bad he uses it for long descriptions of unimportant things. Frankly the whole story could be told in just a few paragraphs. There are big stories, like those that have consequences for the whole human race and there are small stories like a single individual's struggle to survive. Size doesn't often matter. Both types of stories can be fantastic. Unfortunately, this is a s
Apr 15, 2014 Diana rated it 4 of 5 stars
Shelves: 2012
When my daughter was a baby, and I was gobsmacked by exhaustion, we rented an apartment next to Laurelhurst, a pretty ritzy neighborhood, and as I took endless and frequent walks to get my baby to nap, I remember often seeing two little girls with their hispanic nanny and being so envious. I wanted a Hispanic nanny! If I had one, I could take naps, read books, see movies. She could teach the baby Spanish while I did all these things. Also, this nanny seemed to truly love her charges.

The Barbaria
This is one of the most delightful novels I've ever read. I am not an Angeleno, if that is the proper word, but my sense from talking with colleagues more familiar with the area is that the author has gotten about exactly right the flavor and timbre of living there. Add to that an insightful story about what it must be like to "live on the edge" and this is one excellent tale. We see most of the social ills of living in an urban environment that grew out from under its inhabitants, coupled with ...more
Two statements came to mind as I was reading this book:

1. If we could see ourselves as others see us.
2. Perception is reality.

Each character in this book was living thru the same set of events and perceiving it in his/her own way - according to life-experiences, preconceived ideas, culture, political agendas, etc.

The parallel lives of the monetarily successful husband and wife and their illegal alien "help" was fascinating, frustrating and often a bit too stereo-typical. The political bias of th
When the economy tanks, and the nouveau riche of southern California have to economize, the Mexicano/a hired help are the first to go. "Winning" that lottery in the Thompson-Torres household is the housekeeper, Araceli, an undocumented alien who retains her job when the nanny Lupe and the gardener Pepe get fired. But it all goes to hell at that point, with pretty disastrous consequences for Araceli, her bosses Scott and Maureen, and the bosses' sons, Keenan and Brandon.

I really liked this book
A young couple in Orange County, CA with a staff of immigrants finds themselves with strained finances and reduce their domestic help to a lone young woman, who is an illegal immigrant from Mexico. The couple has a big fight and both leave the home, not realizing their partner has also taken flight. Left behind are their two young sons and Araceli, the maid. When she realizes that the parents are gone and not answering their cell phones, her biggest fear is that the boys will be placed in foster ...more
The Barbarian Nurseries takes a few pages getting used to, but once the reader falls into the multiple third-person POV writing style, the book is wonderful - very well written, telling an interesting and relevant story, and displaying the lives of a series of absolutely believable characters. Héctor Tobar succeeds in creating some marvelously realistic and sympathetic characters, as well as writing one of the best child characters I've encountered in an adult-geared book in a long time.

The Barb
The best book I have read in months and months.

Araceli, former Mexican university student and live-in housekeeper to the Torres-Thompson family of a wealthy Orange County gated enclave, suddenly finds herself the only hired help in the house when the gardener and nanny are both let go because of money problems.

Then, after a huge fight, both parents take off for a little "vacation". After 4 days alone with the 8- and 11-year-old boys, Araceli takes them to find their grandfather, armed with an ol
Dec 20, 2011 Judy rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: anyone

I read this wonderful novel simply because the author lives in Los Angeles. Hector Tobar, son of Guatemalan parents who immigrated to Los Angeles in the 1960s, is an LA Times columnist. The Barbarian Nurseries is his third book; his second novel. He has created a unique hybrid: a factual portrayal of a city and its immigration woes couched in fiction and driven by characters who surprised me at every turn.

Araceli is an undocumented Mexican immigrant working for an affluent family inside a gated
Story Description:

HarperCollins Publishers Ltd|September 20, 2011|Hardcover|ISBN: 978-1-44340-709-0

Scott Torres is a thirty-something Mexican American with a beautiful, blonde wife, Maureen; a mansion outside L.A.; and a staff of servants to tend his lawn, clean house and care for the three Torres children. As the novel opens, all the servants have been let go save for Araceli, their maid. Scott has fallen on hard times after a failed investment, and to make ends meet he has been forced to cut c
How disappointing, this book has a very interesting premise - what happens when two parents independently decide to leave at the same time and don't tell each other and on their return home their children are missing? It could have been a fascinating thriller. However it is anything but thrilling.

The interesting premise is smothered by bad execution: poor to non-existent characterisation, far too much exposition and a concentration on mundane detail, plus unnecessary use of untranslated Spanish
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Changó's Beads and Two-Tone Shoes
  • The Free World
  • Ghost Lights: A Novel
  • The London Train
  • My New American Life
  • Harlem is Nowhere: A Journey to the Mecca of Black America
  • Shards
  • Scenes from Village Life
  • Say Her Name
  • The Madonnas of Echo Park
  • Stone Arabia
  • The Grief of Others
  • Seven Years
  • Long, Last, Happy: New and Collected Stories
  • Examined Lives: From Socrates to Nietzsche
  • Parallel Stories
  • Wichita
  • Lost Memory of Skin
Héctor Tobar, now a weekly columnist for the Los Angeles Times, is a Pulitzer Prize–winning journalist and a novelist. He is the author of Translation Nation and The Tattooed Soldier. The son of Guatemalan immigrants, he is a native of the city of Los Angeles, where he lives with his wife and three children.
More about Héctor Tobar...
Deep Down Dark: The Untold Stories of 33 Men Buried in a Chilean Mine, and the Miracle That Set Them Free The Tattooed Soldier Translation Nation: Defining a New American Identity in the Spanish-Speaking United States Les 33 La montagna del tuono e del dolore: La storia mai raccontata dei 33 minatori cileni intrappolaLa storia mai raccontata dei 33 minatori cileni intrappolati ... nella miniera San José

Share This Book

“Maybe innocence is a skin you must shed to build layers more resistant to the caustic truths of the world.” 4 likes
“She would speak her story in Spanish and la señora Maureen would tell hers in English; it was obvious to her that the two languages did not carry equal weight.” 3 likes
More quotes…