Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Sin Hablar = No Talking” as Want to Read:
Sin Hablar = No Talking
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Sin Hablar = No Talking

3.93 of 5 stars 3.93  ·  rating details  ·  11,902 ratings  ·  897 reviews
Dave Packer's fifth-grade classmates are called "The Unshushables." Though Dave likes to talk nonstop, he's determined to go a day without speaking. An encounter with Lynsey incites a debate over whether girls or boys are noisier, declaring a two-day war of silence in which the words of those who speak are counted against them.
Library Binding, 152 pages
Published October 1st 2008 by Turtleback Books (first published January 1st 2007)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Sin Hablar = No Talking, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Sin Hablar = No Talking

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Krista the Krazy Kataloguer
Andrew Clements does it again! I loved this story of a group of fifth-graders who, divided into boys vs. girls, hold a 3-day "no talking" contest. They limit themselves to 3-word phrases or sentences, only to be used with teachers; communication with everyone else must be done by writing, gestures, mime, facial expressions, or sign language. Team captains keep points of everyone who speaks a word over the 3-word limit, and the team with the least number of points wins. What fascinated me about t ...more
Sofia
In the book NO talking by: ANDREW CLEMENTS THERES a boy named Dave Packer, Dave is in fifth grade. Dave goes to Laketon Elementary school .The fifth graders are the noisiest in there school. For an assignment Dave had to read about Gandhi, Dave thought Gandhi was really interesting .It was amazing in one part of the book it said: for many years ,one day each week Gandhi did not speak at all. Gandhi believed this was a way to bring order to his mind. The next day [at lunch] Dave had an idea. Dave ...more
Cheryl
This was *so* funny! Clements is kinda the Spinelli for the younger set, imo. It had insight, poignancy, that kind of thing - but mostly I just couldn't stop laughing.
Sandy
This is an entertaining story about a group of fifth-grade boys and girls who challenge each other to 48 hours of silence. Rules are negotiated - no more than three words may be spoken at a time, and only in response to a teacher - and an honour system of reporting "illegal words" outside of school is established. Because of the competition, both students and teachers alike learn valuable lessons about the value of economy in speech, the willingness to adapt to change, and the importance of co-o ...more
Ibrahim
“Dave was hunting for something strong to say, a real punch line, something that would shut Lynsey up and end this conversation. So he said, “… and anyway, boys never talk as much as girls do, ever!” (Clements, 16).

The book “No Talking” is an amazing novel written by the world’s famous author Andrew Clements. This story takes place in Laketon Elementary School, in the middle of New Jersey. The main characters are Dave, Lynsey, and Ms. Hiatt, the principle. The conflict of the story is boys vs. g
...more
Tiffany
I read this book to my niece and between the two of us we giggled uncontrollably. I don't think I could go 5 minutes without talking let alone 48 hours. It was an interesting concept on a historical person and how they can affect people. It made my niece and I wonder how we would do without talking. Good read for young and old to read together.
Karen
This was better than I thought it was going to be. Yes, it was a kids book. But it had some pretty fun things about learning to communicate, to accept others, to work together, to admit when you're wrong....and it wasn't just the kids in the story learning.

I really liked some of the ideas about words and thinking. It was a quick read. Why not?

Adam
One of the most enjoyable children's books I've read - clever, funny, meaningful and straightforward, with a real message about language and stereotypes, self-control and standing up for yourself. Led to some wonderful, excited conversation in the children's book club I lead. A quick and wonderful read for kids and adults alike!
Danielle Scharen
Realistic Fiction

I chose this book because one of my favorite books is Frindle by Andrew Clements. I always enjoyed a handful of his books, but this is one I never read and was excited to read. It lived up to my high expectations of the author.

This story is about a fifth grade boy who tries to go a whole day without talking. It became more challenging for him when it turned into a competition between the fifth grade boys and the fifth grade girls to see who could be better at not talking for 48
...more
Erin Mullen
Sep 27, 2008 Erin Mullen is currently reading it  ·  review of another edition
So far it is pretty good!
2jk01bcs
It was an OK book!
Dawn
After researching Gandhi for a class projects 5th grader Dave Packer decides to try going a school day without talking to see what it's like. This simple plan escalates into a full-on competition between the entire grade, boys vs. girls. This usually noisy group (nicknamed the unshushables by teachers) suddenly has a silent lunch period, but not all of the teachers are excited by this change.

Overall this was a cute, short read. I liked the idea of having a silence competition, and there are a f
...more
( ●—● ) Evelynn
I have to say, by the time I finished this book, it felt almost...sacriligious...to say more than three words per sentence.

It was genius, really.

The rules? No talking, unless you are asked a question by a teacher, and even then, only three words in response each time. You can make noises (because noises aren't words) and use hand gestures. Each illegal word said besides the maximum of three when answering a question for a teacher is counted against your team. And there are only two teams: Boys a
...more
Shruti S
Laketon elementary is generally a pretty loud school but nothing is louder than the 5th graders. Dave Packer is loud and cant go a second without making a snide remark and is the leader of the boy pack. Lynsey Burgess wants nothing thing to do with stinky smelly loud boys but has to when Dave just pushes her boundaries. Mrs. Hiatt, the principal cannot wait for those noisy kids to graduate so she can finely have some peace. But what happens when Dave and Lynsey get into an argument about who tal ...more
Lindsey
The protagonist of this short novel is Dave Packer, a 5th grade boy. This book is centered around a bet that Dave makes with Lynsey, a girl in his class, about whether boys or girls talk more. The notoriously talkative group decides to have a competition about who can say the least words over 48 hours. They make specific rules about when you can and cannot talk, and decide that it is acceptable only to speak to teachers, and only when you are spoken to, and only in three word phrases. This makes ...more
Keri
Category: Grades 4-6 Book #7

My kids loved this book about a girls vs. boys no talking contest. It is fun to see the kids' reactions to the teachers' reactions in the book when there is complete silence. THe book stems from a group of rowdy, loud children who don't listen to their teachers very well. I liked the book for that reason because it helped me talk to the kids about some of the problems we were having. It helped and now gives us a reference point when discussing being too loud.


Critic Re
...more
Amber Adams
In writing the author italicizes and capitalizes words to to show and intensity in a characters' voice. The author also writes very descriptively and addresses every detail.

The author uses the crafts well in this story. When he capitalizes his specific words, to show emotion through his words, I really felt like one of the students in the classroom. "STUDENTS! YOU ARE TALKING TOO LOUD!" (Pg 37)Andrew Clements also uses different size fonts throughout the book to place intensity on the words.


I w
...more
Toby
I have to say I've been pleasantly surprised by the A. Clements books I've been reading. No Talking started out like a typical boys-against-the-girls school story - and don't get me wrong, there's nothing wrong with a typical school story. But it's evolved into something a bit more thoughtful. The teachers' reactions, for example, to the kids' determination NOT to talk is illuminating, some are so irate that they dare to challenge the status quo and then the English teacher, who thinks it's crea ...more
Abby Johnson
The fifth graders at Laketon Elementary School like to talk. In fact, they talk so much that their teachers have dubbed their class "The Unshushables". But lately, Dave Packer has been doing some thinking about talking. He decides to see if he can go a whole day without talking and he very nearly succeeds. What stops him? In the cafeteria, he overhears Lynsey Burgess talking on and on about a sweater she'd wanted to buy. Before he can stop himself, he's insulting her, and soon after that he's ch ...more
Carolyn
Nov 05, 2010 Carolyn rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Carolyn by: Krista the Krazy Kataloguer
This is my first Clements book, but it won't be my last. I loved the 'voice' he used in telling this story, it was wonderful! ("There's always more to the story.")

This is a great story and has something to think about, for boys, girls, teachers, parents, kids and adults alike. About different ways of communicating, and about working to achieve a common goal.

A very interesting point is that the whole no-talking contest was inspired by David's research to do his Social Studies project on India. He
...more
Dylan S
Feb 11, 2013 Dylan S rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Dylan by: Mrs.Foley
Ian am currently reading No Talking by Andrew Clements. This book is about a completion against loud, disrespectful, mean boys and girls. This book is about a boy named Dave who challenges all the girls at his school to a no talking challenge since they have been really noisy and the principal has gotten really mad and has to use his bullhorn A LOT. I think the author uses great detail and does a great job in every book I've read by him including Lunch Money another book by him that I am current ...more
Madelyn Adams
Personal Reaction:
I thought this book was very humorous book that everyone can relate too. I really enjoyed reading and seeing how the contest developed between the boys and girls. I thought the wording was simple so it was an easy read. Clements does a good job developing the characters of the book and even makes me not like it when the principal uses her bullhorn.

Purpose:
No Talking would be an excellent book for a 3rd or 4th grader. It could be read independently or aloud. There are multiple
...more
Hannah Sroka
No Talking is a book about a fifth grade class. Two students, Dave Packer and Lynsey Burgess, refuse to stop talking. Throughout the day, every day, they talk nonstop. Even though there is a vicious contest between the boys and the girls, the genders envy each other. A dare is created between Dave and Lynsey. Nobody is allowed to talk. They can say no more than three words to the teacher, but that is only if asked a question directly. The whole class becomes involved in the competition to find o ...more
Ellyse Hampshire
This was an awesome book! What started out as an idea for a personal challenge by Dave Packer spread out into his entire community, showing us the power of a small but powerful idea. Dave takes inspiration from Ghandi and his research on him for Social Studies, and tries to go a whole entire day without talking. Dave soon realizes that he really understands from a new perspective on how much he talks, and how little he listens. But when his listening turns into a confrontation with Lynsey Burges ...more
AnimeSketchFuel
Jan 06, 2015 AnimeSketchFuel rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Anyone who wants a funny book
ANDREW CLEMENTS IS BACK! His awesome book "No Talking" is a must read. Now lets see why I like the book.


CHARACTERS

The characters were pretty well developed. Dave is this boy who is a blabbermouth and Lydnsey is his partner in crime. The principal is well mean lady in the beginning who uses a bullhorn at lunch. She yells at people.

The LA teacher is this nice and funny laid back guy who enjoys teaching 5th grade. He made the students do an assignment where they would communicate with four other st
...more
Alice Mcmurray
Dave, a boy in fifth grade, decides to make a contest that is boys vs. girls and they have to try not to talk for two days to see who’s chattier. The contest gets started because Lynsey, a fifth grade girl, was talking so much that it annoyed Dave and he suggested the contest. Even before that Dave decides to be like Gandhi who doesn’t talk once a week for a day. They start the game at lunch the next day and Dave said a word by accident which was “Um, the first day.” The fifth grade was a very l ...more
Sammie Pedersen
No talking was a hilarious book about a boy who got an idea from Gandhi that he was going to try and not talk for a day. After he tried he failed because he couldn’t stop listening to how much the girls blabbered on. Then he decided to make it a two day contest, boys against girls, about which side would talk the most. Eventually this game started to drive the teacher, and principle, nuts! They said it disrupted their lesson and they couldn’t teach properly because the students were only speakin ...more
Van Phan
This book is funny mostly because of their conversation. The whole issue of “no talking” came about when Lynsey was talking with her friends about how boys talk more than girls, Dave a bystander heard and felt the needed to defend his kind, his boys. The dialogue fits the young children up to middle school because they’re more aware of each other existence. Lynsey and Dave made a bet with each other to go the entire day at school with no talking; this game is not just between them, it’s between ...more
Camille
When the entire has a contest between guys and girls on who can say the least amount of words within two days, of course it is going to be big.
This was a great book, and very clever. It gives the loud fifth graders an opportunity to learn the value of silence and different ways to communicate. Some teachers love it, others become annoyed by it and try to exercise their authority to stop it. However, there is no doubt that these two days give everyone a learning experience they will never forget.
Jennifer Yoder
This would be a great read aloud book for any 3rd, 4th, or 5th grade class. The students will be very interested because they will be able to relate to the kids in the book. This text, written by Andrew Clements, is an engaging book about 5th graders who have a no talking contest. It all starts with Dave's research on Gandhi. Gandhi's story intrigued Dave and he wanted to see if he could go a whole day without talking just as Gandhi did. The contest went a lot further than Dave thought. It ended ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Fav No Talking Character and What u liked and disliked about the book. 2 5 Jan 07, 2015 07:41AM  
Slaoui English 7: Book Shares 4 10 Dec 18, 2014 12:49AM  
  • The Aurora County All-Stars
  • The Homework Machine (The Homework Machine #1)
  • Where I Live
  • The Fabled Fourth Graders of Aesop Elementary School
  • Being Teddy Roosevelt
  • How to Steal a Dog
  • Secret Identity (Shredderman, #1)
  • Sahara Special
  • The Thing about Georgie
  • Clementine's Letter (Clementine, #3)
  • The Year of the Dog
  • The Liberation of Gabriel King
  • Brendan Buckley's Universe and Everything in It
  • The Lemonade War
  • Eleven
  • Emmy and the Incredible Shrinking Rat (Emmy, #1)
  • Alvin Ho: Allergic to Girls, School, and Other Scary Things (Alvin Ho, #1)
  • Moxy Maxwell Does Not Love Stuart Little
63095
I was born in Camden, New Jersey in 1949 and lived in Oaklyn and Cherry Hill until the middle of sixth grade. Then we moved to Springfield, Illinois. My parents were avid readers and they gave that love of books and reading to me and to all my brothers and sisters. I didn’t think about being a writer at all back then, but I did love to read. I'm certain there's a link between reading good books an ...more
More about Andrew Clements...
Frindle Things Not Seen (Things, #1) The Report Card The School Story Extra Credit

Share This Book

“Dave couldn't remember the last time a grownup had apologized to him.” 19 likes
“Okay heres the deal a whole day of NO TALKING IN SCJHOOL.Not in class,not in the halls, not on the plaground nowhere.No talking at all. And its a contest- BOYS AGAINST GIRLS. Whichever side talks less, wins.” 7 likes
More quotes…