A World Lit Only by Fire: The Medieval Mind & the Renaissance
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

A World Lit Only by Fire: The Medieval Mind & the Renaissance

3.87 of 5 stars 3.87  ·  rating details  ·  6,310 ratings  ·  523 reviews
s/tPortrait of an Age
William Manchester's A World Lit Only by Fire is the preeminent popular history of civilization's rebirth after the Dark Ages.
ebook, 0 pages
Published September 26th 2009 by Back Bay Books (first published 1992)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about A World Lit Only by Fire, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about A World Lit Only by Fire

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Sarah Fisher
I didn't finish this book. As I basically study the middle ages, all the information was not new or its credibility was highly questionable. Seriously, this guy HATES the middle ages and this book is a one sided rant on how completely dumb and primitive the people were before the Rennaissance saved everyone.

One such random fact that the author gets stuck on is that silverware wasn't introduced until the end of the 16th (maybe 15th...errr) century. Gasp! How can they be so uncivilized??? Using th...more
Katie
I haven’t read anything else by William Manchester, but he’s a good writer, and I’m sure he’s a smart guy. He’s written several biographies on Churchill, and one on JFK, and a memoir detailing his experiences during World War II in the Pacific. But Manchester is a reporter and a chronicler of modern history, and his rather sudden attempt to catalogue the medieval and early modern era in about three hundred pages is – at best – a very misguided effort that paints a terribly artificial and superfi...more
Valerie
Inconsistencies and half truths make for an interesting narrative, but not a good history.

This book attempts to cover a lot of ground. However, several things in the book made me suspicious of the reliability of the information. For instance, Manchester references the events of the Pied Piper, depicting him as an actual historical character and the murderer of 130 children.

I found this intriguing and went online to learn more -- I found a "Straight Dope" column that refuted Manchester's specula...more
Richard Reviles Censorship Always in All Ways
My daughter brought this book to my attention about 10 years ago. "WHAT?!? You haven't read this?!? Here!" with a forceful thrust, causing the book to thump into my chest rather painfully. (The bruises have since healed.)

Since that copy, I have given to others eleven more; I seem to be able to keep the book for about six months before someone just *has* to read it and *now*, so out it goes again. Weeks go by, and I fretfully search the used bookeries for another copy; always one shows up, usual...more
Jessica
I would be lying to you if I didn't admit that I was bitter about this book before I read the first chapter. I made the mistake of reading the preface where Mr. Manchester explained that he wrote this book as a break from writing the final volume to my favorite Winston Churchill biography. He died before he could finish the final volume so his brilliant biography ends in 1945...that's right, at the height of World War II. Useless, but still brilliant.

I think this book lacks on several fronts: no...more
Christian
If you are looking for a well researched and reasoned history of the Dark Ages and the Renaissance do not read this book. If you are looking for a starting point for the Intellectual History of Europe during the Dark Ages and Renaissance; this book might be a good way to go.

The historical accuracy of this book is to be strongly questioned and doubted. However, I still like this book. The reason I like this book is that it is about ideas. What the author does is take a very one sided argumentativ...more
Jane Routley
Didn't finish this. Manchester sees the middle ages as a dark age of ignorance and stagnation the antithesis of the Renaissince. Its a pretty out of date attitude as the current belief is that people invneted and disvoered lots of stuff during the middle ages and that it was the plant that supported the flowering of the Renaissance. Also he's a believer in the Great man view of history also pretty old hat since behind every great man are the toilers who made all his discoveries possible and the...more
Gordon
William Manchester characterizes the Middle Ages as one of "obsession with strange myths and almost impenetrable mindlessness." In fact, this is a perfect description of the flaws of his book, which is among the worst works of history I have ever read. Full disclosure: I put it down in disgust after page 102 and did not pick it up again.

Still, the book did contain the following favorite howlers, which made it so bad that at times it was almost good:
• Medieval people had no sense of time: "Genera...more
Tony
A WORLD LIT ONLY BY FIRE: The Medieval Mind and the Renaissance. Portrait of an Age. (1993). William Manchester. *****.
I’ve been a big fan of Manchester’s books over the years, but I don’t know how I missed this one. It is a popular telling of the history of Europe primarily during the time of the Renaissance, but starts us out at the first sack of Rome in 410 A.D. to the second sack of Rome in 1527 – the end of the Renaissance. This is not a history of Renaissance art, which you might expect,...more
Sherwood Smith
Little primary research and a whole lot of assumptions and judgments about medieval thought made this book repellent. I wondered if it was written fast to gain the popular reader who wants sensational history with a large dose of "We're so much smarter, we moderns."
Mosca
This book is much more a popular epic than it is a serious history. The book is seasoned with sweeping generalizations, prurient and lurid “investigations” into medieval sexuality, and sensationalized descriptions of tortures and executions common to the times. This book seems as if it were written intending to produce a popular, marketable product with the intent to make a profit. There are, of course, many other publications every year with that same intent. There is an entire publication indu...more
Chris Webber
Manchester did an amazing job taking a very convoluted period of time from history and presenting it in an easy-to-read manner. Material rolled out smoothly and was peppered with amazingly specific details that really enhanced my ability to experience medieval times and the nature and plight of the human experience during that era.

For instance, during the times of Henry VII and Henry VII the per capita allowance was a gallon of beer a day - even for nuns and eight year old children. The English...more
Allen
Manchester is highly opinionated, and seldom hesitates to state his opinions as fact. Occasionally those statements border on being flatly wrong. Take this passage on p.12:

"The early Christians, believing that their Lord's return was imminent, celebrated Easter every Sunday. After three hundred years their descendants became reconciled to a delay. In an attempt to link Easter with the Passion, it was scheduled on Passover, the Jewish feast observing the Exodus from Egypt in the thirteenth centu...more
Jack
Nov 29, 2008 Jack rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: History Buffs, Renaissance Faire Patrons and those interested in the history of The Church
Recommended to Jack by: Saw it in Borders at BWI Airport. Manchester is a favorite auth
This is an excellent book on the rise of Christian Europe from the Dark Ages to Medieval times and the Renaissance.

Manchester pulls no punches and leaves no stone unturned when it comes to the corruption of the Papal church, its policies of granting indulgences for a price and how the common people of Europe were actually "Christianized."

He then delves into the Reformation and how it went from a simple religious protest for change back to piety to the fanatical revolution leading to the inquisi...more
Christa
Mar 14, 2012 Christa rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: no one
Recommended to Christa by: several people
Shelves: history
I had been meaning to read this book for a long time. Every time I mentioned reading a book about the Middle Ages, this title seemed to come up, so off to the library I went.

I was very unimpressed. The organization of the book seemed poor almost from the very start. There are no chapter divisions and, seemingly because of this, the author felt free to roam around with little direction. The tone of the entire work is condescending, both to the reader (occasionally), and to the subject matter (al...more
Jack
Aug 13, 2007 Jack rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: people who think the 21st century sucks.
This is a great book to have on your shelf for those times when an iPhone isn't available and you need to find out what Henry the Navigator was like. Or when tou think it sucks that you don't have an iPhone, you can look into this book and see why you don't have it all that bad. Things really sucked when the world was LIT ONLY BY FIRE
Sara
Franny has to read this book for AP European history. I got bogged down in it for a while and there are definitely little things about it that really annoy me: (1) There is an epigraph in German with no translation (or attribution). I asked Uwe to translate it, and I have no idea why it was chosen as an epigraph for the book. (2) At this point in my life, I hardly ever encounter words I don't know, but there were two in this book. "Lentitudinous" from context and etymology obviously means "slow....more
Tara
More propaganda for those who believe everything old is bad and everything new is good. You know what? I'd rather live in a world lit only by fire. Our technology is polluting the skies, polluting the earth, and destroying our landbase. There are more slaves on the planet than at any time in human history - but, but, the Crusades, right? Well, no, let's throw out all our achievements because of our own War on Terror. We have taken the worst from Europe during the Middle Ages, rearranged it, aban...more
Katie
Sep 27, 2008 Katie rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Anyone who likes history or historical fiction
A good companion to medieval historical fiction, Robin Hood, fantasy lit, etc., as well as an aide to church and religious history. He gives a warts-and-all picture of peasant, artisan, clerical and noble life, mostly in the 15th and 16th centuries (little being known about life before then). Actually, make that a wart, pockmark, scrofula, arthritis, and dungheap-and-all picture.

For those loyal to (and innocent about) the Church, here's a bit of a caveat: You won't like the part about the behav...more
Dolly
Until the last year or so, I had not often chosen to read books about history. I think I was just too put off by memorizing dates and names in high school. But I've been impressed with the books I've read recently and my interest is piqued. And this book came highly recommended to me by my hubby's professor, so I figured I'd check it out. Full of intrigue, treachery, lust and greed, it was almost as unbelievable and filled with subplots as a soap opera. They do say that truth is stranger than fi...more
Edwin B
When the Roman empire fell in 5th century AD, Western Europe plunged into the Dark Ages. For a thousand years, barbarian invasions, despotic kings, mercenary knights, corrupt popes, unreasoning Church dogma, intolerance, brute force, superstition, greed, strife and violence ruled the land.

It was from this millenium of darkness that humanism emerged, and against this backdrop of backwardness that the Renaissance shone. In the 15th century, Western Europe rediscovered the Greek classics. The use o...more
'Aussie Rick'

Firstly I must admit that I have very little knowledge of the Renaissance (I found it a boring subject at school!) but I found this book to be a very interesting and entertaining account of that period. The author makes clear at the start of the book that it was not going to be a scholarly masterpiece. Fair enough, he produced what I think was a good book that got you thinking about the subject he was presenting. Now that he has sparked your interest you can go and find some scholarly tome to ge...more
Chris
Nov 21, 2007 Chris rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: history buffs
certainly not a light read. this was a text i was supposed to read in college, but i just got to it last year. it is exactly what the title says, a portrait of the middle ages progressing into the renaissance. i dont think ive ever learned more from a single book. manchester gets down to the most barbaric details of medieval times, while also capturing more worldly themes. i really enjoyed it!
James Holloway
This semester Reading the book a world lit only by fire by William Manchester was fun. A book about the history and mindset man through medieval times and the renaissance. Manchester divides the book into 3 parts: The medieval mind, the shattering, and one man alone. And Manchester goes into great detail in the longest section of the book, the shattering. He goes on and on about the renaissance and the protestant reformation and how it was a “shattering” of the medieval mindset that was in place...more
Jared Logan
This book is breathtakingly good. It's a history that tells how mankind moved from 'the dark ages' -- the 700+ years of savagery and superstition that followed the sack of Rome -- to the illumination of the renaissance in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, an age that saw colossal advancements in science, art and personal identity.

The subtitle is "the medieval mind and the renaissance' and William Manchester starts by deftly guiding you through the medieval point of view. He paints an unforg...more
Loryn
Well, I had to read this for school, so I figured I'd add it. I just read the ending tonight. This one is set up into 3 chunks. I had to write a paper on one, and make a presentation on the other two (one of which I'm about to write out for class tomorrow). I liked it- I did. He made some really interesting points. But I think there was a problem for me connecting all three parts together, and even the pages throughout the parts themselves. Part 1 is a general summary of the medieval-renaissance...more
Tracey, librarian on strike
A little research shows that some of what Manchester presents in this book with utmost certainty isn't at all certain. His brief discussion of the Pied Piper of Hamelin is only one of several explanations for the origins of the legend, and the most tabloid-worthy; apparently the tales of Francis I's sexual exploits are a bit shaky. A review on Amazon says A World Lit Only by Fire is "known among medievalists merely as 'that book'"; there's a wide divergence of opinion on it, with both five-star...more
Barbara
I liked this book, until I read some of the reviews on this website. The idea that the author could be playing "fast & loose" with the facts really dampened my enthusiasm. So, where I would usually say "I learned a lot", I'm not certain I can say that in this case. I do protest (the author's dead, I know) his use of ridiculously obscure words (many olde english) without explaining them, even foreign phrases. Are we all just supposed to know this? Toward the end of the book I began writing th...more
Nosnah
History buffs and religious savaunts and quite frankly really anyone in between, this book is a MUST READ!
(5 out of 5) stars go to William Manchester for enlightening and freeing my mind from the dark, dingy and simply truth-lacking pages that were originally my basis for history.
For all those questioning the credibility of the facts or dates or happenings outlined throughout this novel, do some of your own research and open your eyes to the truth. Although Manchester writes in detail about in...more
Timothy Killeen
Mr. Manchester needs to decide what he wants to do: write a history of the Middle Ages and Rennaissance, or an essay about how terrible is the Church. He begins the book rather interestingly, giving an idea (albeit a highly challenged one) of what the Middle Ages were like for an average European peasant. This is a story that is seldom told and, actually, seemed fairly engaging. However, he quickly gets to his point that such a peasant was kept down by a leacherous and evil Church (not that man...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Why's Magellan so special? 4 29 Jan 09, 2013 08:34AM  
  • The Civilization Of Europe In The Renaissance
  • Life in a Medieval City
  • The Civilization of the Middle Ages
  • The Waning of the Middle Ages
  • The Year 1000: What Life Was Like at the Turn of the First Millennium
  • A Distant Mirror:  The Calamitous 14th Century
  • The Middle Ages
  • 1066: The Year of the Conquest
  • Worldly Goods: A New History of the Renaissance
  • The Hundred Years War: The English in France 1337-1453
  • Mysteries of the Middle Ages: The Rise of Feminism, Science and Art from the Cults of Catholic Europe
  • Medieval Civilization 400-1500
  • The Oxford History of Medieval Europe
  • 1215: The Year of Magna Carta
  • The Greatest Traitor: The Life of Sir Roger Mortimer, Ruler of England 1327-1330
  • A History of the Crusades, Vol. III: The Kingdom of Acre and the Later Crusades
  • The Ties That Bound: Peasant Families in Medieval England
  • Terry Jones' Medieval Lives
11789
William Raymond Manchester was an American author and biographer, notable as the bestselling author of 18 books that have been translated into 20 languages.He was awarded the National Humanities Medal and the Abraham Lincoln Literary Award.
More about William R. Manchester...
American Caesar: Douglas MacArthur 1880-1964 The Last Lion 1: Visions of Glory 1874-1932 The Last Lion 2: Winston Spencer Churchill Alone, 1932-40 Goodbye, Darkness: A Memoir of the Pacific War The Death of a President: November 1963

Share This Book