Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Black Girl,/White Girl” as Want to Read:
Black Girl,/White Girl
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Black Girl,/White Girl

3.22 of 5 stars 3.22  ·  rating details  ·  2,176 ratings  ·  259 reviews
Fifteen years ago, in 1975, Genna Hewett-Meade's college roommate died a mysterious, violent, terrible death. Minette Swift had been a fiercely individualistic scholarship student, an assertive—even prickly—personality, and one of the few black girls at an exclusive women's liberal arts college near Philadelphia. By contrast, Genna was a quiet, self-effacing teenager from ...more
ebook, 304 pages
Published October 13th 2009 by HarperCollins e-books (first published 2006)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Black Girl,/White Girl, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Black Girl,/White Girl

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
The title and book description are misleading. The book has very little to do with race relations, and more to do with the white girl's dysfunctional relationship with her politically controversial father and her own feelings of guilt. The characters are not at all likable, or even ones I could relate to or understand. The white girl tries obnoxiously hard to befriend her black roommate, who everyone else--including the other black students--finds intolerable. The white girl's fixation is rather ...more
From the title of this book and the soundbites on the back cover you would assume this is a book about race in 1960s America. And it is, but it is also a book about a lot more. Mostly, to me, it seemed to be a book about white middle class guilt and political correctness.

The story is written as the 'confession' of Genna Meade, a white 18 year old girl from a rich yet extremely dysfunctional family. Genna's parents are aging radical hippies who have rejected their elitist upbringing and inheritan
While I was expecting superior writing from a novelist as celebrated as Oates (this was my first one) and didn't consistently find it, I have to give her credit for tackling an unusual and difficult subject. White Girl's unrequited yearning for friendship with her (Black Girl) roommate rings true for the time and place depicted. It's a little mysterious as to why Oates chose to make Black Girl so strange and troubled. But then White Girl was pretty troubled too, probably par for the course for t ...more
Larry Bassett
When I was a 10 years old Cub Scout having a regular meeting at TW’s house, his mother found a piece of cake behind the couch; it seemed important to her to determine who had dropped it there. When no one accepted responsibility she took us aside one by one to be questioned about our possible guilt or our possible knowledge of who was guilty. Later I heard that the criminal was found out, but not how or who. That same year I dropped a quarter behind a couch in my house and couldn’t find it no ma ...more
We're accustomed to thinking of race in terms of it being fraught with tension. It has import; it's a Big Deal.

The strength (or weakness, depending on who you ask) of Black Girl/White Girl is that it is a book ostensibly about race written at a very close, personal range. It is an ordinary story about ordinary individuals who are in circumstances that put them ill-at-ease. Genna's circumstances are ones she's grown up with and obsessed over for a long time; Minette's are ones that seem to be re
Abigail Hillinger
Although this book took quite awhile to get into (169 pages, to be precise), I'm glad I read it. Joyce Carol Oates has written a ridiculous number of books, and I was worried her style would be like the female version of Nicholas Sparks--not quite chick-litty or romance, but just...I don't know, 'cheap'. She's definitely not.

There are several techniques she uses that other writers might want to try--her different formations for flashbacks, her repetition of certain phrases/thoughts, the clues of
Caroline Alicia
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
In the searing style of Joyce Carol Oates, we come to know the characters of this tale of the seventies: a story of black and white differences, racial discrimination, and the gray areas of morality.

Two girls from very different backgrounds share a room in the dorm at Schuyler College near Philadelphia: A black minister's daughter from Washington, D. C., and the daughter of Maximilian Meade, wealthy and privileged, yet representing the civil rights of anti-war protestors and terrorists; he is al
Jess Wisloski
This was good, but apparently not good enough for me to remember too well. I know it was compelling, and had something to do with a self-concious, but proud, young Southern black girl who wound up roommates with a self-hating liberal whitey from Pennsylvania. The black girl's own deliberate extracation of herself from the uppity school's largely white, but even black, female community baffles and intrigues her friend, who guiltily takes pride in having a black friend, and uses it as a token to c ...more
I was completely misled by the summary of this book in the inside jacket. I really thought " Black Girl/White Girl" was about the mysterious circumstances surrounding the murder of black liberal arts student at predominately white private school and her roommates finally admiting 15 years later that show was involved and/or know who killed her. Boy, was I mistaken. This is probably the lamest book I've read in years. Minnette Swift "The black girl" is one of the most unlikeable characters in lit ...more
Truth in advertising would require this book to be called White Girl. Ostensibly about two college roommates, one the scion of a white liberal family with a long history of progressive politics and the other the daughter of an African-American minister, it's really about Genna, the white girl of the title, and her relationship w/her radical chic parents and her longing to befriend and be trusted by Minette, the black girl of the title. We see Minette through Genna's eyes, and as even fifteen yea ...more
Shy Genna Meade is descended from hippie activists and abolitionist quakers. Self assured Minette Swift is the daughter of a preacher and one of the few Black students at Schuyler College. Can Genna overcome Minette's tough exterior to reach the person underneath she desperately wants to connect to?

I actually put this down when I first bought it, after a few chapters I couldn't seem to get into it. I picked it up 2 years later and sped right through. Joyce Carol Oates prose is absolutely beautif
I saw some other reviews about how the title and inside jacket were misleading, and I too thought it was about one thing, when it really was about another, but I do not think that should dissuade anyone from reading this strangely suspenseful and mildly uncomfortable book.

I say suspenseful because there is a build up to this tragic death that we have all been waiting for since page 1, as Gemma Meade recalls 15 years later the months leading up to the day that her college roommate Minette Swift
Well, I guess it's inevitable that a prolific writer of 50+ novels would write a clunker or two. I've been a big fan of her dour prose for decades now, and not once have I disliked anything she's bestowed upon us.

And then there's the poorly-titled (if not -conceived) "Black Girl White Girl" starts promisingly enough, with our "white girl", a daughter of a wealthy liberal Quaker family (a family with ties to Black rights movements and the Underground Railroad) who goes off to college in the
Joyce Carol Oates is a very smart author. She knows a lot about location, a lot about history, and a lot about language. However, as a reader, I often find myself feeling very aware of these things as I read her books: that she, as the author, is going to tell me about this location or this event in history or that now, she is going to use this particularly literary device to tell this section of her story. Instead of enhancing her stories, it often fragments them for me, the reader.
In Black Gir
I stumbled upon this book at a recent Joyce Carol Oates reading/signing in my area. (Although the tour was for her new book Dear Husband, I opted for this paperback instead.)

Well-written and detailed, this novel drew me in bit by bit. While I kept reading to find out the fate of the characters, it seemed the entire thing was imbalanced. The main character, Genna's perspective was obsessive and distorted, the dysfunction of her family evident in the fragmented narration. Meanwhile, her black room
Jim Leckband
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Apr 28, 2008 Ola rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: one who wants to read something different
Disclaimer: do not read this book in search of a happy ending. You won't find it here. I promise.

Generva Meade, daughter of radical activist lawyer Maximillian Meade and ex-flower child Veronica Hewett-Meade, is in her freshman year at Schuyler College, some old Quaker school founded by her great grandfather and known for promoting racial integration. She seeks friendship with her roomate Minette Swift, a Merit scholar student, daughter of Revered Virgil Swift.

Generva tries from the start to ear
This book was an interesting exploration of a fictional Caucasian character Genevra Meade, who was assigned to room with an African-American young woman and the story of what happens, their relationship, some insights/questions into race relations, and eventually the death of that roommate (this is revealed in the blurb on the book jacket, so I don't feel like it's a spoiler). I like the way the author spins out details about the characters - some older remembered details and some newer currentl ...more
Oates does such a good job at exploring anxiety and neurosis . I could feel every ounce of the tension and social awkwardness between Genna and Minette, and I really got inside their crazy heads. This was a great snapshot of a particular moment in time as well as a fascinating character study.

I wasn't crazy about the subplot with Genna's father (it was one of those things that either needed more development or to just be dropped completely) but that's a minor nitpick.
Jul 17, 2009 Cris rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: anyone with insomnia..
gosh, i really disliked this book.. it was boring, the title was misleading, the characters totally unlikable..

i may be somewhat dense, but i just did not get what this book was about? a troubled black girl on a merit scholarship to a private northeast college in the mid 70s? or her equally troubled white roommate struggling with her wacky childhood growing up as the daughter of a radical lawyer?

i feel robbed of my time. the title was misleading- and the book itself is misleading-very early in
Ryan Heaven
After having reading Oates' 'Black Water' I longed to read more of her work - and came to reading this one. Oates' characterisation is impeccable here and her control of plot and narrative is enviable. This book really does make you look into yourself and will lead you to find things that maybe you didn't want to notice. Although the political sections of the book dragged slightly, the mysterious characters of Genna and Minette kept me hooked. I'll most definitely be reading more of Oates' work ...more
Paul V.
This is the first Joyce Carol Oates book I've read, and I found it an enigma: Most of the book is about the narrator, a white freshman in an Eastern girls college and her relationship with her roommate, who is a black national merit scholar. The black roommate seems not to be liked by anyone at the school--white or black. She comes off as very resentful and uncommunicative (she only calls her roommate by her name twice). The narrator is a freshman woman who just about kills herself getting her r ...more
Three and a half. The prolific Oates tackles big issues again in Black Girl/White Girl. Most of the reviews I have read here acknowledged the disappointing plot development, moving away from the relationship between white girl Genna Meade and black girl, her freshman roommate Minette Swift. The plot does stray from them, but--and this is important for appreciating what Oates is trying to do--it does so in order to articulate the similarly complex relationship between Genna and her family and Gen ...more
Pamela Scott
HIGHLIGHTS: Oates’s characterisation is spot on. She does a great job of showing us how abrasive Minette is. Genna proves to be an interesting contrast to her. Genna doesn’t just try to befriend Minette; she becomes obsessed with defending her no matter how abrasive and unpleasant Minette is. Minette’s mental health starts to decline as the ‘racial harassment’ becomes gradually worse. These scenes were very well written. I had no idea Minette was actually responsibly for the ‘attacks’ until Oate ...more

Che mi piacciano i romanzi della Oates non è un mistero; che io brami di leggere qualsiasi suo scritto neppure. Ma questa volta con il romanzo “Ragazza nera ragazza bianca” un pochetto, ma solo pochetto proprio poco, mi ha delusa. Se avete voglia di sapere perché… stay tuned!

La trama di “Ragazza nera ragazza bianca” ha tutti i presupposti per essere un romanzo memorabile: anni ’70, un’America che sta combattendo in Vietnam assieme ad un Nixon coinvolto nello scandalo Watergate; Minnette Swift e
Drew me in, getting deeper and deeper into the characters and their themes of loneliness, separation and redemption
Angélique Moreau
I was expecting to love this book which was the first one I read by this author, in its French version, but I was a tad disappointed. Maybe the theme didn't really match what I wanted to read at the time?

It is nevertheless a novel that deals with life in the United States in the 1960, as they are trying to escape from an atmosphere that cannot be called racial segregation anymore, but still reeks of daily racism, which middle-class white good-thinking is trying to eradicate, but only ends up res
My second JCO and, apart from the protagonist's gender, very different. Still within the mood set by the text, the WASP in me thinks I should make some socio-political comment, but the purer reader in me is resistant, as the characters stand as individuals rather than as representatives of their race and class - although, of course, such issues pervade every breath we take.
It is a strong book with an unreliable narrator - unreliable as we all are when we perceive with the doors closed as we must
First off, there are many mixed reviews about this book; it just depends on whose opinion you ask for. Other authors like Oates and people with a more literary background would mostly all agree on one thing. This is a fabulous book. But I am sad to say, I disagree. For the average, everyday reader this book is way too “heavy”. Heavy in the sense that it is way too complicated, complex, difficult, hard to understand…whatever term you want to use. There is so much detail you tend to get over whelm ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • O Caso Morel (Colecção Mil Folhas, #87)
  • La speculazione edilizia
  • A Plan for Escape
  • Sukkwan Island
  • Instrucciones para salvar el mundo
  • Estórias Abensonhadas
  • Sunset Ridge
  • Il filo dell'orizzonte
  • In the Galapagos Islands with Herman Melville, the Encantadas or Enchanted Isles
  • Starr Bright Will Be With You Soon
  • Some Like It Haute
  • Silent Interviews: On Language, Race, Sex, Science Fiction, and Some Comics--A Collection of Written Interviews
  • Fever
  • The Darkest Hour (Detective Ella Marconi #2)
  • Os Transparentes
  • Lunar Caustic
  • Two Testaments: A Novel (The Secrets of the Cross Trilogy #2)
  • The Last Will & Testament of Senhor da Silva Araújo
Joyce Carol Oates is a recipient of the National Book Award and the PEN/Malamud Award for Excellence in Short Fiction. She is also the recipient of the 2005 Prix Femina for The Falls. She is the Roger S. Berlind Distinguished Professor of the Humanities at Princeton University, and she has been a member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters since 1978. Pseudonyms ... Rosamond Smith and Laure ...more
More about Joyce Carol Oates...
We Were the Mulvaneys The Falls The Gravedigger's Daughter Blonde Foxfire: Confessions of a Girl Gang

Share This Book

“And the thought consoled me, as it does now: everything you believe you have imagined is real. You have only to outlive it.” 7 likes
More quotes…