The Punishment of Virtue: Inside Afghanistan After the Taliban
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Punishment of Virtue: Inside Afghanistan After the Taliban

3.91 of 5 stars 3.91  ·  rating details  ·  396 ratings  ·  63 reviews
As a former star reporter for NPR, Sarah Chayes developed a devoted listenership for her on-site reports on conflicts around the world. In The Punishment of Virtue, she reveals the misguided U.S. policy in Afghanistan in the wake of the defeat of the Taliban, which has severely undermined the effort to build democracy and allowed corrupt tribal warlords back into positions...more
Hardcover, 386 pages
Published August 17th 2006 by Penguin Press HC, The (first published January 1st 2006)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Punishment of Virtue, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Punishment of Virtue

The Great Game by Peter HopkirkThree Cups of Tea by Greg MortensonThe Places in Between by Rory StewartMoron to Moron by Tom  DoigThe Empire of the Steppes by René Grousset
Central Asia
136th out of 142 books — 26 voters
The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret AtwoodThe Crucible by Arthur MillerThe Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel HawthorneStolen Innocence by Elissa WallUnder the Banner of Heaven by Jon Krakauer
Religion Gone Too Far
89th out of 96 books — 72 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,170)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Will Byrnes
Sarah Chayes offers an incisive, on-the-ground look at the reality of the conflict in Afghanistan. She informs her observations with historical research, ongoing contact with many significant political players in the country and the experience of living in the country for many years, and comes up with a better understanding of the forces at play than I have seen anywhere else. Her story begins while she is working as a foreign correspondent for NPR, and living with an Afghani family in Kandahar....more
40brown
I have (finally!) finished reading “The Punishment of Virtue; Inside Afghanistan After the Taliban,” by Sarah Chayes. It took as lot longer than I thought it would to finish it. I am both sorry and glad it is over.

This is an intriguing and complex look at warlordism in Afghanistan. It is at times thrilling, a true page turner, made even more exciting by the fact that it is a true insider’s account of post 9-11 Afghanistan. Sarah Chayes certainly knows Afghanistan like no one else - she has lived...more
Gaijinmama
This is a heart-wrenching first-person account of an NPR journalist who ends up quitting her job and basing herself in
Kandahar to run a nonprofit organization and try to do some real good for the people of Afghanistan.
This is not an objective account.
She makes it clear right from the start that she is VERY angry about the way things in Afghanistan have been handled on all sides.
She has an agenda and is absolutely certain of the rightness of her cause and methods. Also, this cause is most defin...more
Ruth
Jan 30, 2008 Ruth rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: Anyone interested in Afghanistan.
Shelves: other-nonfiction
This was a very interesting read about what was happening in Afghanistan after September 11. Sarah Chayes was a reporter who spent some time in the country while the war was going on and after the war when the government was being established. She was close to some high officials in the Afghan government and met many more. Her story seemed slightly biased in that she was very loyal to a few people and portrayed them as nearly perfect in her book; in reality, they may not have been as angelic as...more
Joyce
Nov 26, 2007 Joyce rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: those interested in Afghanistan
Shelves: journalism
This is a weird little number. The author was a reporter for National Public Radio and went in with the U.S. invasion in 2001. She was charmed by both the people and the region she went to - Kandahar. So she left NPR, set up her own charity organization and settled in to do good. She is quickly disillusioned by the U.S. military and government's lack of understanding of the Afghan people and the continuing role Pakistan has been playing in keeping things stirred up. Also, she's a bit too self-im...more
Caitlin
An amazing account of both the history of Afghanistan and its current problems, largely as a result of American mismanagement. Highly recommended to anyone who wants to understand the current conflict.
Ron
This highly readable book is part memoir and part political analysis. The author, a former overseas NPR correspondent, describes her sojourn over the years 2001-2005 in Kandahar, the ancient capital of Afghanistan, where she worked for an Afghan-based NGO and, as an instinctive investigative reporter, formed her own assessment of the political forces at work in that post-Taliban city.

Her conclusions are both alarming and disheartening. She comes to believe that Pakistan is the root cause of poli...more
Matt
Great title, not a very informative book. Despite Sebastian Junger's line on the back ("Every American who wants to know why planes flew into buildings on Sept 11 must buy this book"), this book has nothing to do with that. Nor is Ahmed Rashid or Steve Coll right in their reviews.

I work in Afghanistan (been here 7 months, will be here for 15+ more) and to be honest... by and large, the things she describes are just not all that significant. The murder of her friend (and subsequent investigation...more
Giuliana
Sarah Chayes was an NPR reporter until she was sent to Kandahar. She decided then to quit her reporting job, learn Pashto, and help the Afghan people rebuild their homes and start cooperatives. More than that, her judgment and willingness to adopt the Afghan way of life allowed her to work as intermediary between the Afghani people and the U.S. military.

This wonderful, passionate, and engaging book retells Chayes' first years in Afghanistan and presents a moving portrait of the Afghan people. I...more
Aisling
An amazing account of Afghanistan post Taliban by former NPR reporter Sarah Chayes. A fascinating insider account of the opposing forces, duplicity, backsliding, lies and downright stupidity that has plagued that country.
What an extraordinary brave woman Ms Chayes is and she clearly loves Afghanistan and it's people and has gained a superb understanding of the culture and character of the Afgha people but she does not allow that love to blind her to the negatives. Amazing that a woman journalist...more
Joel Justiss
Chayes gives a first-hand look at the politics and society of southern Afghanistan from 2001 to 2005, with some chapters on the history of the area since the ninth century. She tells a tragic story of a country steeped in tribalism, a government saddled with a tradition of corruption, and damaging U.S. policies based on misunderstandings of the Afghan social power structure.

11 I don’t believe in the clash of civilizations. I believe that most human beings share basic aspirations and values.
It se...more
Steve Van Slyke
It's a sobering look at the realities of life in Afghanistan. One of the prime points that emerges is that there is not one, nor even three (as in the case of Iraq) entities to deal with to reach an agreement on how the country should be governed. There are instead a multitude of tribes. It would be as if the British, instead of coming to North America to colonize in the 1600s, had come instead come to help the native population establish a national government. How do you get tribes that have be...more
Anand Gopal
After covering the fall of the Taliban, NPR reporter Sarah Chayes grew frustrated with editorial censorship, quit and moved to Kandahar as an aid worker. At least that's the official story. In reality, Chayes acts as a de facto policy adviser to President Karzai, the interior minister, and an assortment of American officials.

The book is a curious mix of a recounting of her crusade against warlordism and a retelling of distant Afghan history. She delivers perhaps the best account of post-Taliban...more
AmblingBooks
Jul 25, 2012 AmblingBooks marked it as to-read  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: audiobooks, history
A NPR reporter covering the last stand of the Taliban in their home base of Kandahar in Afghanistan's southern borderland, Sarah Chayes became deeply immersed in the unfolding drama of the attempt to rebuild a broken nation at the crossroads of the world's destiny. Her NPR tour up in early 2002, she left reporting to help turn the country's fortunes, accepting a job running a nonprofit founded by President Hamid Karzai's brother. With remarkable access to leading players in the postwar governmen...more
Tanya
Wow, I feel like I've just taken a course on the history, government, and political situation in Afghanistan. The complexity of it all baffles me! I hear again and again how we lack a strong intelligence network, and then I read this account by Sarah Chayes and see how her deep knowledge was ignored again and again... I see how U.S. foreign policy is often determined by troops on the ground with little understanding of background or longterm implications of their actions... And I now understand...more
Diane
The author tells the story of her entering Afghanistan as an NPR reporter when the war first began after 911. She then became an NGO employee, and finally, a business woman making soap and moisturing products from the resources around Kandahar. Since Kandahar was the home of the Taliban who were just ousted before she arrived as a reporter, the city was still dangerous. However she insisted on staying with the people in Kandahar rather than with her fellow reporters or NGO workers. Through her m...more
Colleen Clark
I read this a couple of years ago. Like many people I was fascinated by her account of living in Afghanistan after 9/11. Just this month (july 2010) I gave this book as a house present to a family full of people interested in the world. Although it was published several years ago I think it's completely relevant to our current involvement in Afghanistan. I heard Chayes say in a TV interview last year that she was working now with the US military. I wonder if she has revised her opinion. What I t...more
Dennis Fischman
Apr 15, 2009 Dennis Fischman rated it 3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: someone who has already read Ghost Wars.
Shelves: nonfiction
This book is a very mixed bag. The historical chapters make me want to go and read the Shahnameh and to find some good sources on the Mughal empire. The contemporary chapters are exciting and informative. I have to admire Sarah Chayes' honesty: when she realizes she's made a mistake or she has been too naive or trusting, she lets you see exactly how. Yet somehow, she still seems confident in her own judgment. I can forgive that: I used to say, "I'd rather be self-righteous than not be righteous...more
Tim
An excellent example of a former journalist becoming an NGO within Afghanistan before the US and the coalition of the willing invasion and during the first few months of that invasion. We look into the nightmarish life within the warzone with the perpetual improvised explosive ordinances claiming the lives of people known to Sarah Chayes in this tell all version of her experiences in Afghanistan. A candid look at the war against Terrorism from the village level and the daily routines of Sarah Ch...more
Yvonne
Sarah Chayes, former NPR reporter and now purusing humanitarian initiatives in Afghanistan accounts her experiences in-country during the breakout of the war and the pursuing years of failures and limited sucesses. She gets into the heart of the local and regional politics and explains why the US State Department or the Military have been so challenged. Eye-opening indeed, yet not terribly surprising. Sarah spends a lot of time delving into the region's history, which can be rather dull reading...more
Peggy Kelsey
Oct 02, 2012 Peggy Kelsey rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: anyone interested in understanding Afghanistan.
Shelves: afghanistan
Chayes was a National Public Radio (NPR) reporter from 1997-2002. She quit her job reporting on Afghanistan to work for Afghans for a Civil Society and later founded an NGO, Arghand Cooperative. This book explores the current situation in terms of her experience living in Kandahar and is grounded in a history of the area. This is one of the most important books I've read yet on Afghanistan for its cultural as well as political understanding of the country and general US foreign policy. Written a...more
Kevin
A compelling and well-written read at least partially undone by the author's self-righteousness, narcissism and sanctimoniousness. By going native for a couple of years she apparently knows more what ails the country than the Afghanis themselves. Her observations and invectives on the unwinding of the country seem apt, but, given we never get much of any perspective other than her own, it's tough to know. As the "Three Cups of Tea" controversy makes clear, one should always be a little leary of...more
David
I've been doing quite a bit of research about Afghanistan and its history and this is the single, best-written, most comprehensive, and insightful book I've read on the subject. I can't think of a single negative to say about it. I'm going to put Sarah Chayes next to Robert Kaplan as one of the best, immersive, travelling, balanced-reporting journalists around. Sarah tells the fascinating story of her own involvement in the local politics in addition to the traditional objective reporting and su...more
Martha
Jun 30, 2008 Martha rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: people wanting a quick, readable introduction to recent Afghani history.
Recommended to Martha by: Saw author at a bookstore reading.
I learned a lot about the current/recent security and political situation in Afghanistan. The author is pretty well-connected with local government officials in Kandahar and members of the Karzai family. Even if you don't take what she says at 100% face value (she comes across as both naive and biased), you get a close-up look at some of the players in Afghani politics it will help inform your reading of unfolding events there. It's definitely just one, very limited perspective, but you can read...more
Laura
Wow. Chayes' book has raised so many issues and questions -- all that I do not know about this area of the world; how ill-informed Americans are, not just laypeople like me, but the armed forces, the state department, and journalists; what is the role of the U.S. overseas; and on and on.

I saw Chayes on The Rachel Maddow Show this week -- nice timing for me. I was glad to see that she was still in Afghanistan and that she is now an advisor to the U.S. military.

Suzanne
I read this book after hearing an interview with the author on NPR. I found some parts of it confusing and hard to follow but I guess that is part of the point - the history and politics of Afghanistan is hard to follow. It gave me a better understanding of Afghanistan.

She also has a very good vocabulary. I found myself noting some words that I needed to look up. It's nice to have a book that stretches your vocabulary every once and a while!
Stephanie
I didn't know much about the war in Afghanistan before reading this book, and I was worried this book would be a slow, somewhat boring read. I was pleasantly surprised at how many sections were page-turners, and the story of the author Sarah Chayes is fascinating and her involvement in politics in Kandahar. I would recommend this book for anyone looking to learn about the war in Afghanistan in 2001 and to get an outsider's insider perspective.
Whitney
This book is, similar to "Sewing Circles of Herat," is a book by a white female reporter about her experiences in Afghanistan, but what a difference! Where Christina Lamb gives her superficial impressions, here Sarah Chayes goes deep into historical analysis and the subtleties of the political and military players after the US invasion and comes out the other side with this extremely satisfying, dense and nuanced book.
Elizabeth S. Q. Goodman
I rate this with 5 stars primarily because I think everyone should read it. There are a lot of books that give shockingly different perspectives on countries than those Americans get from the usual media...but this one also points out the differences. It's a little too emotional at points to be taken as seriously as it should be, but I believe what the author writes and she should be taken seriously.
Roberto
excellent book to gain an understanding of the monumental obstacles that country is facing (the U.S. being one of them, but so is the U.S. media and that includes NPR). Chayes is an expert writer. She makes the history of Afghanistan just come to life and by inserting herself into the narrative just makes the experience of reading the book seem so personal. I loved it.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 38 39 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Descent into Chaos: The United States & the Failure of Nation Building in Pakistan, Afghanistan & Central Asia
  • Engaging the Muslim World
  • Afghanistan: A Short History of Its People and Politics
  • In the Graveyard of Empires: America's War in Afghanistan
  • Afghanistan
  • Seeds of Terror: How Heroin Is Bankrolling the Taliban and al Qaeda
  • An Unexpected Light: Travels in Afghanistan
  • Broken Government: How Republican Rule Destroyed the Legislative, Executive, and Judicial Branches
  • The Duel: Pakistan on the Flight Path of American Power
  • Good Muslim, Bad Muslim: America, the Cold War, and the Roots of Terror
  • Lessons in Disaster: McGeorge Bundy and the Path to War in Vietnam
  • Taj Mahal: Passion and Genius at the Heart of the Moghul Empire
  • Ruins
  • Kabul in Winter: Life Without Peace in Afghanistan
  • The Dark Valley: A Panorama of the 1930s
  • Treacherous Alliance: The Secret Dealings of Israel, Iran, and the United States
  • The Muslim Discovery of Europe
  • The Devil We Know: Dealing with the New Iranian Superpower
Thieves of State: Why Corruption Threatens Global Security The Punishment of Virtue

Share This Book