Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “A Secret Gift: How One Man's Kindness--and a Trove of Letters--Revealed the Hidden History of t he Great Depression” as Want to Read:
A Secret Gift: How One Man's Kindness--and a Trove of Letters--Revealed the Hidden History of t he Great Depression
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

A Secret Gift: How One Man's Kindness--and a Trove of Letters--Revealed the Hidden History of t he Great Depression

3.53 of 5 stars 3.53  ·  rating details  ·  1,722 ratings  ·  496 reviews
"A wonderful reminder that economic hardship can bring suffering but can also foster compassion and community." -The Boston Globe In hard economic times like these, readers will find bestselling author Ted Gup's unique book uplifting as well as captivating. Inside a suitcase kept in his mother's attic, Gup discovered letters written to his grandfather in response to an ad ...more
Paperback, 384 pages
Published October 25th 2011 by Penguin Books (first published 2010)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about A Secret Gift, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about A Secret Gift

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Jeannette Gloge
This book had a very interesting premise. However, I found a lot of redundency in reading the book. I felt like I was being hit over the head many times with the same phrases and wording. How may times does the writer have to spell out that many people do not like to accept charity, but would like to work for a living! I know the content of the letters are repetative, but does the writer also have to hammer the words in his script as well.

Also, I felt the writer was enamored of this journey int
I read this book because I was born in Canton and grew up there and in nearby North Canton; and because I like reading about historical events and times. I had hoped to find a window into the Depression-era Canton my father and his family lived in through these letters. I was also intrigued to find out what the "hidden" history was.

I learned a few things about Canton that I didn't know, but not much new about the Depression - certainly nothing that qualified as a hidden history. Aside from the l
Kay Wright
A business man decides to give $10 gifts to the neediest families in Canton Ohio in 1934. In 200? his grandson finds a suitcase of letters from those needing help and decides to follow up on the families. Interesting idea, good New Yorker article but not enough there for a 300 page book. The stories are all the same, there's no enlightenment about the depression and the grandson tries to make the story more exciting by hyping his grandfather's lack of citizenship. I can't decide if the book does ...more
I wanted to love this book! The premise was unique and inspiring. I sympathized with the author's uncovering of his grandfather's background, and the discovery of his charitable gift. However, I soon realized the book was too disjointed to allow the stories to shine through. I recognized he wanted to weave the stories of those struggling with the Great Depression's hardships along with his grandfather's background and secrets, but it was not done well. The chapter segues were awkward, and he rep ...more
This book gave me a huge insight about the Depression. This book is about a man, Sam Stone, who places an ad under a false name in the Canton, Ohio newspaper offering $10 to 75 needy families for Christmas in 1933 if people will write to him and explain why they need the money. He had so many replies he decided to help 150 families with $5 each. The author intermingles Sam's life story with the stories of the people who wrote the letters to Sam. The letters were stored in a suitcase which was gi ...more
I'd say this was 2.5 stars. I liked it, but I'm not wild about. I love the premise and the idea of a generous man anonymously helping out those who needed it the most in the middle of the depression, but I somewhat annoyed with the writing. I felt like the author was somewhat spoonfeeding us the details of Sam Stone's background and I would have rather come to my own conclusions about his kindness. That's just me though. I love hearing about the different people affected by the gift of the $5 an ...more
I was very excited about this book but it was a little bit of a let down. It was good when the author stuck to telling the stories about the people from the letters. But he often strayed from their stories to insert his own opinion and he seemed to feel the need to remind the reader how horrible the depression was(which wasn't needed as just reading about the families and their dire situations as the reader it was very clear that they were in a depression). At the end of the book the author prov ...more
Kelsey Bryant
I'm writing a novel that partially takes place in Canton during the Great Depression, and this was an absolutely fabulous book for my purposes. I love letters, family histories, and family mysteries as well, so it kept my interest riveted. It was touching and gave eye-opening insight into the mindset of the times. The details about life in Canton are invaluable to me. I will be rereading it!
Nov 30, 2010 Molly rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Molly by: TLC
Reading The Secret Gift, put me in remembrance of Jason Wright's Christmas Jars. The way it's written, the theme, and outcome. However, I can't fully compare the two because the stories ARE different and, of course, one is bigger than the other. The time eras are also different. It's just the meaning behind the story and the emotions that I feel as I read them both. The Secret Gift is a life changing book. So much so, that I feel this book TOPS Christmas Jars. Simply put: I loved this book.

marcus miller
A rather interesting story which combines stories from the Great Depression along with some unique family history. Gup tells the story of being given a box of papers belonging to his grandfather. When he gets around to looking through them he discovers his grandfather had made an offer in the midst of the Depression. Placing an ad in the Canton, OH newspaper, Gup's grandfather offered to give small amounts of money to people suffering from the Depression. The ad was targeted towards those who h ...more
The Christmas season has long been known as the season of giving. When we think of holiday giving we usually think of what to give our loved ones, the boss, or perhaps to a charitable organization. During the Great Depression giving of any kind was an option for very few. The unique exemption was found in Canton Ohio in an ad placed by a Mr. Virdot. A few days before Christmas 1933 Mr. Virdot placed an ad in the paper in which he invited readers to describe their hardships and seventy five reade ...more
Holly (2 Kids and Tired)
I enjoyed this story. I enjoyed it so much that when it disappeared during my recent move, I was more than annoyed. I'm anxious to finish it as soon as it turns up, but my review will be the same, no matter what. Simply put, this is just a captivating book. It's a fascinating look into the lives of every day people during the depression. It's the story of a generous man, who wasn't immune to the troubles of the time, but a man who, during the Christmas of 1933, found himself better off than most ...more
i did like this book, but it took me a LONG time to get through it. the premise of the book is that the author's grandfather gave a gift of money at christmas time to a number of families during the great depression after they wrote to him in response to an ad he put in the paper. the author tracks down the living family members of the recipients and recounts their history since then as well as simultaneously telling his grandfather's story whose life was shrouded in mystery the whole time he kn ...more
My great-grandfather, like the author's grandfather, came with his parents and siblings from Europe and settled in Pittsburgh. He also, like Sam Stone, then settled in Canton, Ohio.

My mother grew up in Canton, and we visited my grandparents and other relatives there throughout my childhood. The street names, churches, local employers, schools, that Gup talks about--many are known to me, either through stories or direct experience.

When I read about Ted Gup's book I was interested: did any of my a
This book was so great for capturing the times in an engaging way. I highly recommend this for history lovers.

Note: This is not a Christian book and a couple of swear words. However the history was very good and worth it.
I highly recommend this book. It really helped me grasp the reality of the Great Depression. I feel like I now have a better understanding of what my grandparents grew up in and what obstacles my great grandparents faced. A truly touching book that has inspired me to give more and be much more appreciative of what I have.
I like how the author wove the letters with the local history of Canton, Ohio and its citizens during the Great Depression. I felt both despair and hope for the community members. I can't wait to take the tour that is being offered to view places in the book.
This was a wonderful read!

The story basically takes off after the author's mother gives him a suitcase filled with family mementos. Inside, he discovers a packet of letters written around Christmas 1933 to one B. Virdot.

After a little investigating, Gup (author) discovers that B. Virdot was actually his grandfather, Sam Stone, and that the B. Virdot is a made-up name comprised of his 3 daughters names -- Barbara, Virginia, and Dorothy.

Anyways, 1933 -- It was the Great Depression, and things wer
There were some interesting parallels between the current economic situation and the depression as described by Ted Gup in this book. The difficulties faced by those in financial hardship were highlighted in the letters Mr. Gup's grandfather received after publishing an advertisement offering a gift of five dollars to a select few of the white collar workers who shared their story with him. He remained anonymous using an alias to hide his identity.
Once you had read a few of the stories the diff
Lo scorso inverno in una delle tante visite in libreria, questo titolo mi colpì molto e decisi di acquistarlo sul momento, senza saperne nulla, un tipo di acquisto che devo dire faccio molto di rado ormai, anche se tanti anni fa era forse il mio modo principale di acquistare libri (ma invecchiando, si sa, i gusti si capiscono e forse addirittura si raffinano ^_^). Ted Gup è un giornalista americano. Diversi anni fa la madre gli regalò una valigia piena di lettere e documenti un tempo appartenuta ...more
A Secret Gift by Ted Gup is the non-fiction account of how one man placed an ad in the newspaper during the depression for those in need, ultimately giving $5 (about $100 in today's terms) to 150 families to help them have a Merry Christmas. The book begins with an ad placed in December 1933, but manages to capture so much more than just a single Christmas, in A Secret Gift Gup manages to capture the entire spirit of the depression, and how in the midst of a time where families were starving and ...more
I grew up in Ohio and the story takes place in Canton, Ohio. While my parents were in their 20s during the Depression they never talked too much about it. But this true story about the author's grandfather deciding to give $5 to as many people as he could during the Great Depression. The grandfather put an ad in the local paper advertising that he would give $10 to a certain number of people who wrote to him. He was flooded with letters and decided to give $5 to people as so many people were in ...more
Lisa N
This is a first-rate story. Ted Gup, a former investigative reporter, a few years ago was given a suitcase full of obscure letters that had belonged to his grandfather. In 1933, his grandfather, under an assumed name, placed an ad in a Canton, Ohio newspaper offering $10 for Christmas to 75 families who would write to him describing their hardships. He promised anonymity. That ad and those letters were the contents of the suitcase given to Gup 75 years later. Gup tracked down information about t ...more
Kristi Thielen
Journalist Ted Gup's grandfather, under a fabricated name, put a notice in a Canton, Ohio newspaper at Christmastime of 1933, that he would send a gift of $10 to anyone who wrote to him describing their financial troubles. The darkest days of the Great Depression were at hand and there was no shortage of letters. The gifts were made, the holiday passed and no one learned the giver's identity. Until Gup uncovered an old trunk with the letters, uncovered the stories of those who made the requests ...more
Interesting book about Christmas 1933--- telling real stories of the plight of many families in the Canton, Ohio, area during the Depression. Stories centers on Sam Stone, who took out an anonymous ad in the newspaper offering $10 to a worthy families who would write to him about their dire situation--- he got so many letters that he ended up sending $5 to many, many families who contacted him. In sharp contrast today's "entitlement mentality" -- these families were ashamed of their situations, ...more
Elaine Bergstrom
Investigative reporter Ted Gup takes the story of his grandfather's anonymous ad in the Canton, Ohio, newspaper at the height of the Depression. In it, he called on "White Collar Men" to mail him a letter explaining their circumstances. As "B. Virdot" Sam Stone sent a $5 Christmas gift to 150 families and saved the letters of those he helped. Decades later, Gup discovered the letters and began tracing the descendents of those Stone helped. The result is a story of survival under the worst of cir ...more
2.5 stars. The premise is very interesting - a journalist "inherits a suitcase of letters" to his grandfather. His grandfather, (Sam Stone)who hid his Romanian immigrant status (Sam Finklestein) donated $5 to people who wrote a letter to pen name, B. Virdot during the Great Depression. (How's that for a one sentence summary?)

I skimmed it pretty quickly because the writing was incredibly journalistic. The author had done his research and traced the families of the letter writers, but it was so o
An excellent recounting of the lives and hard times of the town of Canton, Ohio, during the Great Depression. The author's grandfather anonymously gave a gift of $5 to dozens of families in his town to help them with their expenses the Christmas of 1933. The author recounts many of these families' stories: what they were doing before the Depression, how they coped during it, and how they fared afterward. He interviewed many of the descendants of the original letter-writers, and in one instance, ...more
I didn't finish this one because I ran out of time before book group, and because the stringing together of the various stories -- and the promise of some kind of shocking revelation about the author's grandfather -- wasn't enough to keep me reading after my group had discussed the book. Having said that, I really enjoyed what I read, and felt as though my eyes were opened to some of the realities of the Great Depression. They had no unemployment benefits! There was no Medicaid to help with heal ...more
Lisa Nelson
Feb 04, 2011 Lisa Nelson rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Lisa by: Victoria

I still don't know why goodreads can give a book 4.02 or 3.75 stars and I can't give a book 3.5 without writing it in.

This was the first book that I read on my Kindle. I have mixed feelings about the experience.


*easy to hold while rocking a baby to sleep
*easy to read while nursing,brushing teeth, or blow drying hair
*so nice to transport
*short pages made it seem like reading went fast
*I liked that it showed the % of the book that I had read
*I liked the highlighting features, but th
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Bright Young Things: December 2013- A Secret Gift by Ted Gup 19 20 Feb 07, 2014 11:44AM  
The book 4 20 Dec 05, 2013 10:33AM  
  • Hey, America, Your Roots Are Showing
  • Final Voyage: A Story of Arctic Disaster and One Fateful Whaling Season
  • Washed Away: How the Great Flood of 1913, America's Most Widespread Natural Disaster, Terrorized a Nation and Changed It Forever
  • All the Way Home: Building a Family in a Falling-Down House
  • The Liberator: One World War II Soldier's 500-Day Odyssey from the Beaches of Sicily to the Gates of Dachau
  • The Long Way Home
  • Clover Adams: A Gilded and Heartbreaking Life
  • No Ordinary Joes: The Extraordinary True Story of Four Submariners in War and Love and Life
  • It Is Well with My Soul: The Extraordinary Life of a 106-Year-Old Woman
  • The Great Depression: America 1929-1941
  • Jefferson's War: America's First War on Terror 1801-1805
  • The Great Depression: A Diary
  • American Colossus: The Triumph of Capitalism, 1865-1900
  • Mosaic: A Chronicle of Five Generations
  • A Brief History of the Smile
  • Twilight at the World of Tomorrow : Genius, Madness, Murder, and the 1939 World's Fair on the Brink of  War
  • The Ditchdigger's Daughters: A Black Family's Astonishing Success Story
  • Prepared for a Purpose: The Inspiring True Story of How One Woman Saved an Atlanta School Under Siege
Ted Gup is the author of A Secret Gift, (Penguin Press, 2010) and two previous books: Nation of Secrets: The Threat to Democracy and the American Way of Life (Doubleday, 2007) winner of the Goldsmith Book Prize from Harvard Universitys Kennedy School of Government, and the bestseller, The Book of Honor: Covert Lives And Classified Deaths At The CIA (Doubleday, 2000.) He is a former investigative r ...more
More about Ted Gup...
The Book of Honor: Covert Lives and Classified Deaths at the CIA Nation of Secrets: The Threat to Democracy and the American Way of Life

Share This Book

“He was a simple honest man. He never strayed,

He never drank, he never smoked, and he never kissed a maid.

And when he passed away his insurance was denied,

Because he never lived, they claimed he never died.”
More quotes…