Same Sun Here
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Same Sun Here

3.89 of 5 stars 3.89  ·  rating details  ·  1,294 ratings  ·  267 reviews
In this extraordinary novel in two voices, an Indian immigrant girl in New York City and a Kentucky coal miner’s son find strength and perspective by sharing their true selves across the miles.

Meena and River have a lot in common: fathers forced to work away from home to make ends meet, grandmothers who mean the world to them, and faithful dogs. But Meena is an Indian immi...more
Hardcover, 288 pages
Published February 14th 2012 by Candlewick (first published January 1st 2012)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Same Sun Here, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Same Sun Here

Wonder by R.J. PalacioThe One and Only Ivan by Katherine ApplegateThe Fault in Our Stars by John GreenLiar & Spy by Rebecca SteadThe Lions of Little Rock by Kristin Levine
Newbery 2013
34th out of 116 books — 1,085 voters
Wonder by R.J. PalacioThe One and Only Ivan by Katherine ApplegateThe False Prince by Jennifer A. NielsenHigh in School by Salman AdityaThe Hero's Guide to Saving Your Kingdom by Christopher Healy
Middle Grade Novels of 2012
87th out of 343 books — 591 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Jo
Pre-Review Thoughts: I have such a love/hate relationship with Netgalley. I love it because it’s an invaluable way for me, as a British blogger, to get access to books that aren’t published over here for months or, in some instances, at all. I hate it because it always seems that when a new book comes out it’s a fight to the death to get accepted for the popular, well publicised titles. But what I love most about Netgalley is finding books such as this one that I would probably never have found...more
Paul  Hankins
What kind of genre is necessary to demonstrate that two characters--despite their differences in nationality and identity--share some of the same celebrations? The same concerns? The same worries? The same sun?

Epistolary, of course. Correspondence between two characters is well-recognized within the canon to include classics like THE SCREWTAPE LETTERS and DADDY LONG-LEGS.

And here, Silas House and Neela Vaswani create a memorable relationship--carried by letters written back and forth--between R...more
Sasha
This book was so special to me! Growing up and raising my own family in Eastern Kentucky, it is incredibly refreshing and encouraging to read a work that paints us as many of us are; multifaceted, empowered, passionate, and something much more than "hillbillies looking for handouts." Silas House never fails to make me feel validated each and every time I read anything he writes. This book is no different.

This is an epistolary novel, showcasing letters written between two twelve year olds that b...more
Cassi aka Snow White Haggard
I'm beginning to think that I don't just occasionally enjoy middle grade books, but I might legitimately love it as a genre. I keep reading middle grade books or younger YA books that I think are the exception to the rule. But not everything can be the exception.

Same Sun Here is a delightful story, innocent and youthful. Its the tale of two pen pals. Meena was born in India but currently living in New York City. River is from rural Eastern Kentucky. (Though the county is supposedly fictionalized...more
Heidi
Every once in a great while I find cause to pick up a book I know little to nothing about and am fortunate enough to be utterly charmed. Same Sun Here was one of two Audie nominees for Middle Graders that I was unfamiliar with, and yet I am happy to see it in such good company. For some inexplicable reason, I have shied away from doing epistolary novels via audio. After listening to the absolute joy that was Same Sun Here, I’m putting all epistolary reads in my TBR into my TBLT (to-be-listened-t...more
Sandy
This was a nice book and everything, but I got crabby every time something political came up. Unfortunately, that was quite often.

I'm totally fine with lessons in social responsibility and being good to your neighbor or even references to specific historic political events, but it seemed to me that these authors had a clear political agenda. Only one end of the political spectrum was ever mentioned and it was brougt up repeatedly and only in glowing terms. I don't care what political party you...more
The Rusty Key
Reviewed by Jordan B. Nielsen

Recommended for: Both boys and girls ages 10 and Up for discussion of racism, troubled family life and general maturity of themes. The narrative is split between a male and female character making it relatable to either gender.

One Word Summary: Ebullient.

Same Sun Here by Silas House and Neela Vaswani is like a blast of air conditioning from an open door on a baking hot Manhattan day, at once refreshing, relieving, sweet and enlivening. With easy, commanding authori...more
Alex Baugh
From the publisher:
Meena and River have a lot in common: fathers forced to work away from home to make ends meet, grandmothers who mean the world to them, and faithful dogs. But Meena is an Indian girl living in New York City's Chinatown, while River is a Kentucky coal miner's son. As Meena's family studies for citizenship exams and River's town faces devastating mountaintop removal, this unlikely pair become pen pals, sharing thoughts and, as their camaraderie deepens, discovering common ground...more
Katie Fitzgerald
This book obviously has an agenda and a particular political point of view, which promotes activism, criticizes government, and laments society’s unfairness toward marginalized groups. There’s nothing inherently wrong with that except that sometimes - especially in the latter half of the book - the agenda overpowers the story. River performs an act of defiance that puts him suddenly in the spotlight in a way I found irritating, and from then on, his story takes center stage, while Meena’s ends u...more
Pam Torres
The first thing I noticed immediately was the voice and it isn't a Young Adult voice at all. River and Meena are definitely Tweens. A distictive voice is a common thread in the middle grade fiction that I'm attracted to. There's also a strong sense of place and time. Both writers create their worlds through words in letters, an art that many of our middle grade students are losing to the brevity of text and email. The contrast of the Appalachian rural and Indian urban worlds creates a wonderful...more
Stephanie Fatemi
The Same Sun Here by Silas House and Neela Vaswani is a novel that consists of letters between two middle school pen pals, River Dean Justice and Meena Joshi. River is a boy living in the mountains of Kentucky while Meena is an immigrant from India living in Chinatown in New York. While they come from very different backgrounds, they are able to become close friends through their writing.
They each face their own kind of prejudice in their lives (River for being from the Kentucky hills and Mee...more
Abby Johnson
When New Yorker Meena and Kentucky boy River sign up for a pen pal program, they have no idea that they're each finding a kindred spirit. Who would have thought that two 12-year-olds from such different backgrounds could have so much in common? Meena was born in India and moved to New York City to be with her family when she was nine. River has lived in a tiny town in Eastern Kentucky his entire life. As the two write letters back and forth, they discover that they share a love of mountains, the...more
Melanie
Meena and River become pen pals due to a school assignment. After the assignment is long over these two find themselves still writing to each other. They find a friendly ear is helpful when dealing with the complications of their lives.

Meena is struggling to try to fit back into her family after being left with her grandmother in India when her parents and brother emigrated to America when she was quite young. She feels left behind, left out. And she misses her grandmother dearly. the family is...more
Georgene
Although the voices rang true in this epistolary novel, the friendship seemed a little far-fetched. Meena is an Indian immigrant girl who is living with her family in New York City. She is pen pals with River Justice, who lives in the mountains of Kentucky. Meena's family lives illegally in a rent-controlled apartment that their landlord will evict them from if he finds out about them. River finds that his beloved woods near his house are being bulldozed by a coal company that is removing the mo...more
Anna
A delightful little tale in accepting differences, this book follows the lives of two young teens and their hardships and celebrations. I felt that it was a bit forced, and the characters too far-fetched, with its attempt, and somewhat success, at fitting every "alternative" aspect of life in the few pages. While I enjoyed it, I probably would not recommend it to students or adult friends, mainly for that reason.
John
Same Sun Here is a thought-provoking novel that will lead to amazing discussions about the environment, immigrants, unlikely friendships, politics, and so much more. I'm having a difficult time "assigning" it an interest level. Maybe grades 6 and up? Maybe grades 7 and up? I think it really depends on the reader.
Leigh Mantle
Great epistolary novel set in Kentucky & New York City with two 12-year-olds writing each other about their very different and yet similar lives.

Favorite quotes: "I cannot tell from your name if you are a boy or girl so I will just write to you like you are a human being."

"Hug your neck"
Lopez Camille
I personally had learn many things in this book..
to mention the few things...
1.how to grow taller by some stretching-your-leg exercise
2.that living on New York can't really make someone's mind insane if he or she is just smart enough
3.That its hard to be an American (esp. if you are not born one yourself
..

Okay, so this book talks about some sensitive topic, not your typical story if you like fantasy.. still this is an eye opener book and i like to recommend it to young readers so they could see...more
Michelle Neuwirth Gray
To me it was okay. I just didn't get into the plot very well, and I felt like the authors kept name dropping on popular titles, Hunger Games and Twilight, and it just didn't sit with me. I also didn't always feel like the dialogue was very authentic for 13 year olds.
Jordan
I actually got really bored with this book, so I didn't finish haha I know... shame on me! I enjoyed the two-toned narrative and the fact that two authors came together to write the one novel, but you could tell that they both had a little bit of a political agenda and that was getting on my nerves. I don't think it's something kids would pick up on.

I've heard a little bit of hubbub about some parents having issues with the age group this book is recommended for. For the most part, at least as...more
Lynn
Many good things about this and I think kids will like it as the two cultures will be unfamiliar to many kids. It felt a bit too purposeful to me with the author's hand too visible at times but I was engaged in the story and wanted to follow it through.
Lindsay
The entire book is a series of letters between two twelve-year olds who meet through a school pen pal program. This book touches on a ton of issues - political, environmental, social - but never feels preachy.
Gina
This is an innovative book told from two viewpoints. Two very different pen pals become friends over the course of their correspondence. River is a young boy from rural Kentucky and Meena is an Indian immigrant living in the Chinatown area of NYC. They both confide in each other. River's grandmother is trying to help fight against mountaintop removal mining in their community. Meena's family live illegally in a rent controlled apartment, the landlord is trying to drive out all the old tenants to...more
Susan

"I like that library books have secret lives. All those hands that have held them. All those eyes that have read them." Meena pg. 87
Arianne
Same Sun Here will enrich the worlds of both urban and rural youth, who will find within the pages a familiar soul and a brand new one. Meena's letters tell of immigrant life and New York City, the perils and the pleasures of growing up in the center of her parents' American Dream. River's letters reflect a family life built around tradition and roots, newly threatened by mountain top mining. Both narrators share their experiences with family, stereotypes, and identity, offering young readers pl...more
Mary
voices felt real but agenda driven
Laura
The novel is epistolary, written in letters from pen pals, an Indian American girl in New York City (Meena) and a Kentucky boy (River). Vaswani and House alternate chapters and letters in the voices of these different characters.

The book was sweet in the way that childhood innocence can be. The two tweens get to know each other through their writing by asking about their families and preferences. The book is set in 2008, so there are cultural references that were cute to read about the characte...more
Jennifer
2-3 stars for the book, 3-4 stars for the audiobook.

I really enjoyed the audiobook version of Same Sun Here. The book was really brought alive in the recording, probably because the two authors voiced the characters' letter that they each wrote. I probably would've liked the book less if I hadn't listened to it (which is the opposite of what usually happens for me).

Although I found the book funny, endearing and a convincing portrayal of the experiences of two middle grade kids that manages to to...more
Kathleen
An unlikely combination of subjects - coal mining through mountaintop removal and living illegally in a rent-controlled apartment - are joined in this epistolary novel, a moving series of letters between pen pals from Kentucky and New York City's Chinatown. Choosing a name randomly from the snail mail list, 12-year-old Meena Joshi from NY strikes up a friendship with River Dean Justice from Kentucky. Their letters reveal their parallel family issues, shared love for their grandmothers, environme...more
The Styling Librarian
Same Sun Here by Silas House & Neela Vaswani - I admit it, I LOVE book where there are different voices communicating with one another. This one especially flowed well in addition to touching on multiple sensitive topics in a beautiful way... I loved the messages mingled through the book as well, quite powerful. Additionally, I found so many "golden lines" - favorite lines- throughout the book, I started an Evernote log for them. Here are a few treasured lines:p. 5 "In New York, the building...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Unforgotten Coat
  • Kepler's Dream
  • Twelve Kinds of Ice
  • After Eli
  • The Five Lives of Our Cat Zook
  • Summer of the Gypsy Moths
  • Laugh with the Moon
  • Summer of the Wolves
  • The Unfortunate Son
  • Katerina's Wish
  • Fourmile
  • Crow
  • Glory Be
  • A Diamond in the Desert
  • The Year of the Book
  • On the Road to Mr. Mineo's
  • Shadow on the Mountain
  • Hound Dog True
13978
Silas House is an American writer best known for his novels. He is also a music journalist, environmental activist, and columnist. He lives in Eastern Kentucky, where he was born and raised.

House's fiction is known for its attention to the natural world, working class characters, and the plight of the rural place and rural people. He is also a music journalist, environmental activist and columnist...more
More about Silas House...
A Parchment of Leaves Clay's Quilt The Coal Tattoo Eli the Good Something's Rising: Appalachians Fighting Mountaintop Removal

Share This Book

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

“In New York, the buildings are like mountains in some ways, but they are only alive because of the people living in them. Real mountains are alive all over.” 6 likes
“I like that library books have secret lives. All those hands that have held them. All those eyes that have read them.” 5 likes
More quotes…