Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Judgment” as Want to Read:
The Judgment
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Judgment (Rose Trilogy #2)

4.23 of 5 stars 4.23  ·  rating details  ·  2,815 ratings  ·  141 reviews
Lewis, the top name in Amish fiction, pens a tale of two sisters struggling to find love, acceptance, and their place in the Amish community.
ebook, 254 pages
Published April 6th 2011 by Bethany House Publishers (first published January 1st 2011)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Judgment, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Judgment

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Stella
This is book #2 of The Rose Trilogy. Like all of Ms. Lewis' books, this was a fast and enjoyable read. Main characters were two sisters - "Hen" who was married to Brandon, an Englisher, and Rose, engaged to Silas but secretly in love with bad boy Nick Franco.

Brandon is having issues with his wife Hen rejoining the Amish community and becomes mean and nasty. He wants a divorce and threatens to gain custody of little Mattie unless she comes home and dons her jeans.

Silas tells Rose he wants to br...more
Carly
I have, on several occasions, come into a series from somewhere other than the beginning. This usually is not a problem for me because so many authors are good at getting stragglers like me caught up on what has happened in the previous books. For some reason, The Judgment didn’t do that very well. Throughout so much of the book, I felt like I was lost and trying to figure out what was going on. I just never felt engaged or really into the story. I think this would not have been a problem if I h...more
Clockstein Lockstein
The Judgment by Beverly Lewis is the second book in the Rose Trilogy. Rose Kauffman's Amish community is still recovering from the tragic death of Bishop Aaron Petersheim's son, Christian and foster son Nick Franco's running away. Rose's friendship with Nick makes her one of the few people not blaming Nick for Christian's death, but she's trying to focus on her new engagement to Silas Good. Elder sister Hen has returned home to live with her daughter Mattie Sue leaving her Englischer husband, Br...more
Miriam
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Laura
Title: THE JUDGMENT
Author: Beverly Lewis
Publisher: Bethany House
April 2011
ISBN: 978-0-7642-0600-9
Genre: Inspirational/Amish/Women’s fiction

Two Amish sisters, reunited by unforeseen circumstances…

Hen left the Amish years earlier to marry an English man, one that has completely destroyed—even forbidden—her to interact with her family. When Hen takes her four year old daughter and leaves her husband to return home to think, Brandon responds harshly, serving Hen with divorce papers, and threatening...more
Robin
The Judgement
Beverly Lewis
This novel is the story of an Amish family that is torn apart by a mysterious accident to the main characters mother. The main story line is about 2 sisters and each one is finding her way through their family, faith and life. I found this to be a good character story that I breezed through quickly. I am glad I waited till all books were available before I started reading. That way I could finish within a brief period of time and not have to sit on pins and needles wond...more
Casey
One of the things I love about Beverly Lewis’s books are the characters. “The Judgment” is no surprise either. They are wonderfully crafted and stand from the page in full three dimension. I feel I could step into the story and pick right up with the characters, as well as I know them after reading these two books.

In the second book of The Rose Legacy, the reader picks up again with the characters and situations established in book one. I would recommend you read these books in order, you will h...more
Elizabeth Dyck
Book 2 in the series and it just couldn’t get better.

Rose has agreed to marry Silas Good who has been courting her for the last months. But she can’t forget Nick, a friend that was closer then she realized. It was to late though, Nick was gone, perhaps forever.

Hen is facing her own problems. She realizes that she has created most of them herself. If she wouldn’t have left her home to marry Brandon, she wouldn’t be here today. Brandon has given her the choice of either a divorce or giving up her...more
Lauren
This is the sequel to "The Thorn" (Book 1 in the Rose Trilogy).

The major highlights of the book for me include Rose Ann's courtship with Silas Goode, and Brandon and Hen's impending divorce.

Rebekah Bontrager, a childhood friend, returns to Lancaster County after her family had moved to Indiana. Known for being exceptionally beautiful, Rose Ann begins to have some worries when she sees her interactions with Silas. There's a lot more to this courtship that Rose Ann doesn't know yet...

Despite Hen'...more
Janet C.
Got hooked on this trilogy. Just ordered Book #3. Continuation of a story of 2 sisters. One thatreained strong in the Amish culture and one (Hen) that married outside the Amish faith before she was baptized. Hen now has decided she wants her "English" daughter raised the way she was in the Amish ways and the struggle now with her "English" husband. Rose, her younger sister, who is baptized realized she has fallen in love with Nick a foster child of her Bishop raised in the Amish way but who left...more
Maureen Timerman
The Judgement is the continuing story of Rose Ann Kauffman and her family. Loved getting reacquainted with everyone. Rose Ann is now secretly engaged to Silas Good, her sister Hen and niece Mattie Sue are living in the Dawdi House. Her Mamm is still struggling with the constant pain from her accident. Rose is still missing Nick, and the Community is morning Christian.
Mattie Sue is missing her Dad, who won't accept that Hen misses the Simple Life. Don't know what the answer is going to be here. B...more
Sherrill
Beverly Lewis writes very nice little books with nothing disturbing and nothing particularly unhappy. She almost makes you want to be Amish. Even though the book was pretty predictable--like I think she does not need a whole trilogy to tell her story. Still I just had to know what happened after I read The Thorn and I suppose when the final book of this trilogy comes out in Sept I will have to read that one too because she is the master at leaving threads undone. It is sort of refreshing to read...more
Karen
Rose is engaged to Silas, a neighboring farmer, but she still thinks about Nick, the foster son of the bishop who left the Amish life and didn't tell anyone where he was going. What about the new girl in town, Rebekah who seems to have an eye for Silas. And what about her older sister, Hannah, who has left her Englisher husband and moved back to her parent's Amish farm with their daughter.
I love all of Beverly Lewis's books, can't wait for the 3rd book in this series.
I know these are romantic fi...more
Robin
I had never heard of the "Amish Romance" genre before a friend loaned me "The Rose Trilogy" by Beverly Lewis. She is a wildly succesful author in this genre, having written 70 bestsellers, with several adapted into movies. Coming off reading "The Glass Castle" by Jeanette Walls I wanted to read something light, where everything works out at the end. The trilogy was a very quick read, with a simple romance at the core of the story. You can see the plot twists coming a mile away, and some of the w...more
Kim
The 3rd book in this series could not come out fast enough! I made the mistake of buying and reading the first two books of this series well in advance of the 3rd book's release. Needless to say I was standing in my local bookstore on the day of release with book mark in hand and ready to read :-) The author continues to bring the trials of 3 main families to life in the 2nd book of this series. It is easy to get involved in their daily life as this book is very well written. It is a pleasing th...more
Staci
My Thoughts: I love Beverly Lewis. She is the ultimate writer for Amish fiction. She always keeps me interested in the storyline and I can honestly feel the authenticity of her characters coming through the pages. I believe her writing and am always fully engaged with the plot. I'm so happy that book three will be out in the fall...the suspense is killing me!!!!!!!!!!!!

Recommend? Of course....Lewis is hands down the Queen of Amish Fiction. I love that she usually writes trilogies and her stories...more
Gail
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Jerry
A Quickie Review

The story in this one is a little bit better than usual, but everything else is just more of the same, though that isn't a bad thing. I'm curious to see how Ms. Lewis will wrap the series up in the series' finale. As I said in my review of the first book: "If you've read any of Beverly Lewis' Amish books, you know what to expect, and that's what you'll get from this book."



Score: 4.25/5...more
Mayda
In the second novel in The Rose Trilogy, Beverly Lewis continues her saga of the struggles Rose and her sister Hannah endure in remaining true to their beliefs while fulfilling their place in the world. Should Hannah sacrifice her Amish beliefs to save her marriage? Should Rose sacrifice true love to marry an upstanding Amish man? You won’t want to miss reading this novel while you ponder what advice you might offer these two young ladies.
M.K.
LOVED jumping back into some Beverly Lewis...it had been far too long.

The Judgment follows Rose through shifting dynamics in her relationship with her betrothed, Hen through the murky waters of a failing marriage, and the lovable Beth who brings hope and joy to the Kauffman family.

Now I'm just wondering what happens in the final book...glad I found it on the library shelves!
Marianne Stehr
Does nothing good ever happen on an amish farm? These stories are killing me. I want happiness for these people I grow to love while reading the stories, but alas it is not to be, I am not sure I can wait until Sept 2011 to continue this story.
Linda
I thought I already wrote a review on this book, but I must have only thought about what I would write. Let me see if I can gather my thoughts...

I am reading this series absolutely backwards, because I accidentally picked up the last book in the series and read it first, so when I started to read this one, the second in the Rose Trilogy, I thought I had already read it. But it didn't take me long to realize what had happened, and that although I knew the end result, I didn't know much of what ha...more
Autumn
I really loved this book! I didn't expect to like it this much, but it was intriguing and mysterious from start to finish! I will most definately be reading the next one.
M. Patrick
The Judgment by Beverly Lewis was a very odd listen for me. I bought it as a daily special on Audible. I felt a little embarrassed when I realized that young adult females who are devout Christians were the target audience. As a senior male, I still found the simple story with minimal conflict interesting because decorated the story with peaks into the rich Amish culture of Lancaster county, Pennsylvania. The Judgment is the second installment in the Rose trilogy, named for main character and na...more
Deborah
Rose Kauffman is finally engaged to Silas Good, but she pines for Nick Franco, the foster son of their neighbor bishop. Nick disappears after the death of his brother - of which he is a suspect, but Rose cannot keep him out of her mind and heart. Engaged to Silas, but loving Nick, can she marry a man she doesn't love? Or will she forever love a man she cannot have?

Hen has returned to her parent's farm to live in their Dawdi Haus with her daughter Mattie. Separated from her husband, Brandon, by m...more
Shari Larsen
This is book #2 of The Rose Trilogy. Rose Kauffman is now engaged to Silas Good, a well-liked Amish man, but she still pines for Nick Franco. Nick is the former foster son of the bishop who left the community under a cloud of suspicion after the death of the bishop's biological son. Will Rose still marry Silas, even though she struggles with romantic feelings for Nick?

Meanwhile, Rose's older sister, Hen, has returned with her young daughter Mattie to live at her parent's farm. Hen and her modern...more
Lwf
Second in this trilogy, The Judgment was a better book than The Thorn to me. I suppose I enjoyed it much more as the characters went into more depth, the story continued and took twists which I did not see coming.

I highly recommend reading this book if you read The Thorn, don't stop there! I very much enjoyed this and read it much faster than The Thorn. I'm looking forward to beginning the third book now, "The Mercy" which I have here reading to read!

Good, Christian reading for all ages.

THX...more
Trish
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Paula-O
This is book #2 of the Rose Triolgy for Beverly Lewis, I really liked reading about Rose and her family, Sister "hen" had left the comunity to marry and englisher and then after having a child some years later wanted to return to the amish life and caused much conflict with her husband. Rose had become engaged to Silas Good in this book but felt she had feelings that she should not have had for Nick who had left suddenly from the comunity, they had been friends for many years. When a young woman...more
Donna
This was another good book by Beverly Lewis. The second book in the series The Rose. Hen is still having a hard time with Brandon, but things change for her late in the book. Rose is unsure of Silas when she sees him with another girl. Nick and Christian are still at odds, and a lot more happens in the family so on to book three for the conclusion.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
HENN HUSBAND 2 20 Jan 20, 2013 07:22AM  
HENN HUSBAND 1 8 Sep 11, 2012 07:26PM  
  • The Search (Lancaster County Secrets, #3)
  • The Journey (Kentucky Brothers, #1)
  • A Place of Peace (Kauffman Amish Bakery, #3)
  • Plain Promise (Daughters of the Promise, #3)
  • The Harvest of Grace (Ada's House, #3)
  • Christmas in Sugarcreek: A Seasons of Sugarcreek Christmas Novel
  • The Amish Nanny (The Women of Lancaster County, #2)
  • Ella's Wish (Little Valley, #2)
34227
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.

Beverly Lewis, raised in Pennsylvania Amish country and both a schoolteacher and an accomplished musician, has been an award-winning author for over a dozen years. Her acclaimed novel, The Preacher's Daughter, was a 2006 Quill Book Award finalist in the romance category. Her books have appeared on numerous best...more
More about Beverly Lewis...
The Shunning (The Heritage of Lancaster County, #1) The Covenant (Abram's Daughters, #1) The Betrayal (Abram's Daughters, #2) The Sacrifice (Abram's Daughters, #3) The Prodigal (Abram's Daughters, #4)

Share This Book

“Happiness isn't wanting what you can get, but wanting what you have.” 23 likes
More quotes…