16th out of 196 books
—
45 voters
God Knows
Joseph Heller's powerful, wonderfully funny, deeply moving novel is the story of David -- yes, King David -- but as you've never seen him before. You already know David as the legendary warrior king of Israel, husband of Bathsheba, and father of Solomon; now meet David as he really was: the cocky Jewish kid, the plagiarized poet, and the Jewish father. Listen as David tell...more
Paperback, 368 pages
Published
November 12th 1997
by Simon & Schuster
(first published 1984)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,655)
Originally published on my blog here in May 2004.
Even for the most dedicated Heller fan, and the impact of Catch-22 created vast numbers of them, his second and third novels are frequently heavy going. But then eventually (over twenty years into his career, for he was never a particularly prolific novelist) came God Knows - immediately accessible, hilariously funny and wickedly subversive.
The idea behind God Knows is simple. David, King of Israel, author of the psalms, recounts his life while on...more
Even for the most dedicated Heller fan, and the impact of Catch-22 created vast numbers of them, his second and third novels are frequently heavy going. But then eventually (over twenty years into his career, for he was never a particularly prolific novelist) came God Knows - immediately accessible, hilariously funny and wickedly subversive.
The idea behind God Knows is simple. David, King of Israel, author of the psalms, recounts his life while on...more
Sort of a madcap version of King David's story, told in the first person, of course including more vivid descriptions of some of the bawdier details than the Bible does. Heller doesn't sacrifice the real account at the expense of entertainment though, so I came away really being amazed by David's story told again, and reminded of many details I had forgotten. I was impressed by his steadfastness in the face of serious hardship and adversity and his faithfulness to God, even though there is plent...more
This is my second draft of my review of this book. In my first, I began by comparing God Knows to Heller's masterpiece Catch 22. This I realize is unfair, of course, and not really taking God Knows on its own terms, so consider that review stricken from the record. It isn't Catch 22. There enough said.
Here's the gist, one of King David's laments:
Here's the gist, one of King David's laments:
"I know if I were God and possessed His powers, I would sooner obliterate the world I created than allow any child of mine to be killed in it, for any...more
In Joseph Heller's novel "God Knows", the Jewish protagonist is an old man named David, looking back with bittersweet fondness but mostly regret at his turbulent life: numerous marriages, ungrateful children, constant battling with in-laws and relatives, and a God that seems to have either forgotten or forsaken him. It may help to know that the David in the novel is King David, of the biblical account, kvetching on his death bed about what a mess his life has become but mostly because he can't g...more
Having been a huge fan of Catch-22, I had been curious to read more of Heller's work for a long time. Something Happened, his follow-up to Catch-22, is the book that I had heard the most about- mainly that it was a challenging read that left many of his fans reeling and wondering whether he had lost his knack for finely honed satire. I had never even heard of God Knows until it was placed in my hands last week with the recommendation that it was "like Lamb: The Gospel According to Biff, Christ's...more
A curious novel, cast as a rambling memoir by a dying King David. Bawdy & violent, as, indeed, David's story is, it's remarkably faithful to the biblical text (except for the casting of Solomon as a fool), with much of the dialogue actually quoted directly from the King James Bible but juxtaposed with invented dialogue & narrative worthy of a Tom Robbins novel and with intentionally ridiculous anachronisms. For example, after trying to seduce Bathsheba with language from the Song of Solo...more
Jan 29, 2008
julie
rated it
2 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
those who have semi-knowledge/interest of the old testament and can overlook the blasphemy as humor
Shelves:
back-on-the-shelf
I am naturally interested in the Old Testament and especially King David (I think he's one of the most screwed up yet passionate figures in the Bible)... but his angst-driven hoopla and paranoia annoyed me after the first 300 pages or so.
Another fine novel from Joseph Heller, which was all I wanted or expected from this title. For the first fifty pages or so I was getting intense Something Happened vibes, but that faded and I enjoyed the work thoroughly in its own right.
It has many of the themes you'd expect, the type of wild and sometimes maudlin humor that seems so right and that Heller exceeds at executing. While I didn't enjoy this as much as, say, Catch 22, this book left me with no critical points. It was well written and...more
It has many of the themes you'd expect, the type of wild and sometimes maudlin humor that seems so right and that Heller exceeds at executing. While I didn't enjoy this as much as, say, Catch 22, this book left me with no critical points. It was well written and...more
Joseph Heller has caused me grave disappointment. This novel in no way measures up to he other works such as Catch-22 or Something Happened. King David speaks in the first person throughout the novel, narrating his troubled relationship with God, Bathsheba, Samuel, Saul and his children (Absalom and Solomon).
The novel starts off in a very interesting manner. Heller provides his irony and satire in heaps as he gives an irreverent wink to the debauches and dissembling of King David.
The bad part is...more
The novel starts off in a very interesting manner. Heller provides his irony and satire in heaps as he gives an irreverent wink to the debauches and dissembling of King David.
The bad part is...more
The story of King David, portrayed as a wunderkind whose time has passed, who has lost his God; Solomon is a moron, Bathsheba a schemer. It was funny and touching. It mixed Biblical speech with modern slang to humorous effect. David's references to many things modern, although "now" in the book is when he is seventy and this it's still Biblical era, did throw me a bit. What I liked best was how human the characters were, how Heller took apparent discrepancies in Scripture and made them into symb...more
This book is really quite sad. It's an "autobiography" of King David, "written" during his last days when he was essentially confined to a bed.
The basic plot is Bathsheba is trying to convince David to name Solomon his heir. David doesn't want to do this because he thinks Solomon is a dunce. Interwoven in these conversations are David's remembrances of his life.
David's pretty depressed. He misses Absalom. He misses Bathsheba's love. He thinks Solomon is a fool. And he is really mad at God and w...more
The basic plot is Bathsheba is trying to convince David to name Solomon his heir. David doesn't want to do this because he thinks Solomon is a dunce. Interwoven in these conversations are David's remembrances of his life.
David's pretty depressed. He misses Absalom. He misses Bathsheba's love. He thinks Solomon is a fool. And he is really mad at God and w...more
Having created two classic Jewish male characters who weren't -- Catch-22's Armenian/Assyrian John Yossarian and Something Happened's uncircumcized-because-that-will-throw-you-off Robert Slocum -- and a much less classic Jewish male character in Good as Gold Bruce Gold, Heller decides to take on the biggest Jewish Enchilada of them all (so to speak): King David. He reduces the King to a lesser figure than any previous protagonist: a whiny old Jewish man, part-Catskills comic and part-Catskills v...more
Reading this book is like trying to walk through a lake of treacle. Readers of Heller's other books will notice that the density of his prose gets worse with each novel, reaching its nadir in this work. The story of King David has a few chuckles in it but nothing really rib-cracking. I got bored half-way through and put it aside, only coming back to it a week later since I felt duty-bound to give it a chance and it was due back at the library in a few days. The rest of the book was no better. I...more
I laughed at the humor, but suffered through the tedious parts. It has the type of tedious descriptions that serve only to cause suffering, without adding any actual enhancement to the work.
The story is of King David, from the Old Testament, who is old and laying in his deathbed. There is a lot of poking fun at religion, and the humor is quite unique. But there are other moments when the story just drags on and gets extremely boring (not unlike the Bible).
If you like Heller, then you probably sh...more
The story is of King David, from the Old Testament, who is old and laying in his deathbed. There is a lot of poking fun at religion, and the humor is quite unique. But there are other moments when the story just drags on and gets extremely boring (not unlike the Bible).
If you like Heller, then you probably sh...more
OPINIA Z 25 KWIETNIA 2008
Starotestamentowy Dawid, pogromca Goliata, odlicza godziny do zakończenia swego żywota, podczas trwającego w państwie chaosu: samowolną koronację na króla Adoniasza. Mając wiele czasu do namysłu, może wybrać czy poprzeć hulakę Adoniasza, czy niedołężnego Salomona, przy okazji wspominając całe swe dzieje,... dzieje opisane w hellerowski sposób. Czyli nie zabraknie świnskich tekstów w stylu "ciągniecie druta" przez Batszewę, narzekania na nadmierną ilość napletka na rzeźbi...more
Starotestamentowy Dawid, pogromca Goliata, odlicza godziny do zakończenia swego żywota, podczas trwającego w państwie chaosu: samowolną koronację na króla Adoniasza. Mając wiele czasu do namysłu, może wybrać czy poprzeć hulakę Adoniasza, czy niedołężnego Salomona, przy okazji wspominając całe swe dzieje,... dzieje opisane w hellerowski sposób. Czyli nie zabraknie świnskich tekstów w stylu "ciągniecie druta" przez Batszewę, narzekania na nadmierną ilość napletka na rzeźbi...more
Oct 09, 2010
Jamie
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
probably someone who already knows Abiathar from Abishag and Adonijah
Shelves:
favorites
I was the kid in Sunday school the poor teachers must’ve hated: peeking behind the curtain, pulling the strings on our tidy little Bible lessons to go wide-eyed and watch the real, wild Bible go up in flames. Well, I guess it’s a habit I never outgrew. So there you have me, ever the rebel kid still, relishing the secret that behind all those prettily bow-tied morals are wild kings and bloodbaths and blasphemous sacrilege that no one’s paying any mind.
And here you have Joseph Heller. Since Catch...more
And here you have Joseph Heller. Since Catch...more
Jan 05, 2008
Ravi
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
those who can see humor in the absurd.
I really enjoyed this book, laughed my way through it, and also learned a bit about King David's life that I never knew. Of course, I know this is fiction, seeing King David's life through his own eyes, but if you're like me and was only familiar with the David vs. Goliath story, then you might enjoy at least his own take on the great event.
This was my first Joseph Heller book (I know - gasp!), and it is because of this book that I went on to Catch-22. Heller's ability to take somewhat familiar...more
This was my first Joseph Heller book (I know - gasp!), and it is because of this book that I went on to Catch-22. Heller's ability to take somewhat familiar...more
Jul 09, 2007
Itai Miller
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Anyone who is interested in Religion, from any aspect of it.
I've resisted reading Catch-22 for years. To be honest, I still haven't read it. I even eschewed using the term. Probably because the book sat on my mother's dresser for nearly 10 years and I kept trying to read it between the ages of 10 and 14 and never got past the 1st paragraph.
A friend of mine gave me "God Knows" saying, "I'm giving you this because I hated it and I know you'll love it." And I do, not only because it features my name (I haven't reached that part yet, but was shown it by my f...more
A friend of mine gave me "God Knows" saying, "I'm giving you this because I hated it and I know you'll love it." And I do, not only because it features my name (I haven't reached that part yet, but was shown it by my f...more
Laugh-out-loud at times, this irreverent take on the life of David is thought-provoking, distinctive, and, unfortunately, fairly tedious. Heller employs the same storytelling technique he used in Catch-22, introducing stories and referencing them several times before actually laying them out in full. I thought this approach was quite effective in Catch-22, a good example of technique enforcing theme. Here, however, the repetition as you get closer and closer to the whole story is tiresome. I thi...more
At first this book really seemed offensive, but by the end, I believe that it just paints King David as a human being. O fcourse Heller deliberately makes things sounds as offensive as possible, but if you can make it through the whole thing, you can see that David wrestles with feelings about himself, his family and his relationshoip with God that everyone probably wrestles with. It still isn't that great of a book. It pales in comparison to Catch-22.
This book is pretty much the sum of its parts: it’s the story of David, told in Joseph Heller’s style. You have to be willing to put up with a dense text that takes a long time to say very little, but it definitely has its moments. Heller does a really good job of humanizing such a famous character, essentially making him a genuinely sympathetic figure by highlighting how unsympathetic he is. After all his cantankerousness, caprice, and unjustifiable meanness, his last line manages to frame the...more
I am so relieved to be done with this book. I didn't enjoy it very much - there were a few funny snippets here and there but for the most part I felt like I was force-feeding myself monotonous Heller prose. The book is the story of King David, slayer of Goliath, King of Israel, father of Solomon, husband of Bathsheba, etc. Heller attempts to modernize the story by adding some fiction into David's story. It just didn't really gel very well for me. This was one of those books that I found myself n...more
I read this when it first came out and loved it. It's full of his usual, crazy mixed up characters and situations that seem impossibly real. Every time something goes wrong and the ending is unbelievable, the main character says,"Go figure."
It's kind of become an anthem I've used to cope with paradoxes, especially the ones that are hopelessly irreversible.
It's kind of become an anthem I've used to cope with paradoxes, especially the ones that are hopelessly irreversible.
Dec 03, 2012
Philip
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
humor,
religious-inspirational
Very, very funny book as I remember it -- but no one else seems to have ever heard of it, and it's pretty difficult to find anywhere. Was it really that politically incorrect that it's more or less disappeared? This really should have gotten a wider readership than it apparently did, as I don't recall it being religiously offensive at all.
From a rare five stars for Catch-22 to a two for this book and I am being generous. I liked Catch-22 so much and was delighted to see another book by Heller that I splurged on a hard bound. There are a few spots where Heller's special form of wit shine through an otherwise boring story. I don't think I even finished the book.
This book was a must-read of the year. Anyone wanting a crash course in wit, irony, sarcasm, and satire can find it here. At the time, it was racy to make light in fiction of Biblical personages. We were not yet on today's 24/7 cable news cycle, so I'm not sure if there were press releases from Virginia condemning the book.
Making the Bible fall-off-your-chair funny takes imagination, timing and a gift for the absurd in refrains not immediately suggested by the source material. Making Solomon "schlo-mo" is a brilliant, and Bathsheba's cheerful sexual manipulation is masterful. Heller demonstrates a deep understanding of the story which he updates to modern concerns (sometimes quite literally) with a healthy dose of foul-mouthed real politick. It's a triumph.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I like it a lot better than Catch-22, but I have a soft spot for underdogs. Catch-22 deserves its renown, to be sure, but God Knows is underappreciated brilliance
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name.
Joseph Heller was the son of poor Jewish parents from Russia. Even as a child, he loved to write; at the age of eleven, he wrote a story about the Russian invasion of Finland. He sent it to New York Daily News, which rejected it. After graduating from Abraham Lincoln High School in 1941, Heller spent the next ye...more
More about Joseph Heller...
Joseph Heller was the son of poor Jewish parents from Russia. Even as a child, he loved to write; at the age of eleven, he wrote a story about the Russian invasion of Finland. He sent it to New York Daily News, which rejected it. After graduating from Abraham Lincoln High School in 1941, Heller spent the next ye...more
Share This Book
2 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“But how can one be warm alone?”
—
16 people liked it
“That's another thing that pisses me off about that Michelangelo statue of me in Florence. He's got me standing there uncircumcised! Who the fuck did he think I was?”
—
9 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...






























How do you find the book so far?
It has been sitting on my shelf for a long time. However, I have heard that apart from Catch-22, Heller's wor...more
Jun 24, 2010 05:06pm