Lucky Girls: Stories
by Nell FreudenbergerSign in to Goodreads to see your friends' reviews of this book.
discuss this book
friend reviews (0)
To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
lists with this book
Where's the love? Add this book to your favorite list.
other reviews (showing 1-20 of 393)
bookshelves:
growers--not-showers,
left-unfinished
Read in January, 2006
"What's that game where the wooden blocks are stacked so precariously and wooble on their tippy toes till they crash?"
"You mean Jenga?"
"Perhaps, perhaps. But I prefer to think of it otherwise."
"You mean Jenga?"
"Perhaps, perhaps. But I prefer to think of it otherwise."
Like this review?
yes
(3 people liked it)
add a comment
Unfortunately for Nell Freudenberger, I would have given this a way higher rating if it wasn't for me having just read another short story collection by Alice Munro. All the stories in here are interesting (although I'm naturally biased since they're all about expat girls and I'm an expat girl) and have good premises (for example, white girl living abroad in India has longterm affair with older Indian man; he dies and his mom and wife start getting involved in white girl's life) and are entertai...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Lucky Girls by Nell Freudenberger generated a lot of attention when it first came out and not necessarily for its merits (see all the hating reivews on Amazon). It seems that Freudenberger was an intern at The New Yorker, which chose to run one of her stories and it also turns out that she has had somewhat of a privileged life being a young attractive woman with a degree from Harvard as well as a big advance for a book based on the short stories in her collection Lucky Girls.
As for th...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in May, 2007
recommends it for:
people who are not failed writers
It's hard to be objective when the reason you picked up this book in the first place was jealousy. You had just finished your M.F.A. Saved on your computer was a spreadsheet listing every single rejection letter you ever received -- and the list was long. You had pretty much given up on creative writing all together and had settled for a horrible job in community journalism.
And Nell came along, and she was your age and pretty and her first story was published in the New Yorker, of all places...more
And Nell came along, and she was your age and pretty and her first story was published in the New Yorker, of all places...more
Like this review?
yes
1 comments
bookshelves:
shortstories
Read in June, 2007
I tried, really tried, to like this book. Alas. I didn't even finish.
A collection of short stories, Freudenberg takes either hybrid identities or expat Americans in southeast Asia as her subject matter, illustrating the circumstances of five girls/women.
I think my problem is right now I'm looking for plot-driven stories. Freudenberg, upon first glance, looked like she was duplicating the success of Jhumpa Lahiri's Interpreter of Maladies, which I loved. But no, Freudenberg i...more
A collection of short stories, Freudenberg takes either hybrid identities or expat Americans in southeast Asia as her subject matter, illustrating the circumstances of five girls/women.
I think my problem is right now I'm looking for plot-driven stories. Freudenberg, upon first glance, looked like she was duplicating the success of Jhumpa Lahiri's Interpreter of Maladies, which I loved. But no, Freudenberg i...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in August, 2008
recommended to jen by:
books inc's sale shelfrecommends it for: women i love
the first story, which takes its name from the title of the book (aka Lucky Girls) is so lovely it has inspired me to gift this book to a friend for her birthday after i'm done reading it. (yea i give used gifts, look out.)
the last story i kind of skimmed. i just couldn't get into it.
all the stories in between i really enjoyed reading, even though none of them really ended up anywhere. but that's the thing with short stories, they're a little glimpse into a life not your own and it's ok that...more
the last story i kind of skimmed. i just couldn't get into it.
all the stories in between i really enjoyed reading, even though none of them really ended up anywhere. but that's the thing with short stories, they're a little glimpse into a life not your own and it's ok that...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
short-stories,
top-shelf
recommended to Tatiana by:
i wish i could remember
okay, i admit it, i have a huge chip on my shoulder for all the mid-20's wunderkind who are already published and living the preppy artist's life in a nice dusty brownstone in brooklyn. someone recommended this and i was like oh sure, she got published in the new yorker on her first story, which, is like deciding to become and bank robber and robbin fort knox, and then got a book deal off of that one short story? that, too me, sounds like the makings of a really crap writer, because stuff like...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
This was fun set of contemporary short stories with Asian thems.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in June, 2007
I heard about this book on NPR right before it came out. I kept meaning to pick it up and kept meaning to pick it up, then finally saw it at work on one of my final work book raids. This is a solid little collection of stories. There are some character similarities across the stories that made me wonder if a lot of her characters were based on similar people, but taken as individual stories, all very readable. Freudenberger is a good writer, I'm interested in reading more by her.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in September, 2006
What I do remember about this book is running into a pristine copy of it on sale for $9 at a street-side book vendor's table in Park Slope while I was still deep in the queue for it at the library. I love when things like that happen. I'm sad to say I can't remember any specific details from any of the stories right now, though. I have a vague memory of some Andrea Lee -esque tales...
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
2008
Read in March, 2008
This is a book of 5 short stories and I liked them all except the last. I got a little weary of the similar themes running through them all. The author must have been going for cohesion but it felt more like a lack of creativity. However, I like her writing style a lot and she has interesting characters. I thought the first and third stories were especially engaging.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in January, 2008
recommends it for:
Liz Guharoy
Such a highly recommended book. I love the subject matter (girls/women in SE Asia, esp. India, oh India) and I thought it was well written, especially for a first effort. The characters were vivid and the endings of the stories always left me thinking. I think that Nell Freudenberger will get better and better as she writes more--I would love to read a novel.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
I approached this collection with skepticism after all the hype, but was pleasantly surprised. After reading so many stories about Indians (and Bengalis and Pakistanis) in Britain and the US, reading about Americans in the subcontinent was a refreshing inversion. The collection is uneven, and some of the stories feel redundant, but, really, not bad.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in January, 2005
ugh, privileged viewpoint and gimmicky, contemporary prose. i couldn't finish it. not bad writing, but very self-conscious in feeling and disappointing, especially from an alumna of my high school. and here i had been hoping to write her fan mail, become her protegee, and ride her coattails. alas.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Solid, intrigueing story-telling, especially with the first four stories in this collection. The last, "Letters from the Last Bastion," seems uninspired and a bit cliched, but "Lucky Girls" and "The Tutor" make this short short story collection worth reading.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Has a copy to sell/swap
—
Read in December, 2007
I don't think I'll finish this one. It's supposed to be 5 "novella's" but each story is so similar to the previous one that I kept getting them confused. They didn't seem to have any real direction to them, either. The writing is mediocre at best.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Freudenberger is the real deal. The attention her work has gotten is well deserved. It seems there isn't any aspect of craft that she can't tackle with confidence and grace. Looking forward to reading her novel, "The Dissident," which came out in 2006.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
fiction-and-literature
Read in May, 2004
recommends it for:
short story enthusiasts
Five short stories - all about other cultures and realities presented from the perspective of American women.
The first short story read like the first chapter of a novel. I was disappointed that this was a collection of short stories.
The first short story read like the first chapter of a novel. I was disappointed that this was a collection of short stories.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in July, 2008
Liked the stories "Lucky Girls" and "The Tutor," thought "Outside the Eastern Gate" was okay, and just skimmed "The Orphan" and "Letter from the Last Bastion" because they didn't hold my attention. So really I'd give it 2.5 stars.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Her stories are very "orange," if stories could be described like that. I want to dislike this book, but in truth I love it. I'm kind of surprised no one in the Asian American community has cried foul on this one.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment

























