Crescent and Star: Turkey Between Two Worlds
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Crescent and Star: Turkey Between Two Worlds

3.78 of 5 stars 3.78  ·  rating details  ·  565 ratings  ·  101 reviews
“A sharp, spirited appreciation of where Turkey stands now, and where it may head.” —Carlin Romano, The Philadelphia Inquirer
In the first edition of this widely praised book, Stephen Kinzer made the convincing claim that Turkey was the country to watch—poised between Europe and Asia, between the glories of its Ottoman past and its hopes for a democratic future, between the...more
ebook, 288 pages
Published September 22nd 2001 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,091)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Annie
I was equal parts enthralled and frustrated by this book. Kinzer clearly loves Turkey. He adores it. He sees how insanely fucked up it is, but loves it anyway. While he is not an apologist for for the essentially military-run government, he deftly puts it into a perspective in a way only a person who is both an insider and an outsider can, which as a whole makes certain events (like the military coups) much more understandable in post-Ataturk Turkey.
However, he on occasion comes off as the lectu...more
Henna Paakkonen-Alvim
Kinzer´s book is a wonderful read to understand Turkish 20th century history and politics and the challenges that the country has faced and faces in being in the crossroads of Europe and Middle East, with multiple ethnicities and religions. The book basically covers the period from Ataturk to Erdogan, discusses Kemalism, the Army, Religion, Kurdish problems, Armenian past, and the democratization challeges. Turkey´s strive for EU membership and the changing foreign policy of country are also cov...more
Gordon
Stephen Kinzer is an ex-New York Times correspondent who has written about many parts of the world, while based in locations as varied as Nicaragua, Berlin and Istanbul, the latter two as bureau chief. He has covered Central America, Eastern Europe, the Middle East, Turkey, Africa … -- in short, he's been around.

I picked up this book because I read one of his previous efforts, Blood of Brothers, while travelling through Nicaragua in 2008. Daniel Ortega had just been re-elected, and the book dea...more
Lynn
So, finally I am done. Please do not mistake the great length of time I took to complete this book to mean anything other than I awful at managing time as of late...this was a great read. As someone who visited Turkey and read a handful of fictional literature about the great city of Istanbul and life under the Ottoman Empire this book wove together a bunch of missing facts and political details I was otherwise unaware of.

It is obvious the author is passionately in love with this county, he is...more
Diane
Written in the very early 21st century, this book combines 20th century history with current politics to give the reader a history and contemporary view of Turkey. The author has spent many years in the country as a journalist, and he clearly has a great love of his subject. He serves as a major booster for the country. Since this book was written 10 years ago, much of the contemporary information is dated, but Kinzer has done a good job of predicting future trends. Many of the author's predicti...more
Doug
This is the second Kinzer book I've read. He's a talented writer who brings his subject to life with a clear, direct, active style.

In both books I've read, Crescent and Star and All the Shah's Men (about the US/British overthrow of the Mossadegh government in Iran), Kinzer turns potentially dry subjects into page-turners.

Perhaps as a by-product of his accessible style, Kinzer arrives at simplistic solutions. In Crescent and Star, the overall thesis is that the founders of the Turkish Republic we...more
James
Crescent and Star is probably a bit basic for anyone who's familiar with Turkish politics and 20th century history, but I found it a great sub-250 page introduction. It focuses almost exclusively on the Turkish Republic and its people, from Ataturk to the present, but not at all in chronological order. I don't know how objective this book is, as the author, a American journalist, spends plenty of words criticizing (berating?) the military and its omnipresent role in government. But you might, to...more
Faye
Stephen Kinzer was a journalist who lived in Turkey for a long time and his book has personal impressions as well as interesting political commentary and historical perspective. Great read in preparation for my trip to Turkey in a few months.
Selcuk dönmez
You insult turkish people all over the world, turk state, everything that made up my people. Stop this.
Stephen kinzer doesnt know anything about my country, and people. So who are you that saying about turkisness. According to you turk isnt etnic people. It is only common name that given by Atatürk.

"We are turk nomads. We are Yoruk, Turkmen, Turkic people. We have several state and the last one Turkey Repeblic will live forever. Atatürk says that "One day my mortal body will turn to dust, but...more
Justin Tapp
Read this in preparation for going to Turkey in August. Kinzer is a former NY Times correspondent who has written several books. Seems like he is a good journalist who learned the language and culture very well and was granted access to important figures.

One passage from his inter-chapter interludes got me particularly excited, Kinzer talks about the countless historically and archeologically significant sites that no one even knows about:

"Even the discovered sites are so remote and widely scat...more
Alec
When digesting Stephen Kinzer's book, "Crescent and Star," the reader may feel that Turkey is much like the exotic spice bazaars in Istanbul lovingly described by the author. Like those clamorous bazaars, the land of Atatürk is an iconoclastic milieu of both ancient and modern in which the denizens loudly haggle among themselves about the direction their country should go. This spirited debate on a national level – as well its chaotic uncertainty – underscores every chapter and, in the eyes of K...more
Blue
Kinzer is a great writer and a good storyteller. He alternates cultural mini-chapters with more analytical writing in Crescent and Star: Turkey Between Two Worlds. As a Turk who was heavily brainwashed with the "official history of the country during and post-Ataturk", there is much I can and should read, and this book is a good starting point. I can write a whole other book as a response to Kinzer's very insightful study, but for the most part I agree with the bulk of his criticisms and analyse...more
Guy
Kinzer was a foreign correspondent for the NY Times who lived in Turkey for several years and who clearly has a deep and abiding affection for the country. For my money (and, after just one trip of two and a half weeks to Turkey, albeit intense, I am anything but an expert), he does a good job of deconstructing the puzzle that is the Turkish Republic: militantly secular and yet deeply Islamic, attached to its traditions but determined to modernize, unable to decide if it is a multi-ethnic state...more
Alex
An interesting read if only because Kinzer is tending to approach Turkey from a Turkey-is-European (or at least proto-European) than a Turkey-is-fundamentally-different standpoint. I worry that Kinzer is eliding some important differences even though he does do a fine job of balancing his viewpoint.

As with any book written about a country by a non-native, I also worry about his pile of "reccomendations" for Turkey, and am concerned that his obvious pro-Europe slant is coloring his perceptions of...more
Nicolette
Finally! A political, historical, and cultural book that is not written by the likes of bored, mindless, uncreative drones at McGraw Hill! I absolutely love social science/historical books that aren't written in your typical textbook format. The book was certainly thorough and interesting; I lived in Turkey for quite some time and felt myself reliving some of those moments by the pictures painted by Kinzer throughout his book.

There were some things that I did question (I have it noted in the ma...more
Michael
I picked this up based on the recommendations of Goodreads users. I was hoping for a good history of modern Turkey, and instead found a journalistic sketch of the country. I was not impressed. Bouncing around between history, contemporary politics (circa early 2001), and light observations of Turkish life, Kinzer spends a good deal of time scolding the Turks for failing to fully embrace democracy. The word "should" appears prominently in each chapter, and I found this to be both distasteful and...more
Michael
A readable and consistently interesting short introduction to current political trends and issues in Turkey. Kinzer was the NYT's Istanbul bureau chief in the late 90s and his strong affection for the country comes through on every page as he lucidly and concisely walks you through fascinating twists and turns from Ataturk to Erdogan.

Turkey is in a remarkable political moment, with an Islamist government gently but firmly prying the military's fingers off of the political machinery, and democra...more
Michael
Great information. I felt like the book could have been a 5 if Stephen had kept to a chronological order. For the most part he did, but he jumped back and forth from the 1980's through 2007. It left me feeling disoriented about the present state of Turkey. His last chapter attempted to show the present state of Turkey, but Stephen again left me feeling like Turkey is on the brink of disaster and also so close to becoming what it has desired to be for so long. That is probably the intended effect...more
Alice
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Patrick
Another really good book by Kinzer. Though not as exciting and engaging as "All The Shah's Men", it is still very interesting and informative.

Turkey is a fascinating country stuck between two worlds and Kinzer does a great job of relaying the history and culture of the only Islamic European nation. The political structure in Turkey is very unique and Kinzer skillfully explains the history and the ideology behind it. The chapters on Kemal Ataturk and on Turkey's tumultuous relationship with Gre...more
Jana Hawley
A fabulous book to better understand current Turkey politics. I wish I had finished it before i was in Turkey this summer.
Read it before you go!
Fusun Dulger charles
Great book if iyi want to understand Turkey, it's people and politics.
I am Turkish, very involved in politics and found it most insightful.
Fusun
Debbi
Kinzer was a NY Times correspondent to Istanbul and lived there 6 years. His writing is compellilng and concise. He describes the current culture and political structure of Istanbul, and much of TUrkey, within an historical context. Turkey is a very important nation, geographically, with eight borders - Bulgaria, Iraq Iran, syria, Kazakstan, Armenia, Georgia, and Greece and has two major seas, the Meditteranean and Black Seas. Istanbul has been the prize for kings, sultans and rulers for hundred...more
Tobin Fricke
This is a great little introduction to modern turkey, written by someone who was the New York Times bureau chief in Istanbul for a few years. It is full of enthusiasm for Turkey, and covers the basics: who was Atatürk, what has happened since then, lite coverage of the Armenian genocide, and the Kurdish insurrection. Between these chapters are more personal chapters (written entirely in italics for some reason) about the authors experiences and adventures in Turkey (such as swimming across the B...more
Bulent
Rakıdan Atatürk'e, Cumhuriyet'in arkasında bir tehdit gibi dalgalanan Osmanlı'nın hayaletinden, imparatorluklar batırmış bir toplum olmanın psikopatolojisine kadar Türkiye'ye dair her şey, Türkiye'ye dışarıdan bakabilmiş bu usta yazarın satırlarında gizli.

Yıllarını Türkiye'de geçirmiş bu usta gazetecinin, bizi bizden çok daha iyi anlatan kitabına dair tek eksiklik bence, 2002 yılında basılan Türkçesinin son 10 yılda yaşananları içermemesi.

Türk bir okur olarak Kinzer'in Türkiye'nin AK Parti ikti...more
Sooz
great introduction to the modern day country of Turkey and an overview of the historical elements that still have a lot of influence.
Mike O' Brien
A harrowing glimpse into the dark world of Turkish politics, religious and ethnic strife.
Katie
I read this book in preparation for a trip to Turkey, and would recommend it to others with similar purposes. I sincerely learned a great deal, both historically and culturally, from the text, and left feeling like I better understood the country.

Although I can understand the criticisms, I didn't find Kinzer to be overly prescriptive--that is, it was clear to me that this book is not a tome on solutions to Turkey's problems, and that prescriptive instances were based on the author's own feelings...more
GeekChick
Oct 26, 2007 GeekChick rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: people interested in Middle Eastern history
This is a very interesting political history of modern Turkey. The book starts with the question, "Are the Turkish people ready for democracy? Or do they need the army to continue to enforce secular reforms?" (lest the populace elect Islamic fundamentalists to office). Which of course highlights the contradiction of secular reforms intended to bring about democracy, that have to be enforced militarily.

The book is a history of Kemal Ataturk's reforms and what has occurred since. Anyone interested...more
Lauren Albert
A reporter's affectionate but critical book on Turkey and its history. He shows how Turkey's repression of Kurdish culture and language has fostered extremism, as has its repression of Muslim religious expression. He shows how great Turkey has been, is, and how much greater it could be if it trusted its citizens and the democratic process. His section on the aftermath of the great earthquake when the Greek government and people rallied to Turkey's side, volunteering and donating in droves, is a...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 36 37 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Tales from the Expat Harem: Foreign Women in Modern Turkey
  • A Fez of the Heart: Travels Around Turkey in Search of a Hat
  • Turkey
  • Atatürk: The Biography of the founder of Modern Turkey
  • Portrait of a Turkish Family
  • Osman's Dream: The History of the Ottoman Empire
  • Black Sea
  • Eastward to Tartary: Travels in the Balkans, the Middle East, and the Caucasus
  • The Shia Revival: How Conflicts within Islam Will Shape the Future
  • The Ayatollah Begs to Differ: The Paradox of Modern Iran
  • Empire of the Mind: A History of Iran
  • Dreams and Shadows: The Future of the Middle East
  • The Punishment of Virtue: Inside Afghanistan After the Taliban
  • Treacherous Alliance: The Secret Dealings of Israel, Iran, and the United States
  • Descent into Chaos: The United States & the Failure of Nation Building in Pakistan, Afghanistan & Central Asia
  • Hezbollah: A Short History
  • Taj Mahal: Passion and Genius at the Heart of the Moghul Empire
  • Travels with a Tangerine: A Journey in the Footnotes of Ibn Battutah
6333
Stephen Kinzer is an award-winning foreign correspondent who has covered more than 50 countries on five continents. His articles and books have led the Washington Post to place him "among the best in popular foreign policy storytelling." (source)
More about Stephen Kinzer...
All the Shah's Men: An American Coup & the Roots of Middle East Terror Overthrow: America's Century of Regime Change from Hawaii to Iraq A Thousand Hills: Rwanda's Rebirth and the Man Who Dreamed It The Brothers: John Foster Dulles, Allen Dulles & Their Secret World War Reset: Iran, Turkey, and America's Future

Share This Book