Past Caring
1910: Distinguished MP Edwin Strafford resigns at the pinnacle of his career, removing himself from the public eye. The woman he loves, and for whom he was willing to sacrifice everything, suddenly and coldly rejects him. All the reasons for his fall from grace are shrouded in darkness.
Seventy years later, historian Martin Radford is down on his luck when a mysterious bene...more
Seventy years later, historian Martin Radford is down on his luck when a mysterious bene...more
Paperback, 624 pages
Published
September 30th 2010
by Corgi
(first published 1986)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,039)
I stopped reading another book mid-stream because I was so excited when I got this one. I read a list of books recommended by some authors and Stephen King recommended this author so highly, it reminded me of me when I get excited about an author or book. So far I am in love with this book - it's a great mystery with several layers of mystery. I'm loving it! We'll see how it ends...
Great book!!!!
Great book!!!!
Thoroughly enjoyable read...and perfect for a holiday. A book that delivers on all the promises made by the blurbs at the back, this is indeed a compelling novel about betrayal, jealousy, lies and other great ingredients. While much of the book uses turn-of-the-last century British politics as a background, this does not make the book any less interesting. Goddard manages to weave in historical events such as the Suffragette movement and the Boer War seamlessly into his plot. Great twists and un...more
Read this one a long time ago and just remembered it. I loved this one. I went on to read other Robert Goddard books. They're kind of all the same in the way all Hitchcock movies are the same, which is to to say that they're all the same, and why shouldn't they be? They're great and fun. Goddard writes about men with pasts that come back to haunt them. I can't say I remember the story of this one well other than some scenes on the island of Madeira, layers of the past being revealed one by one.....more
I found this book took a long time to get into with the scene setting and the writing style hard going. I was tempted to abandon but as a book group read this was not an option. I was pleased I finished the book even though for me, it certainly wasn't a great read. It became predictable, it was obvious the beautiful Eve was a temptress up to no good and our main character Martin was weak and ineffective. The only likeable character in the book turned out to be Strafford's intended. The 'baddies...more
I'm hovering between a 3 and a 4 on this.
I love Goddard's later books and this shares some good things with them: it's a gripping page-turner, written with intelligence and extensive background knowledge, while never getting above itself or claiming to be more than the clever piece of escapism it is. I liked the way that he paralleled many of the issues and themes of the Edwardian part of the story in the present day: e.g. the Suffragette movement was juxtaposed with a battle-of-the-sexes storyl...more
I love Goddard's later books and this shares some good things with them: it's a gripping page-turner, written with intelligence and extensive background knowledge, while never getting above itself or claiming to be more than the clever piece of escapism it is. I liked the way that he paralleled many of the issues and themes of the Edwardian part of the story in the present day: e.g. the Suffragette movement was juxtaposed with a battle-of-the-sexes storyl...more
Past Caring is my third and final book in the Great Transworld Crime Caper. The previous two books were easy picks, because I knew when I saw the subjects I definitely wanted to read those. The last book though was a tough choice, mostly because there were some amazing sounding books to choose from. In the end I picked Robert Goddard's book because it had a historical slant to it. And it turned out to be a good choice. The book is a fat novel, clocking in at 623 pages, but I had a hard time putt...more
This is the second book I’ve read for the Great Transworld Crime Caper. As soon as I read the synopsis of the book I thought it sounded like my sort of book, within a few pages I knew I’d made a good choice.
The plot is split between the present (though that’s in the 1980s, back when the book was written) and the past, as historian Martin Radford tries to investigate what happened to Edwin Strafford back in the 1910s. Edwin’s story is told through his memoir, both plots are gripping and once they...more
The plot is split between the present (though that’s in the 1980s, back when the book was written) and the past, as historian Martin Radford tries to investigate what happened to Edwin Strafford back in the 1910s. Edwin’s story is told through his memoir, both plots are gripping and once they...more
Once I find a writer I like, I tend to binge on them. I stop when I have had enough or when I realize I am about to exhaust the oeuvre. In the mid-90s I read all of Robertson Davies and was sad when I all I had left was personal letters and the like. I similarly tore through Patrick Robinson's and Dennis Lehane's crime novels and the Barset Chronicles by Anthony Trollope. Robert Goddard's body of work turned out to be too large to consume all at once. Already in the teens when I started him, I r...more
The first three hundred pages of this book were absolutely riveting -- I could not put it down, this story of a out-of-work historian in the 1970s who stumbles upon an old, turn-of-the-century mystery involving a British cabinet member and his mysterious fall from grace. I suspect this first half was so riveting because it was the memoir of the cabinet member in question and his circumstances were fascinating. Alas, the second part of the book involves the contemporary historian solving the myst...more
Read for Transworld's Great Transworld Crime Caper
What appealed to me the most about Past Caring is the way it entwines two stories: Strafford’s memoir is told in its entirety, while in the here and now Martin Radford, our far-from-flawless protagonist searches for the answers that have painfully eluded Strafford in life. I immediately took to poor conscientious Edwin, so brutally condemned for crimes he appeared to have no knowledge of. Was this true though? Did he not tamper with the truth in...more
What appealed to me the most about Past Caring is the way it entwines two stories: Strafford’s memoir is told in its entirety, while in the here and now Martin Radford, our far-from-flawless protagonist searches for the answers that have painfully eluded Strafford in life. I immediately took to poor conscientious Edwin, so brutally condemned for crimes he appeared to have no knowledge of. Was this true though? Did he not tamper with the truth in...more
I came across a reference to this author in a review of Tess Gerritsen's "The Bone Garden", where the reviewer basically said that Gerritsen was good, "but no Robert Goddard". So, always on the lookout for a new (to me) and promising mystery author, I looked him up, and borrowed this book, his first, from the local town library.
I am impressed! The writing is very good -- perhaps a little on the old-fashioned side, but in the sections based on Edwardian England that was quite proper. I consider t...more
I am impressed! The writing is very good -- perhaps a little on the old-fashioned side, but in the sections based on Edwardian England that was quite proper. I consider t...more
You too would reach the point where you were PAST CARING if the found that your perfect life had been wrenched from you; the love of your life had suddenly abandoned you and your once promising career was in tatters all for reasons unknown to you…….reasons that no one would explain but vehemently insisted were known to you.
Such is the fate of Edwin Strafford. Once a man with a promising political career as a British cabinet minister, contemporary and friend to the likes of Winston Churchill and...more
Such is the fate of Edwin Strafford. Once a man with a promising political career as a British cabinet minister, contemporary and friend to the likes of Winston Churchill and...more
I had never read anything by Robert Goddard before, but I certainly will try more of his books. In the blurb on the cover, it was compared to The Magus and The French Lieutenant's Woman (I didn't see the blurb until I had finished the book) and I have to agree, in that it has that same mysterious, convoluted plotting of Fowles's works. The protagonist is an admittedly weak, easily-led man, down on his luck, who is offered an assignment he simply can't refuse, to look up the "real" history of a l...more
Half way through this book I thought I was going to give it 5 stars but downgraded it to 3 upon completion. At first I couldn't put it down but by the end I wanted to finish it quickly and start another. Without revealing the plot, for me the character of Eve was no less than nerve-grating and believe the story would have fared better with a male, 'non love interest' counterpart with a twist. The Couchmans also seemed to get under my skin at times; very clichéd. Nevertheless, this is story-telli...more
This book had the most profound impact on me. I read it many years ago and there were elements to the story that reminded me of John Fowles' "The Magus" which is one of my all-time favorite books. Mr. Goddard is not only a gifted writer, but he has an understanding of human nature and human psychology which transcends that of the vast majority of fiction writers.
The title does not fit the novel and in fact, it detracts from the novel. I've no idea why he chose this rather trite title for such a...more
The title does not fit the novel and in fact, it detracts from the novel. I've no idea why he chose this rather trite title for such a...more
Take the Suffragette movement and blend it with high power political stakes including Churchill, Asquith and the like and throw in the intended marriage of a cabinet minister of the time and a leading suffragette. Edwin Strafford plans to marry Elizabeth Latimer but one of them has to give up their political life to make it happen. Edwin chooses to resign but after he does this Elizabeth completely shuns him and the Prime Minister refuses to take him back.
Why is Edwin shunned so suddenly and why...more
Why is Edwin shunned so suddenly and why...more
Jul 09, 2011
FittenTrim
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
top-shelf-best-books-ever
A few months ago, I raved about Goddard's In Pale Battalions, but in some ways, this book is even better. It gets off to a quicker start as the novel's desperate & flawed hero takes a job which (any reader can see) is a set-up sure to destroy his life. Goddard's books follow a formula where the past is always loaded with secrets and scandals which will haunt a flawed protagonist searching for the truth. While these books are so great, I should note that the endings are always more downbeat...more
Read by................... Paul Shelley
Abr/Unabr................ Unabridged
Total Runtime.......... approx 19 Hrs 40 Mins
blurb - Written in clear, resonant prose, Goddard's first novel, nominated for the Booker prize, is a poised telling of a complex tale. A fascinating "could this be true?" story within a story is reminiscent of Josephine Tey's Daughter of Time, while Thomas Hardy's tragic characters are deliberately echoed in the Edwardian British politician Edwin Strafford and the troubled his...more
My first RG book was "Sight Unseen", picked up on a whim in a supermarket and enjoyed. Recently I came upon 6 of his books in a 3 for £5 promotion in Morrisons... so obviously I had to buy all 6 for £10! I decided to start with RG's first novel, the one I'm reviewing now. Martin, the narrator/protaganist, turns out to be a pretty pathetic chap. Despite being well qualified and having both teacher and historian on his CV, he is naive, gullible and misses some pretty obvious clues. Knowing that RG...more
This was recommended by a friend and I got the audiobook and plunged in without even reading a blurb or a short review so I wasn't sure what to expect. About 100 pages in, I was a bit fed up, it was clearly of the 'historical crime' genre with emphasis on the historical and I knew so little about the politics of the early 20th century that I was losing interest. The book also felt densely written, with little dialogue, and the pace was lethargic. I'm glad to say I was wrong. I think it does need...more
so was i after struggling through to about page 300 . I just could not face picking the book up again and reading about an obscure minor event that happened in 1910 so it went on the floor and straight to a charity shop .. It was obvious early on which way the story was going and so the mystery element never engaged me . The only mystery to me is why such a feeble book should attract so many good reviews .
Did I mention the writing ? I had better not ......
Did I mention the writing ? I had better not ......
I enjoyed reading the book. Lots of characters and suspense and complex connections. Provided some views into different cultures, different times, different values. Troubled by the authors lack of developing one character that he should have left out of the story if he wasn't going to fully utilize the her (the protagonist's daughter). I could not wait to get back to the book and keep reading it but the ending left a bad aftertaste. Too bad!
I found the main character in the present day part of the story (written in 1988), to be quite unlikeable. I suspect that was the author's intent. The story goes between the present and the past, as the disgraced historian, Martin, tries to solve a mystery from the early 1900's. It is interesting to see the similarities between the characters and story lines of the two times, the present mirroring the past.
Aug 15, 2011
LG
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
summer readers
Recommended to LG by:
Biogeek
This turned out to be a great beach read! I mean, it’s a story about a British Member of Parliament, and one from the early 1900s at that – not something I’d ordinarily care about. And yet I was rapt. Whether it was narrator Martin Radford’s, or that of his disgraced subject Edwin Strafford, every part of the story kept me turning the pages. Goddard is the kind of veteran storyteller who makes compelling characterization and well-paced plot twisting look effortless. I’d raise an eyebrow at the b...more
Thank you fellow GoodRead Goddard fans. I am listening to Past Caring - and I must admit I was getting a bit tired of the background story and wishing for the book to move on. But the other reviewers have reminded me to take a breath and enjoy the ride. I have loved the other Robert Goddard books I have read and I know he will surprise and delight me with a wonderful masterful style of writing. So thank you fellow GoodReaders.
A split plot, just the kind of format I like. In the 1980s, a historian takes on the job of figuring out why a prominent young politician in the 1910s would resign without reason and disappear into obscurity. Armed with the politician's memoirs he gradually learns the truth, and realises that the past can be just as dangerous now as it ws then. Great twists and turns and a well-paced plot.
I love Goddard and buy everything he writes as soon as it comes out. I save his books until I have time to spend and a hankering for something well above the common. In this case, Past Caring struck me as a little long-winded, but he is forgiven. Goddard writes an old fashioned mystery, and this time his style was positively victorian. He must also have spent some lovely hours on islands in the Mediterranean since several of his novels feature a village of blindingly white stucco cottages facing...more
This was my first Robert Goddard and I've read all his books since. You need to space them out as they obviously have a similar formula, but I enjoy them as thrillers/light reading. They often weld past and present together in telling the stories, and there are plenty of twists. Good quality holiday reading.
I've just read this book for the second time and I have to single it out for a special recommendation. It is absolutely brilliant. Evocative of places I love - Madeira and Devon. Craftily hinged around historical detail. Amazingly cleverly plotted and so gripping I didn't want to go out!
Quite the best book I've rerad in years. I'd love to hear if anyone else shares my enthusiasm for it.
Quite the best book I've rerad in years. I'd love to hear if anyone else shares my enthusiasm for it.
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Is there an error? | 3 | 14 | May 20, 2012 01:11am |
In a writing career spanning more than twenty years, Robert Goddard's novels have been described in many different ways - mystery, thriller, crime, even historical romance. He is the master of the plot twist, a compelling and engrossing storyteller and one of the best known advocates for the traditional virtues of pace, plot and narrative drive.
More about Robert Goddard...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“But perhaps revelation often comes when you’re not looking for it, resolution when you don’t realize you need it.”
—
8 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...





















Mar 26, 2013 05:36pm