The Buddha in the Attic
by
Julie Otsuka
Julie Otsuka’s long-awaited follow-up to When the Emperor Was Divine is a tour de force of economy and precision, a novel that tells the story of a group of young women brought from Japan to San Francisco as “picture brides” nearly a century ago.
In eight incantatory sections, The Buddha in the Attic traces the picture brides’ extraordinary lives, from their arduous journey...more
In eight incantatory sections, The Buddha in the Attic traces the picture brides’ extraordinary lives, from their arduous journey...more
Hardcover, 144 pages
Published
August 23rd 2011
by Knopf
(first published 2011)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
After the first chapter of this book, I thought I had hit upon a goldmine of a book and wondered how anyone dared to rate it less than 4 stars. Otsuka draws the reader in by offering up a kaleidoscope of experiences by a flock of Japanese women clustered in the ship's steerage bound for California as mail-order brides. Lest you think this is a silly book. It is not. Here is what I liked:
*Otsuka clearly has researched, read her history of Japanese emigration, interviewed obsessively to come up wi...more
*Otsuka clearly has researched, read her history of Japanese emigration, interviewed obsessively to come up wi...more
It truly boggles the mind all of the attention this book has gotten. The premise is very simple: told in the first person plural, the stories of the women who were brought over from Japan before WW2, generally to miserable lives they had not anticipated, is related. There is no story in this book, however, as it is everyone's story. So we get every variation of where they had come from, every variation of sex for the first time with their husbands, childbirth, work, raising children, interacting...more
A chorus of narrators – the “we” tense – is not the easiest voice to pull off. Julie Otsuka adroitly uses the tense to great effect in her latest book, The Buddha in the Attic. It’s a searing insight into an entire community of innocent and naïve Japanese women who arrived in California after World War I, with dreams of their new American life that would soon be cruelly shattered.
Each of these women – whatever fate decrees for her – is also connected to the larger body of the sisterhood, women w...more
Each of these women – whatever fate decrees for her – is also connected to the larger body of the sisterhood, women w...more
This short novel, a novella really, just got the Femina. I was at Fnac to buy a few comic books, as I like to do every time I am in Europe, and they were just mounting the display. Talk about buying a book for its cover: I didn't even know Otsuka was an American, nor that this was a translation...
Her use of the first person plural is powerful, her simple prose, mimicking I suppose the uneducated heroins, incredibly moving.
An awesome tale of courage!
Her use of the first person plural is powerful, her simple prose, mimicking I suppose the uneducated heroins, incredibly moving.
An awesome tale of courage!
My father served in World War 2, Korea and Viet Nam. He never really talked too much about any of these wars. When we talked about World War 2 the only thing he said was that the American Government's treatment of Japanese Americans was one of the most shameful things we had ever done as a nation, at least in his life-time. He was sickened every time he thought of it. While he was alive, one of his good friends was another retired Colonel named Yamamoto who served with him in World War 2 and bey...more
What a fabulous read!!! From the journey from Japan to San Francisco of Japanese mail-order brides to the onset of Japanese Americans sent off to internment camps during WWII, I was spellbound by Julie Otsuka's "The Buddha in the Attic." Narrated from first person plural and told from the POV of a group of women, this is a powerful story, for it allows the reader to see multiple perspectives yet still see the women as individuals. This would be a terrific selection for a book club.
I loved this book! At only 129 pages, it was a quick read. This book tells the story of a group of young women brought from Japan to San Francisco as "picture brides". The book traces their extraordinary lives from their journey to America by boat, to their arrival and meeting with their "husbands" who seem years older than their photographs, their first nights as new wives (many were virgins), to raising their children who would later reject their culture and language. Then the war comes and th...more
of note, this almost won the national book award 2011, and jesmyn ward DID win with "salvage the bones", both by young Salvage the Bones authors, both specifically looking at brutal and unjust situations/groups that are marginalized in the extreme, and from woman POV. hear hear i say on that, but do the NAB judges have an agenda? or are they just reflecting some concerns of many after the usa decades long wars creating brutal unjust situations/groups that are marginalized in the extreme?
anyway,...more
anyway,...more
A lovely poemovella. Or novellem? How would one categorize this hybrid poem-novella? Whatever its genre, it is without a doubt eloquent and unforgettable. Within this slim volume the history of 20th century Issei and Nisei - first and second generation Japanese immigrants to the western hemisphere - is told by Japanese women, who must "blend into a room", who must "be present without appearing to exist." Otsuka gives these women fearless, tender, angry, sorrowful voices and dares you to not hear...more
When starting this book I kept thinking "Did I read this already?" It turns out somewhere along the way I read the short story that begat the full novel. And it's a great opener. But I had a little trouble settling into the the first person plural perspective. I kept waiting for it to shift to a singular point of view, but it never did. However, I ended up liking the impact this pov had on the sense of belonging, or not belonging, the Japanese had in their American communities. The "we", "us", a...more
This is an odd book, so points to the author for originality of thought. She wrote of the experiences of Japanese women brought to America by paid matchmakers from Japan. Each chapter: The Whites, The Births, The Children, etc. is filled with joy and heartbreak.
There are no individual characters; only a narrative written in first person plural "we." For instance, "We gave birth in an orchard. We gave birth behind the curtain of our husband's barber shop, holding back our cries. We gave birth and...more
There are no individual characters; only a narrative written in first person plural "we." For instance, "We gave birth in an orchard. We gave birth behind the curtain of our husband's barber shop, holding back our cries. We gave birth and...more
Half-way through The Buddha in the Attic it seemed one of those books that you admire but don't particularly like. I appreciated Otsuka's technique, the use of the collective "we," to drive the story of Japanese "picture brides" journeying to Northern California in the 1920's. It lets her emphasize the anonymity of the women--indeed, the anonymity of any immigrant group--in their new country. And it enables her to speak in shorthand about the women's varying experiences--underlined by the common...more
I have never read a book quite like this one. Instead of four or five central characters, there seems to be hundreds. The book opens by recounting the experiences of young Japanese women coming to America to become brides—based on photos and letters from prospective husbands. They come from all backgrounds and walks of life and are dispersed throughout California. Some of the women become farmers, shop keepers, maids, prostitutes or laundresses. The author contrasts Japanese culture versus Ameri...more
Si è già detto di quanto è interessante la scelta stilistica di un romanzo corale; riuscita benissimo. Di quanto è interessante il tema poco conosciuto di intolleranza e razzismo verso i giapponesi nella seconda guerra mondiale. Un argomento che comprensibile o no, fa sempre il suo effetto.
Anche io come molti altri lettori non ho apprezzato al meglio i continui elenchi corali di qualsiasi argomento trattassero, consapevolmente descritti dalla scrittrice. Alla lunga l'ho trovato stancante. Gli e...more
Anche io come molti altri lettori non ho apprezzato al meglio i continui elenchi corali di qualsiasi argomento trattassero, consapevolmente descritti dalla scrittrice. Alla lunga l'ho trovato stancante. Gli e...more
Buddha in the Attic is a quick, and different, read. The style in which the author narrates is definitely going to polarize opinions of it. It does take a little getting use to, but for me, it reminded me of other books I have read regarding paper wives and internment camps during WWII, such as Honolulu and Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet.
The way in which the book is written mostly reminds me of a long conversation I had with an elderly Japanese woman in the late 90's regarding her time...more
The way in which the book is written mostly reminds me of a long conversation I had with an elderly Japanese woman in the late 90's regarding her time...more
Julie Otsuko, who wrote 'When the Emperor Was Devine', a book about a family interned during WWII, follows that book with this one. The Japanese American themes continue, although this one is more of a collage than a story. She tells the stories of picture brides, women who came from Japan to America, having seen only a picture of their intended husbands. The marriage was brokered by a middle man who had no hesitation about lying--the men were farm hands, rather than the professional men they we...more
Julie Otsuka's The Buddha in the Attic, the follow-up to When the Emperor Was Divine was shortlisted for the 2011 National Book Award for Fiction and the 2011 Los Angeles Times Book Prize, and winner of the Pen Faulkner Award for Fiction 2012.
Between the first and second world wars a group of young, non-English-speaking Japanese women travelled by boat to America. They were picture brides, clutching photos of husbands-to-be whom they had yet to meet. Julie Otsuka tells their extraordinary, h
I loved this book about the Japanese picture brides who came to this country early in the 20th century hoping for a better life. It reminded me of a haiku in that there are just enough words and no more; it touches the reader's emotions without telling the reader what or how to feel; it presents things as they are--allowing the light and the dark to inhabit the same space; it captures a moment in time, but in that moment there is everything.
I loved Otsuka's use of the collective first person na...more
I loved Otsuka's use of the collective first person na...more
This has been on my to-read list for so long, but just never surfaced to the top. When I was looking for a short book that I could read on my phone (yes, I still have a page limit for books I’m willing to read on my phone) it seemed a natural choice. For a book of its length I was startled by how full and rich it was. It tells the stories of Japanese mail-order brides arriving in California at the beginning of the 20th Century. The writing style is somewhere between poetry and incantation with a...more
This brief, strange novel packs a wallop. It's a story of "picture brides" from Japan who came to marry Japanese immigrants in California in the 1920s. The narrative is written in the unusual first person plural -"we"-throughout the book, so that although the story is general about the women's fears, joys, and sorrows, it is also very, very detailed. The reader slowly recognizes that the narrative is building sentence by descriptive sentence, as the author jumps from one woman to another: "On th...more
This short 100-page read felt to me like riding in a human river and feeling magically a part of it. Otsuka enjoins the reader to flow with the voices of Japanese women from their sea passage to San Francisco as mail-order brides in the 20s to the time of internment in camps during World War 2. Though the women voice many different responses to the challenges they faced, they go through similar stages in the transformation of their hopes and dreams to the new realities of their life in America....more
If you haven’t already heard of this 2012 Winner of the PEN/Faulkner Award For Fiction, then pay attention. The Buddha in the Attic is technically nothing new; many readers of historical fiction are already familiar with novels focusing on the lives of Asian women immigrants in the U.S., such as Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club and Lisa See’s Shanghai Girls. Yet it is the voice of the story which makes Julie Otsuka’s novel different.
Written from the first-person-plural point of view, this story deta...more
Written from the first-person-plural point of view, this story deta...more
This is a short fiction book about the Japanese picture brides who immigrated to the United States at the beginning of the 20th century. Although it is fiction, the author took the information from her research into the Japanese immigration experience and incorporated it into this historical novel, so that it seemed more like a relaying of stories told to her by actual people who lived during this time period. At first I had trouble with the first person plural format, and thought I would become...more

Julie Otsuka’s The Buddha in the Attic gave a voice to a group of Japanese women immigrating to the United States in the early twentieth century. While the story was a beautiful representation of the hardships these women experienced in their new lives, it left me dissatisfied. The story is written in a 1st person collative narrative. “On the boat, we often wondered: Would we like them? Would we love them? Would we recognize them from their picture when we saw them on the dock?” (3-4) everythin...more
This is a very good book, wonderfully written. It's about young Japanese women coming over to America to marry other Japanese men they have never met. It's about their bravery, imaginations and expectations and how those were blasted by the brutal reality of their lives once they reached our shores. It is hard for me to imagine how most of us, no matter how challenged our circumstances might be, would be able to cope with the nastiness of the lives these women were subjected to after their arriv...more
I know this book is highly acclaimed but it left me cold. Otsuka summarizes the collective experiences of Japanese women who emigrate to America to marry Japanese husbands who have paid for their passage. It started off interestingly enough, with their passage on the ships, but deteriorated from there. She goes straight from their hard, early years to Japanese American internment with almost no positive experiences in between. I'm not denying that being an immigrant is extremely difficult....see...more
Mar 19, 2013
Brittany (lemondrop)
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
books-i-ve-listened-to
for more book reviews, visit www.1000thvoice.wordpress.com
This was a really entertaining but brief listen. Unabridged the audiobook clocked in at about four hours. What this book lacks in length it makes up for in emotion. To say it packs a wallop is truly an understatement. The complexity of emotions, of many emotions to be more accurate, was stunning.
Despite the deep emotions, the hallmark feature of this novel that will have a lasting impact on me is the narration. Told in third person plural...more
This was a really entertaining but brief listen. Unabridged the audiobook clocked in at about four hours. What this book lacks in length it makes up for in emotion. To say it packs a wallop is truly an understatement. The complexity of emotions, of many emotions to be more accurate, was stunning.
Despite the deep emotions, the hallmark feature of this novel that will have a lasting impact on me is the narration. Told in third person plural...more
Julie Otsuka creates poetic and powerful chorus-like narrative of the journey of Japanese women who came to California in the first half of the XXth century to marry men they had never seen but as a photography. She manages to convey both their individual intimate experiences and their collective fate. Forced to marry men they had never met, disciplined through a hard working-life and enstranged in a country where Asians were recent immigrants, they will be seen as potential «traitors» after the...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Book Club: Buddah in the Attic | 7 | 2 | May 18, 2013 03:12pm | |
| The Book Club: Background Information for Buddah in the Attic | 8 | 1 | May 17, 2013 01:35pm | |
| THE LISTS: (Rationale) My Second Novel "the Buddha in the Attic" | 1 | 6 | Mar 04, 2013 03:53pm | |
| Thanks for comments. Discussion is now closed. | 5 | 189 | Aug 19, 2012 06:24pm |
Julie Otsuka was born and raised in California. After studying art as an undergraduate at Yale University she pursued a career as a painter for several years before turning to fiction writing at age 30. She received her MFA from Columbia. She is a recipient of a Guggenheim Fellowship, the Asian American Literary Award, and the American Library Association Alex Award.
Her first novel, When the Empe...more
More about Julie Otsuka...
Her first novel, When the Empe...more
Share This Book
4 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“women are weak, but mothers are strong”
—
7 people liked it
“We lost weight and grew thin. We stopped bleeding. We stopped dreaming. We stopped wanting.”
—
3 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...










view all 20 comments































