Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Family Orchard: A Novel” as Want to Read:
The Family Orchard: A Novel
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Family Orchard: A Novel

3.03 of 5 stars 3.03  ·  rating details  ·  404 ratings  ·  65 reviews
In the bestselling tradition of The Red Tent, The Family Orchard is a spellbinding novel of one unforgettable family, the orchard they've tended for generations, and a love story that transcends the ages.

Nomi Eve's lavishly imagined account begins in Palestine in 1837, with the tale of the irrepressible family matriach, Esther, who was lured by the smell of baking bread in
Paperback, 336 pages
Published September 11th 2001 by Vintage (first published 2000)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Family Orchard, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Family Orchard

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 809)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Ayelet Waldman
I'm just going to refer you to the brilliant Daniel Mendelsohn's review of this novel:
Made it to page 102. I couldn't take it. I don't like to force myself to read a book. It has to make you want to read it.
Kris - My Novelesque Life

"A magical, multigenerational saga encompassing two hundred years in the life of an unforgettable family--a book of love stories, ill-fated and blessed, sensuous as a dream, unfolding in a time and a place where fable is more potent than fact, where the imagination is more powerful than any truth, where the line between myth and history has all but dissolved: Jerusalem, from the early years of the nineteenth century to the present.

They left Eastern Europe for Israel and emerged, six gen
I read this book when I was in my teens and knew very little about the conflict in Palestine. I loved it back then, for its language and its quirkiness.
So I thought I d read it again, to see what I had overlooked, now that I know more about what is happening there...
The Family Orchard tells the story of the many branches of a Jewish family tree, from the 1850s to the present day. It is mostly based around Jerusalem and Palestine.
The book is full of anecdotal and domestic detail, it is romantic
The book follows a family’s 200 year history as they travelled from eastern Europe to Israel and put down their toots there. The characters are interesting and well–drawn but at times the book goes off on spiritual and artistic tangents that are difficult to follow. I also found that it kind of dwindled off at the end.

Anne Marie
This book wasn't as bad as I thought it would be after reading a couple of the not-so-great reviews. I was at least able to finish the book, unlike one of the reviewers, who had to stop at page 100. I thought the author had really great subject matter even though it was fiction, but realistic fiction, about her Jewish ancestors. Some of the stories were interesting; I liked how grandparents and great great grandparents came to life in their time period. But other times, it was difficult and rath ...more
Where to begin? I had this book on my shelf for ages - years in fact. Something led me to take it off the shelf and start it a few weeks back... Maybe because I have been reading other books at the same time, I found the opening chapters took a while to get into. I soon got into my stride though, and found myself really enjoying Nomi Eve's writing.

Her characters were so real and interesting. Their flaws and foibles making them very intriguing personalities. This is a book about family and place
This novel is an interesting exercise in weaving history, legend, fact and memory as Nomi Eve composes her own midrash from her father's family history research. He records births, marriages, and migrations; she constructs secret desires and personality quirks. Each chapter gives a fleeting glimpse of a couple or an individual in the family from 1837 to the author herself.

I'm afraid the premise is at times more interesting than the execution. Sometimes Eve's flourishes and embroideries are a bi
An unsatisfying read. I enjoyed the first 100 pages or so, in which the characters from history were presented. As she got closer to the modern characters, they got less and less interesting, and more unappealing. In general, it is not a flattering picture of a family. As others have noted, the depiction of this family in isolation from much of the world around them (Palestinians, in particular) was odd.

The idea of the orchard as a theme did not really work. It seemed more like a lot of research
This was like reading short stories, and I was looking for a different kind of family saga, the kind where one generation slowly slips into the next. This book makes one abrupt jump after another. The redeeming feature is that Nomi Eve is quite a good writer, but she needs to get the movement in the narration better. This is a debut novel so perhaps she will.
Eve's bits with the supernatural do not resonate well with me, and if I know that sort of thing is in a book, it probably would have been
Megan Lillian
An interesting style of narrative, the history of a family from Jerusalem is unraveled through both the narrator's father's factual historical lens and her own fantastical, imaginary version of each generation's lives, loves, and losses. Several of the details were beautiful, or clever, or both. I liked the descriptions of each of her characters very much. The last chapter was the weakest and I felt the author fell into trite love-isms as she tried to find some way to wrap up... Overall, the boo ...more
This is the story of a family that spans generations and is in many ways a fictionalized history of immigration to Palestine. Um, Palestinians dont really play a role in this one. We are really talking about a history of European immigration to Palestine. A Palestine sin Palestinians. So a lot of interesting and important history goes unfictionalized and thus silenced in this book. That said, there are some passably hot sex scenes, but dont get too excited because somehow throughout the generati ...more
I'm not sure if it was just because this was the first book I read after my 2nd baby was born or what, but I didn't really like it. For one thing, it took me over a month to read, and if you know me, you know that I generally read books in days, not weeks. Partly that could be attributed to that "new mommy haze", but part of it was the book. It was a family history, but there wasn't enough plot to keep my interest. It kind of dragged along. The first two chapters were almost soft porn, but the r ...more
A multigenerational saga told as a family history. It starts with the great-great grandparents of the author. Each story is so intimate and sensual. Woven throughout are women with special talents - embroidery, baking, stealing even. It tells some deep dark secrets/family secrets and how it alters their life/lives and their histories. Beautifully written She is fine story teller. The family mostly lives and grows up on a citrus orchard. The descriptions you can almost taste. The orchard is in Is ...more
Sara Steger
Eve's family history in fiction. Very nicely done. She draws her charactes well. The problem for me is that just when you become invested, she moves on to the next generation.
This was an interesting read. It was a good lazy winter read and kept my attention. It was written in a unique way, with the authors grandfather and father narrating the book.
Definitely interesting in some parts, but seems muddled in others. Overall I found it enjoyable but I wouldn't rush to read other books by the author.
Debby Carroll
I liked the book, particularly the premise of the daughter's words and the father's words telling the same stories. I think the writer has some very strong moments and some weaker ones, leaving me feeling like this could have been a great book but stopped at good. I know the writer was young and she may grow into her craft over time. This is a wonderful first effort and I believe it could be re-written stronger. The transitions were weak from story to story but I think that careful editing and c ...more
Mooi boek voor iedereen die geïnteresseerd is in familiegeschiedenis. Het boek begint met Esther en Yochanan en van daaruit volgt een verhaal over de vele generaties die vanuit hun huis in Jeruzalem worden geboren en opgroeien. Het leest een beetje vreemd (vandaar 3 sterren) want het is een soort stamboom dat uit verhalen bestaat, waarbij een 'vader' de feiten vertelt en een 'ik'persoon deze aanvult met verhalen. Door de feiten wordt het verhaal steeds onderbroken en leest het niet echt als een ...more
This is her one book. It reminds me of the Latin American surrealists but based in Israel over generations. So far she has a nice touch. You feel like she was enjoying this while she was writing it.

And in the end, not a great book, but a good book. There was much love in writing this. She took her family history and made a real life fairy tale out of it.

I'm fascinated by the fact that she disappears after. As Ken Kesey said, isn't writing just one good book enough? Probably. She just put some mu
A promising premise: it's written in conversation with, and as fictional elaboration on, the author's father's history of their family, whose ancestors emigrated to Palestine in the 1830s. Unfortunately, the execution doesn't live up to the promise; we don't spend enough time with any of the characters to get intimately familiar with, or care about, them, and there's not enough treatment of changing historical contexts to take advantage of the story's broad historical sweep through a most intere ...more
Verfaille Dirk
great storytelling
As of p. 72, this book is pretty much just about sex. Not bad, but thus far it is definitely not a family saga following the history of Israel. It's a sexy romance novel with a slight plot.

I've gotta stop choosing my reading from the discard cabinet.

After about half way through, a story begins to develop with a little history and some stuff about caring for orchards. I liked it better then. Still, it was with a sense of relief and accomplishment (not enjoyment) that I turned the last page.
I really enjoyed reading this book. The characters felt real and I enjoyed their stories.
I wanted to like this. The setting was intriguing, the language was beautiful and poetic in places, and I generally love multi-generational sagas, but somehow it didn't come together to create a compelling whole. I think part of the problem was that the author tried to cram in too many generations, so you only got to know one set of characters for 20 or so pages before moving on to the next generation. In the end, reading this felt more like work than a pleasure.
wasn't into it, stopped reading it before the end. maybe i'll try it some other time.
Dec 09, 2009 Ellen added it
December Book Club book

Meh. I would not have finished it if I didn't feel like I had to for book club. I think it was well-written, but each chapter is about a different generation of this family, so you don't really follow any one character for very long. It's kind of like how I feel about Benjamin Button: I'm sure it's well done, but just not my thing.
I particularly liked the structure of this book, the father giving a factual account of the family history and Nomi Eve embroidering the stories of the various ancestors. Especially the early part reminded me of the magical feel of Like Water for Chocolate. It tapers off a bit towards the end, but overall a very enjoyable reading experience.
Apparently "in the tradition of the Red Tent" means "about a Jewish family through history."

Two narrators -- a father and a daughter -- tell the tale of their family: him through a more-factual account, her a fantastical.

But with no characters to guide us through the whole book and very little interesting plot, it falls a little flat.
This book possessed qualities that I always adore in a book- earthiness, a wordy sensuality, hints of the spiritual, generational timelines. It fell short of my desires, though, due to a sort of odd sexual nature- difficult to explain- and a something else I'm still not sure of. Someday I'll write a more complex review.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 26 27 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Almonds and Raisins
  • The Book of Splendor
  • The Marshmallow Incident
  • My Name Is Not Alexander
  • The New York Times Presents Smarter by Sunday: 52 Weekends of Essential Knowledge for the Curious Mind
  • Yiddish with Dick and Jane
  • My Mother's Spice Cupboard: A Journey from Baghdad to Bombay to Bondi
  • The Girl from Human Street: Ghosts of Memory in a Jewish Family
  • Songs for the Butcher's Daughter
  • The Walls of Jericho (Ben Kamal and Danielle Barnea, #1)
  • Exiles
  • Gorgeous Lies
  • Fork in the Road
  • A Divided Inheritance
  • The Cooper's Wife Is Missing: The Trials Of Bridget Cleary
  • Black Potatoes: The Story of the Great Irish Famine, 1845-1850
  • Unconfessed
  • George And Rue

Share This Book

“The word legend comes from the Latin “legere,” which means “to read.” The word fiction comes from the Latin “fingere,” which means “to form.” From fingere we also get the word fingers. We form things with our fingers. The word history comes from the Greek “istor,” which means “to learn” or “to know.” I believe in original etymology. I believe that fiction is formed truth. I believe that history is a way of knowing all of this. I believe that legend is how we read between the lines.” 4 likes
More quotes…