Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Steel” as Want to Read:
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview


3.4 of 5 stars 3.40  ·  rating details  ·  4,818 ratings  ·  655 reviews
It was a slender length of rusted steel, tapered to a point at one end and jagged at the other, as if it had broken. A thousand people would step over it and think it trash, but not her.

This was the tip of a rapier.

Sixteen-year-old Jill has fought in dozens of fencing tournaments, but she has never held a sharpened blade. When she finds a corroded sword piece on a Caribbe
ebook, 304 pages
Published March 15th 2011 by HarperCollins (first published February 25th 2011)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Steel, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Steel

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Erica (daydreamer)
Steel. Ooh, shiver me timbers just thinking about it! Can I just say epically amazing! Oh yeah, this is the book. It is brilliant! I was so excited to read it and so ready to love it, and boy did it deliver! It’s everything it promises and more! It’s an incredibly exciting, roughish adventure that you can’t just help getting caught up in. I was engrossed from the very beginning, and couldn’t stop reading it.

The characters were brilliant. Jill was a strong heroine (I mean pirate, oh yeah ;). On
There are a lot of elements to Steel that seem as if its bound to be a win.
Time travel?
A touch of romance?
They’re all there. But I never really connected to Steel the way I would have liked.

I mean, it was enjoyable enough, but there were some things that held me back and created a bit of a disconnect. Jill was a bit too moody and petulant for me. I get that she’s a teen (and probably a spoiled rich one - who else fences?), and I get that super competitive people are real
Well, shiver me timbers: this was better than I had expected matey.

The Good:
C’mon it’s about pirates!!!!!
Female “hero” who actually fights
The rapier’s story and history
The characters
Feeling connected to our main character and knowing what she was thinking and feeling.
It was fun.

The bad:
A little bit “pirates of the Caribbean” girl-style for me. And, the fact that in the Author’s Notes in the back she specifically says her pirates are not “movie-pirates”. Disagree.
It wasn’t as exciting
Unfortunately, this was a huge disappointment. I stopped reading at about 75 pages, simply because I was overcome with how heinous this all was. And my reading resolution for 2015 is to not waste time on books that I do not enjoy. Trust me, I did not remotely enjoy this one.

With that being said, en garde to the reasons I detested this novel.

1. The watered down plot:
When I think of pirates, I want the gritty, dangerous, and driven by greed variety. Something along the lines of Pirates of the Cari
YA books do not have to be all Disney. They can deal with hard issues, tough situations, and difficult consequences all while being age appropriate, well written, and still entertaining. Unwind by Neal Shusterman is a perfect example of that.

This book, like many other YA novels coming out right now, takes what would normally be an extreme situation fraught with danger and dumbs it down to a series of easily survivable occurrences, unusually helpful people, and settings that are never as dangero
Mary (BookHounds)

Carrie Vaughn is one of my favorite authors, so when she started to write young adult novels, I was more than thrilled to get a sneek peek at this one. Steel is just a fun and fabulous read that combines a bit of time travel with historical fiction. It has great characters and a believable plot. Well, as far as you can get with time travel and historical fiction. I found myself transported back in time and spent the afternoon googling the pirates named in the story.

Jill is an
Novel Novice
The comparisons to the Disney franchise are inevitable. Steel by Carrie Vaughn follows 16-year-old Jill as she travels back in time, and finds herself in the midst of a pirate crew sailing the Caribbean. But make no mistake: there are no signs of Captain Jack Sparrow here, and Vaughn lets you know in an author’s note that it’s deliberate.

Her decision to make her pirates a little tamer than some of the more vicious tales is also deliberate. That’s because more than anything else, Vaughn wrote the
Lydia Presley
I think I am going to be kinder in this review then I want to be for two reasons mostly.

I read this book after reading a fantastic novel with pirates, seafaring terms and a cast of brilliant characters.
I really, really loved the cover. It's gorgeous.
In Steel, Carrie Vaughn sets up a story about Jill, a fencing student who just barely falls short of making the mark. The chapter titles are fencing terms, which is interesting in itself and sets the mood for each chapter well.

However, it also means
Let’s take a moment and gaze upon the awesomeness that is the cover of Steel. The girl with the calm, steady gaze – a determined glint in her eyes, I’d say – and the sparkly sword. The two things together promise a novel that is full of bad-assery and will have you at the edge of your seats as you travel the seas, fighting pirates and finding love.

The reality is a lot different.

I was excited to read this book. When my hold finally came in, I went to the reserve shelf, got it in my hands and did
I would give this 3.5 stars actually.

I love the cover on this book, it is amazing! I normally love pirate stories, but this one was just likable. The story just seemed to be missing something. It just felt loose, I don't know if that's the right word or not. The main character wasn't actually my favorite character, Henry or Captain Cooper, or even the Captain Bain. As a reader I found them more interesting than the main and I found myself wanting to know more about there lives. That was another
This was definitely a unique story. You don't find many pirate stories that have a girl as the main character (or at least, I haven't read any). I liked reading this from a female point of view.

This was definitely an action drived story. There really didn't seem to be much character development. But hey, its a pirate story. It's going to be action-packed, right? I would have liked to get to know a little more about Jill and even Henry. And while the summary of the book says that romance was in
Steel is a fantasy/time travel stand-alone novel for young adults. Jill is a sixteen year old girl whose main hobby and passion in life is fencing and competing in fencing tournaments. Her goal is to make it to the Olympics someday. On a family holiday in the Bahamas Jill discovers the tip of a rapier that is hundreds of years old and this is somehow connected to an accident that leads Jill back in time to the golden-era of piracy. Jill has to learn how to survive on the pirate ship that fishes ...more
♆ BookAddict  ✒ La Crimson Femme
Honestly I have no idea why this book was on my TBR list. Trying to clear off my shelf, I finally borrowed this from the library and read it. After reading it, I still have no idea why I had this on my list of books to read. Totally not my genre and the book did nothing for me.

Ms. Vaughn is a good writer, there is no doubt. The fantasy she weaves is good. The world building is innovative. The characters are so-so. This book is really more for young adult and it's probably why it did nothing for
Page (One Book At A Time)
The idea behind this one was a new one to me, and I admit it intrigued me greatly. I think with the latest Pirates of the Caribbean coming out in 2011, HarperTeen probably has a hit on their hands.
I thought Jill was a great character from the opening pages. She's dedicated to her sport and shows real discipline in it. I liked the fact that it was fencing because it was so appropriate to what happens to her. I enjoyed her character even more when she's transported back to the 18th century. She ke
Veronica Morfi
Rating: 4.5/5

Jill is in love with fencing but after losing a very important game she retreats in the Bahamas with her family. There she finds a tip of a broken rapier in the sand and realizes it's a 300 year old piece of history so of course she holds on to it. After an accident, involving a boat and some crazy waves, she ends up on board a pirate ship, at the time where the rapier tip came from.

All aboard!

This is the perfect read for people like me that love pirates and good swordfights. Jill
Review originally posted at: A & C Book Junkies - ARC Review: Steel (By Carrie Vaughn)

This was my first Carrie Vaughn experience and I must say, it was a rather pleasant one. This story is about a teenager, Jill, who is a highly competitive fencer. She lives fencing; she breathes fencing; she is fencing. Or so that is the mantra she goes by when the novel first beings. Have you ever wanted something so badly, come within its grasp, only to lose it completely? Well, that is where we meet Jill
I didn’t think I'd enjoy a story about a girl and pirates, but I did. The story just works. A little bit of magic and a lot of adventure and this outlandish tale of a girl finding herself in place unknown was a fun read. From a romance angle, the story is kept relatively clean… not many passionate embraces here! But that’s OK, because it's a story driven by and steeped in adventure. The hints of magic didn't hurt either. And while I wanted the magical part explored a bit, as it stands I am satis ...more
Ace Turnberry ♠
Carrie Vaughn: A swashbuckling tale of magic, romance, and pirates.
Me: A dull time-travel story of magic that wasn't even the focal part of the story, tasteless romance (not the lovey-dovey kind), and unappealing pirates.

This had so much potential. I mean come on, a story about sword-fighting and grimy pirates?

But Steel proved to be just one of those books with nothing but an eye-catching cover to offer.

I literally did not feel anything for any of the characters. Cooper's past was sad, but tem
2.5 stars.

I read this so long ago I can’t remember much about this so I’m going to apologize in advance. This review is probably going to be very short and not very thorough like my others.

You see that cover? Awesomeness, right? Then you read the premise – pirates, time travelling, and sword fights! It’s a freaking bonanza of awesome! Until you start reading…

This girl is one whiny brat. Just because she lost a match she gets all habut (local slang, sorry) or maybe in other words, salty balls. Su
What a great YA book for fans of pirates!

A co-worker said this was her favorite stand alone of Carrie Vaughn's & I have to agree. It took a chapter or two to get going, but once in, I really enjoyed it. I loved the pirate lore - she has a short explanation in the back about what is real history and what is embellished...there's some sailing 101 mixed into the story, as well.

She makes the main character's progression believable, especially the change from fencing to fighting for "real." I lik
Mundie Moms & Mundie Kids
4.5 stars

Talk about an adventure on the high seas! Steel is a fantastic read that not only took me back to the 18th century via a pirate ship, but this is one of the few books I've read involving pirates and I really enjoyed it. It's action packed, pirate talk & rich history made for a fun, engaging read.

Jill, an avid fencer is on a trip with her family to Jamaica when she comes across part of a centuries old pirate sword. The magic from this sword ends up taking Jill on an unforgettable ad
I saw this book one day when I was looking on the Barnes and Noble web page and thought that the premise was good enough to add it to my shopping cart. After checking out it's page on Goodreads I found that Steel got mixed reviews. A lot of 3 and 4 star ratings.

I thought that the idea behind the story was right up my alley...mainly because it was a new-to-me idea. I think reading Steel helped me get into the proper frame of mind for the new Pirates of the Caribbean movie that came out last weeke
This book felt more like a historical tour of a working pirate ship than a real adventure. I think when writing this the author got a little too excited/carried away by all the pirate facts she compiled and forgot to focus on developing the plot as much. As a result, even the main character Jill admits the thing she learned after everything was how fiercely independent lady pirates are, not exactly a great sign.

Jill’s basically a tourist on the working pirate ship. She’s forced to scrub the deck
Alex Bennett
I was very excited to read this book, very excited. Before Steel, I had never read a pirate book, crazy, but true. With the hype for Steel and all of Carrie Vaughn’s books, I thought this would be the perfect book to lose my pirate virginity to. I was right.

Jill is a strong, empowering female protagonist. She sticks it through her difficult troubles, while still getting the guy. Most of the other pirates weren’t explored very much as characters, but they were entertaining and I loved reading abo
This book, while enjoyable and solid, was a bit of a letdown for me. I'm a fencer myself, and I really appreciated the angle the author used. So many books (and movies) just give their character a fencing background and voila! they can deal with sword fights no problem. That's not how it goes, and I was really grateful to the author for playing out that truth in the book. I also think that the book as a whole had a lot of information about how pirates used to live, and while some liberties may h ...more
This book bothered me. When I read the summary about a fencer who is pulled back in time to the era of pirates, I thought that it had that potential to either be rather unique or incredibly cheesy. It ended up being the latter. The characters had little depth, the main character's reason for going back in time felt like it was not well thought through, the romance wasn't really a romance, the plot felt lackluster, and the ending was very disappointing.
I’m not gonna lie, I find swords to be pretty badass weapons. Fencing is a beautiful sport, evoking that scene in The Princess Bride when Wesley and Inigo Montoya are fighting. In Steel by Carrie Vaughn, swords and fencing take center stage.

Read the rest of my review here
Olivia Script
I will admitthat this book took me a while to finish it being summer. Do I can say this book is not worth it not worth it all. The girl goes on a time adventure finding a boy just so happens to fence just as well as she can and that automatically makes him the main love protagonist and blah blah blah sappy ending and ending that everyone wants and this book was just not entertaining to me. I wouldn't say I didn't enjoy it was just not very entertaining it didn't really keep you hooked for that l ...more
Oct 07, 2010 Jess marked it as to-read  ·  review of another edition
Oh my goodness, I have to read this!!! Let me think, pirates, sword fighting, an amazing cover? Yes please!
Kelsey Ketch
I had fallen in love with the concept, but was disappointed by the execution.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
  • Warped
  • Dark Mirror (Dark Mirror, #1)
  • The Locket
  • Enchanted Ivy
  • In the Shadow of the Lamp
  • Once Every Never (Never, #1)
  • Wake Unto Me
  • Entangled
  • So Shelly
  • The Iron Witch (The Iron Witch, #1)
  • Blood & Flowers
  • The Vespertine (The Vespertine, #1)
  • The Iron Thorn (Iron Codex, #1)
  • The Jewel and the Key
  • The Eternal Sea (Everlasting, #2)
  • Exile (Aurelia, #2)
  • Star Crossed (Thief Errant, #1)
  • Vesper (Deviants, #1)
Vaughn was born into a military family and has lived all over the U.S. She received a BA from Occidental College, after which she went on to work too many jobs to count until she went back to school to receive her MA from University of Colorado at Boulder. She currently lives in Boulder, CO.
More about Carrie Vaughn...
Kitty and the Midnight Hour (Kitty Norville #1) Kitty Goes to Washington (Kitty Norville, #2) Kitty and the Silver Bullet (Kitty Norville, #4) Kitty Takes a Holiday (Kitty Norville, #3) Kitty's House of Horrors (Kitty Norville, #7)

Share This Book

5 trivia questions
1 quiz
More quizzes & trivia...
“It’s only a scratch, don’t cut my arm off!” 17 likes
More quotes…