Yükseltin Tavan Kirişini Ustalar ~ Seymour - Bir Giriş
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Yükseltin Tavan Kirişini Ustalar ~ Seymour - Bir Giriş

by
4.12 of 5 stars 4.12  ·  rating details  ·  30,329 ratings  ·  997 reviews
Two novellas in one volume:
1. Raise High the Roofbeam, Carpenters
2. Seymour, An Introduction
Paperback, 150 pages
Published March 1999 by YKY (first published 1955)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

Be the first to ask a question about Yükseltin Tavan Kirişini Ustalar ~ Seymour - Bir Giriş

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Paul
In retrospect it's a great shame The Carpenters missed their golden opportunity to release a single called "Raise High the Roof Beam".
Paquita Maria Sanchez
It was with simultaneously satisfied and wistful closure that I shut this book. I guess I've now read all the Salinger in almost-chronological order. This book made me especially sad about that fact considering that I was very much aware of what was clearing away as I was vacuuming it up, yet I couldn't make myself sit with it and take it in as slowly as a long goodbye should warrant. Seymour Glass would not approve. Of course, it's likely that there are Salinger shorts out there that weren't pu...more
Mariel
Dec 13, 2012 Mariel rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: reciprocity is a pestilent compulsion to bear
Recommended to Mariel by: hold me suspended in a dream
"This is too grand to be said (so I’m just the man to say it), but I can’t be my brother’s brother for nothing, and I know – not always, but I know – there is no single thing I do that is more important than going into that awful Room 307. There isn’t one girl in there, including the Terrible Miss Zabel, who is not as much my sister as Boo Boo or Franny. They may shine with the misinformation of the ages, but they shine. This thought manages to stun me: There’s no place I’d really rather got rig...more
Rolls
Mar 07, 2007 Rolls rated it 2 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Salinger completists
Anyone who read my review of Salinger's "Nine Stories" knows I love this man's work to death. I've read and enjoyed "Catcher in the Rye" and "Franny and Zooey" a whole hell of a lot too. I picked this up with a heart filled with admiration and optimism. Well that optimism was dashed upon the rocks of Salinger's self-indulgence and apparent disregard for his readers.

This book compiles two short stories first published in the New Yorker and are the final two entries in Salinger's Glass family saga...more
Jacob
October 2009

So basically, I’m waiting for Salinger to die.

I don’t mean that maliciously. Really. I bear no ill will towards the man, and I’d wish him a long and pleasant life as a hermit, full of good health and completely lacking in the company of stupid humans--except, well, he’s already had his. The old man is ninety, slowly doddering his way to ninety-one. Hasn’t published in decades. No one’s seen him in years; he doesn’t even yell at those durn kids to get off his lawn because then people...more
Ashley Lauren
There were times when I was reading this book that I wondered whether or not I should reconsider Salinger as my favorite author. I mean, these stories are all over the place... but then I realized why I love him so much. Salinger does not write "skim-worthy" sentences. I really feel like the depth of his writing cannot be grasped if a person is not reading them with the utmost concentration. His short stories (Raise High the Roof Beam, Carpenters and others I have read) seem, more or less, usele...more
Joshb
Salinger is very, very high on the sentimental favorites list, which makes this difficult to assess objectively - so let's start with the easy half of this two-novella collection.

Raise High The Roof Beam, Carpenters is wonderful, and while it occasionally dips a little too deeply into the preciousness well (the same well that Salinger comes oh-so-close to drowning in in Franny and Zooey), it works, and, if you've read A Perfect Day for Bananafish, serves as a pretty chilling prequel to the entir...more
M. Sarki
Nov 03, 2013 M. Sarki rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: serious writers and poets
Shelves: 5-star-wonders
http://msarki.tumblr.com/post/6577883...

I hear myself out on the literary field of battle loudly cheering, and if you look hard enough you can see me flailing my arms as well. I have my own Davega to share. A gift to be given for the meek and serious among you. I am speaking to the seriously patient and long-suffering reader, and not instead to a citizen submissive or spineless in any way. I mean a searcher as I am; one looking for the hard truth and all its surprises.

The credentialed shine, bu...more
Majid M

اگر خوانواده ی گلس را نمیشناسید مرا با شما لاابالی ها کاری نیست. اگر خانواده ی گلس را میشناسید و سیمور، فرزند بزرگ خوانواده و سردمدار و مراد و شاخص آن را نمیشناسید، احتمالن از مشکل سندروم داون رنج میبرید و نیازی نیست من با ریویوی خود شما را دچار رنج و عذاب بیشتری کنم. همانگونه که از واو در عنوان کتاب پیداست، کتاب شامل دو داستان ِ "تیرهای سقف را بالا بگذارید نجاران" و “سیمور: پیشگفتار" است. خواننده ی سلینجر پیش تر با کاراکتر سیمور در داستان یک روز خوش برای موز ماهی (یکی از داستان کوتاه های سلینجر...more
Dan
May 24, 2008 Dan rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: fans of Salinger
For as long as I can remember, people have told me that this was the worst of the Salinger collection. His Godfather III if you will. Having read it, I'm not sure what the hell they were thinking. For me, I enjoyed these two stories immensely. Raise High is written in the style of Franny and Zooey, though from the perspective of a different brother (Buddy). Seymour is different. I don't want to characterize it in one form or another. As a piece of background, both stories revolve around the elde...more
Sandra
Da tempo questo librino sostava nella mia libreria, acquistato sull’onda di un commento anobiano entusiasta e per la curiosità che il titolo mi aveva messo. Solo quando ho deciso di leggerlo ed ho sfogliato le prime pagine ho capito il significato del titolo: sono due racconti, uno intitolato “Alzate l’architrave, carpentieri” e l’altro è “Seymour. Introduzione”. Ho scoperto anche l’origine del titolo del primo racconto, consistente nei versi di un’ode di Saffo che così recita: “Alzate l’architr...more
Alex
Comprised of two novellas. Raise High the Roof Beam, Carpenters is Salinger at his best. Seymour an Introduction is self-indulgently insufferable.
Julian
My story is a classic one. Boy reads book (Catcher in the Rye). Boy likes book. A lot. Boy decides to read everything author ever wrote, discovering that some of that happens to be a rambling, unfocused mess. I have now read everything that Salinger has ever published in the Glass family saga and am beyond glad to be done with the whole mess. Seymour: An Introduction, a novella that details narrator Buddy Glass's struggle to describe his deceased brother, is a story so bad that it makes me want...more
Jeff
Today marks the one year anniversary of Salinger's death, and fittingly, though not purposefully, today I finished the final story of his that I had yet to read. That is to say, that he published. After reading "Seymour" I can't help but want to write long-winded parenthetical-laced (double worded singular nouns with impregnated hyphens) sentences that go on and on and force a reader to go back to the baptismal font to capture a glistening sliver of what the Hell I'm talking about.

Still, could t...more
Abbyjay
I can never Really tell what makes a book, or an author, an immortal classic. I thought I did for a while but I clearly don't. I do know however, luckily enough, if I like a book, and almost always, why.
I read salinger's Franny and Zooey when I was 16 and was so, so compelled and only understood a mere estimated 35% of the reason why I loved it so much. I thought I loved it because it dealt with the struggles with the terrible ego associated with making art, and that was a very huge reason, but...more
Guido
Felice di avere ormai letto tutto ciò che di Salinger è stato pubblicato in Italia (almeno ufficialmente), e un po' malinconico per il medesimo motivo. Questo volume completa la serie di racconti sulla famiglia Glass, con precisi ed espliciti riferimenti ai "Nove racconti" e "Franny e Zooey". E' uno strano modo "polifonico" di entrare nella vita di una famiglia, ascoltando il punto di vista di ciascuno dei fratelli Glass in tempi e luoghi molto diversi, ed è difficile capire se Salinger intendes...more
Ilenia Zodiaco
Se riflettessimo su chi sia il nostro scrittore preferito, probabilmente ci limiteremmo ad un silenzio imbarazzato. Troppi nomi, troppi libri, troppi personaggi affastellati nella nostra testa da lettori. Eppure. Eppure. Eppure, miei cari. Se, come me adesso, vi ritrovaste intatti - non solo intatti ma anche, per così dire, accesi - dopo la lettura della più insopportabile, verbosa e straordinariamente prolissa baggianata che sia mai stata scritta (per i meno svegli: Seymour, un'introduzione), a...more
Zahra
A nose-dive into knowing more about Seymour : The very mysterious and leading member of Glass family.
dara
Oct 06, 2009 dara rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: The first story to anyone; the second story to no one.
I wish I could give this book two different ratings--obviously for the two drastically different stories. As it is I have to settle for subtracting a star from the 5-star rating I would have given this if it had been "Raise High the Roof Beam, Carpenters" alone.

From a sense of charity alone, I'd give "Seymour: An Introduction" one star. When other reviewers advise skipping it, they aren't kidding. Not only is "Seymour: An Introduction" a tedious, unpleasant read, but it's the pretentious sort th...more
Rebecca
Many times I have referred in conversation to the introductory pages of Raise High the Roof Beam, Carpenters. Our narrator Buddy Glass tells about the night little sister Franny wouldn't sleep. His brother Seymour, age 17, says, "I thought maybe I'd read something to her." Buddy, age 15, says, "She's ten months old, for God's sake." Seymour: "I know. They have ears. They can hear." Seymour proceeds to read to Franny a Taoist tale. "To this day," our narrator tells us, "Franny swears that she rem...more
Anne
As I may have mentioned before, for a long time I didn't care for Salinger. I feel a little like a tool for re-visiting him because he died, but oh well.

"Raise High the Roof Beam, Carpenters" and "Seymour: An Introduction" both took me a while. They're the kind of stories that I feel like I read without really absorbing much, so I think I've missed a lot of important stuff in there. In the end, I think I preferred the latter. It's almost like Tristram Shandy (of which I read about 150 pages and...more
Heather
While Seymour did start to get a little old with the narrator, Buddy’s, description of his older suicided brother, Seymour, I love the tone, the voice, the undercurrent throughout. And what Salinger was trying to do: keep Buddy’s older role model brother young alive and still a model, someone who Buddy can continue learning from. In that way Buddy is able to deal (or not deal) with his grief. Or more accurately, he starts to reminisce and to grieve. We bear witness to this as writing about Seymo...more
Núria
Oct 10, 2008 Núria rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: (antiguos) niños inadaptados
Siempre he querido ser una Glass. Siempre he querido ser uno de los hermanos Glass de las obras de J.D. Salinger. Es verdad que todos los hermanos Glass son unos niños prodigio egocéntricos, pedantes y repelentes, pero sería inútil negar que en realidad tengo más cosas en común con una familia así que con la mía propia. Si se tiene en cuenta que soy hija única de una familia trabajadora de clase baja para nada intelectual, se puede entender en parte mi fascinación por esta familia de ficción com...more
Екатерина
Странна комбинация са тези две повести или дълги разкази. Първият "По-горе билото, майстори" се оказа че вече съм чела. В този разказ Селинджър показва действително най-доброто от себе си - майсторско изграждане на образи, гмурване в обстановката до всеки дребен детайл, гънка на дреха, жега и задушен въздух, до такава степен, че читателят просто присъства там на място, той е участник в действието. Всичко е много интересно, неочаквано, държи в напрежение до края - какво ще се случи в крайна сметк...more
Жор
Повече за Селинджър от мен:
http://knizhenjor.com/2014/01/salinger/

"По-горе билото, майстори" е първата от повестите за семейство Глас, която прочетох, четири или пет години, след като четох "Спасителят в ръжта". Сиймор ми е много любим и се вълнувам как на практика той не участва в собствената си история, понеже (с изключение на "Идеален ден за лов на рибка-бананка) тя винаги е разказвана в ретроспекция/от Бъди.
"Сиймор. Запознаване" задължително ще препрочета след време, май някои неща ми се и...more
Jim
I first encountered Salinger when I was about fourteen and we were given Catcher in the Rye to read at school. I was the right age to read the book and it had a profound effect on me. I read it again twenty years later and was underwhelmed. We’re now a further twenty years down the track so I thought I’d take another crack at Salinger, something different this time. The decision regarding what to go with was completely arbitrary; it could just have easily have been Franny and Zooey or Nine Stori...more
Кремена Михайлова
Явно обичам „да си пъхам носа“ в семейство Глас. Като хора, които познавам, но искам още да науча за тях. Направо към клюкарстване клони… А как обичам техните писма и дневници… Такова обсебване от друг автор не си спомням. Всъщност преди около две години пак ми се случи нещо подобно – с един автор на име… Дж. Д. Селинджър.

Този път не успях да събера впечатленията си в 6-7-9 страници, а в доста двуцифрен брой. За да реша да не ги копирам тук засега и да си кажа: „Мирясай най-после, ум глупав!

За...more
Shauna
Like so many other high school students, Salinger's the one who first got me "on to" novels in the way I read them now -- feverishly, single-mindedly -- so I can't account for why it's taken me more than a decade to revisit him. Every sentence in this is glistening and polished, but for all their exactness, the overall effect is one of subtle, self-deprecating comedy. The narrator's subject in both sections is his brother, who committed suicide at 31, but there's no trace of the sinister -- in f...more
Adrienne
I think I love spending time with the Glass family as much as Salinger did. They are a unique and complicated group of "children" and every story I've read that features them at the center has stayed with me long after I've turned the last page. "Raise High the Roof Beam, Carpenters" was beautifully written and it is probably the better of the two stories when I'm being objective, but the second, "Seymour: An Introduction", is far more touching and definitely more earnest. Listening to a younger...more
Adam
Part of the fun of reading Saligner’s short stories is piecing together the story of the Glass family. Rather than writing a single novel about the Glass family with a linear plot, told by a single narrator, he has split the story up into multiple ones, told at different times from different characters. This makes for more active and exciting reading.

"Raise High…" is hilarious. It’s the story of Buddy en route to his brother Seymour’s wedding. The plot moves faster than the plots of either Fran...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Call If You Need Me: The Uncollected Fiction and Other Prose
  • The Short Stories
  • Miss Lonelyhearts/The Day of the Locust
  • Music for Chameleons
  • Johnny Panic and the Bible of Dreams: Short Stories, Prose and Diary Excerpts
  • Rabbit Novels: Rabbit, Run and Rabbit Redux
  • Revenge of the Lawn: Stories 1962-1970
  • Portrait of the Artist as a Young Dog
  • Rock Springs
  • Maggie Cassidy
  • Eleven Kinds of Loneliness
  • The Short Stories
  • J.D. Salinger: A Life
  • Jesus' Son
  • Winesburg, Ohio
  • نان سال‌های جوانی
  • Forty Stories (Penguin Twentieth-Century Classics)
  • Three Complete Novels: Howards End, A Room with a View, Where Angels Fear to Tread
819789
Jerome David Salinger was an American author, best known for his 1951 novel The Catcher in the Rye, as well as his reclusive nature. His last original published work was in 1965; he gave his last interview in 1980. Raised in Manhattan, Salinger began writing short stories while in secondary school, and published several stories in the early 1940s before serving in World War II. In 1948 he publishe...more
More about J.D. Salinger...
The Catcher in the Rye Franny and Zooey Nine Stories A Perfect Day for Bananafish جنگل واژگون

Share This Book

“I'm a kind of paranoiac in reverse. I suspect people of plotting to make me happy.” 658 likes
“I have scars on my hands from touching certain people…Certain heads, certain colours and textures of human hair leave permanent marks on me.” 217 likes
More quotes…