Unprotected Texts: The Bible's Surprising Contradictions About Sex and Desire
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Unprotected Texts: The Bible's Surprising Contradictions About Sex and Desire

3.54 of 5 stars 3.54  ·  rating details  ·  169 ratings  ·  53 reviews
Bible scholar Jennifer Wright Knust addresses the big questions that dominate today's discussions and debates when it comes to sex and the Bible: Is premarital sex a sin? When, and in what contexts, is sexual desire appropriate? With whom can I legitimately have sex? Are same-sex relations permissible? In an era where the phrases, "the Bible says," and "God says," are so o...more
ebook, 352 pages
Published January 25th 2011 by HarperCollins e-books (first published January 20th 2011)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Unprotected Texts, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Unprotected Texts

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 566)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Naftoli
This book Unprotected Texts: The Bible’s Surprising Contradictions about Sex and Desire by Jennifer Wright Knust is a gem. It is scholarly yet flows easily. Written for an educated audience that is also Bible-literate there is much to learn from Knust’s presentation of current issues as portrayed in Jewish and Christian scripture. Here is a religious scholar who is also an ordained Baptist pastor and yet she is able to speak critically about these sacred texts; one wonders if her windows are bul...more
Peggy Bird
Everyone who uses the phrase, "but the Bible says" should be required to read this book. The author, an ordained pastor and assistant professor of religion who holds a doctorate in religion and a master of divinity, points out that almost any position on matters sexual can be bolstered by what's actually in the Bible. After discussing all sorts of contradictions and differing interpretations on celibacy, sex before or during marriage, multiple marriages and bodily fluids (just to name a few subj...more
Terence
Jul 15, 2011 Terence rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: People interested in Biblical interpretation
Recommended to Terence by: Interview on KPCC's AirTalk
“(T)he truth of the Bible is never obvious, but always in need of further thought and study.” (p. 244)

Jennifer Wright Knust’s Unprotected Texts: The Bible’s Surprising Contradictions about Sex and Desire should terrify fundamentalists of any stripe. It should make even mainstream and liberal believers squirm in their seats for if her logic is carried to its end, her argument undermines the idea that there is a “Word of God” that is a meaningful, universal guide to human conduct. In her conclusio...more
m
Raised as a fundamentalist Baptist but having drifted from the dogma, I am sympathetic to the author's point of view and was looking forward to well-argued and footnoted exposé of the Bible's internal contradictions.

What I got was certainly well-footnoted, but argued? Not so much. I measure these kinds of books in their ability to sway people of other viewpoints. This book plays to the like-minded but is unlikely to convert the born-again.

My key complaint is the author's tendency to cherry-pick...more
Tucker
Worthwhile, extensive review of Biblical sources that present conflicting opinions on sexual morality.

Knust says "the Bible offers no viable solution to our marriage dilemmas. There is no such thing as a single, biblically based view of legitimate marriage." Under the Sinai covenant, "marriage unites free Israelite men with as many women and slaves as they can reasonably support" and "from the perspective of the Hebrew Bible there is nothing inherently wrong with visiting a prostitute." Initiall...more
Matt
Feb 13, 2011 Matt rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Those interested in Religion and human sexuality
goodreads does not allow half ratings, but I really give the book 3.5 stars, rather than just three. It's a fine read in many ways: nice prose style, accessible, clear, and engaging. Certainly pleases you in the department of readability.

As far as the merits of the work as a piece of Biblical Scholarship my opinion of it is a little lower. This book certainly demonstrates that the Bible has no unified view of sexuality or sexually permissible behavior. But then again, that conclusion could not...more
Sheri
What does the Bible have to say about sex? Many contradictory things. If all the Bible's sex-related prohibitions were literally enforced, we'd have to stone or at least kill about a quarter of the population.

Knust breaks up the book into topics (e.g., marriage; desire/lust; body parts; the relationship between the sexes; etc.) and lays out in detail everything the bible offers on each topic. She takes care with the issue of translations, and how those have affected what we think the Bible says...more
Mike
The premise of the book is fascinating: Have we completely misunderstood what the Bible says about sex? And if we have misunderstood it, is there another legitimate way to interpret some of the more misunderstood passages?

Those are legitimate questions, but we will have to wait for someone more skilled at interpreting the Bible than Knust to answer them. It constantly seems like she has already made up her mind to arrive at particular conclusions (such as the legitimacy of extra-marital, homosex...more
Emily
I read this at about the same time as I read God and Sex: What the Bible Really Says by Michael Coogan. And then I got busy and waited a bit to write this review, so I'm afraid the two books are now hopelessly and inextricably smooshed together (yes, that's a technical term) in my brain. So please keep that in mind as you read the review...

Dr. Knust pulls out some fascinating contradictions about sex, marriage, and the body - both male and female - in the Bible between Genesis and Revelation, as...more
Hannah M.
All too often, religious beliefs make their way into arguments surrounding law-making. The huge debate over whether or not gay marriage should be made legal is only one example, but it is a good one. No matter where you go in the U.S. (even in my liberal home state) someone is going to say that The Bible says homosexuality is not to be tolerated, therefore, allowing gay marriage is not okay. But, what does The Bible really say when it comes to matters of sex and desire? In Unprotected Texts, Jen...more
Sophia
In Unprotected Texts: The Bible's Surprising Contradictions About Sex and Desire American Baptist pastor and professor of religion Jennifer Wright Knust does the academic legwork to show that the Bible does not have one singular message about sex, desire, and human bodies. Instead, she takes even readers not familiar with the Bible through its often contradictory messages about gender roles, homosexuality, and the role of sex in human life. It is well-footnoted and written in accessible "academi...more
Renee Peterson
This was a fascinating read, and deserves at least one or more re-readings once you've reached the end. I was most impressed with the unbiased way the author presents the evidence- she neither endorses nor denounces the Bible as a Holy Book, but instead presents evidence in an impartial manner, detailing the differences between what society *thinks* the Bible says and what is actually written.

The author's ideas are well thought out, well presented, and appear very well researched. There are no c...more
Jennifer
Nothing like getting a scholarly shout-out for being the home of a religious bigot. (Pages 113-114, reminding us why it's a good thing that Jacksonville rarely makes the national news.) Other than that small moment of personal shame, Knust's book is surprisingly readable, if perhaps a little too lingering in its examination of biblical circumcision.

While extremely similar to Coogan's God and Sex (which predates Knust's work by a year) in topic, the tone of the two works differs greatly. Coogan...more
Libby
We hear an awful lot of people who feel obliged to tell us how to manage our most intimate activities these days. Mostly those folks feel we are a lot more sinful than they are, and they're mighty anxious to tell us that God doesn't approve of us and the Bible says so. Now I actually have read the Bible, all of it, more than once, and I never quite understood how that kind of folks could be so SURE they were right and all the rest of us are sinners. I was really gratified to read Jennifer Wright...more
Troy
I thought the book pretty good with the analysis of certain verses and overarching Biblical concepts, with my only quibble being her "my translation" showing up pretty often.

I found her analysis pretty common-sensical; the Bible says this, but then it says this other thing which contradicts this. 50 pages of bibliography means she did her homework, not to be summarily tossed by the wayside as "her tone was sarcastic".

In the reviews here, and in a lot of the ratings given with no reviews, I simp...more
Rick Edwards
Jennifer Wright Knust examines a range of biblical texts relating to sex and sexuality, highlighting the differences of narrative setting, theological purpose, and ethical postures represented. As she proceeds, it becomes ever clearer that the Bible does not speak on these matters with one voice. Particular portions of scripture need to be read and considered with bookmarks in several other places so that you can move back and forth. New Testament writers referring to Sodom and Gomorrah rarely r...more
Dray
Frankly, I read this book to try to get some support for my "I'm a Christian and I have premarital sex and I don't think that makes me terrible!" tirade. I get quite a lot of disapproving looks due to my choices, even though I'm a 22 yr old adult in a monogamous relationship. So I thought maybe I'd read up on other views and have some good arguments. Too bad her supporting evidence was weak (even though there were 50 pages of it in the bibliography) and not well argued. Honestly, due to my extre...more
Bianca
I received this copy of Unprotected Texts from Goodreads First Reads Program. Thank you Goodreads! In this book, Jennifer Wright Knust, a professor of religion at Boston University, highlights the many contradictions in the Bible concerning areas such as marriage, sex, desire, and so on. Her research seems very well documented (with over 50 pages of notes at the end of the book), giving credibility to her interpretations. She writes about these topics in a generally accessible way, using uncompl...more
M Christopher
A very useful book by a fellow American Baptist pastor/scholar. The research is well-done and the writing is clear but it fails to be compelling, perhaps because it is essentially trying to prove a negative. Dr. Wright Knust's thesis is that the Bible does not present a unified stand on sexual issues and she proves it well but the conclusion that there is no conclusion is rather unsatisfying. Still, it's a good entree to discussions of sexual ethics, especially if one is looking for arguments ag...more
Daniel
Well written scholarly look at the wide variety of positions that the Bible posits on sexuality and sexual behavior. It is a shame that more people who claim "Biblical Authority" don't both actually read the Bible and read more scholarly critiques of the Bible. The attitude of the book is best summed up by the author herself: "Those who attempt to belittle or demean a class of people, denying them rights on the basis of an unexamined interpretation of a few biblical passages, are expressing not...more
Eric Black
I was very disappointed. So much promise; so little delivery. Also, to promise a fair treatment of the text with such a strong bias going in seems a promise impossible to keep.
Alison
I didn't read 100% of this book (it's a little deep for the layman) but it was a good read. I like that it gives an alternate perspective to what is generally accepted by fact by many Americans. What I ultimately got out of the book was that the Bible is too complex and written from too many perspectives separated by too much time to be taken as having one opinion about anything, be that homosexuality, slavery, marriage, premarital sex, etc. Regardless if the reader agrees with the author's view...more
Karen Weatherwax
Wow! If all Christians upheld the reality that the Bible is a collection of contradictory views about sexuality and marriage, then I might actually want to be Christian.
Erin
I didn't find it surprising.

I don't think that what author calls contradictions in the Bible actually are different things with opposite intent. What Paul says about the preference of celibacy does not negate what any other Bible writer says about having sex or getting married. They are statements made hundreds of years apart and can co-exist in context, not conflict.

Much of what Knust points out as novel or unknown is not actually the text in Scripture, but the lens through which ancient Jews a...more
Jon
Not bad. It got much better towards the middle, but that might be because it delves into some parts of the Genesis mythology that I find interesting. On the other hand, there were occasional spots where arguments felt stretched. The underlying point of contention about biblical interpretations of sexual behavior being an old, old problem is a good one. Some reviewers on other sites have commented it felt dry, but it didn't come across that way to me. Not a bad read. Not one I'd necessarily recom...more
Brian
More like 3.5 stars...a fascinating read, especially for those of us who grew up with the preconceived notion that the scriptures speak univocally regarding issues of relationships, family systems and sexuality...the book tries a bit too hard at times to make connections that are a bit tenuous, and all the minutia regarding stuff like the multiplicity of meanings and purposes for bodily fluids gets somewhat tedious, but I appreciate the breadth of scope and insight presented. A worthwhile read f...more
Tori Danielle
Since this book combined three of my favorite things to study (religion, history and sex) I thought I would absolutely love it. At the very least I thought it would present some compelling arguments about why what many people believe the Bible to say about certain issues could be wrong. Instead it gave me a scholarly rendition of the Bible stories I've grown up hearing. It was a chore to get through. There were interesting little pockets of info, but they were few and far between. I hate that I...more
Kim Phipps
An eye-opener, especially for women. Written by a very astute Bible scholar, this book examines and dismantles the "Bible is our standard" idea when it comes to human sexuality, which is so prevalent in American religious teachings, which of course trickles down to politics, and affects everyone, believer or non-believer alike. I appreciate that she doesn't try and give answers, because at the end of the day, the Bible is NOT meant to be a directional handbook on love, sex, and marriage. But it...more
Mary Weatherwax
I would especially recommend the last chapter. Very thought provoking .
Ben Tousey
So what does the bible REALLY say about sex? Well, first of all, the bible is not a single-homogenous book, and it was written in a different time. I love the way she weaves the political, sociological, and religious aspects into the narrative, and, to be honest, it's one of those books that if, like me, you spend a lot of time talking to Christians about sex, this is a book you want behind you. It's a book you'll want to read many times, even memorize some of it.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 18 19 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • God and Sex: What the Bible Really Says
  • Christianity After Religion: The End of Church and the Birth of a New Spiritual Awakening
  • The Misunderstood Jew: The Church and the Scandal of the Jewish Jesus
  • The First Paul: Reclaiming the Radical Visionary Behind the Church's Conservative Icon
  • What the Bible Really Says about Homosexuality
  • Fall to Grace: A Revolution of God, Self & Society
  • Just Love: A Framework for Christian Sexual Ethics
  • How to Read the Bible: A Guide to Scripture, Then and Now
  • A Community Called Atonement
  • Living in Sin?: A Bishop Rethinks Human Sexuality
  • The Historical Jesus: The Life of a Mediterranean Jewish Peasant
  • The Future of Faith
  • Faith Seeking Understanding: An Introduction to Christian Theology
  • Almost Christian: What the Faith of Our Teenagers Is Telling the American Church
  • The Origins of Sex: A History of the First Sexual Revolution
  • Proverbs of Ashes: Violence, Redemptive Suffering, and the Search Fo What Saves Us
  • Inspiration and Incarnation: Evangelicals and the Problem of the Old Testament
  • The Book of Psalms: A Translation with Commentary
15036
Jennifer Wright Knust is Assistant Professor of New Testament and Christian Origins at Boston University. She came to BU from the College of the Holy Cross, where she taught Religious Studies for five years. At BU, she is appointed to the faculties of the School of Theology and the College of Arts and Sciences and is affiliated with the Religion Department, Judaic Studies, and the Women's Gender a...more
More about Jennifer Wright Knust...
Abandoned to Lust: Sexual Slander and Ancient Christianity Ancient Mediterranean Sacrifice Scotland and the Union: Hume Papers on Public Policy 2.2 Circumpolar Religion And Ecology: An Anthropology Of The North

Share This Book