31st out of 517 books
—
515 voters
Njal's Saga
by
Anonymous,
Robert Cook
Written in the thirteenth century, Njal's Saga is a story that explores perennial human problems-from failed marriages to divided loyalties, from the law's inability to curb human passions to the terrible consequences when decent men and women are swept up in a tide of violence beyond their control. It is populated by memorable and complex characters like Gunnar of Hlidare...more
Paperback, 384 pages
Published
May 28th 2002
by Penguin Classics
(first published 1275)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,869)
I really enjoyed this one. There's some likeable characters -- even from my soft-hearted modern point of view -- who I really got to care about, which isn't always the case with sagas. I was kind of sad when they went out of the saga. The translation is good, clear and easy to read, and there's helpful footnotes, a good introduction, and other helpful supplementary material. As with all sagas, there's an awful lot of names, but it's still pretty easy to follow.
I found some of it amusing in a som...more
I found some of it amusing in a som...more
In the tradition of Icelandic sagas it is very violent and barbaric. Tons of fun in other words, and based on a true story by all accounts. Lots of modern law practice goes back to the people and principles described in this book. My favorite part is the vision of the Valkyries at the end. Delightfully macabre!
Who knew the Vikings were also skilled lawyers?
Okay, apparently using the word Viking is a misnomer as in the text 'Viking' is used to represent raiders of indistinguishable origin.
Anyway, written 800 or 900 years ago, and purportedly describing events taking place 1000 years ago, this saga has it all, giving truth to the use of the word 'saga.' It has battles, romance (as much as you can have when marriages are arranged - Does this man please you? Good, because you are now married), the conver...more
Okay, apparently using the word Viking is a misnomer as in the text 'Viking' is used to represent raiders of indistinguishable origin.
Anyway, written 800 or 900 years ago, and purportedly describing events taking place 1000 years ago, this saga has it all, giving truth to the use of the word 'saga.' It has battles, romance (as much as you can have when marriages are arranged - Does this man please you? Good, because you are now married), the conver...more
One of the best sagas, without a doubt. Epic in scale, but still intensely human, the story of burnt-Njal is dramatic, moving and highly entertaining. The saga style takes some getting used to if you've never experienced it before. It is terse, to the point, characterisation and description is kept to a bare minimum, the plot races along at break-neck speed, there's a plethora of characters (a lot of whom have very similar names). It requires... concentration, and you'll almost certainly have to...more
So engrossing that I missed my bus stop once while reading on the bus. I think that is a good sign.
Basically guys hack each other to pieces for 50 years until eventually the only two dudes left finally make peace. People who are all like "Oh our culture is so violent nowadays" should read this for a little perspective. Because a guy will be like "Where's so-and-so?" And another guy will be like "Oh, I severed his head." And the first guy will be like "Oh, that seems like something you'd do." And...more
Basically guys hack each other to pieces for 50 years until eventually the only two dudes left finally make peace. People who are all like "Oh our culture is so violent nowadays" should read this for a little perspective. Because a guy will be like "Where's so-and-so?" And another guy will be like "Oh, I severed his head." And the first guy will be like "Oh, that seems like something you'd do." And...more
It is one of the greatest crimes of recent literature that Penguin has replaced this -- one of the truly great English translations of any work by anyone -- with a horrendously execrable translation whose only distinguishing characteristic is that it was done more recently. Seek out Magnus Magnusson's translation (thankfully there are oodles and oodles of them second hand due to it being assigned in college courses for decades) at all costs.
This book is really in a class by itself. It might be a...more
This book is really in a class by itself. It might be a...more
This book is a translation of an anonymous thirteenth-century Icelandic saga, written about a blood feud spanning some fifty years before and after 1000 AD. It is a wonderful story (the anonymous author rearranges actual chronological events to fit his story) of tragic people, and one that I very much enjoyed reading.
The saga revolves around the wise Njal Thorgeirsson, his family, his friends, and his alliances; and one is happy that there is a Glossary of Proper Names in the back of the book, b...more
The saga revolves around the wise Njal Thorgeirsson, his family, his friends, and his alliances; and one is happy that there is a Glossary of Proper Names in the back of the book, b...more
I really enjoyed this.
At some point, a researcher summed up the Icelandic Sagas in four words: "Farmers came to blows". This story was like that.Tthere is a blood feud that accounts for rounds of slayings. The surviving combatants then are required to pay indemnities at the annual Assembly, not that that resolves anything. There are still scores to settle. The climax comes when Njal's homestead is burned along with Njal, his wife and their sons. (A foster son escapes to continue the revenge). P...more
At some point, a researcher summed up the Icelandic Sagas in four words: "Farmers came to blows". This story was like that.Tthere is a blood feud that accounts for rounds of slayings. The surviving combatants then are required to pay indemnities at the annual Assembly, not that that resolves anything. There are still scores to settle. The climax comes when Njal's homestead is burned along with Njal, his wife and their sons. (A foster son escapes to continue the revenge). P...more
It's a bit trite to give Njal's Saga a score out of five. How do you rate an 800 year-old piece of literature? It has clearly played a more important role in Icelandic society than mere entertainment. It's an historical document, a foundational document, a compendium of cultural aspirations, and mythological story.
There are three things to take away from reading Njal's Saga. They are, in ascending order of importance:
1. Medieval Icelanders needed a wider pool of names to draw upon. Reading this...more
There are three things to take away from reading Njal's Saga. They are, in ascending order of importance:
1. Medieval Icelanders needed a wider pool of names to draw upon. Reading this...more
Great stuff. It was sweeping, as befits a saga, but often personal as well. It is a story about warriors, and also of lawyers. It is necessarily battle-filled, but also punctuated with the humor of an insult or an understatement. The prose is sparse though the book is long. The epic nature of the story could only exist with its roots in Iceland's pagan past, but the fact that it was written down meant it came after a Christian veneer was laid on top of the society. That world is complex, but exp...more
I read this one for school. I’m not sure whether I would ever read this by my own volition. It wasn’t terrible and in fact good at parts, but nevertheless there are so many other books I would prefer to read. Besides, there is obviously so much lost in translation. The extensive passages about the proceedings of Icelandic law are extremely tedious and the passages where the narrator relates the characters lineage all the way back to Odin are laborious as well. Icelanders and a few Norwegians enj...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Often when thinking about the rise of the European novel there's a tendency to look to Cervantes or maybe back to "The Golden Ass". Yet longer sagas like Njal's saga seem to be very much like novels to me.
This is an amazing work. Partially based on fact and factual events such as the coming of Christianity to Iceland the saga traces a quarrel. As it gets out of hand and men reach for weapons calmer heads build settlements. However the causes of unhappiness cause the quarrel to break out repeated...more
This is an amazing work. Partially based on fact and factual events such as the coming of Christianity to Iceland the saga traces a quarrel. As it gets out of hand and men reach for weapons calmer heads build settlements. However the causes of unhappiness cause the quarrel to break out repeated...more
Jan 09, 2009
Peter
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Pretty much anyone who like some leagle wrangling and stabbing
Shelves:
middle-ages,
alternate-history
OK, it's only "alternate history" because I don't really believe that this is an exact and factual description of life in Iceland during the time the story is set. Unlike many sagas, this one is pretty down-to-earth -- a bit of prophecy, but no magic or monsters. It does have great protagonists, succinct psychological portraits, great fight scenes, heroes and villains with believable flaws, and some great legal wrangling. It's kind of like John Grisham with a lot more stabbing, which, to be fair...more
The children at school throw around the term "epic" in such a haphazard fashion that I spend fruitless hours attempting to define what the word actually means. At times I think I've made an impression, but then the walls come crumbling down when mere moments later, someone's ranting about "epic fails" and some other nonsense. Then I resort to demanding that they "save their cussin' and sassin' for the streets."
If only I call upon Njal's Saga in my defense. This book is truly an epic. The storyli...more
If only I call upon Njal's Saga in my defense. This book is truly an epic. The storyli...more
May 04, 2009
Eric
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Any literate person, any lover of adventure , SF, or fantasy fiction
Recommended to Eric by:
English major at the U. of Chicago
Go for the Penguin edition/translation by Magnus Magnusson and Herman Palsson. This is the greatest of the Icelandic sagas and ranks with any of the classics of world literature. . . . The sagas are the originals of most of the themes elaborated in science fiction and adventure games of all kinds. Njals saga includes more of the themes, characters, and settings than any other saga. Blood, sex, chases, battles at sea and on land, meanness, jealousy, greed, and honor. The worldview of the sagas is...more
Dec 12, 2008
Cwn_annwn_13
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
on-my-shelf-home-library
Yet another great Icelandic saga. Much of the usual sort that you would expect in these sagas. Blood fueds, witchy supernatural prophecies coming true, coniving women, outlawry, and more blood fueds. What could you expect in a society where one was almost obligated to kill someone for even the slightest insult or to not would mean losing ones honor and respect? Also provides a look at the legal system of Iceland during this time period, (you could more or less legally kill someone as long as you...more
The saga: surprisingly readable—and relevant. An all-too-human tale of honor, vengeance, redemption; of mistakes and acceptance and occasional learning. The characters are multidimensional, believable. The setting was especially vivid after having hiked some of that area. This is a moving story about flawed people doing what they think is best in difficult times. Like reading Seneca or Marcus Aurelius, useful as a reminder of how little we've changed.
The Penguin Classics edition: outstanding. Th...more
The Penguin Classics edition: outstanding. Th...more
This is one of the most exciting books I have read in a long time - blood feuds in 10th c Iceland. Kind of like a mix of Deadwood (or Brisco County) and those Martin novels, except predating them by 700 years, and based on a true story. Graphic violence often leavened with some dry humor. Why every fantasy reader doesn't know about Gunnar and Njal, etc, is incomprehensible considering how awesome this saga is. Halberds, spears, swords, prophetic dreams, chases on horseback and ship, numerous beh...more
Fabulous saga - loved the commentary about men's and women's relationships from 1,000 years ago. This is from handed down oral tradition. When we went to Iceland, we took a tour of where some of the events took place. They're just fields now, and people who had not read the book couldn't understand why we were oohing and ahhing over an empty field. Loved the scene where the warrior's body rises up in the moonlight. It's about many things, not the least of which is how a culture benefited when Ch...more
Interesting tale of a feuding between families which last some 50 years. The violence and feuding was prevalent throught with respect, valued highly and given for heroic deeds and lusty adventures.
There were the usual difficulties with having an extensive cast of characters and with the language in certain places but this was balanced with passages of richness in description and poetry and some of the phrasing was considered quite modern.
I felt that the writer had a misogynistic attitude towards...more
There were the usual difficulties with having an extensive cast of characters and with the language in certain places but this was balanced with passages of richness in description and poetry and some of the phrasing was considered quite modern.
I felt that the writer had a misogynistic attitude towards...more
Actually, it's the translation by Magnus Magnusson, but that version wasn't a choice on Good Reads. Biggest down-side of the book: try as I might, I lost all track of who was who about 2/3 of the way through. This seems to be a characteristic of Icelandic sagas. Up-sides: You get names like Ragnar Hairy Breeks, you get a really good look at the religious and political institutions of the day, perhaps the tensest moment of the book is a courtroom drama. Also, Iceland is the world's oldest continu...more
Sadly, this is one of the most disappointing books I've ever read. If only I'd read the introduction before purchasing, where the reviewer summed it up as "Icelanders fall to blows". This is possibly the most accurate pithy description of a book you might ever find because that is all it is about. Seriously, this Icelander kills or maims that one, so another kills and maims someone else and so it goes on... and on... and on... About the only people who could love this book would be Mafioso types...more
The storyline of Njal’s Saga can seem hopelessly complicated at first glance. The tales are based on historical events, so there are a number of people who play only minor roles, there are long lists of characters’ ancestries, and there are people who share the same name. However, just a little way into the book, the reader should be able to pick out and focus on the key characters with ease, and once he does, he will become wonderfully invested in their lives. The cast of Njal’s Saga is quite f...more
Spoilers. La Njàl's Saga es 354 páginas de matanzas ojo por ojo en un lugar donde se supone se regían por leyes y había abogados (Njàl es abogado) y así. Me mataste a mi criado, te mato al tuyo. Me mataste a mi otro criado, te mato al otro. Así, así hasta el final. Por cada asesinato que alguien de tu grupo hacía, debías pagar de acuerdo al valor de la persona... Porque todo mundo sabe que un criado no vale lo mismo que un gran señor. Todo comienza cuando una vieja bien pleitos y mala leche (su...more
Njal's Saga was given to me as a birthday present at university by a friend who was studying Anglo-saxon and Nordic literature. Expecting that it might be heavy going I left it for several years... More fool I! The saga is interesting for many reasons. The portrayal of combat, humour and stoicism is unlike anything I have read before. On the page the words seem stark and unembelished ('he made a sweep with his sword and hit Thorkel on the neck, and the head flew off'), almost plain. In much mode...more
De acuerdo a las recomendaciones, esta es una de las Sagas de Vikingos mejor escrita, la traducción es excelente, utilizando Inglés antiguo, lo cuál hace un poco difícil su lectura en un inicio, pero una vez que tomas el ritmo ya no es necesario tener el diccionario al lado. La saga esta narrada en una forma muy literaria y con algunas exageraciones de esperarse de parte del escritor, al fin y al cabo se trata de historias que pasan de voz en voz. Hasta hace poco que comencé a familiarizarme con...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Books can be attributed to "Anonymous" for several reasons:
* They are officially published under that name
* They are traditional stories not attributed to a specific author
* They are religious texts not generally attributed to a specific author
Books whose authorship is merely uncertain should be attributed to Unknown.
More about Anonymous...
* They are officially published under that name
* They are traditional stories not attributed to a specific author
* They are religious texts not generally attributed to a specific author
Books whose authorship is merely uncertain should be attributed to Unknown.
Share This Book
4 trivia questions
1 quiz
More quizzes & trivia...
1 quiz

Loading...










view 1 comment






















