Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “My Dearest Holmes” as Want to Read:
My Dearest Holmes
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

My Dearest Holmes

4.13  ·  Rating Details ·  1,173 Ratings  ·  48 Reviews
"... The accounts of these cases are boo bound up with events in my personal life which, although they may provide a plausible commentary to much of my dealings with Mr Sherlock Holmes, can never be made public while he or I remain alive ..."

Although Dr Watson is known for recording some sixty of his adventures with the celebrated Sherlock Holmes, he also wrote other remin
Kindle Edition, 146 pages
Published (first published January 1st 1988)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about My Dearest Holmes, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about My Dearest Holmes

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Jan 28, 2011 Nikki rated it it was amazing
Shelves: romance, mystery, lgbt
My Dearest Holmes contains two stories, with the conceit that they're both stories Watson set aside as being impossible to publish given the social circumstances of his day, and that he left them to be published years after his death, when it couldn't possibly affect him or his associates. The first deals with Watson's apparently unrequited love for Holmes, and provides background to his swift marriage to Mary, an arrangement of mutual benefit that allows both Watson and Mary to disguise their t ...more
Rebecca Tayles
I was a little nervous about finally getting to read this - it had the potential to be really bad fanfic. But Piercy's writing actually fits right in with that of the Sherlock Holmes canon, making this feel very natural.

Set shortly before The Sign of the Four, the first half of My Dearest Holmes deals with a woman worried about her housemate's disappearance. I won't spoil that case, which in itself is rather interesting with plenty of the sorts of twists you expect from a Holmes case, but during
This book is pure garbage. I found the content tedious and needless.
Jan 31, 2013 Rachel rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Well, I'd say its for completists only, given that the premise is that Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson are gay, and most of the book is about Watson pining in unrequited love for Holmes. That's going to be a dealbreaker for a lot of readers, which is understandable. The stories of the Sherlockian Canon are about the deep friendship between the two as much as they are about crime-solving, and most fans don't like to see that friendship tampered with. I happen to be a completist, and owner of such ...more
Elisa Rolle
First of all you have to consider that this novel was released in 1988, so well ahead of the movie on Sherlock Holmes and James Watson that so openly suggested that the relationship between the two had a sexual undercurrent. Actually I have two thoughts in mind upon finishing this book: one is that both movie than book have to be very accurate to the original characters since they share so much in common that only having the same origins can explain that, or second hypothesis is that maybe the s ...more
Jul 11, 2012 Jen rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Portia Costa
Nov 13, 2011 Portia Costa rated it really liked it
Recommends it for: Sherlock Holmes fans open to something different, fans of gay male romance
I was intrigued by this item, a gay interpretation of the great friendship between Holmes and Watson, and I wasn't quite sure what I was going to make of it when I first started reading. I've always thought there was a deep and powerful bond between the two men, but I wasn't sure I liked the idea of it being more than that.

However, when I got into the story, I was very pleasantly surprised. The writing is excellent, and despite the obvious differences from the canonical, the voice is believable
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Jan 29, 2012 Erastes rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: gay-historical
A nice deceit, that Rohase Piercy found the manuscripts and has published them. Watson’s preface is rather sad as it talks of how he hopes that men of his type have things better than men of his generation.
It’s been a very long time since I read Holmes in canon. I have the complete works and I hoovered them up all at once in my 20′s and haven’t read them since, but from what I remember these two little novellas, each cataloguing a different case of the great detective, are written by a true Holm
Tanya Herig
Sep 04, 2010 Tanya Herig rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
One of the best modern Sherlock Holmes interpretations I have ever read! At times I was almost certain the words were Arthur Conan Doyles. Beautiful style of writing. The story draws you in from start to finish. And the end was simply perfect.
I said to Paul, "This is the best book written in the history of literature," and I meant every word of it. Every sentence is incredibly satisfying, if you love angst. And my god do I love angst
Nov 10, 2012 Fox rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I'm pretty sure I've read this book before but I couldn't recall the plot. So I read it again. And thoroughly enjoyed.

4.5 stars
This was amazing, I'm so astonished by how well Rohase Piercy was able to capture Watson's style and tone. I loved everything about this, it's super angsty (which honestly I generally cannot stand but it was so well done and it somehow worked miraculously), warm and fluffy and beautifully gay. All I need to be satisfied!
I know a lot of people don't like the idea of Holmes and Watson being together but if you do (I DO!) or don't mind it and just enjoy their adventures and stories I'd say definit
Dec 08, 2016 Ailbhe rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Maria Teresa Zumbo
I loved this book. As simple as that.
I loved it probably more than I should have, this book been written by someone different from Conan-Doyle.
I always thought reading Sherlock Holmes that the relationship between him and the good doctor was deeper than a normal relationship between friends would be. It goes without saying that deeper doesn’t mean necessarily romantic. But it was nonetheless an idea that allowed me to read this book open minded and ready to discover the author point of view on
La Stamberga dei Lettori
Adoro i prequel/sequel/spin-off e quant'altro prolunghi il piacere di leggere i miei romanzi preferiti raccontandone retroscena o punti di vista alternativi, a patto che venga rispettato lo spirito del romanzo originale. Per questo mi sono avvicinata con curiosità mista a diffidenza a questa rilettura delle avventure di Sherlock Holmes in chiave romantica. Chiunque abbia una qualche familiarità con il grande detective, infatti, conosce la sua indole distaccata e la quasi totale indifferenza vers ...more
This book will most likely remain unread by people who can't conceive of any other sort of relationship between Watson and Holmes other than platonic friendship - and that's a pity, because they're missing out on a good book. It's certainly better written than most of the pastiches I read, and with more respect for the characters. Indeed, it is very IN character, somehow. Expect nothing terribly shocking (like smut, ha) but expect lots of angst... The first part (story) is a very Conan Doyle-esq ...more
Mar 19, 2012 Joe rated it really liked it
Shelves: fiction
This is pretty much Harlequin Romance meets Sherlock Holmes, recorded in Doctor Watson's voice as so many of the original cases were. The book is divided into two halves. The first, a mystery worthy of Conan Doyle himself, in my opinion, but interwoven with an insight into the relationship, or lack thereof, between Holmes and Watson, and set shortly before the events of The Sign of the Four, which, devoted readers will know, is the case in which Watson meets the woman he will marry. The second h ...more
May 11, 2012 Amy rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: glbtq, 2012
I absolutely loved this. I might have a hard time going back to the Doyle books or other adaptions after this one, and not just because Watson was pining for Holmes. This is the point of view that I was missing from House of Silk, even though both that and this were told by Watson. I really felt like I was there with him, experiencing things with him, and I really felt my heart breaking for him at times.

This book is split into two parts. The suddenness that the first one ended took me a bit by s
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Apr 10, 2010 Megan rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2010
This book is in two parts: part one, a "previously-unpublished" case, and part two, a rewriting of the Final Problem/The Empty House. The twist in the case was unique and fun, and I wish Piercy had given more attention to the mystery (my perennial complaint with Holmes pastiches); likewise, the twist in her rewrite of Holmes's return was clever but underplayed.

I liked her portrayals of Holmes and Watson, and the slash was central but never gratuitous. (Unless you think that sort of thing is grat
Sep 12, 2011 Ariel rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
This was a rather delightful little book. Very much in the tone of Doyle, it touched on the heartbreak of John Watson's being in love with Sherlock Holmes and thinking the other man indifferent.

Since I've been on a huge Sherlock Holmes kick (or mainly Sherlock/John, thanks to the new BBC show) I was thrilled to find this in the library, and devoured it. And it was adorable! Not fanfiction-y (which is a concern), no crazy sex-against-a-wall (which was, perhaps, a bit disappointing, but stuck wit
I've been a Sherlock Holmes/Dr. Watson fan since my mom bought me "The Adventures of sherlock Holmes" when I was in grade school. I've read and re-read them and watched so many of the movie and tv adaptations that I can't even count them. Currently re-watching "Sherlock" the BBC series of a modern Holmes/Watson duo. LOVE IT.

Anyway, I was totally impressed with the writing in My Dearest Holmes. It has a wonderful wealth of feeling but still with clear and concise descriptions. This allows this st
Presented as memoirs found in a locked box, which Dr Watson instructed was not to be opened until 100 years after the events described, this book consists of two short stories that reveal the true, romantic nature of Watson’s relationship with Sherlock Holmes. This is as good as really good fanfiction – that’s a compliment, and more than I can say of a lot of Sherlock Holmes pastiches. I loved the romance and the angst, and how the author handled Mary Morstan, and the supporting cast of queer or ...more
Sep 03, 2010 Dana rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Once I picked it up, I did not put this book down until it was finished. This is a beautiful story in Holmesian tradition. It casts a deeper look on the relationship between Holmes and Watson while keeping true to the original feel of Doyle's classics. Piercy's Watson has soul and depth. Her Holmes is right on the mark and shows a glimmer of tragic and poignant emotion. I loved it pure and simple. I wish there was more books out there like this one. Now to (im)patiently await the second Sherlock ...more
Impressive ! The author is so respectful of the Canon yet she manages to introduce masterfully her own view of the relationship between Holmes and Watson. This is a non graphic and beautifully written romance and we can't be anything but touch by this tale of these famous men is the Victorian era, when it's was so difficult and dangerous for two men to express their feelings for each other. A MUST read to all Holmesian/Sherlockian who are not opposed to male relationships.
Soledad P
Aug 04, 2015 Soledad P rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: detective, novela
Este libro se ambienta en el universo de Sherlock Holmes, pero más inclinado al fandom. En la primera parte tenemos a un Dr. Watson gay, temeroso de declararse a Holmes y de fondo una historia bastante simple y sin misterio plagada de lesbianas. La segunda parte se ambienta en la muerte de Sherlock Holmes y cómo Watson la lleva hasta que Holmes se le aparece y tienen momentos bastante mamones y cursis. Lectura rápida e inocente, pero al menos me amenizó la tarde.
Kasey Monckton
A 3.5 for the very realistic account of what it would have been if Holmes and Watson were truly feeling more than friendship. Huge sympathy for Watson but also a frustration and empathy for Holmes. If you enjoy Sherlock Holmes of any sort I would give it a read. The mystery is obvious to me but I didn't mind that. It was the story going on inside it that I was interested in and it was a wonderful end.
Chelsea Cahill
Sep 05, 2014 Chelsea Cahill rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Wow this even more enjoyable than I thought it would be going in! I love the depictions of the characters here and how real the emotions felt all with respect to the time period. I also really enjoyed the portrayal of women here--not shown as lesser beings, but as friends (especially in the case of Mary-- I love Mary here and would have loved to seen some things from her perspective) going through some similar challenges, in the case of the women featured. Would recommend.
Jun 04, 2015 Ludovica rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
The novel was overwhelming and impeccably written. As a fan of the genre, I have been dying to read this one, and after a year and a half, I decided to buy it. Yesterday it finally arrived and this morning I could not help plunging into into!
I loved the plot, the style and the suspense! I absolutely recommend it, it is surely worth the time (and the feelings!)
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • A Study In Lavender: Queering Sherlock Holmes
  • Kissing Sherlock Holmes
  • The Private Life Of Sherlock Holmes
  • The Crimes of Dr. Watson
  • Sherlock Holmes: The Unauthorized Biography
  • Sherlock Holmes in America
  • The Man from Hell (Further Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (Paperback))
  • The Science of Sherlock Holmes: From Baskerville Hall to the Valley of Fear, the Real Forensics Behind the Great Detective's Greatest Cases
  • Sherlock Holmes in Orbit
  • The Progress of Sherlock Holmes
  • The Further Adventures of Sherlock Holmes: The Veiled Detective
  • Gaslight Arcanum: Uncanny Tales of Sherlock Holmes
  • The Affair of the Porcelain Dog (Ira Adler #1)
  • Gaslight Grimoire: Fantastic Tales of Sherlock Holmes
  • The Further Adventures of Sherlock Holmes: The Giant Rat of Sumatra
  • The Trial of Sherlock Holmes (Sherlock Holmes Dynamite, #1)
  • The Breath of God (Sherlock Holmes)
  • The West End Horror: A Posthumous Memoir of John H. Watson, MD

Share This Book

“Although we have shared lodgings for seven years, we are not--on intimate terms."

I spoke earnestly, for I certainly could not afford to have her misunderstand the situation. She regarded me seriously.

"You are very fond of him, however, and would wish things otherwise," she said.

I gripped the edge of my seat and did not reply. Turning to look at the street, I observed that we were just passing the door of the Cafe Royal and were approaching Regent Circus. I shifted my gaze abruptly to the swaying interior of the hansom. I felt Miss D'Arcy's eyes upon me.

"Is it so very obvious?" I said at last.”
More quotes…