The Girl in the Mirror
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Girl in the Mirror

3.05 of 5 stars 3.05  ·  rating details  ·  122 ratings  ·  27 reviews
Jeanne, a young French exile orphaned by the wars of religion on the continent, is brought to London as a young girl disguised as a boy. Growing up, the disguise has not been shed and she finds a living as a clerk, ending up in the household of Robert Cecil. As she witnesses the intrigues and plots swirling round the court of Elizabeth I in the last days of Gloriana's reig...more
Paperback, 352 pages
Published June 9th 2011 by HarperCollins Publishers (first published 2011)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Girl in the Mirror, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Girl in the Mirror

The Boleyn King by Laura AndersenThe Luxe by Anna GodbersenClockwork Princess by Cassandra ClareRumors by Anna GodbersenThe Girl in the Steel Corset by Kady Cross
Fair is the Red Rose
177th out of 241 books — 64 voters
The Secret Keeper by Sandra ByrdTo Die For by Sandra ByrdThe Boleyn King by Laura AndersenAt the Mercy of the Queen by Anne Clinard BarnhillRoses Have Thorns by Sandra Byrd
Best Tudor dresses
102nd out of 137 books — 50 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 845)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
I'm partial to a bit of historical fiction and my tastes are quite catholic running as they do from Hilary Mantel to Emily Purdy via Rosemary Sutcliff, Jean Plaidy and Philippa Gregory. Sarah Gristwood, like Alison Weir, is a historian turned novelist and I've enjoyed her non-ficton ['Arbella' and 'Elizabeth and Leicester'].

I was enjoying this tale of a cross-dressing female Huguenot gardener unwittingly involved in Tudor espionage until I came to pg 130 and the following sentence:

'As her ladies...more
That lovely cover caught me first, and when I read an opening that was just as beautiful I was completely captivated.

“Sometimes I think I can feel the garden, like a prickle of awareness on my skin, as if sight – and smell, and sound – were not enough and I want to wrap myself in it, like you wrap yourself in fur on a winter’s day. I suppose those times should come most often in the mayday, the hay day. when the roses and the fleur du luce and the honeysuckle are in flower. When, in the knot gar...more
One of the few historical books that I have struggled to read through. I picked up the book because the story seemed very interesting.

Jeanne Musset is an orphaned little girl who is smuggled into England dressed as a boy. She grows up in disguise and ends up working in the office of Sir Robert Cecil, at a time when Queen Elizabeth is aging, talk of her successor is raging and the court is full of intrigue. Somehow she catches the eye of Earl of Essex, and life changes for her.

It seemed like a...more
This book was close to torture. I forced myself to finish reading it; took me ages despite it being quite a short novel. The language / writing style I just found quite stiff and really hard to engage with. It was a slog. The main reason I persevered was that I actually did like the characters and the premise of the novel - it's unusual I think for Robert Cecil (as opposed to the old Lord Burghley) to ever be a central character in a book about Elizabethan England. There probably are some people...more
Hiep Huynh
This is not a very good review because I didn't get very far into the book. Although that does say a lot. I mean, I made myself finish the first Twilight novel even though I wanted to punch myself in the face. This book was the opposite. Instead of being frustrating and silly, it was mind numbingly boring.

The pretty cover, the 'historical fiction' label and the blurb made it sound very enticing. Instead, it was slow, stiff and just didn't pull me in.

To sum up my rating, I did not like it.
Tanya Negrey
Ugh. I got about 3/4 of the way through then finally took it back to the library. Definitely not worth the late fees of $2.60. Disjointed, superficial, no strong story line. Painful.
Very disappointing, as the premise of the book-a young woman (Jeanne) posing as a male in late 15-th/early-16th century England-is a good one. I'd love to see this idea done with the storyline flushed out first, and with qualities to the characters that make the reader care about them.
For instance, nothing is writt...more
I generally love historical novels, especially about this particular time period. I even really liked the concept that Gristwood had chosen to explore.

Unfortunately I found this book incredibly difficult to get through. The writing style didn't flow well for me, and I found most of the characters rather flat. In the end, I forced myself through this on the sheer desire to want to be able to pick up a new book.
This wasn't what I expected at all, and that would've been okay had I received something different to enjoy. Instead, I was confused and bored; I only read to the end because I didn't want to leave it unfinished.

I didn't realize until a little bit in that there were multiple characters (and it wasn't solid in my mind until that one scene that was repeated in the POV after it) even though there were headings that stated who the POV was from. The characters didn't have their own voices, either – a...more
A disappointing way to start the year's reading. An interesting premise to re-tell a story that has been told a thousand times, but it just never got underway. Disjointed, often implausible. It was impossible for me to understand Jeanne's motivations, and I really couldn't be bothered even tring,
This was a first for me! After decades of avoiding bodice rippers I finally succumbed to this after a friend recommended it. Totally not my style (no spaceships / aliens / unicorns or magic for start) and also it was a story told around historical events which normally I would avoid like the plague. (No pun intended - this is not about the black plague.)

This is the story of a young French orphaned disguised as a boy living in London who unwittingly stumbles into the middle of a circle of secrets...more
Karen Brooks
A beautifully written tale of cross-dressing, machinations, plots and self-discovery set during the last years of Queen Elizabeth the first's reign. Told from three different points of view (the young woman, Jeanne, a religious refugee in England, one of Elizabeth's ladies-in-waiting and Secretary of State, Robert Cecil), it covers the decline in relations between Elizabeth and the ebullient and erratic Earl of Essex.

Initially, the story grabbed me and I thoroughly enjoyed the gardening metapho...more
Vikas Datta
Another compelling read that brings to life the shadowy world of plots and conspiracies in the closing years of the Glorious Queen of England's reign. A narrative structure switching between multiple characters is a difficult gambit to pull of successfully but Ms Gristwood succeeds most admirably. A cast of characters would have helped though. The narrator is a inspiring creation and should not go waste after just one adventure...
Jo at Jaffareadstoo
It's refreshing to have a book about Elizabethan England that doesn't focus entirely upon Elizabeth the Queen.

This book follows the fortunes of Jeanne Musset, orphaned, and forced to flee the Low Countries as a small child, Jeanne lives her early life in London, disguised as a boy. As an adult, her exceptional talent for drawing botanical specimens will take her into the circle of the charismatic Earl of Essex, whose own meteoritic rise to glory is about to come to an end.
Beautifully written, th...more
I tried so hard to read this book. It started out well but quickly devolved into the tedious minutiae of life at court during the latter years of the reign of Elizabeth I. The novel presupposes a certain degree of familiarity with many of the key historical figures. People not already heavily steeped in the period may find this book confusing. The pacing was painfully slow and I made it about about a third of the way through before I gave up waiting for something to happen. Moving on to somethin...more
Historian turned novelist, Sarah Gristwood, has written a beautiful book about Elizabeth I and the Earl of Essex. Instead of the squalor that one usually reads about in that period of history, we have detailed descriptions of sumptious meals eaten by the nobility and of glorious gardens. However, there are serpents in paradise in the form of spies, intrigue, rebellion and gruesome punishment. Whilst sticking as closely as possible to historical fact, the author presents us with an interesting fi...more
Maureen Grenier
I think “The Girl in the Mirror” by Sarah Gristwood is a wonderful book. The story is set in the Elizabethan Era and revolves around the conflict between the ageing Queen and the ambitious Earl of Essex. This is a fictional account supported by historical fact and the author lets us know at the end of the book what parts are based on supposition. We follow the story through the adventures of a young female gardener-artist, disguised as a male, which means we are also treated to information about...more
Margaret Jones
What I liked most about this book was the mix of fiction and fact. The fact that in between each section she put quotes from the people mentioned throughout the story.

I must say that the story itself about the relationship between Essex and Elizabeth was not one that particularly gripped me. I did like how the story was told through the eyes of a girl posing as a boy who becomes a clerk in the court of Elizabeth. I did also like the way the reader always know who was telling the story and when....more
Amanda Stanzel
I really didn't care for this book. It was slow and hard to get through.
I particularly like historical fiction based in this period and although this was enjoyable , there are far better novels out there. I felt that the voices of the three narrators were too similar, both in language and thought.
However as I love gardens I did like the how the story was entwined with plant references.
So, if you get given this book and have some to relax - go ahead and enjoy it, just don't rush out to buy it especially!
Actual rating 3.5 stars.

Interesting in that it focuses on one particular episode in the reign of Elizabeth I - Essex's downward spiral. Also interesting in that it is from the point of view of a commoner on the fringes, and even more so a girl masquerading as a boy.

I liked how the garden/flower theme was carried through the book, with descriptions of the changing seasons and weather all done in terms of flowers.
It was a really interesting book. After reading a lot about the same time in history it starts to get a tad boring. However, this shows a different side to the time when Elizabeth I was on the throne. You see the story through the eyes of a girl who is dressed as a boy. I recommend it!
Sarah Gristwood is no Philippa Gregory (yet) but this is a good first novel. I am admittedly fascinated by the Tudors, British history and a self-professed Anglophile so I am a wee bit biased but the world she creates is believable and you will become wrapped up in the intrigue.
Apart from my earlier comments i really liked this book.
It helped because i read the notes at the end first giving the background.
Sarah writes beautifully and her first novel is a credit.
I hope another is on the way.
I am preparing to read Blood Sisters now.
An interesting insight into the final years of Queen Elizabeth's reign. Well written and engaging.
Suzy Platt
An excellent book, kept my intrigued to the end, looking forward to more from this author.
Maryann Macpherson
Such wonderful prose - I hope she has another novel coming out soon.
Quite interesting. Bit ponderous at times.
Kirsty Pearson
Kirsty Pearson marked it as to-read
Aug 21, 2014
Nancy marked it as to-read
Aug 18, 2014
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 28 29 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Queen's Secret
  • The Queen's Sorrow
  • The Tudor Throne
  • The Irish Princess
  • To Serve A King
  • Secrets of the Tudor Court
  • Elizabeth and Essex
  • The September Queen
  • In a Treacherous Court (Susanna Horenbout and John Parker, #1)
  • All the Queen's Players
  • The Queen's Promise
  • Rival to the Queen
  • Madame Bovary's Daughter
  • The King's Confidante (Tudor Saga, #6)
  • The Queen's Handmaiden
  • The Flower Reader
  • His Last Letter: Elizabeth I and the Earl of Leicester
  • The Tudor Secret (The Spymaster Chronicles, #1)
Sarah Gristwood attended Oxford and then worked as a journalist specializing in the arts and women's issues. She has contributed to The Times, Guardian, Independent, and Evening Standard.
More about Sarah Gristwood...
Elizabeth & Leicester: Power, Passion, Politics Arbella: England's Lost Queen Blood Sisters:  The Women Behind The War Of The Roses The Breakfast at Tiffany's Companion. by Sarah Gristwood Bird Of Paradise: The Colourful Career of the First Mrs Robinson

Share This Book