The Magnificent Spilsbury and the Case of the Brides In the Bath

The Magnificent Spilsbury and the Case of the Brides In the Bath

3.73 of 5 stars 3.73  ·  rating details  ·  105 ratings  ·  26 reviews
Bessie Mundy, Alice Burnham and Margaret Lofty are three women with one thing in common. They are spinsters and are desperate to marry. Each woman meets a smooth-talking stranger who promises her a better life. She falls under his spell, and becomes his wife. But marriage soon turns into a terrifying experience. In the dark opening months of the First World War, Britain be...more
Paperback, 292 pages
Published 2011 by John Murray Publishers
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 225)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Meaghan
This was excellent. The story of George Joseph Smith's life and crimes is interesting enough by itself (I wrote about him in a guest entry for the blog Executed Today), but Robins also did a good job putting the story in its proper historical context.

Women were supposed to be wives and mothers, and the general belief was that if a girl wasn't married or at least engaged by the time she was in her mid-twenties, there was something wrong with her. It was also very difficult for a single woman to s...more
Sam Woodfield
I reviewed this book for a major book seller pre-release and as a lover of true crime, I really enjoyed it. However, thats not to say that a non-crime fan would not enjoy this read as Robins gives a facinating insight into Britain 100 years ago, and manages to write true crime in a novel-like way making some of the scientific (in the Georgian sense of the word) content much easier to digest.

The lives of Bessie Mundy, Alice Burnham & Margaret Lofty are explored in some depth by Robins, showin...more
Damaskcat
This marvellously readable book is much more about Bernard Spilsbury’s work than his life. The framework used for it is the chronology of the famous ‘Brides in the Bath’ case in which George Joseph Smith disposed of three of his wives by drowning in order to collect their savings and their life insurance. It is the story of a conman in an age when respectable young women were desperate to marry and have their own homes rather than be left to eke out a miserable and lonely existence in a boarding...more
Jane
In June 1915 Britain was at war, and yet a different story filled the front pages of the newspapers and captured the public imagination. The story of the trial of George Smith. He stood accused of marrying a young woman and then drowning her as she bathed. On three occasions.

The three young women were swiftly dubbed “the brides in the bath”, and it is they, not George Smith and not the Magnificent Spilsbury, who are at the heart of this book.

Bessie Mundy. Alice Burnham. Margaret Lofty.

Three ver...more
Nancy Oakes
As England was heading into and then in the beginning years of World War I, within the short space of three years, three women, all of whom had married George Joseph Smith (who used multiple aliases) died while taking a bath. Each individual death had been legally attributed to natural causes after proper inquests, the doctors finding no evidence of foul play. But early in 1915, Detective Inspector Arthur Neil from the Kentish Town police station was going through his workload and came across an...more
Caroline
This book charts one of the most famous murder cases of the era George Orwell called 'our great era in murder', roughly 1850 to 1925 - the Brides in the Bath. I had heard of this case before, but I didn't know very much about it. I certainly didn't know the extent of George Smith's victimisation of women, the number he had married and abandoned, not just murdered.

Robins intersperses each chapter narrating the course of Smith's crimes with a chapter about Bernard Spilsbury and his evolution into...more
Ali
I actually picked this book up at a recent bookcrossing meet up here in Birmingham, telling myself grumpily that I didn’t need any more books and I really shouldn’t be taking anything else home with me. Well I am glad I ignored that inner voice – because I thoroughly enjoyed this book.

The Magnificent Spilsbury is an enormously readable historical true crime book. Well written and researched it is a truly fascinating page turner. A must for fans of historical murder mysteries and Sherlock Holmes...more
Anne
This non-fiction book tells fascinating story of the 'real life' Sherlock Holmes - Dr Bernard Spilsbury, and how forensic science emerged into the world of the police. Jane Robins is a writer and journalist.

The Brides In The Bath case fascinated the whole of England and the book covers each case in detail. It is fascinating to read of how these women all fell under the spell of one clever con-man and how unmarried women of those times were so desperate to become wives that they all gave up their...more
Josette
The infamous 'Brides in the Bath' murders of Edwardian England, gripped the country and brought to its attention one Bernard Spilsbury; Home Office pathologist and the 'father of modern forensics'. This book relates the story of the murders, the people involved in bringing the murderer to justice, and the burgeoning role forensic science was beginning to play in criminal trials of the time.

I thoroughly enjoyed this book; it's so well written that it reads like a piece of superb detective fiction...more
Dawn
I bought this book at The Secret Book & Record Store in Wicklow Street, Dublin to soothe my crime drama appetite in the days leading up to the new season of Sherlock on BBC. I was roped in by the promise of a face-off between a dastardly Edwardian serial killer and a founding father of forensic science, the "real life Sherlock Holmes," Sir Bernard Spilsbury. It's a swift and solidly entertaining read, but it lacks the energy and allure of Erik Larson's Thunderstruck. The difference is that J...more
Lisa
I'd heard of this book in a Financial Times review years ago and finally bought it online from a UK bookseller since I couldn't get it in the US. It was too quick a read. I enjoyed the alternating chapters between true crime from 1914 and the beginning of forensic science. I also liked the way the author developed the social environment of the times, describing women's rights and social systems in England at the time. It was entertaining and I learned a lot. I've already recommended it to others...more
Rose
In the summer of 1915, the British public experienced a temporary, if morbid, diversion from the horrors of World War I. George Smith, a middle-aged serial bigamist who was accused of drowning three wives for their money between 1912 and 1914, stood trial for murder. The Fleet Street dailies christened it the Brides in the Bath case.

Smith targeted spinsters who were considered past marriageable age. Their gratitude at finding a husband in a world unfriendly to single women weakened their instinc...more
VAle
preso in biblioteca

Cronaca dai primi del Novecento.
Mentre l'Europa è dilaniata dalla Prima Guerra Mondiale, in Inghilterra si indaga su una serie di omicidi che a primo avviso non sembrano tali.
Un affresco dell'epoca, tra scienza e costume, un saggio agile e scorrevole sull'affermazione della medicina legale nei tribunali.
Interessante, anche se la forma-saggio non lo rende appassionante come un giallo.
Fatatat
A well crafted factual rendition of the birth of forensic science in England. The author presents this historical novel jammed full of fact in an easy to read and immensally interesting way with almost no bias or subjectivity, Allowing the readers mind to wander and interpret as they wish.
While reading this book I could easily imagin these events actually happening and found it hard to put down. Captivating
Andrea
Historical true crime... dastardly narcissistic and controlling man... women desperate to be married... class revenge... this book has it all. I read it in one day and enjoyed every minute of it. I did like the way the author interspersed the stories of the poor women's lives and deaths with the growth / re-emergence of forensic science in the court's witness box. I thought she re-created the essence of pre-war Britain very well.
"
I really liked this book. It is full of details about the cases and the development of new techniques of forensics. I learned that if you pull someone's legs up while they're in the bath, they will die instantaneously because of the shock.
Becca Haynes
I really enjoyed this book and the cases of the Brides in the Bath and Dr Crippen Sir Bernard Spilsbury worked on. Fascinating cases, fascinating book. I highly recommend.
Ffiamma
saggio piuttosto interessante sul patologo spilsbury che aiutò nelle indagini su casi di annegamento di giovani donne nelle vasche da bagno delle case che avevano affittato. più che di medicina legale, si parla dei costumi dell'epoca (soprattutto i condizionamenti sociali che influenzavano potentemente il sesso femminile), di alcuni famosi casi di cronaca nera che sconvolsero l'inghilterra all'inizio del 900. la robins racconta minuziosamente gli omicidi e descrive la figura di un truffatore e a...more
Jo
The mysterious case of the Brides in the Bath, women who died suddenly after they were wed. Interspersed with a kind of biography of Bernard Spilsbury, the man considered the 'Father of Forensics'. Simply written with little sensationalism, the author presents the facts and explores the advancement of science in crime fighting. Interesting read.
Terri Cornwall
I chose this as I wanted to know more about the start of forensic science but there was far to much detail about what was happening elsewhere in world events and what was excepted of women in those days. I personally found this distracting from the crimes themselves and didn't enhance the book in anyway.
Deanne
Very good factual accoumt of the crimes, the trial and Sir Bernard Spilsbury's involvement.
Helen
Interesting read, featuring crimes very much of their time. I already knew of 'the Brides in the Bath', but it was good to get some in-depth background on the cases, and to ponder what motivated Smith, and the poor women who were fooled by his dubious charms. Made me very grateful to be a woman in the 21st century, and not around in the early 20th century!
Michael Flanagan
A well written and interesting book covering a serious of murders and the start of the career of Bernard Spilsbury the father of modern forensics. The book is well balanced but for me seemed to lack something I could not quite put my finger on.
Desiree
Interesting. The behind-the-scenes of early 20th century forensics, and though it is a report on real facts, it is writting in such a way as to be very captivating and interesting. Definitely a book to read
Jim
Very well researched true story of the 'Brides in the bath' murders. The early days of forensic science and its use in catching criminals.
Kimberly
May 18, 2013 Kimberly marked it as to-read  ·  review of another edition
Nicole
May 15, 2013 Nicole marked it as to-read  ·  review of another edition
Tria
May 09, 2013 Tria marked it as to-read
Nita
May 05, 2013 Nita marked it as to-read  ·  review of another edition
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Historical murder 3 6 Sep 22, 2012 08:38am  
The Magnificent Spilsbury and the case of the Brides in the Bath (Uncorrected Proof)
The Magnificent Spilsbury And The Case Of The Brides In The Bath (Hardcover)
Il magnifico Spilsbury ovvero gli omicidi delle vasche da bagno (Hardcover)
The Magnificent Spilsbury And The Case Of The Brides In The Bath
The Magnificent Spilsbury and the case of the Brides in the Bath (Kindle Edition)

The Trial of Queen Caroline: The Scandalous Affair that Nearly Ended a Monarchy The Curious Habits of Dr Adams

Share This Book

Your website