A Separate Country: A Story of Redemption in the Aftermath of the Civil War

A Separate Country: A Story of Redemption in the Aftermath of the Civil War

3.22 of 5 stars 3.22  ·  rating details  ·  786 ratings  ·  184 reviews
Set in New Orleans in the years after the Civil War, A Separate Country is based on the incredible life of John Bell Hood, arguably one of the most controversial generals of the Confederate Army--and one of its most tragic figures. Robert E. Lee promoted him to major general after the Battle of Antietam. But the Civil War would mark him forever. At Gettysburg, he lost the...more
Paperback, 448 pages
Published March 10th 2011 by Grand Central Publishing (first published September 2nd 2009)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,026)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Janessa
I always love a book with a strong sense of place. In fact some of my favorite books seem to have this quality. The quality of evoking a place and using that place as if it were also a character in the book, psycho geography, how a place influences its characters. That is why I like the Alexandria quartet so much and books like Istanbul. They have a sense of place. This book achieves that perfectly in evoking New Orleans right after the civil war. The sights, sounds and smells of New Orleans com...more
Susan
A Separate Country by Robert Hicks is set in post-Civil-War New Orleans. CSA General John Bell Hood commanded the Battle of Franklin, where thousands died; years later he becomes introspective as his life comes to an end.

The tedious tale of misery, cruelty and perversion was a chore to read, taking weeks to finish, when I usually read 2 books per week. The beginning is a telling preview: the book starts with John Bell Hood and his wife Anna Marie dying/dead from yellow fever, in poverty and dis...more
Friends of  Linebaugh Library
I really liked The Widow of the South and was excited when I saw that Robert Hicks had published a new book. A Separate Country does not disappoint. Set in New Orleans during the Reconstruction of the south, Confederate General John Bell Hood is trying to reinvent himself, deal with the demons of the Civil War, and rescue his reputation. Hood, for whom the Texas Army base is named, was a tragic and extremely controversial commander in the Confederate Army. He lost the use of his left arm because...more
Jasmyn9
7. A Separate Country by Robert Hicks
Genre: Historical Fiction
Pages: 419
Acquired: 10/3/2009
Book of Your Shelf? Yep
Why I have/read it: Group Read that I didn't have time for originally
Series: No

Eli Griffin has been given a special task by General Hood. A task that will take him deep into the Hood family's history and open a whole can full of mysteries and intrigue. General Hood and his wife, Anna Marie, have both written their histories down and we follow their tale as Eli reads through it, with...more
Saskia Marijke Niehorster-Cook
After having traveled to new Orleans for the first time last fall, I was stunned by the European flavor this city possesses, and yet it is unlike Europe in many ways as well. It also shares some of the flavor I enjoyed while living in the Caribbean.It is an amalgamation of places and people who live side by side not always bearing each others interests as their priorities, but somehow still getting by.
A Separate Country captures the flavor of this place, the richness of life and the reality tha...more
Judy
I really liked The Widow of the South and was excited when I saw that Robert Hicks had published a new book. This book does not disappoint. Set in New Orleans in the Reconstruction South, Confederate General John Bell Hood is trying to reinvent himself, deal with the demons of the Civil War, and rescue his reputation. Hood, for whom the Texas Army base is named, was a tragic and extremely controversial commander in the Confederate Army. He lost the use of his left arm because of wounds received...more
Hood
FICTION Miami Herald

http://www.miamiherald.com/living/sto...

Review | A Civil War figure battles misfortune, himself in 'A Separate Country'

Battered Gen. John Bell Hood settles in New Orleans, fathers 11 children and learns from the errors of his ways.

BY JOHN HOOD

A SEPARATE COUNTRY. Robert Hicks. Grand Central. 432 pages. $25.99

There may be more famous or heroic generals in Civil War history. But there is not a Civil War general whose life was as tragic as that of John Bell Hood, who lost the Bat...more
Tammy
Robert Hicks’s new novel, A Separate Country is a novel about Confederate General John Bell Hood’s life after the Civil War. General Hood was a strong and tough General. The decisions he made during the war stayed with him the rest of his life. Hood lost the Battle of Peachtree Creek, Battle of Franklin and Nashville. When the war was over, Hood headed to New Orleans, the only Southern City that still functioned as a city, to try to live out the rest of his life. While attending a ball, he meets...more
Joanne
This book is a fictional account of the post-war life of Confederate General John Bell Hood. There are three narrators: General Hood, his real life wife Anna Marie, and Eli Griffin, who I assume is a fictional character. While much is known about General Hood's military career, only the bare outline of his post-war life is known. The author takes those few facts and creates his vision of what post-war life was like for the Hoods. Hood's attempts at redemption and love in New Orleans are vividly...more
Elizabeth
In high school I was a huge Civil War buff, reading both fiction and non-fiction and seeing any films I could get my hands on. I knew about the various generals on each side, most of whom had attended West Point together as youths, and served in the US Army together before the secession. I read little information about what the defeated generals did after the war. Did the US Army take them back? Did they emigrate, leaving the land of their birth to start fresh somewhere else?
A Separate Country b...more
Anne
I really tried to like this book, or even to finish it, but I just had to give up when I realized after struggling through about half of it that I was unconsciously skimming. I picked it up, having read Hicks excellent Widow of the South. Unfortunately, rather than a similar book with characters you grew to know and fascinating historical detail, it was a tedious, slogging through the self-flagellating "journals" of John Bell Hood and his wife Anna Marie. I never got to know either character apa...more
Judy
This book covered some familiar territory for me (Civil War, South, New Orleans)but it was focused on some events and people I hadn't read about. John Bell Hood and his wife Anna Marie are the central characters in this story. I had no idea Hood died in New Orleans, for some reason I always thought he was buried in Texas somewhere. They seem to have been soul mates and certainly had a LOT of children. The book paints Hood as a tormented man over his role in the Civil War and Anna Marie is a woma...more
Rob Atkinson
"A Seperate Country" is an enjoyable work of historical fiction, set in post-Civil War New Orleans. Hicks imbues the novel with a palpable sense of place -- one can practically feel the suffocating heat and damp, and see the colorful pageant of late 19th century New Orleans street life and society -- and his unlikely cast (the haunted and maimed Confederate General John Bell Hood, his independent-minded white Creole wife Anna Marie, and her unlikely friends the criminal dwarf Rintrah, the gentle...more
Sue
I feel compelled to make a comment about a book I rated so poorly. I typically like historical fiction, and having been to New Orleans many times, the setting sounded appealing also, BUT I simply could not made myself care about any of the book's main characters -- and I tried, I did. Anna Marie, in particular, came across as unbelievable to me -- I had trouble believing a girl of her social class would have been allowed so much freedom as a child (which is central to one of the sub-plots). And,...more
Betsy
A historical novel based on the life of the Civil War General Hood set in New Orleans after the War. It was a difficult book to complete. The major themes seemed to be the General's overwrought guilt of his role as a Confederate General, somehow it being much worse than any other soldier due to the fact that the South lost the War. This sentiment combined with the overwhelming annoyance caused by the situations, dialog and events lauding the point of view constantly expressed, that somehow one c...more
Kelly
I enjoyed Hick's Widow of the South, but this book is much better. The characters are real, fully developed, and interesting. When a book impels me to research the characters in real life to learn more about them, then I consider that book a worthy read.

The use of three voices - Anna Marie's diary entries, General Hood's memoirs, and Eli's tale - is contrived, but that didn't bother me at all. I was completely taken in by the story, found the demise of Hood and the South after the Civil War com...more
Angela
Interesting story of Confederate General John Bell Hood. He was one of the most famous leaders of the civil war, but struggled to function in everyday life after the war. He married Ann Marie Hennon with whom he had 11 children !! This is the story of their life together, their great love and his many struggles and failures after the war. Interesting glimpses into New Orleans society life, the terrible epidemics of yellow fever that plagued the city, and their eventual death. They left behind 9...more
Melissa Kayden
Very disappointed by this book, especially since I really liked Hicks' first book, The Widow of the South. This book was way too verbose and I really feel like Hicks was trying too hard. In theory, the story was good, but the dialogue and writing was just overwhelming and needless. I would have liked to see more interaction between John and Anna Marie, but a little less of John's narrative, which I found particularly painful. I am not a big reader of historical fiction, and after this book, I pr...more
Carol
The author of "Widow of the South" returns with another historical novel inspired by the Civil War; this one taking place after the war in New Orleans, and is based on the life of the real Confederate Gen. John Bell Hood. It is told mainly through the memoirs of Hood and his beloved wife, Anna Marie, during the last days of their lives. Hood spent his days after the war trying to atone for the lives lost under his command, and through the love of his wife and children he comes to peace with who...more
Robyn Hawk
A Separate Country is a story of the post Civil War era. It is based on the life of Confederate General John Bell Hood.

This is a life time full of tragedy and misfortune. It felt a little slow at times but I am not sure if that is the writing or if it is just really hard to read about such sadness! Hood was marked for life by the war, he was a defeated man, mentally and physically...and his story just starts there.

From the book jacket:
A Separate Country is the bittersweet story of a decent and g...more
Tanja Szabo
I liked this book quite a lot, despite it being somewhat clunky at times. The characters were well fleshed out, and the three perspectives made for an interesting contrast. What I liked was the combination of real history with some poetic license to set forth a story of regret, attempts at redemption, and the cruelties of war and disease. In the hands of any other author, this could have been a disaster, but Hicks (a new writer for me) is a master at description and at making the characters, and...more
Brittni
I'm honestly not sure I have a strong opinion on this book. It wasn't bad; however, it wasn't awesome. The story line was somewhat bland in my opinion. I kept waiting for an amazing punch line to a seemingly never-ending series of mysteries, but all I really got were predictable explanations.

I did enjoy the rich descriptions of New Orleans and I feel that Hicks definitely captured the diversity present in the city. I also found his thoughts on how confederate generals may have felt after the wa...more
Linda
There were some things I liked about the book. The characters were well-drawn, and the Hoods are interesting people. But I thought the premise of the book was just too unlikely. The book was told through the journals of three different people. I know people keep journals, but not in the kind of detail in this book. The book was just way too long. I mean, how does a woman with eleven children (and no servants or modern convenciences) find time to write in a journal? She even keeps writing at leng...more
Marie Z. Johansen
I enjoyed Robert Hicks' last novel "Widow of The South" quite a bit and was curious how this new book would compare. This book paints a rather poignant view of a Civil War hero, General John Bell Hood, returning home & re-settling in New Orleans after the horrors of the war; trying to return to a life that would never be 'normal' again. Although this book was, perhaps, a bit drawn out it is an excellent read that will especially please Civil War buffs and it will also keep you thinking long...more
Marleen
I’ve opted for the Audio-version of A SEPARATE COUNTRY, and I’m so happy I did because for this type of storytelling the “spoken” version works perfectly. I don’t think I would have enjoyed the reading experience as much seeing this is quite a hefty read and taking into consideration that I’m not a native English speaker. Still English’s like a natural second language to me, and I exclusively read novels in English because I so immensely enjoy the language. I also want to get better and better a...more
Darlene
This book, written by Robert Hicks, is a fictional account of one of the Confederacy's most controversial generals.... John Bell Hood. Hood was promoted by Robert E. Lee to the rank of major general after the Battle of Antietam. He suffered a crippling injury to his left arm at the battle of Gettysburg and lost his right leg at the Battle of Chicamauga. Hood became controversial because some felt that his aggressiveness in battle led to his making very reckless decisions which ended up killing t...more
Michelle
Being a fan of Civil War era historical fiction, this book was definitely for me. It was much more interesting and addicting than I would have thought, and I really grew to love the characters. I feel like I know them, and that is always the sign of a good book. Hicks' other novel "The Widow of the South" was good, but this one was far better. It had a fresh perspective on this genre because it focused on what happened AFTER the war- what did a Confederate general do once the fighting was over?...more
Rachel
2.5, but since I had to really force myself to finish, 2.

Granted, I listened to this via audiobook, which might have hurt my perception of this book. The voices narrating the story were soft and low drawls that easily lulled me into sleep or lethargy. I picked it up at the end of April but it took me until the end of May, simply because I found interest in other books I wanted to read more.

It's an interesting perspective of the South, one that is often forgotten in the stories of the War of Nort...more
Sandy Vaughan
I must thank Hachette Books for letting me read this book with such an enticing cover. Before I started reading it, I knew the post my dad retired from was named after John Bell Hood. I had wanted to read about the Confederate General who was so honored. So excited was I when the book arrived, it got moved up to the top of the to be read list.

This book has some beautiful descriptive writing. The best characters are Yellow Jack (Yellow Fever) and the weather in New Orleans. What a horrible way to...more
Kathy (Bermudaonion)
John Bell Hood was a very well known Confederate General. Having lost a leg and the use of an arm during the Civil War, he decided to settle in New Orleans to start his life over again, since the city was largely untouched by the war. In New Orleans, he met, fell in love with and married Anna Marie Hennen. Together they had eleven children.

A series of events involving John and Anna Marie and some of her childhood friends made them re-evaluate their lives and take some chances. They did something...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 67 68 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
has anyone started this book? 7 20 Apr 26, 2013 07:24pm  
A Separate Country (Hardcover)
A Separate Country (Audio CD)
A Separate Country (Kindle Edition)
A Separate Country (ebook)
A Separate Country (Hardcover)

40507
Robert Hicks has been active in the music industry in Nashville for twenty years as both a music publisher and artist manager. The driving force behind the perservation and restoration of the historic Carnton plantation in Tennessee, he stumbled upon the extraordinary role that Carrie McGavock played during and after the Battle of Franklin. He is the author of The Widow of the South and A Separat...more
More about Robert Hicks...
The Widow of the South A Guitar and a Pen: Stories by Country Music's Greatest Songwriters Greening Aid? Understanding the Environmental Impact of Development Assistance Coffee's Little Secrets - Delicious Coffee Recipes Manual Biblico Nelson: Tu Guia Completa de La Biblia

Share This Book

Your website
“The pieces of soul can't be cut out without filling them up again, that's a real law there. God's law. Can't cut out the pieces any more than you can go around with a big hole in your gut. Got to be plugged up, replaced somehow.” 1 person liked it
More quotes…