In the Beginning...Was the Command Line

In the Beginning...Was the Command Line

3.78 of 5 stars 3.78  ·  rating details  ·  4,084 ratings  ·  198 reviews
This is "the Word" -- one man's word, certainly -- about the art (and artifice) of the state of our computer-centric existence. And considering that the "one man" is Neal Stephenson, "the hacker Hemingway" (Newsweek) -- acclaimed novelist, pragmatist, seer, nerd-friendly philosopher, and nationally bestselling author of groundbreaking literary works (Snow Crash, Cryptonomi...more
ebook, 160 pages
Published October 13th 2009 by HarperCollins e-books (first published January 1st 1999)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Greg
This essay is nearly 8 years old, and in dire need of an update. So in 2004 Grant Birkel set out to do just that, producing a set of comments called "The Command Line in 2004". It's freely available on the web, and I suggest you read that version instead of the (older) book.

As far as Stephenson's original writing: Wow, what a disappointment. I think Neil Stephenson writes some fun and highly entertaining fiction, and I really enjoyed both Snow Crash and The Diamond Age. However, this was a subje...more
Tracey
Recently finished the e-book version of this; not sure if it was the whole book or the lengthy essay that the book was based on - since I read it on & off over the past few months, I didn't get a good feel for how long it was.

It's bit dated (at one point he indicates he is writing a portion in Jan of 1999), but still has some excellent observations on the past, present and future of personal computers, as well as human acceptance of & interaction with computer interfaces. He examines th...more
Sarah Sammis
In the Beginning... was a RABCK to me from another BookCrosser. I had put it on my wishlist after enjoying Snowcrash and wanted to see what he'd have to say in a nonfiction book about computers. Stephenson's turn of phrase reminds me a bit of Scott Adams in both the good and the bad.

Overall I enjoyed the book but I was glad it was a short one. The chapters from his comparison of Disney World to the modern day operating system onward drag. These final essays are more rants than insights into the...more
Ashish
This. Is. Mindblowing.

A tiny little thing, just a long essay, really, yet so packed with one explosive idea after another, brilliantly and beautifully written, sliding under your overconsciousness like the cutting razor edge of broken glass and stripping the carefully-pasted skin and gloss of perception off the world you see around you - smashing illusions, firing x-rays through groupthink and consensual mass delusion, laying bare the way the world actually works underneath how we think it does...more
Bria
The advantage of being old enough to have lived through much of the history of the development of computers (or any technology) is that you automatically know the history and understand to some degree how it works. If you're old enough to have had no choice but to learn to drive a manual transmission, then you can't help but both have that skill and the necessary knowledge of a little bit of how it all fits together that goes with that ability. Likewise with computers: what's underneath a GUI is...more
Nate
Jul 07, 2012 Nate rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Techies and nerds who fought with early 1990s PCs
Stephenson's book, I found, to be a [slightly] meandering essay about his experience with operating systems. Set in the 1990s when he wrote it, he provides what is largely his take on the genesis of the major operating systems that he has experienced. It is as the back of the book says: "... a thoughtful, irreverent, hilarious treatise on the cyber-culture past and present, on operating system tyrannies and downloaded popular revolutions; on the Internet, Disney World, Big Bangs, not to mention...more
Remo
A NS le han encuadrado siempre en la literatura “ciberpunk”, que vaya usted a saber lo que es. NS es, en mi humilde opinión, un tipo que escribe de puta madre sobre cualquier tema, y especialmente sobre aquellos que tengan que ver con la tecnología en general y los ordenadores en particular. La edición que he leído es el original inglés, pero el libro está traducido al español y, lo que es aún mejor, se puede leer gratis en la Red.
Se trata de un ensayo sobre los sistemas operativos (Dios mío, si...more
Snail in Danger (Sid) Nicolaides
May 11, 2011 Snail in Danger (Sid) Nicolaides rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: computer geeks, technology historians, and Neal Stephenson fans
I'm not sure if this is interesting but fundamentally dated, or dated but fundamentally interesting. One of the two.

I first read this around the time it was published, when it was released for free as a file on Neal Stephenson's web site. This was so long ago that no one used the word "ebook," at least not as a matter of course. I think the book may have been released simultaneously as a dead tree book and as a distribute-for-free file under the GPL or something similar, but the difficulty of fi...more
Courtney
This ridiculous collection of interrelated essays by Neal Stephenson manages to be both dated and contemporary, depending on whether you're still ranting about the advance of computer operating systems, or you've accepted the inevitable but are frustrated with its intractable failings.

Stephenson wrote this book in 1998 and '99, and in it he rails against Windows and the Mac OS for taking away the power of the DOS prompt and making us all view computers visually. A professional writer, he believe...more
Valia
Nov 21, 2010 Valia rated it 2 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: фанатам Нила Стивенсона, для коллекции %)
Стивенсон путает плохой интерфейс с GUI (графическим интерфейсом), а хороший— с CLI (командной строкой). Ему это дается особенно легко, потому что все его примеры— про редактирование текста: или написание кода, или составление текстового документа. Он почему-то нигде не пишет про радости рисования с помощью текстовых команд %)

Вообще, конечно, стремно, что он везде превозносит книги и чтение, а все остальные способы восприятия информации явно считает второсортными.

Ближе к концу он приводит пример...more
Parker
I read this right after re-reading Snow Crash, and it's a little funny how much Neal Stephenson writes like himself. This was the first non-fiction of his that I've read, but it wasn't much of a surprise, as it stuck pretty close to what you'd expect from him.

That said, it doesn't have the benefit of other Stephenson books of being science fiction, and so instead of talking about the future, he talks a lot about the present. (I know that sounds funny, and that science fiction writers just descri...more
Paul
It begins with an entertaining walk down the memory lane of operating systems, although, having been written in 1999, it starts to get a bit dated when he moves on into the "present". Reading it now, more than 12 years after he wrote it, it's still interesting to see which opinions and predictions ultimately were vindicated or panned out, and which weren't or didn't.
He himself said in a Slashdot interview in 2004, "I embraced OS X as soon as it was available and have never looked back. So a lot...more
Jaap
This book is completely misunderstood as actually being about computers. To paraphrase Dijkstra, this book is no more about computers than astronomy is about telescopes. The core of this book is really the chapter called "The Interface Culture," where Stephenson draws an extended analogy between computer operating systems and ways of experiencing the world. It's a tortured chapter: Stephenson is clearly viscerally uncomfortable with "interface culture" but has come to accept it, rationally, as t...more
Sean
This book is now of course thoroughly dated, although in all fairness, the thoughts espoused by the author were inline with current enlightened geek thinking at that time - 1999. We all thought that Linux would sweep the world clean of previous OS's in a heartbeat - if only it could somehow get itself together on the installation and desktop side of things.

Arguably it did sort of manage that but nobody cared because it wasn't easy to buy in big box stores, installation is still somewhat mysterio...more
Jane Sandberg
An strange little essay, originally released for free on the website for Stephenson's book Cryptonomicon (and, incidentally, still available there). In the essay, Stephenson offers clear, intuitive definitions to concepts such as Operating Systems, UNIX, and Graphical User Interfaces (GUIs), before extolling the virtues of command line interfaces.

For me, this book fell into a really weird gray area. I certainly learned things from it; when Stephenson is presenting information, he presents it wel...more
Sandy
A dated look at the Linux, Windows and Mac OSes (written circa 1999). Stephenson's enthusiasm for anything cool and hackerish - solely based on it's hackerishness - is a trait that informs a lot of his fiction works in a very positive way (his ability to dive into technical miscellany and history, his enthusiasm in imagining where neat things are headed), but unfortunately backfires here, in a straightforward essay on then-modern operating systems and, eventually, why Linux is the best of them....more
Andy
After reading The Cryptonomicon, I started looking for a decent history of the development of the computer, and I came across this tiny tome. If it hadn't had Neal Stephenson's name on it, I wouldn't even have pulled it off the shelf.

Who would have thought someone could make such a geeky subject matter interesting and relevant?
John
A few dud universes can really clutter up your basement.

- Neal Stephenson, "In The Beginning. . . was the Command Line"


What a fun read. It's about technology, sure, but more about culture. Neal takes a good look at operating systems, why we get emotionally involved with them, and why Windows is still so popular. He does this with a grand detour to Disneyland, and a hefty dose of humor. The above quote was from near the end of the book, where he imagines hackers creating big bangs from the comman...more
Brad
I read this once in college; as a music student and hobbyist hacker (somewhat as Stephenson describes himself), I thought this lengthy essay was interesting but not all that compelling.

Now, however, as an engineer and hobbyist theologian, his words have tremendous import. The relationship between technology and cultural philosophy is well-studied and presented with the sort of humor that makes the pointedness of the issues go down easily. And it encourages the weary reader to think again of idea...more
Kevin
I should preface my comments by saying that I am a huge, one might even say rabid NS fan, but I can't help but be a little disappointed by this essay.
Stephenson's central argument concerns the power of metaphor (confined mainly to CLI [teletext metaphor:] vs. GUI [desktop metaphor:] ) in shaping human perceptions. I have no major arguments with any of the author's conclusions, but his ridiculously brief history of GUIs leaves a lot to be desired. For Stephenson, the GUI story begins with Apple....more
Leonardo Etcheto
I enjoyed it immensely, especially because the whole OS discussion is something I have only vaguely heard about but he makes it very vibrant. Great cultural commentary. He is very correct that nobody now can be an expert on everything, you have to choose your battles.
Next time I upgrade a computer, I will see if I get Linux or BeOS for the old one. The mediated life is definetly not for me. His Disney world analogy was very good. Liked how he is opiniated but still very human, he understands why...more
Brett
In this book Neal Stephenson portrays his view of the computer operating system and its development through a series of essays. Stephensons voice in the book relies on the use of highly compelling metaphors for various aspects of the relationship between the machine the user and the operating system. Reading this book has affected strongly with a new perspective of the user, their expectations, their choices, and the ability of their choices to fulfill their needs.

Stephenson makes a somewhat res...more
Chris McClinch
Fascinating look into operating systems and the need for interfaces. Many of the specifics are, of course, dated, as you would expect of any book about computers written over a decade before it was read. The underlying concepts, however, are still entirely fresh. The book looks at Windows, MacOS, Linux, and BeOS, explaining what each are, what they represent, who uses them, why Linux and BeOS are inherently superior, and why they will probably never capture the mindshare that Windows and MacOS e...more
Kathleen
Dated as any ten year old book about computing is going to be, I still highly recommend this exploration of the Operating System. A great deal of the history of Microsoft and Apple has now become myth, but Stephenson breaks it down nicely as what it really is--two corporations trying to make money. His metaphors--and the idea of the operating system as a metaphor--displayed the deft mastery of writing that one expects from him as an author. His broad knowledge of computing explained how he becam...more
John
Still a brilliant exposition, but will probably pass by the audiences that most need to WTFU* - the brainwashed Apple/Macintosh users, and the 'can't be bothered to look elsewhere' or 'corporate drone' Windows users. Stephenson has a phenomenal ability to present and summarise complex issues through analogy and humour. Further, I think that works like Cryptonomicon and the Baroque Cycle will become regarded as major classics by future generations. Shame that the 'SF' tag puts some readers off.

C...more
Silvio111
I am surprised that none of the people who reviewed this book mentioned its most interesting and relevant allusion to dystopian novel THE TIME MACHINE by H.G. Wells. Stephenson compares our current society, in which you have the consumers who don't necessarily understand the workings of the Internet, and then you have the techies, who build all the software and control the tools we use for our business, pleasure, and communication, to the novel's ELOI (elite powerful and ignorant of tools) and M...more
Dene
Quite easy to read - though computer related, you shouldn't have too much trouble as long as you understand the concept of an operating system that isn't windows.

Something I particularly liked was the exploration of a GUI as a metaphor.

What explains how it's affected my perspective most in my own words would be
"Sorry gillette, you can keep your plastic cartridge refills and cans of goop. A badger hair brush, some shaving soap and a cut throat razor are all I need."

That's not a bad comparison, b...more
Preston Lee
An editorialized history of the modern operating system, written circa 1999 for a "typical" consumer of the day. The first half is filled with amusing analogies on the nature of how computer systems work. Despite outdatedness, much of his observation still holds true, and for an established geek is still entertaining.

The latter half, however, largely reads as a rant on his love for Linux. As a Linux lover myself I can appreciate his enthusiasm, though I would have preferred he temper his commitm...more
Jean Tessier
Second reading.

Essay about the nature of mediated experiences and the trade
offs we make between being in control and being able to do complex
things. He uses the history of operating systems between Apple,
Microsoft, and Linux to illustrate the discourse and draws
parallels with the evolution of culture and pop-psychology.

I've enjoyed Stephenson's fiction writings and this is a smart
essay where he shows that he's a geek too. Some of the Windows
versus MacOS is starting to show its age, but the point...more
Dirk
Fascinating little book by Neal Stephenson. On the surface it is about technology and it's pitfalls; pointing to Microsoft/Apple and Windows/Linux or Be. It however also is about the relationship between culture and technology. Whilst some reviewers here describe the book as 'dated', it already contains many of the arguments nowadays (2012) are made by Rushkoff or Lanier regarding social media/networks and modern day computing technology that in their view creates dumb users who don't know what'...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
In the Beginning...was the Command Line (Paperback)
En el principio... fue la línea de comandos
In the Beginning...Was the Command Line (ebook)
In the Beginning...was the Command Line (Kindle Edition)
In the Beginning...Was the Command Line (Hardcover)

545
Neal Town Stephenson is an American writer known primarily for his science fiction works in the postcyberpunk genre with a penchant for explorations of society, mathematics, cryptography, currency, and the history of science. He also writes non-fiction articles about technology in publications such as Wired Magazine, and has worked part-time as an advisor for Blue Origin, a company (funded by Jeff...more
More about Neal Stephenson...
Snow Crash Cryptonomicon The Diamond Age Anathem Quicksilver (The Baroque Cycle, #1)

Share This Book

Your website
“A few dud universes can really clutter up your basement.” 9 people liked it
“I use emacs, which might be thought of as a thermonuclear word processor.” 6 people liked it
More quotes…