The Net Delusion: The Dark Side of Internet Freedom
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Net Delusion: The Dark Side of Internet Freedom

3.67 of 5 stars 3.67  ·  rating details  ·  619 ratings  ·  102 reviews
"The revolution will be Twittered!" declared journalist Andrew Sullivan after protests erupted in Iran in June 2009. Yet for all the talk about the democratizing power of the Internet, regimes in Iran and China are as stable and repressive as ever. In fact, authoritarian governments are effectively using the Internet to suppress free speech, hone their surveillance techniq...more
ebook, 432 pages
Published January 1st 2011 by PublicAffairs (first published November 16th 2010)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Net Delusion, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Net Delusion

Steve Jobs by Walter IsaacsonHackers by Steven LevyGhost in the Wires by Kevin D. MitnickThe Cuckoo's Egg by Clifford StolliWoz by Steve Wozniak
Silicon Valley
27th out of 207 books — 230 voters
The Marriage Plot by Jeffrey EugenidesThe Leftovers by Tom PerrottaThe Art of Fielding by Chad HarbachThe Sense of an Ending by Julian BarnesCatherine the Great by Robert K. Massie
New York Times 100 Notable Books of 2011
88th out of 100 books — 41 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,410)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Michael Burnam-fink
Morozov is on a crusade against 'Internetic-centric foreign policy' and 'cyber-utopianism', which he describes as a constellation of power interests linking Silicon Valley tech companies (Google, Twitter, Facebook) with Cold Warriors (Cheney, Clinton, Rumsfeld) in a profoundly misguided and dangerous effort to promote democracy overseas through technology. He argues that rather than being an unalloyed force for freedom, the internet can be used in many ways that strengthen authoritarian regimes....more
Ron
This is worth reading in combination with The Master Switch for those interested in the topic. Evgeny provides a much needed corrective to all of the overly optimistic thinking about the role of the Internet in repressive regimes around the world. I was introduced to him through debates he had with Clay Shirky, a super optimist on the subject. Evgeny points out that repressive regimes are becoming good at using the Internet to suit their purposes, so the mere fact that there is a free and uncens...more
Leah R
Really important book for the modern age- Morozov exposes the cliches that policymakers use when talking about the internet and explains the harm such oversimplifications can cause. However, the poor writing style of this book detracted from my reading experience- the book needs more editing, for typos, awkward phrasings, abused idioms, and grammatical errors unfortunately abound. Some of the ideas, as well, were poorly developed and some terms were never defined (like democracy! He kept using i...more
Shua
Few things delight me as much as a contrarian.

I enjoy reading Wired magazine; its a welcome blast of techno-optimism every month. And yet... Wired magazine stands out for its high concentration of "the Internets shower the masses with freedom and young entrepreneurs will solve all of life's minor inconveniences"! Wired is not alone in this attitude and is not the worst; its just an easy target for me because I actually read it. I avoid the other stuff.

Evgeny Morozov picks apart many of the assum...more
Doug
I remember reading an article saying how the internet is making us dumber, and I was cynical on how some pundits claim that this same internet is introducing democracy to despotic regimes through Facebook and the Twitter Revolution and whatnot (Malcolm Gladwell also has a good take on this). This book brings it all together.

On a 2009 visit to Shanghai, Barack Obama was all too happy to extol the virtues of the Internet, saying that "the more freely information flows, the stronger society becomes
...more
Trish
Morozov is debunking the notion that internet access = internet freedom. In fact, he tells us that internet "freedom" is a term with no meaning in the conventional sense since it implies that users are free to say what they like and use the technology for their own ends. But, his argument goes, if one user (an authoritarian regime, say, with a reason to dampen enthusiasm for democratic reforms) controls any points of internet access, or subverts the open sharing of ideas on social networking pla...more
Jeff Scott
The ideas in this book are not unique. Social networking has many advantages, but people tend to exaggerate their performance and importance. In a general setting, this might hurt a corporations marketing plan, but Morozov does something different here. He discusses the problems with applying this notion that social networking and free internet in oppressed areas is the miracle drug that will free everyone. He argues that other causes lead to a successful revolution and to believe that the use o...more
Daniel Elder
A refreshing read in the age of cyber-utopianism. Morozov gets unfairly labeled as either being an anti-tech Luddite and an Internet-hater but he actually carves out a great argument for more reasonable approaches to technology and shifting our perspectives on it to understand that it's not technologies that shape societies so much as societies that shape technologies. Technologies change rapidly but human nature far less so. The penultimate chapter is a fantastic exploration of the ways in whic...more
Michael Hughes
I finished more than a third before throwing in the towel. Morozov's analysis is strong, and his writing is often quite funny, a must given the sometimes dry material. While reading, however, I found myself flirting with other books on my shelves, casting sidelong glances that lasted longer and longer. Ultimately, it came down to, what am I going to do with this information, having acquired it? How much of it will I even remember? Isn't this really for policy wonks in a position to do something,...more
Andrea
Morozov has done extensive and excellent research on how the Internet is heralded as a democratizing tool on theory but how things happen in practice. He has looked at the wide context surrounding events such as the "Iranian Twitter Revolution", something we cannot say of many journalists and certainly not of Internet gurus. It also gives a good overview of people´s expectations to various technologies throughout history such as the telegraph and the airplane.
It is a serious book that is probab...more
Joshua
This is an interesting book that makes good points. Sure, it sets up straw men, but the "the Internet will save the world" crowd can really get ahead of itself, so refuting seemingly ridiculous arguments is sometimes in order here. Where the net delusion goes wrong is in trying to take its hard headed pessimism too far, and ending up contradicting itself. The Internet cant be both an ineffective way for progressives to organize popular protest and an effective way for reactionaries to organize p...more
Raj Agrawal
Clever, cynical, and powerful. Morozov clashes wills against what he calls "cyber-utopians" in an effort to convince the reader that cyber policy must be shaped to ensure the Internet aggressively supports democracy rather than enabling authoritarianism. The author insists that the very e-market that idealists believe will bridge the gap between the information and and uninformed has in fact encouraged Internet freedom fighters to support government agencies. Morozov is highly critical of the "W...more
David
I discovered Morozov via this exchange he had with then Slate.com technology columnist Farhad Manjoo. Manjoo was playing checkers, Morozov was playing Go. (See what I did there).

Morozov is a refreshing voice in a cultural climate where internet/technology-worship is the norm. It seems that there is hardly a problem that technology can't solve, and with Washington mired in partisan gridlock, Silicon Valley looks like a veritable Shangrila for our aspirations for a more truly democratic world.

Moro...more
Jeffrey Hart
I was primed not to like this book, but Morozov disarmed me by writing an intelligent critique not of the Internet per so, although he has lots of negative things to say about it, but of the recent tendency in U.S. foreign policy to promote democracy and human rights by advocating "Internet freedom." He is particularly critical of Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and advisers like Jared Cohen. Morozov is critical of a variety of viewpoints: including cyber-utopians (by which he means the folks...more
André
Morozov is describing the dark side of the internet (freedom). The book is a tremendous work with examples of when and where the internet has failed as a tool of foreign policy especially when it comes to democratizing foreign authoritarian states. Additionally he is also pointing out that criminals - from fraud to paedophilia - misuse the internet. All the cases Morozov is highlighting, you have to agree with him that the internet is just a tool that can be used by good and evil minds.

In the en...more
Edwin
(Z mojego blogu: http://bendyk.blog.polityka.pl/2011/0...
Jednocześnie w dwóch niezwykle ważnych i opiniotwórczych amerykańskich magazynach, „Foreign Policy” i „Foreign Affairs” ukazały się duże artykuły krytykujące politykę Internet Freedom zainicjowaną przed rokiem przez Hillary Clinton. W styczniu ub.r., po sławnych chińskich atakach na Google i kilkadziesiąt innych amerykańskich korporacji, po których nastąpił otwarty konflikt Google’a z władzami Chin Clinton ogłosiła, że USA będą bronić woln...more
David Dinaburg
The first throes of modern Internet nostalgia have descended, and with it, the weight of reconciling not only life pre-‘net but the fresh idealism that always accompanies a shift in telecommunications (see: telegraph, telephone). Twitter’s constant deluge of compressed inanities and pointless musings have supplanted Usenet’s core of dedicated, experienced and technically savvy users. The internet used to have some barriers to entry; most of them were financial. If you were “online” it was becaus...more
Wise_owl
This is a good solid book about a very important subject. Questioning the way in which policy makers in the west have become enamored of the 'democratizing' nature of Internet technology, and how that ideology of 'cyber-utopianism' is making policy, for lack of a better word, stupid.

Morozov touches on the origins of these trends, how they have expressed themeselves, the clearest example being the talk that surrounds the Iranian 'Green Revolt', or how the US interprets the emergence of bloggers i...more
Craig Shier
The Net Delusion is an extended discussion of the relationship of the Internet, authoritarian governments and western foreign policy. The main thesis is that Internet technology will not inevitably lead to democratic revolution in autocratic regimes across the world.

Morozov provides powerful examples from around the world demonstrating the less than desirable consequences of promoting Internet freedom in repressed countries.
- Large segments of the population are content with the entertainment...more
Chris Bronsk
Morozov attacks both cyber-utopians (if there are any still out there) and neoliberal triumphalists who want to credit the Internet for, well, just about anything that benefits them. These critiques sound very much like mainstream globalization debates with some anti-capitalist rhetoric refocused toward the Internet and digital media communication technologies. That is, nothing new. But this book is nevertheless an important critique for how Morozov, through his lively style and effective use of...more
Forrest
The following is a joint review of two books by Evgeny Morozov and is cross-posted in both review sections.

This is going to be a very atypical review. In reading The Net Delusion and Click Here, I was attempting to develop a cohesive personal position on the problems of internet advocacy. There is a lot of literature and scholarly articles on the benefits of using the internet in the cause of advocacy, either as a method of raising awareness or as a means to a fundraising end, but there is very...more
Bob
The internet has a dark side, a dark side in that it is not only those who love freedom and want others to be free that use it but dictators and tyrants use the net as well. The author shows how the net is used by those (both individuals and governments) who want to bring about change, specifically the toppling if oppressive regimes. He then evaluates the effectiveness of the net. By dealing with how the internet affects us socially and psychologically, he the reveals that the net has not been a...more
Woliver
En general este libro me ha gustado sólo hasta el final, si no fuera por el apéndice me hubiera quedado confundido, ya que es donde el autor define por fin su postura y la tesis principal del libro, matiza sus argumentos y aclara qué quiso decir con determinados argumentos y qué no quiso decir.

Esto es algo no muy atinado si tomamos en cuenta que afirma que el apéndice sirve para aclarar y responder preguntas de sus críticos.

Por más absurdo que parezca, el libro (sin su apéndice) no define estos...more
mingfrommongo
It should be obvious. The internet does not make us smart, or stupid, or better-looking (or get the weeds out of our lawns). It just gives us more opportunities to show how smart or stupid or good-looking we are. Yet there are many, in and out of government, who think that internet applications an achieve foreign policy goals by themselves. When the same class of idiots that said "We will, in fact, be greeted as liberators" starts talking about "internet freedom" and "Twitter Revolutions", it's...more
Victor Gonzalez
It is not difficult to imagine that technologies that are created for one purpose end up being used for another. Technology is used and adapted by the needs of each person that use it. If we talk about the use of twitter, some might use it to sell their persona, as a politician, as a guru in one are or they might use it to explain the situation that is happening in the place they are. Each user of twitter has a reason for using the technology and they use it according to their own purpose.

In the...more
Steve Stanton
The Net Delusion is an insightful political commentary debunking the myth of cyber-utopianism, the notion that freedom of information will lead to democratic change in the world. With extensive and detailed historical research, Evgeny Morozov argues that the internet is just another form of entertainment and not a tool of empowerment, and that technological determinism ratifies current culture worldwide.

Western governments are increasing censorship and surveillance techniques in response to int...more
D.M. Dutcher (Sword Cross Rocket)
Good, if over-long book about how the power of the internet is often overrated when it comes to helping democracy flourish. It can easily defuse movements and be co-opted by the state for propaganda and surveillance.

Evgeny would call himself a cyber-realist, and his book is a needed corrective to the idea that Twitter and Facebook can cause revolution and peaceful change. He witnessed the failure of the net in Belarus, and his arguments are multiple and well founded. Facebook can connect disside...more
Pliss Quern
Wow cool thanks goodreads for losing my review. This'll be a lot shorter than it was previously.

My dad got me this for Christmas because I'm into "the internet and stuff". Which is true. I am also into being bored, miserable and seeking attention. Wow.

Initially, with its snarky title and chapters like "Orwell's favourite lolcat", I was sceptical, but this is a book which is easily accessible to people with scarce knowledge of technology or foreign policy (such as myself) whilst avoiding excessiv...more
Nate Huston
Very well-written and easy-to-read book. Morozov's purpose with the book is to provide an alternative narrative to the so-called cyber-utopians and internet-centrists of the world who believe that all internet is good internet (i.e. "information will set you free") and those who cannot look beyond the internet in their analysis of its impact (e.g. to understand the impact of Twitter in the Arab Spring, one must look beyond Twitter itself (p324)).

Though the book at first comes off as a bit one-s...more
Cathy (Ms. Sweeney)
Long story short - the internet and technology is a double edged sword that can be used for promoting a free exchange of ideas and philosophies and can be used by authoritarian governments to track opposition groups and individuals, spread misinformation, and distract the people.

And the author really seems to dislike Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.

I found the book interesting, in the beginning, although not quite as original and earth shattering as the author seemed to believe. The somewha...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 80 81 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Consent of the Networked: The Worldwide Struggle For Internet Freedom
  • The Future of the Internet and How to Stop It
  • The Googlization of Everything: (And Why We Should Worry)
  • The Wealth of Networks: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom
  • Who Controls the Internet?: Illusions of a Borderless World
  • Is the Internet Changing the Way You Think?: The Net's Impact on Our Minds and Future
  • The Filter Bubble: What the Internet Is Hiding from You
  • The Master Switch: The Rise and Fall of Information Empires
  • Code: Version 2.0
  • What Technology Wants
  • You Are Not a Gadget
  • Smart Mobs: The Next Social Revolution
  • Cognitive Surplus: Creativity and Generosity in a Connected Age
  • Being Digital
  • Convergence Culture: Where Old and New Media Collide
  • Program or Be Programmed: Ten Commands for a Digital Age
  • Wired for War: The Robotics Revolution and Conflict in the 21st Century
  • Born Digital: Understanding the First Generation of Digital Natives
4113527
Evgeny Morozov is a contributing editor to Foreign Policy and runs the magazine's "Net Effect" blog about the Internet's impact on global politics. Morozov has been a visiting scholar at Stanford University, a Schwartz fellow at the New America Foundation, a Yahoo! fellow at the Institute for the Study of Diplomacy at Georgetown University, a fellow at George Soros's Open Society Institute, and th...more
More about Evgeny Morozov...
To Save Everything, Click Here: The Folly of Technological Solutionism Contro Steve Jobs Smarte neue Welt: Digitale Technik und die Freiheit des Menschen (German Edition) To Save Everything: The Folly of Technological Solutionism The Baffler No. 22

Share This Book

“The most effective system of Internet control is not the one that has the most sophisticated and draconian system of censorship, but the one that has no need for censorship whatsoever.” 0 likes
“although virtually limitless in their power, our technologies are tools without handles.” 0 likes
More quotes…